View Full Version : Stupid Shit in Kyiv
Pages :
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
[
18]
19
What's up with all this palestine middle east talk in the Ukraine forum? Me no likey. But since we're on that subject, then I do have a lifelong fantasy fetish bucket list type thing. I've always wanted to fuck a hijab babe. Like she's all in the hijab gear, pretending to be all demure and stuff, but deep down inside she's a super skank. Then she'd get completely naked except the head covering, but not the full face only see the eyes ninja type, more like the one's you see in Indonesia, type. But with a Mia Khalifa look, big titties and all that. Yeah. Man, I'd pay real money to fuck that. That's my dream. Then I'd come all over her face, while she still has the hijab on. That would be so awesome! It'd be even better if I can fuck her on a Friday. IYKYK.
Better yet, if she was like an Uzbek type, or maybe a more blondish Lebanese type. The whole forbidden fruit thing, you know?LOL, I don't know, some people are just obsessed about the Israel-Palestine conflict. It's because they don't know anything else and have been brainwashed.
I think your bucket list thing is way more interesting as I share your fetish.
The closest I've come to achieve this fetish is with a Palestinian girl that used to wear a hijab when she visited the mosque during Ramadan.
Israel is the Greatest and most Just country to ever have existed.
This sick puke of a comment being what I thought was the most rotten thing I have heard from a fool like you, was eclipsed by this:
<< what else to expect from the irish, terrorism is deeply rooted in your culture. .
A cowardly dog like you smears the Irish anonymously and wouldn't do so in real life.
I have been on marches and I have said to the face of zionists what I think of them. I have stood shoulder shoulder with jews. Some of them orthodox- in these marches on the condemnation of Zion evilness. You insult Ireland and Irish people like the lowly coward that you are online, Shoebrain. In another age, it were no doubt your forefathers that oppressed the Irish and now you egest your hate.
Your so called greatest country that ever existed was BORN in terrorism.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_terrorism
And this is why the rightful minded world despises you zionists: your evil hypocrisy which is used to nefariously further your goals of brutalisation and the massacre and exporpriation of the Palestinians by you evil zionists. So evil, that even the unconscionable right wing ardent zion supporting media, the Telegraph, AKA The Jerusalem Post, is disturbed by your perverseness:
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2025/04/15/israeli-settlers-emboldened-by-trump-lay-siege-to-west-bank/
"It's not morally controversial to advocate for a Jewish, or Christian, state "? Well, it is when it is built on stolen land and on greater and greater theft and when the residents of that land are massacred in their 10's of thousands so that the evildoer's like you can get the resources and land. You know what that is, zionist? That's Lebansraum. The only difference between Nazi Germany and Israhell is that Nazi Germany doesn't exist today.
Keep massacring innocent babies, women and children, monster. Karma has a way of righting the wrongs of your kind. The brutality and wickedness of your Zionazis will be your downfall in 1 year, 10 years or a 100 years. Just as it was for your fellow nazis- and there won't be anyone left this time to shed tears for you and your ilk.The hypocrisy is your obsession and hatred against Israel when you don't spew any of that hate against turkey, and they murdered over two million Christians*.
It's embarrassing to see your unwillingness to criticize the radical palestinians no matter what. *.
The palestinian terrorists murdered, raped and kidnapped more than a thousand Israelis in one day and you're pretending that the Palestinians are the good guys. *.
I'm sorry but the hypocrisy is all yours.
Damn, you can't even see the most obvious.
Let me start by saying that the rise of Israel is extremely beautiful and just. The second coming of Israel is a rare example of how Karma actually can come back to bite some very bad people.
I know history, I understand why Israel had to be revived. *.
My question to you is: how can you deny Jews and Christians their human rights, forcing them to live in fear as second-class citizens, persecuted and oppressed?
What we need now is a Christian state in the Middle East. *.
Through centuries Palestinian terrorists kept massacring innocent Israeli babies, women and children. But Israel has a way of righting the wrongs of your kind. The brutality and wickedness of you Palestinian nazi-islamic terrorists is your downfall. I love how you nazi-islamic terrorists keep speaking about the "downfall of Israel" when it's becoming increasingly clear that your downfall is taking place right now in front of our very eyes. Just as it was for your fellow nazis in Germany and Islamist terrorists in Raqqa. *.
Can you clarify what you meant with this quote: "There won't be anyone left this time to shed tears for you and your ilk. ".
Did you read that in Mein Kampf or was it something you heard in a speech?
The 7th October 2023 will forever mark the beginning of the end of your atrocities against peaceful civilians.
I still don't get why you insist on hating Israel when Israel created an oasis of peace and freedom in a desert of terrorism, radical islam, oppression and persecution of females and religious minorities.
You have*.
It's always the same procedure, the Palestinians (and other Nazi-Islamic terrorists) starts a war against Israel and are boasting about how they are going to kill all the Jews and when reality sets in you start to cry about how "evil" Israel is because they wouldn't let you rape and murder all the Israelis.
The palestinians aren't interested in peace.
You're a hypocrite, you believe that Palestine should be for Arabs only but you have no problem with Arabs migrating to Europe and Australia.
We do not murder Arabs, we give them citizenship, social welfare and free education and health care.
It's nauseating to see your hypocrisy and willingness to accept the ideology of ISIS.
The war against Israel is not only about land, it's about religion. It's a religious war, Jihad, where people are considered pawns to be sacrificed at any time in any number. *.
And that's one of the key issues, palestine will never be free if it's governed by an ISIS look alike.
Palestinians are murdered by hamas and you don't care. Young palestinians are arrested for having a coffe with a person of the opposite sex.
What more do you want from me? Do you want me to defend Kim Jong Un, North Korea and pretend as if the North Koreans are "free"?
Everyone knows the North Korean people would be better off with a different government so why is it so controversial to say the same about Hamas, and the other extremist terrorists in Gaza and the West Bank?
QUOTE=Newton York; What's up with all this palestine middle east talk in the Ukraine forum? Me no likey. But since we're on that subject, then I do have a lifelong fantasy fetish bucket list type thing. I've always wanted to fuck a hijab babe. Like she's all in the hijab gear, pretending to be all demure and stuff, but deep down inside she's a super skank. Then she'd get completely naked except the head covering, but not the full face only see the eyes ninja type, more like the one's you see in Indonesia, type. But with a Mia Khalifa look, big titties and all that. Yeah. Man, I'd pay real money to fuck that. That's my dream. Then I'd come all over her face, while she still has the hijab on. That would be so awesome! It'd be even better if I can fuck her on a.
Friday. IYKYK.
Better yet, if she was like an Uzbek type, or maybe a more blondish Lebanese type. The whole forbidden fruit thing, you know?/ QUOTE.
For Your Eyes only, 2 Forbidden Fruits, But Not on a Friday, LOL.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Mm_kmgQ24QE
Jewish women wearing veils.
QUOTE=Newton York; What's up with all this palestine middle east talk in the Ukraine forum? Me no likey. But since we're on that subject, then I do have a lifelong fantasy fetish bucket list type thing. I've always wanted to fuck a hijab babe. Like she's all in the hijab gear, pretending to be all demure and stuff, but deep down inside she's a super skank. Then she'd get completely naked except the head covering, but not the full face only see the eyes ninja type, more like the one's you see in Indonesia, type. But with a Mia Khalifa look, big titties and all that. Yeah. Man, I'd pay real money to fuck that. That's my dream. Then I'd come all over her face, while she still has the hijab on. That would be so awesome! It'd be even better if I can fuck her on a.
Friday. IYKYK.
Better yet, if she was like an Uzbek type, or maybe a more blondish Lebanese type. The whole forbidden fruit thing, you know?/ QUOTE.
For Your Eyes only, 2 Forbidden Fruits, But Not on a Friday, LOL.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Mm_kmgQ24QE
Jewish women wearing veils.
The Rada has voted to extend Martial Law for 90 days. This means no elections and continuation of mobilization.
The Rada can at any time vote again to suspend Martial Law. Elections can't be held during ML as per the country's constitution as well as free debate and activity of opposition parties can't be sustained.
Continuation of mobilization means no ceasefire as it's a condition by Russia to implement one.
Presidential elections can be held as early as 60 days after the lift of ML, and elections to Rada as early as 90 days. This is the math for 2025.
The hypocrisy is your obsession and hatred against Israel when you don't spew any of that hate against turkey, and they murdered over two million Christians*.
It's embarrassing to see your unwillingness to criticize the radical palestinians no matter what. *.
The palestinian terrorists murdered, raped and kidnapped more than a thousand Israelis in one day and you're pretending that the Palestinians are the good guys. *.
I'm sorry but the hypocrisy is all yours.
Damn, you can't even see the most obvious.
Let me start by saying that the rise of Israel is extremely beautiful and just. The second coming of Israel is a rare example of how Karma actually can come back to bite some very bad people.
I know history, I understand why Israel had to be revived. *.
My question to you is: how can you deny Jews and Christians their human rights, forcing them to live in fear as second-class citizens, persecuted and oppressed?
What we need now is a Christian state in the Middle East. *.
Through centuries Palestinian terrorists kept massacring innocent Israeli babies, women and children. But Israel has a way of righting the wrongs of your kind. The brutality and wickedness of you Palestinian nazi-islamic terrorists is your downfall. I love how you nazi-islamic terrorists keep speaking about the "downfall of Israel" when it's becoming increasingly clear that your downfall is taking place right now in front of our very eyes. Just as it was for your fellow nazis in Germany and Islamist terrorists in Raqqa. *.
Can you clarify what you meant with this quote: "There won't be anyone left this time to shed tears for you and your ilk. ".
Did you read that in Mein Kampf or was it something you heard in a speech?
The 7th October 2023 will forever mark the beginning of the end of your atrocities against peaceful civilians.
I still don't get why you insist on hating Israel when Israel created an oasis of peace and freedom in a desert of terrorism, radical islam, oppression and persecution of females and religious minorities.
You have*.
It's always the same procedure, the Palestinians (and other Nazi-Islamic terrorists) starts a war against Israel and are boasting about how they are going to kill all the Jews and when reality sets in you start to cry about how "evil" Israel is because they wouldn't let you rape and murder all the Israelis.
The palestinians aren't interested in peace.
You're a hypocrite, you believe that Palestine should be for Arabs only but you have no problem with Arabs migrating to Europe and Australia.
We do not murder Arabs, we give them citizenship, social welfare and free education and health care.
It's nauseating to see your hypocrisy and willingness to accept the ideology of ISIS.
The war against Israel is not only about land, it's about religion. It's a religious war, Jihad, where people are considered pawns to be sacrificed at any time in any number. *.
And that's one of the key issues, palestine will never be free if it's governed by an ISIS look alike.
Palestinians are murdered by hamas and you don't care. Young palestinians are arrested for having a coffe with a person of the opposite sex.
What more do you want from me? Do you want me to defend Kim Jong Un, North Korea and pretend as if the North Koreans are "free"?
Everyone knows the North Korean people would be better off with a different government so why is it so controversial to say the same about Hamas, and the other extremist terrorists in Gaza and the West Bank?I posted a long response to your contemptible rant, zionist, which appears not to be posted yet, but as an addendum, read this and weep you lying zionist:
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/apr/18/jerusalem-christians-easter-israeli-crackdown-church-holy-sepulchre
I have seen with my own eyes how the Christians are spat at by the Israeli jews and cursed in a video in fact. So much for your "protection" of christians. Happy Easter.
Israel is an evil colony which is the tail that wags the American dog and warps the minds of evildoers like you to massacre and brutalise the Palestinians and encroach upon and steal their lands. The lies manifest in your post above are manifest in the Zionist owned media too, and the truth suppressed by jailing or deporting or punishing people for speaking the truth, and I have posted the facts which you conveniently ignored about how the genesis of Israel was terrorism, the real terrorists are the Israelis. You are merely a willing, mindless zionazi underling.
Bennett tried to negotiate a ceasefire or peace agreement between Ukraine and Russia in March of 2022. The two sides were very close. Here's the interview.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qK9tLDeWBzs
The part about Russia starts 2:20 (2 hours and 20 minutes) into the video and goes onto the 3 hour point. Remember that Israel depends on the USA for military, economic and moral support, and so Bennett isn't going to bite the hand that feeds it. Still the interview is eye opening. Here's a summary.
The USA believed there was no chance peace could be negotiated. The interviewer asks Bennett, "Maybe they (the USA) didn't want you to succeed?" Bennett: No response.
Bennett got Putin to agree to end his demand for denazification, which potentially would have involved killing Zelensky. Putin explicitly agreed than Zelensky would not be killed. Putin also agreed that Ukraine would not be required to disarm.
Zelensky agreed that Ukraine would not join NATO. The war broke out because Ukraine demanded to join NATO. So getting Zelensky to renounce this demand or goal was a big deal.
Earlier Ukraine had demanded a security guarantee, from France, the USA and Britain. Russia would have viewed such a guarantee the same as Ukraine joining NATO. It was a deal breaker.
Bennett told Zelensky, do you really think the USA is going to guarantee your security, say, 7 years from now? After it left Afghanistan with its tail between its legs? He encouraged Zelensky to look at Israel. It has a strong, independent military and can protect itself. Ukraine can do the same. Forget about the guarantees and build a strong military. As a result of Bennett's persuasion, Zelensky was willing to give up a security guarantee.
So there was a breakthrough. Both sides accepted this.
Then Bucha happened. (Details of the deaths of civilians in Bucha hit social media.) "I said it's over. I (still) saw solutions in that regard, that I don't want to go into. They're primarily related to postponing the argument by 99 years. "(In other words, he wasn't ready to give up.).
Bennett gave peace negotiations a 50% chance of success. Both sides very much wanted a ceasefire. Putin gave up denazification and Ukrainian disarmament. He did not want to continue at all costs. Yes, people can put on an act of course. But Bennett didn't think he was. And Zelensky had renounced joining NATO.
Boris Johnson adopted the aggressive line. (Boris wanted the war to continue.) The other point of view is that both sides lose in a war. Macron and Scholz were of (that kind of) more pragmatic view. Biden was in between.
There was a decision by the West to keep striking Putin, to take the more aggressive approach.
Everything I did was coordinated down to the last detail with the USA, France, Germany. They blocked it. I thought they were wrong. In retrospect though it's too soon to know. The downside of continuing the war was that there would be more Ukrainian and Russian casualties. This was a huge blow to Ukraine. Infrastructure was destroyed. There will have to be a Marshall Plan to rebuild it. Energy costs went up. Food exports to the Middle East and Africa were affected for a time. On the other hand, Biden created an alliance, that can reflect on other areas, like China and Taiwan. (In other words, he's saying western support for Ukraine may serve as a warning to other countries not to engage in something similar, like a Chinese takeover of Taiwan.).
There was a good chance of reaching a ceasefire if they (western powers) had not curbed it. But I'm not claiming it (blocking a ceasefire) was the wrong thing. In real time I thought the right thing was a ceasefire. Now I can't say. Maybe a ceasefire would have conveyed the wrong message to other countries. (Tiny's note: Is Bennett sincere, or is his statement colored by Israel's dependence on the USA?)
At the interview below:
"Denazification" of Ukraine should be understood as "prohibition of all neo-Nazi movements" and the need to "get rid of those people who leave this theory and practice in life and try to preserve it," Putin explained in an interview with Carlson. The President noted that this problem was discussed during the talks in Istanbul in the spring of 2022, an agreement was even reached to ban the cultivation of neo-Nazism in Ukraine, but Kyiv withdrew from the negotiation process.
Vladimir Putin, in an interview with Tucker Carlson, at the request of the American journalist, explained the meaning of the word "denazification" - this, according to him, is "the prohibition of all neo-Nazi movements. " The transcript of their conversation was published on the Kremlin website. The president repeated the thesis that Russia has not yet achieved the goals of the "military special operation"* in Ukraine.
Putin also explained the reasons why, in his opinion, denazification was necessary. The head of state noted that after the start of World War II, part of the "nationalistically minded elite" began collaborating with Adolf Hitler because they thought that he would "bring them freedom. " And although the shoots of nationalism are now being "crushed" in many countries, this is not happening in Ukraine: there, according to Putin, people who "destroyed Poles, Jews and Russians" were made into national heroes. "We need to get rid of those people who leave this theory and practice in life and try to preserve it. That is what denazification is. That is what we mean by it," the head of state emphasized.
Putin noted that denazification was one of the issues discussed during the negotiations in February-March 2022. According to him, during these negotiations an agreement was reached that "neo-Nazism will not be cultivated in Ukraine", it was to be prohibited at the legislative level. But as a result, Kyiv withdrew from the negotiation process, Ukraine "threw out all these agreements and accepted the instructions of Western countries under its salute", Putin concluded.
At the end of 2023, during a direct line and a large press conference, Putin said that peace in Ukraine would come after Russia achieved the goals of the "special operation". "These goals do not change", we are talking about denazification, demilitarization of Ukraine and its neutral status, Putin emphasized. He recalled that in 2022, Ukraine insisted during peace talks with Russia that there was "no fascism" in the country. "Well, how could there not be? When the national hero there is not just a nationalist, but a Nazi. Bandera, he is elevated to the rank of a national hero," he said on this matter. And he recalled that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, during a visit to Canada, stood up and greeted the former soldier of the SS Galicia Division, 98-year-old Yaroslav Hunka, who, according to Putin, "directly participated in the extermination of 1. 5 million Jews, Russians and Poles in Ukraine. " "Therefore, the issue of denazification is relevant," the president concluded.
After the start of the "special operation", the parties held several rounds of negotiations: the first three were held in Belarus in late February and early March, and the fourth on March 29,2022 in Istanbul. After that, the negotiation process was frozen. On May 14,2022, Putin said that the negotiation process was "effectively" suspended "by Kiev, which shows no interest in serious and constructive dialogue. " In September 2022, the President of Ukraine signed a decree that "states the impossibility of holding negotiations with the President of the Russian Federation V. Putin. ".
Putin gave an interview to Carlson on February 6. It was published at about 2:00 Moscow time on February 9 on the journalist's website. In the morning, as promised by the Russian president's press secretary Dmitry Peskov, it appeared on the Kremlin website, including in Russian.
The Rada has voted to extend Martial Law for 90 days. This means no elections and continuation of mobilization.
The Rada can at any time vote again to suspend Martial Law. Elections can't be held during ML as per the country's constitution as well as free debate and activity of opposition parties can't be sustained.
Continuation of mobilization means no ceasefire as it's a condition by Russia to implement one.
Presidential elections can be held as early as 60 days after the lift of ML, and elections to Rada as early as 90 days. This is the math for 2025.Ukrainians support Zelensky who has balls to resist to criminal Putin and senile stupid Trump. It would be easier for Putin, if no more Zelensky.
At the interview below:
"Denazification" of Ukraine should be understood as "prohibition of all neo-Nazi movements" and the need to "get rid of those people who leave this theory and practice in life and try to preserve it," Putin explained in an interview with Carlson. The President noted that this problem was discussed during the talks in Istanbul in the spring of 2022, an agreement was even reached to ban the cultivation of neo-Nazism in Ukraine, but Kyiv withdrew from the negotiation process.
Vladimir Putin, in an interview with Tucker Carlson, at the request of the American journalist, explained the meaning of the word "denazification" - this, according to him, is "the prohibition of all neo-Nazi movements. " The transcript of their conversation was published on the Kremlin website. The president repeated the thesis that Russia has not yet achieved the goals of the "military special operation"* in Ukraine...I'm sorry but basically nothing you wrote is true.
Putin never wanted a ceasefire.
There's a reason why the war never ends from the Russian side.
Putin never gave up his demands when it comes to his desire to dictate Ukrainian politics and the disarmament to Ukraine to the degree where they won't be able to defend their country.
It's obvious that Ukraine need concrete security guarantees and any deal without it is a carte blanche for Putin to continue his war crimes in Ukraine.
At the interview below:
"Denazification" of Ukraine should be understood as "prohibition of all neo-Nazi movements" and the need to "get rid of those people who leave this theory and practice in life and try to preserve it," Putin explained in an interview with Carlson. The President noted that this problem was discussed during the talks in Istanbul in the spring of 2022, an agreement was even reached to ban the cultivation of neo-Nazism in Ukraine, but Kyiv withdrew from the negotiation process.
Vladimir Putin, in an interview with Tucker Carlson, at the request of the American journalist, explained the meaning of the word "denazification" - this, according to him, is "the prohibition of all neo-Nazi movements. " The transcript of their conversation was published on the Kremlin website. The president repeated the thesis that Russia has not yet achieved the goals of the "military special operation"* in Ukraine.
Putin also explained the reasons why, in his opinion, denazification was necessary. The head of state noted that after the start of World War II, part of the "nationalistically minded elite" began collaborating with Adolf Hitler because they thought that he would "bring them freedom. " And although the shoots of nationalism are now being "crushed" in many countries, this is not happening in Ukraine: there, according to Putin, people who "destroyed Poles, Jews and Russians" were made into national heroes. "We need to get rid of those people who leave this theory and practice in life and try to preserve it. That is what denazification is. That is what we mean by it," the head of state emphasized.
Putin noted that denazification was one of the issues discussed during the negotiations in February-March 2022. According to him, during these negotiations an agreement was reached that "neo-Nazism will not be cultivated in Ukraine", it was to be prohibited at the legislative level. But as a result, Kyiv withdrew from the negotiation process, Ukraine "threw out all these agreements and accepted the instructions of Western countries under its salute", Putin concluded.
At the end of 2023, during a direct line and a large press conference, Putin said that peace in Ukraine would come after Russia achieved the goals of the "special operation". "These goals do not change", we are talking about denazification, demilitarization of Ukraine and its neutral status, Putin emphasized. He recalled that in 2022, Ukraine insisted during peace talks with Russia that there was "no fascism" in the country. "Well, how could there not be? When the national hero there is not just a nationalist, but a Nazi. Bandera, he is elevated to the rank of a national hero," he said on this matter. And he recalled that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, during a visit to Canada, stood up and greeted the former soldier of the SS Galicia Division, 98-year-old Yaroslav Hunka, who, according to Putin, "directly participated in the extermination of 1. 5 million Jews, Russians and Poles in Ukraine. " "Therefore, the issue of denazification is relevant," the president concluded.
After the start of the "special operation", the parties held several rounds of negotiations: the first three were held in Belarus in late February and early March, and the fourth on March 29,2022 in Istanbul. After that, the negotiation process was frozen. On May 14,2022, Putin said that the negotiation process was "effectively" suspended "by Kiev, which shows no interest in serious and constructive dialogue. " In September 2022, the President of Ukraine signed a decree that "states the impossibility of holding negotiations with the President of the Russian Federation V. Putin. ".
Putin gave an interview to Carlson on February 6. It was published at about 2:00 Moscow time on February 9 on the journalist's website. In the morning, as promised by the Russian president's press secretary Dmitry Peskov, it appeared on the Kremlin website, including in Russian.Thanks for the explanation of denazification Questner. It makes a lot more sense than the Israeli Prime Minister's.
In the course of the interview, the PM mentioned going to Germany, to visit Olaf Scholz. Bennett was conducting shuttle diplomacy. He said he made a vow to never visit Germany, because of the atrocities committed by the Nazis on Jews during World War II. But he made an exception for the cause of peace.
From memory (I haven't gone back and listened to the audio again), Bennett said something like "the only way to deal with a Nazi of course is to kill him. " That would reflect his abhorrence and anger, at what the Nazis inflicted on Jews and others. Said another way, "The only good Nazi is a dead Nazi." I suspect he equated denazification with killing "Nazis" in the Ukrainian leadership based on his prejudices, not on what Putin told him.
And before one of our fellow board members jumps down my throat, I'm not calling Zelensky a Nazi.
Thanks for the explanation of denazification Questner. It makes a lot more sense than the Israeli Prime Minister's.
In the course of the interview, the PM mentioned going to Germany, to visit Olaf Scholz. Bennett was conducting shuttle diplomacy. He said he made a vow to never visit Germany, because of the atrocities committed by the Nazis on Jews during World War II. But he made an exception for the cause of peace.
From memory (I haven't gone back and listened to the audio again), Bennett said something like "the only way to deal with a Nazi of course is to kill him. " That would reflect his abhorrence and anger, at what the Nazis inflicted on Jews and others. Said another way, "The only good Nazi is a dead Nazi." I suspect he equated denazification with killing "Nazis" in the Ukrainian leadership based on his prejudices, not on what Putin told him.
And before one of our fellow board members jumps down my throat, I'm not calling Zelensky a Nazi.Like Yehud Barak Bennett might be lucky in his military service but not so skillful as a politician. His revelation of buying a book and seeking advice from National Security Council on the atrocities of the WWII says it all about him. He did the right thing with respect to Israelis and Jews in Ukraine however did not admit he was played in the dark as 'more serious intermediary'.
The interview translation does not follow exactly the role of Biden as presented by Bennett. Bennett basically says Biden was in support of the continuation of the war.
On Bucha: Until Ukrainian side comes with names of the civilians who lost their lives under the circumstances as they were described I would continue to see it as staged propaganda operation.
There were two types of civilian deaths all very tragic: territorial defence and collateral losses. Personally I did my inquiry on the morgues records with names, addresses and ages and added them into a geo location map.
There are also speculations about the longevity of Mr. Zelensky but I can't verify them. He did and said publicly enough to be sure he is gone.
Any association with the nazi collaborators and their ideas and legacy is beyond the pale. Just to give you a very minor hint in comparison: How would you feel if the next US administration topples the monuments on the Arlington Cemetery and renames the streets around World Trade Center in NY in memory of the binladen crew?
Looks like Trump is ready to walk away from this whole mess created by America itself. The dictator with no cards Zelensky has rejected the American peace proposal, the Russians seem to be ok with it.
I hope Trump makes good on his threat and walks away. This should mean no aid or support to Ukraine. IF that happens, expect a collapse of the Ukrainian front lines in the future. And IF that happens, expect the Russians to not just take 4 Oblasts (including Crimea) but 4 more.
Zelensky is a curse for Ukraine.
Looks like Trump is ready to walk away from this whole mess created by America itself. The dictator with no cards Zelensky has rejected the American peace proposal, the Russians seem to be ok with it.
I hope Trump makes good on his threat and walks away. This should mean no aid or support to Ukraine. IF that happens, expect a collapse of the Ukrainian front lines in the future. And IF that happens, expect the Russians to not just take 4 Oblasts (including Crimea) but 4 more.
Zelensky is a curse for Ukraine.You are an idiot.
Looks like Trump is ready to walk away from this whole mess created by America itself. The dictator with no cards Zelensky has rejected the American peace proposal, the Russians seem to be ok with it.
I hope Trump makes good on his threat and walks away. This should mean no aid or support to Ukraine. IF that happens, expect a collapse of the Ukrainian front lines in the future. And IF that happens, expect the Russians to not just take 4 Oblasts (including Crimea) but 4 more.
Zelensky is a curse for Ukraine.One of the opinions is that the US wants to save face by walking away. The Ukrainian project that benefited the MIC and LNG and harmed absolutely everybody and everything else is now failing and its time to fold. Every sane stakeholder would prefer to end the hostilities. Trump is right when he says this war would not have happened should he be the POTUS. Trump would never have armed, financed and charged the AFU into the conflict. Just recently Ukraine failed to reach a deal with holders of $2. 6 billion in debt during talks in Washington this week. If no agreement is reached, the country faces default. Without financial aid and military support from the US Ukraine will eventually face a collapse even if it takes 1 to 2 years.
Looks like Trump is ready to walk away from this whole mess created by America itself. The dictator with no cards Zelensky has rejected the American peace proposal, the Russians seem to be ok with it.
I hope Trump makes good on his threat and walks away. This should mean no aid or support to Ukraine. IF that happens, expect a collapse of the Ukrainian front lines in the future. And IF that happens, expect the Russians to not just take 4 Oblasts (including Crimea) but 4 more.
Zelensky is a curse for Ukraine.Ukrainians, even those who didn t vote for him, support Zelensky who has balls to resist versus criminal dictator Putin who killed so many Russians with his personnal war, and stupid shameful robber Trump who just want to rob Ukraine. All my support to Ukrainians who were already stolen Crimea which did belong to Ukraine in 1991 , when Putin was nothing in KGB at this time.
One of the opinions is that the US wants to save face by walking away. The Ukrainian project that benefited the MIC and LNG and harmed absolutely everybody and everything else is now failing and its time to fold. Every sane stakeholder would prefer to end the hostilities. Trump is right when he says this war would not have happened should he be the POTUS. Trump would never have armed, financed and charged the AFU into the conflict. Just recently Ukraine failed to reach a deal with holders of $2. 6 billion in debt during talks in Washington this week. If no agreement is reached, the country faces default. Without financial aid and military support from the US Ukraine will eventually face a collapse even if it takes 1 to 2 years.Trump is just so senile, when his administration refused in 2018, only 7 years ago, Crimea robbery by Putin, but his too old neurons forgot. Old senile shameful for USA.
One of the opinions is that the US wants to save face by walking away. The Ukrainian project that benefited the MIC and LNG and harmed absolutely everybody and everything else is now failing and its time to fold. Every sane stakeholder would prefer to end the hostilities. Trump is right when he says this war would not have happened should he be the POTUS. Trump would never have armed, financed and charged the AFU into the conflict. Just recently Ukraine failed to reach a deal with holders of $2. 6 billion in debt during talks in Washington this week. If no agreement is reached, the country faces default. Without financial aid and military support from the US Ukraine will eventually face a collapse even if it takes 1 to 2 years.It's important to understand that putin is a war dictator. During putins dictatorship he has steadily had at least one war ongoing. There's no hope of russia living in peace during putins dictatorship.
I'm extremely thankful that Biden was the president and not the corrupt Donald trump who's most likely controlled by Russia.
Not only would putin have started the war against Ukraine, Russia would have received help from trump.
There's no end in sight to this war. Putin may short terms victories thanks to his control over trump; but they won't last.
Trump's living on borrowed time just like putin and Russia.
Putin isn't interested in peace and he's even less interested in having hundreds of thousands soldiers back in russia. If the war in Ukraine ends putin will just start a new one.
Looks like Trump is ready to walk away from this whole mess created by America itself. The dictator with no cards Zelensky has rejected the American peace proposal, the Russians seem to be ok with it.
I hope Trump makes good on his threat and walks away. This should mean no aid or support to Ukraine. IF that happens, expect a collapse of the Ukrainian front lines in the future. And IF that happens, expect the Russians to not just take 4 Oblasts (including Crimea) but 4 more.
Zelensky is a curse for Ukraine.You mean the mess created by russia and their dictator Vladimir putin.
Putin must have at least one active war during his bloody dictatorship.
Putins love for war is a curse for russia and all of Europe to be completely honest.
Only if putin loses his war in Ukraine can russia win. Regular russians and the russian economy will continue to suffer even (especially) if their dictator achieves his goals in Ukraine.
Did you ever consider Putin should pay a price for his atrocities? Or would you just prefer to be on good business terms with any warlord in the workd?
You are an idiot.And you are Slim Pickens.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snTaSJk0n_Y
Pickens, also known as Major Kong, is the guy in the cowboy hat riding the bomb. Not to give away the plot but he's smack dab over Mother Russia and about to set off a bomb that leads to nuclear Armageddon.
I've decided you're a better candidate for the Slim Pickens award than Paulie97. Sorry Paulie.
Like Yehud Barak Bennett might be lucky in his military service but not so skillful as a politician. His revelation of buying a book and seeking advice from National Security Council on the atrocities of the WWII says it all about him. He did the right thing with respect to Israelis and Jews in Ukraine however did not admit he was played in the dark as 'more serious intermediary'.
The interview translation does not follow exactly the role of Biden as presented by Bennett. Bennett basically says Biden was in support of the continuation of the war.
On Bucha: Until Ukrainian side comes with names of the civilians who lost their lives under the circumstances as they were described I would continue to see it as staged propaganda operation.
There were two types of civilian deaths all very tragic: territorial defence and collateral losses. Personally I did my inquiry on the morgues records with names, addresses and ages and added them into a geo location map.
There are also speculations about the longevity of Mr. Zelensky but I can't verify them. He did and said publicly enough to be sure he is gone.
Any association with the nazi collaborators and their ideas and legacy is beyond the pale. Just to give you a very minor hint in comparison: How would you feel if the next US administration topples the monuments on the Arlington Cemetery and renames the streets around World Trade Center in NY in memory of the binladen crew?A better analogy would be memorials to Confederate War Heroes. In 1861, southern states in the USA seceded from the country and formed a new government, called the Confederacy. One of its aims was to maintain the institution of slavery. Many cities in the South have or had statues and the like, honoring men who served in the Confederate army.
There used to be a school in a city where I lived, called Robert E. Lee Elementary School. Robert E. Lee was the top general of the Confederacy. There was a movement to change the name of the school. I thought that was a great idea. How would you like to be a black kid, attending a school named for someone who fought to keep your ancestors enslaved? Well, there were a lot of people in the community who disagreed. Two of them ostracized me because I wouldn't sign their petition to keep the name.
But is that sufficient reason for a war? Admittedly I'm a pacifist, but I don't think so. NATO's continued encroachment to the east and the borderline persecution of some Russian speakers in eastern Ukraine would be much stronger arguments.
As to Bucha, regardless of whether it was real, shit happens. It happened to Vietnamese at the hands of Americans at My Lai. Americans gunned down women, children and old men. They raped some of the women first. The alleged death tolls at Bucha and My Lai were similar.
That doesn't change the fact that not that many civilians have died in the Ukraine War. The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights puts the total 12,910 through March 31,2025 for Ukraine. The UN put the total at 45,000 Palestinians in Gaza as of December, 2024. There were about 18 X more people in Ukraine than there were in Gaza before the wars. And the war in Ukraine has been going on longer. The UN believes their estimates are low, for both places. But still it's hard for me to believe that the Russian leadership is targeting civilians, in Bucha or elsewhere. By the numbers, Israel obviously has a lot less respect for the lives of noncombatants than Russia.
Newton York
04-26-25, 05:03
It used to be that stupid shit in Kyiv was about bad taxi drivers or girls not being nice to you, or scams in the city, etc. Now it's all politics here. War, politics, war and then more politics. I'm sad about this. Dudes, come on man. Let's talk about pussy. Ukraine chicks. Hot Ukraine chicks!
A better analogy would be memorials to Confederate War Heroes. In 1861, southern states in the USA seceded from the country and formed a new government, called the Confederacy. One of its aims was to maintain the institution of slavery. Many cities in the South have or had statues and the like, honoring men who served in the Confederate army.
There used to be a school in a city where I lived, called Robert E. Lee Elementary School. Robert E. Lee was the top general of the Confederacy. There was a movement to change the name of the school. I thought that was a great idea. How would you like to be a black kid, attending a school named for someone who fought to keep your ancestors enslaved? Well, there were a lot of people in the community who disagreed. Two of them ostracized me because I wouldn't sign their petition to keep the name.
But is that sufficient reason for a war? Admittedly I'm a pacifist, but I don't think so. NATO's continued encroachment to the east and the borderline persecution of some Russian speakers in eastern Ukraine would be much stronger arguments.
As to Bucha, regardless of whether it was real, shit happens. It happened to Vietnamese at the hands of Americans at My Lai. Americans gunned down women, children and old men. They raped some of the women first. The alleged death tolls at Bucha and My Lai were similar.
That doesn't change the fact that not that many civilians have died in the Ukraine War. The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights puts the total 12,910 through March 31,2025 for Ukraine. The UN put the total at 45,000 Palestinians in Gaza as of December, 2024. There were about 18 X more people in Ukraine than there were in Gaza before the wars. And the war in Ukraine has been going on longer. The UN believes their estimates are low, for both places. But still it's hard for me to believe that the Russian leadership is targeting civilians, in Bucha or elsewhere. By the numbers, Israel obviously has a lot less respect for the lives of noncombatants than Russia.Why do you pretend that Volodymyr Zelensky, a Jewish Ukrainian, is a nazi?
I'm glad however that you are finally out of the closet as a pro-Putin, pro-Russia, pro-disinformation and pro-war troll.
There are more nazis in russia than in Ukraine, it's a fact. European neo-nazist even travelled to russia for training camps together with the russian nazis.
So no, there's no basis for your shameless lies.
What excuse are you going to give for putins war against Georgia? Are the Georgians also nazis?
You're running out of excuses, but your credibility is already long gone.
Putin is a war criminal that's actively targeting Ukrainian civilians and children. There's no way any human can defend that, but you defend it.
You have zero regard for Ukrainian lives.
You, putin and russia have murdered at least 60'000 Ukrainians.
A better analogy would be memorials to Confederate War Heroes. In 1861, southern states in the USA seceded from the country and formed a new government, called the Confederacy. One of its aims was to maintain the institution of slavery. Many cities in the South have or had statues and the like, honoring men who served in the Confederate army.
There used to be a school in a city where I lived, called Robert E. Lee Elementary School. Robert E. Lee was the top general of the Confederacy. There was a movement to change the name of the school. I thought that was a great idea. How would you like to be a black kid, attending a school named for someone who fought to keep your ancestors enslaved? Well, there were a lot of people in the community who disagreed. Two of them ostracized me because I wouldn't sign their petition to keep the name.
But is that sufficient reason for a war? Admittedly I'm a pacifist, but I don't think so. NATO's continued encroachment to the east and the borderline persecution of some Russian speakers in eastern Ukraine would be much stronger arguments.
As to Bucha, regardless of whether it was real, shit happens. It happened to Vietnamese at the hands of Americans at My Lai. Americans gunned down women, children and old men. They raped some of the women first. The alleged death tolls at Bucha and My Lai were similar.
That doesn't change the fact that not that many civilians have died in the Ukraine War. The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights puts the total 12,910 through March 31,2025 for Ukraine. The UN put the total at 45,000 Palestinians in Gaza as of December, 2024. There were about 18 X more people in Ukraine than there were in Gaza before the wars. And the war in Ukraine has been going on longer. The UN believes their estimates are low, for both places. But still it's hard for me to believe that the Russian leadership is targeting civilians, in Bucha or elsewhere. By the numbers, Israel obviously has a lot less respect for the lives of noncombatants than Russia.Let me tell you what my close friend was told by his ethnic russian relatives living in one of the occupied Ukrainian territories; Russians were not persecuted by Ukraine, but are afraid of putin, Russia and their unprovoked violence against Ukraine and civilians residing in Ukraine.
They do not want to be a part of putins dictatorship, and today they see no chance of ever being a part of a democratic russia in a humane way.
Let me be extremely clear, these are people that lived safely in a democratic Ukraine but now is forced to live in a war zone and they never know what will be putin's next genocidal move. Putin do not protect them, he puts them in danger. In fact, he has killed several ethnic russian Ukrainians.
One of the opinions is that the US wants to save face by walking away. The Ukrainian project that benefited the MIC and LNG and harmed absolutely everybody and everything else is now failing and its time to fold. Every sane stakeholder would prefer to end the hostilities. Trump is right when he says this war would not have happened should he be the POTUS. Trump would never have armed, financed and charged the AFU into the conflict. Just recently Ukraine failed to reach a deal with holders of $2. 6 billion in debt during talks in Washington this week. If no agreement is reached, the country faces default. Without financial aid and military support from the US Ukraine will eventually face a collapse even if it takes 1 to 2 years.You may very well be correct in saying that the United States just wants to save face and find an excuse to walk away. Trump has already said a few times that this is Biden's war, meaning he started it, and yes that is correct. But now it's Trump's war and he has to figure out what he is going to do.
I am on record saying here that this will be decided on the battlefield, with the Russians taking much more territory than what they currently hold and a collapse of the AFU. If Trump makes good on his vow to walk away and that means cutting off funding to Ukraine (that would make sense), then that is a very likely outcome.
The Russians will win an ugly victory and Ukraine will lose more territory. I would be happy if both sides accept the deal currently offered by Trump but I don't it's going to happen. I really hope I'm wrong. For Ukraine's sake.
John Clayton
04-26-25, 20:14
...I am on record saying here that this will be decided on the battlefield, with the Russians taking much more territory than what they currently hold and a collapse of the AFU. If Trump makes good on his vow to walk away and that means cutting off funding to Ukraine (that would make sense), then that is a very likely outcome...I am on record saying Putin will be killed by his generals, the Russian army will collapse and rapidly abandon Crimea.
...I would be happy if both sides accept the deal currently offered by Trump but I don't it's going to happen. I really hope I'm wrong. For Ukraine's sake.There are a lot of other people who hope the for the same, on both sides. Especially the grunts on the front lines:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uk8XJNn9Xtg
Let me tell you what my close friend was told by his ethnic russian relatives living in one of the occupied Ukrainian territories; Russians were not persecuted by Ukraine, but are afraid of putin, Russia and their unprovoked violence against Ukraine and civilians residing in Ukraine.
They do not want to be a part of putins dictatorship, and today they see no chance of ever being a part of a democratic russia in a humane way.
Let me be extremely clear, these are people that lived safely in a democratic Ukraine but now is forced to live in a war zone and they never know what will be putin's next genocidal move. Putin do not protect them, he puts them in danger. In fact, he has killed several ethnic russian Ukrainians.And this is what my colleague wrote to me in an email in July of last year.
This is a message I got today from a western business associate who worked in the FSU for a couple of decades. It's about one of his business partners who was originally from the Donbas. I've omitted places and names so I don't "out" myself or him.
*****s extended family, Aunts and Uncles and cousins live in (Name of city and area in Donbas) under the jack-boot of the Ukrainian Army and last time I heard feed-back about six months ago, they were fearing for their lives daily. Skin-heads patrol the streets and pistol whip any dissenters. They are afraid to speak Russian as they have a mixed Russian and Cossack heritage. *****s aunt and uncles and cousins have been living in their respective basements for a few years now, one cousin died of a heart attack last year (only 30 years old). ***** was devastated, it's all very sad for Ukrainians to be thrust into a major war with one of the most effective yet brutal armies historically and the west pouring weapons in, to 'save Ukraine just increases the misery of the people who can't do much as they don't live in a democracy as we understand it.
Reading is fundamental ShooBree.
Why do you pretend that Volodymyr Zelensky, a Jewish Ukrainian, is a nazi?Please note below.
...And before one of our fellow board members jumps down my throat, I'm not calling Zelensky a Nazi.
I'm glad however that you are finally out of the closet as a pro-Putin, pro-Russia, pro-disinformation and pro-war troll.
There are more nazis in russia than in Ukraine, it's a fact. European neo-nazist even travelled to russia for training camps together with the russian nazis.
So no, there's no basis for your shameless lies.Perhaps you'd like to point towards those shameless lies. I said denazification is NOT sufficient reason for a war. I can see why a monument to a leader of an organization that exterminated Polish and Jewish civilians in large numbers would grate on people though.
What excuse are you going to give for putins war against Georgia? Are the Georgians also nazis?
You're running out of excuses, but your credibility is already long gone.
Putin is a war criminal that's actively targeting Ukrainian civilians and children. There's no way any human can defend that, but you defend it.
You have zero regard for Ukrainian lives.I have a much higher regard for Ukrainian lives than you do. My constant message in this forum for the last couple of years has been that this is a stupid war and the powers involved need to end it, so people can stop dying.
Your claim that Putin's targeting Ukrainian civilians and children is bull shit. The numbers don't bear you out. Please see my comparison between civilian deaths in Ukraine and Gaza below in a reply to Questner, post #4271. Roosevelt and Churchill did target civilians and children in large numbers, when they carpet bombed Germany and Japan. There were single days when they killed more civilians than Russians killed during the entire Ukrainian war.
If you're going to adopt a very loose definition of "targeting", then maybe you have a case. But then wasn't George W. Bush orders of magnitude worse than Putin? Over 4 million people have died in post 9/11 wars by one estimate.
You...have murdered at least 60'000 Ukrainians.Get a grip ShoBree. You're not logical when you're hysterical. You might want to look at some of Paulie's posts on logic in this thread, although you'll have to wade through a ton of neoconservative clap trap to find them. I'm a poster on a hooker board. I'm not the Almighty. And like I said.
...I'm a pacifist...
I am on record saying Putin will be killed by his generals, the Russian army will collapse and rapidly abandon Crimea.OK, I'll go on record too, saying the clouds are made of cotton candy and the sky is a sea of dreams.
I am on record saying Putin will be killed by his generals, the Russian army will collapse and rapidly abandon Crimea.It will be best for Russians and our world, if we could be gotten rid of criminal dictator Putin. Unfortunately, stupid Trump wants to give him Donbass and Crimea, forgotting what he said in 2018 . Just senile and now robber.
I am on record saying Putin will be killed by his generals, the Russian army will collapse and rapidly abandon Crimea.Well, you're a dumbass, so you going on record doesn't mean jack shit.
Regards,
Blood Red.
Newton York
04-27-25, 01:42
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C7ylnQBRa28
Vladimir Putin was informed about the defeat of the Ukrainian Armed Forces: Kursk region is liberated, the army is moving to Sumy.
The last village in Kursk Oblast has been cleared of Ukrainian soldiers, the Ukrainian operation has finally failed.
The fighting on Russian soil cost the AFU dearly. Kyiv brought in 60,000 men. They were completely ground to pieces in six months. The Ukrainian Armed Forces suffered no less heavy losses in military equipment.
76 thousand people. Losses killed and wounded. 7,700 units of military equipment were destroyed, including 412 tanks, 340 infantry fighting vehicles, 314 armored personnel carriers, 2,300 other armored combat vehicles.
- I would like to separately note the participation of the DPRK military personnel in the liberation of the border areas of the Kursk region. Soldiers and officers of the Korean People's Army, performing combat missions shoulder to shoulder with Russian military personnel, demonstrated high professionalism, showed fortitude, courage and heroism in battle, - The Chief of the General Staff.
Gerasimov reported. At the same time, the general emphasized that the participation of Korean soldiers is fully consistent with international standards. After all, the countries have a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership Treaty, which entered into force on December 4, 2024.
So, we have expected the above results around end of December or early January but it took longer.
John Clayton
04-27-25, 05:23
Vladimir Putin was informed about the defeat of the Ukrainian Armed Forces: Kursk region is liberated, the army is moving to Sumy...Ukraine says they're still there...
Ukraine says they're still there...And you believe it. Dumbass. LOL.
If you knew absolutely anything about the conflict and have followed it over the years, you'd know that Ukraine never admits a loss until a long time afterwards. Like with Bakhmut, Avdivka, etc etc. They admitted they were driven out months later.
Vladimir Putin was informed about the defeat of the Ukrainian Armed Forces: Kursk region is liberated, the army is moving to Sumy.
The last village in Kursk Oblast has been cleared of Ukrainian soldiers, the Ukrainian operation has finally failed.
The fighting on Russian soil cost the AFU dearly. Kyiv brought in 60,000 men. They were completely ground to pieces in six months. The Ukrainian Armed Forces suffered no less heavy losses in military equipment.
76 thousand people. Losses killed and wounded. 7,700 units of military equipment were destroyed, including 412 tanks, 340 infantry fighting vehicles, 314 armored personnel carriers, 2,300 other armored combat vehicles.
- I would like to separately note the participation of the DPRK military personnel in the liberation of the border areas of the Kursk region. Soldiers and officers of the Korean People's Army, performing combat missions shoulder to shoulder with Russian military personnel, demonstrated high professionalism, showed fortitude, courage and heroism in battle, - The Chief of the General Staff.
Gerasimov reported. At the same time, the general emphasized that the participation of Korean soldiers is fully consistent with international standards. After all, the countries have a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership Treaty, which entered into force on December 4, 2024.
So, we have expected the above results around end of December or early January but it took longer.Another failure for the Nazi Kiev regime. I said at the start that this was a huge blunder and only for optics. And Zelensky was going to use this as a bargaining chip, that sure turned out nicely. Now he wants to send 18 year olds to the front line. What an enormous tragedy.
Newton York
04-29-25, 02:43
While we're here talking about Kyiv. Which do you think is worse?
Being in an actual prison, like in Bangkok's Bang Kwang. Or the metaphorical prison of being trapped in a shitty job in the States?
One is literally prison, but it's in beautiful Thailand. While the other is not actually prison, but sure as hell feels like it. Especially with the asshole co-workers. Life is tough dudes. Fucking tough *sigh*.
'Our position on the agreement is well known. We proceed from the fact that Kiev's non-membership in NATO and confirmation of its neutral and non-aligned status in accordance with the 1990 Declaration of State Sovereignty of Ukraine is one of the two pillars for a final settlement of the Ukrainian crisis that meets Russia's security interests. The second is to overcome the consequences of the neo-Nazi regime in Kiev, formed as a result of the February 2014 coup, including its actions to legislatively and physically exterminate everything Russian — language, media, culture, traditions, and canonical Orthodoxy.
International recognition of Russia's ownership of Crimea, Sevastopol, Donetsk People's Republic, Lugansk People's Republic, Kherson Oblast and Zaporizhia is imperative. All of Kiev's commitments must be legally enforceable, have enforcement mechanisms and be permanent. On the agenda are the tasks of demilitarizing and denazifying Ukraine, lifting sanctions, lawsuits and arrest warrants, and returning Russian assets "frozen" in the West. We will also seek reliable guarantees of the security of the Russian Federation against the threats posed by the hostile activities of NATO, the European Union and its individual member states on our western borders. '.
Full interview here:
https://oglobo.globo.com/mundo/noticia/2025/04/28/a-bola-nao-esta-do-nosso-lado-diz-lavrov-sobre-negociacao-com-ucrania.ghtml
Another failure for the Nazi Kiev regime. I said at the start that this was a huge blunder and only for optics. And Zelensky was going to use this as a bargaining chip, that sure turned out nicely. Now he wants to send 18 year olds to the front line. What an enormous tragedy.Ukrainians are nazis? And Putin is best for human rights?
Reiner Otto
04-29-25, 16:59
It will be best for Russians and our world, if we could be gotten rid of criminal dictator Putin. Unfortunately, stupid Trump wants to give him Donbass and Crimea, forgotting what he said in 2018 . Just senile and now robber.Simplest and fastest and cheapest solution to end the war: Put a "contract" on Putler, just 1 Billion Dollars should do the trick.
Said it already 2 years ago.
Just take the money from the frozen assets.
Simplest and fastest and cheapest solution to end the war: Put a "contract" on Putler, just 1 Billion Dollars should do the trick.
Said it already 2 years ago.
Just take the money from the frozen assets.Good solution and Russians would be more free and could live with their brothers Ukrainians. Problem is Trump is too stupid and preferred to suck him and wants to rob poor Ukrainians.
'Our position on the agreement is well known. We proceed from the fact that Kiev's non-membership in NATO and confirmation of its neutral and non-aligned status in accordance with the 1990 Declaration of State Sovereignty of Ukraine is one of the two pillars for a final settlement of the Ukrainian crisis that meets Russia's security interests. The second is to overcome the consequences of the neo-Nazi regime in Kiev, formed as a result of the February 2014 coup, including its actions to legislatively and physically exterminate everything Russian language, media, culture, traditions, and canonical Orthodoxy.
International recognition of Russia's ownership of Crimea, Sevastopol, Donetsk People's Republic, Lugansk People's Republic, Kherson Oblast and Zaporizhia is imperative. All of Kiev's commitments must be legally enforceable, have enforcement mechanisms and be permanent. On the agenda are the tasks of demilitarizing and denazifying Ukraine, lifting sanctions, lawsuits and arrest warrants, and returning Russian assets "frozen" in the West. We will also seek reliable guarantees of the security of the Russian Federation against the threats posed by the hostile activities of NATO, the European Union and its individual member states on our western borders.In other words; the war will continue.
There won't be any international recognition, the Russian assets are now Ukrainian assets and the sanctions from the EU won't disappear.
How can Russia pretend to be the victim when they have nuclear weapons and always start wars against their peaceful neighbors, like Ukraine and Georgia.
They seem to live in a post truth society where every day is April fool's day.
I love how the Russian regime is crying about Russian culture in Ukraine when Putin killed the future of Russian culture in Ukraine. You don't exactly win the Ukrainian people's hearts and minds by murdering their children.
Newton York
05-03-25, 02:08
This war is getting out of hand. I don't understand why Russia is targeting Spain and Portugals power grid. This is getting scary guys.
Russia invaded Ukraine during the previous administration as they simply watched, played cheer leader, sent the money entrusted to them to others when it would be better spent on my fellow Americans. Trump has been in office for just over 100 days. Give the man at least as long as the previous administration has to effectively do something.
During this period of time France has not put boots on the ground to help the Ukrainians!
Good solution and Russians would be more free and could live with their brothers Ukrainians. Problem is Trump is too stupid and preferred to suck him and wants to rob poor Ukrainians.
Elvis 2008
05-03-25, 16:12
In other words; the war will continue.
There won't be any international recognition, the Russian assets are now Ukrainian assets and the sanctions from the EU won't disappear.
How can Russia pretend to be the victim when they have nuclear weapons and always start wars against their peaceful neighbors, like Ukraine and Georgia.It is pretty funny about how Europe is saying Russia being in Ukraine is so intolerable to Europe. The scam here is the same as almost every war has been since WW2, something akin to the domino theory. If we do not stop them in Ukraine, they could be breathing down the necks of Germany in no time.
What is so stupid is from 1945 to 1989, Russia was already in East Germany.
And they are supposed to give up their nuclear weapons is a new one. Really? Yeah, well, you are right. If that is a question of peace, the Russians can and should keep fighting.
The irony of the domino theory is that NATO did in fact expand until they were right on the Russian border and worse than that with NATO help, Ukraine actually invaded Russia. That the Russians want to keep a buffer zone and their nukes seems rational to me given all that has gone on.
Ukrainians are nazis? Some are yes, and they are a big part of the government. I guess you've not heard of the Azov battalion.
This war is getting out of hand. I don't understand why Russia is targeting Spain and Portugals power grid. This is getting scary guys.You're sounding like some of the Russophobes here Newton. They were sure that Russia sabotaged the Nord Stream pipelines transporting its own gas. Ridiculous.
The power outage in Spain was caused by overreliance on solar and wind energy and underinvestment in the grid.
You're sounding like some of the Russophobes here Newton. They were sure that Russia sabotaged the Nord Stream pipelines transporting its own gas. Ridiculous.
My favorite lie was that the Russians were bombing the Zaporzhia nuclear power plant, which they control. So basically the Russians were bombing themselves. Amazing.
Oh yeah the Russians are running out of missiles. The Russians are fighting with shovels too.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQgr3De1AUQ
Posted today a unique interview with the President covering 25 years. Use Setting to generate captions. The translation has mistakes but generally tolerable. It's a long watch but highly recommended.
Some are yes, and they are a big part of the government. I guess you've not heard of the Azov battalion.Ukrainians never attacked Russia, not even after Crimea robbery, when criminal dictator Putin attacked Ukraine. These are real facts and so many Russians killed because of only Putin.
Ukrainians never attacked Russia, not even after Crimea robbery, when criminal dictator Putin attacked Ukraine. These are real facts and so many Russians killed because of only Putin.Crimea has always been Russian and the Crimean people voted to join Russia. I thought you folks in the collective west believe in democracy? Or do you only accept referendums that you yourself conduct and accepts the results you like, like the one in Kosovo?
Crimea has always been Russian and the Crimean people voted to join Russia. I thought you folks in the collective west believe in democracy? Or do you only accept referendums that you yourself conduct and accepts the results you like, like the one in Kosovo?Wasn t Crimea belonging to Ukraine since 1991 , when Putin was nothing then. Putin didn t respect what he signed in Minsk and fucked elections, so, same level of democracy than in Russia, killing challengers. He also tried to fuck elections in Georgia, Moldavia, Romania. For sure, Putin level of democrat, when a real criminal and dictator. Russians are too blind, when Putin is their worst disease. Opinion of somebody who love Russia, so I can only hate Putin who dirty Russia. Same for Trump in USA.
John Clayton
05-06-25, 06:13
Crimea has always been Russian and the Crimean people voted to join Russia. I thought you folks in the collective west believe in democracy? Or do you only accept referendums that you yourself conduct and accepts the results you like, like the one in Kosovo?This is pure Russian propaganda and disinformation. The history of Crimea is a complex; however, a unifying theme has been Russian imperialism attempting to gain total control over the last 250 years. Crimea was only demoted to an oblast in 1945 following the ethnic cleansing (by the Russians) of the Crimean Tatars in 1945. The Russians have wanted Crimea for centuries, but it has never been Russian.
Crimea has always been Russian and the Crimean people voted to join Russia. I thought you folks in the collective west believe in democracy? Or do you only accept referendums that you yourself conduct and accepts the results you like, like the one in Kosovo?Crimea as well as present territory of Kherson region became Russian in April of 1783.
As well,
Field Marshal Alexander Suvorov crossed the Swiss Alps between September 11 and October 7, 1799. This was part of his Swiss campaign during the War of the Second Coalition, where his Russo-Austrian forces attempted to drive the French out of Switzerland. His army faced extreme hardships, including fierce battles and treacherous terrain, but managed to escape encirclement.
Crimea as well as present territory of Kherson region became Russian in April of 1783.
As well,
Field Marshal Alexander Suvorov crossed the Swiss Alps between September 11 and October 7, 1799. This was part of his Swiss campaign during the War of the Second Coalition, where his Russo-Austrian forces attempted to drive the French out of Switzerland. His army faced extreme hardships, including fierce battles and treacherous terrain, but managed to escape encirclement.Crimea did belong to Ukraine since 1991 and according to Russia, til 2014 . At this time, when USSR split, Putin was only a nothing in KGB. When Russians and Ukrainians are brothers with so many mixed families, Russians should never follow such criminal dictator. Same for Israel with Netanyahou and USA with Trump.
Putin is kind of Staline hidden son and Russians are just pieces of meat for him. Russians would live more free and better without such criminal dictator.
Some are yes, and they are a big part of the government. I guess you've not heard of the Azov battalion.There are no nazis in the Ukrainian government, but there are a lot of nazis in Russia and the Russian government.
Crimea as well as present territory of Kherson region became Russian in April of 1783.
As well,
Field Marshal Alexander Suvorov crossed the Swiss Alps between September 11 and October 7, 1799. This was part of his Swiss campaign during the War of the Second Coalition, where his Russo-Austrian forces attempted to drive the French out of Switzerland. His army faced extreme hardships, including fierce battles and treacherous terrain, but managed to escape encirclement.Crimea and Kherson became Ukrainian in 1922 respectively 1954.
Crimea has a long history of being anything but Russian. Moscow's shameless and brutal imperialism doesn't give Russia right to anything but contempt.
If you want to talk history you're obligated to start with saying that Karelia belongs to Finland and how Russia started wars and murderous war crimes to steal Karelia from Finland. Russia also need to give up Kaliningrad since it's historically not a Russian territory.
Putin is kind of Staline hidden son and Russians are just pieces of meat for him. Russians would live more free and better without such criminal dictator.Putin showed again today to our world he doesn t want to stop war he started, while stupid crazy Trump keep on playing dangerous clown. Our world have to really isolate Russia and block their values, only way to stop this war making Russia broke, when they are not far to be.
Do not expect that once taking advantage of Russia's weakness, you will receive dividends forever. Russian has always come for their money. And when they come. Do not rely on an agreement signed by you, you are supposed to justify. They are not worth the paper it is written. Therefore, with the Russian is to play fair, or do not play.
The secret of politics? Make a good treaty with Russia.
Even the most favorable outcome of the war will never lead to the decomposition of the main forces of Russia, which is based on millions of Russian. The latter, even if they break up international treaties, just as quickly re-connect with each other, like pieces of a particle of mercury.
Ukraine still winning? Obviously, the whole country will be taken.
Elvis 2008
05-27-25, 02:44
Do not expect that once taking advantage of Russia's weakness, you will receive dividends forever. Russian has always come for their money. And when they come. Do not rely on an agreement signed by you, you are supposed to justify. They are not worth the paper it is written. Therefore, with the Russian is to play fair, or do not play.
The secret of politics? Make a good treaty with Russia.
Even the most favorable outcome of the war will never lead to the decomposition of the main forces of Russia, which is based on millions of Russian. The latter, even if they break up international treaties, just as quickly re-connect with each other, like pieces of a particle of mercury.That is probably the smartest thing I have read. There would have been no war in Ukraine if the USA kept its word about not moving NATO to the East. I get Trump's frustration with Putin but also why Putin and Russia cannot trust Trump. It is not Trump, but the fact that Trump will not be in office in 2029. What happens then? We have seen Russia make a deal with one American administration just to have another one come in and nix the plan later.
Kamala bragged about brining Ukraine into NATO right before the war. Does anyone believe she or any of the other Democrats would not do the exact same thing once Trump is out of office? Virutally all Democrats want Ukraine in NATO, and the Russians know it.
Ukraine still winning? Obviously, the whole country will be taken.Yes, Ukraine is winning.
The Russians are running of missiles. The Russians are running out of drones. The Russians are fighting with shovels. Putin is gravely ill. Crimea will be retaken. The Russians are bombing the ZNPP. The Russians blew up Nordstream. Russia has lost over a million soldiers.
Russia is broke, where did you get that from? Even after paying for a war now for several years, Russia's debt to GDP ratio was around 20 to 25%, unlike the 120% for the US or circa 90% for the Euro area. Russia is far from broke.
Putin was quite clear; you put Nato in my backyard and I am going to respond. So he responded.
History is a great teacher, the Europeans / Nato should have known better than to bait the bear!
Putin showed again today to our world he doesn t want to stop war he started, while stupid crazy Trump keep on playing dangerous clown. Our world have to really isolate Russia and block their values, only way to stop this war making Russia broke, when they are not far to be.
The Azov brigades and their backers in the Ukrainian establishment may disagree.
Western media was extensively reporting the far right threat from Ukraine all the way up to the point where they stopped as Europe suddenly became Ukraines ally in the war against Russia. Western media is morally bankrupt, why would you believe anything that comes from them over the Russians. Putin may only give you half the truth, but its more than you will get from the bastions of free speech in the West.
There are no nazis in the Ukrainian government, but there are a lot of nazis in Russia and the Russian government.
Yes, Ukraine is winning.
The Russians are running of missiles. The Russians are running out of drones. The Russians are fighting with shovels. Putin is gravely ill. Crimea will be retaken. The Russians are bombing the ZNPP. The Russians blew up Nordstream. Russia has lost over a million soldiers.I'm afraid Crimea and probably part of Donbass won't return to belong to Ukraine. Trump is sucking too much Putin and only interested to rob poor Ukrainians, with his lies about USA help money.
Russia is broke, where did you get that from? Even after paying for a war now for several years, Russia's debt to GDP ratio was around 20 to 25%, unlike the 120% for the US or circa 90% for the Euro area. Russia is far from broke.
Putin was quite clear; you put Nato in my backyard and I am going to respond. So he responded.
History is a great teacher, the Europeans / Nato should have known better than to bait the bear!I wrote: Rather than a stupid sucker Trump, our world have to make Russia becoming broke, not buying petrol and gaz which enable Putin to buy weapons to kill women and children, even many Russian companies are not paid by Putin. This war is only criminal dictator Putin war, when Ukraine and NATO never threatened Russia and same for Finland. For sure, Russian medias are as objective as in north Korea.
I'm afraid Crimea and probably part of Donbass won't return to belong to Ukraine. Trump is sucking too much Putin and only interested to rob poor Ukrainians, with his lies about USA help money.But I thought Ukraine was winning? That's what the mainstream western media keeps telling me. Are you saying they are lying?
But I thought Ukraine was winning? That's what the mainstream western media keeps telling me. Are you saying they are lying?Which western media claim Ukraine is winning? Tell us, when most medias report about too many killed by criminal Putin. But Ukrainians are for sure very courageous to resist to weak Russian army since more than 3 years.
Very long read however very important read on the above.
Declassified documents show security assurances against NATO expansion to Soviet leaders from Baker, Bush, Genscher, Kohl, Gates, Mitterrand, Thatcher, Hurd, Major, and Woerner.
Slavic Studies Panel Addresses "Who Promised What to Whom on NATO Expansion?
https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017-12-12/nato-expansion-what-gorbachev-heard-western-leaders-early
Of course Gorby the traitor didn't listen to Baker's advice on economy, but it's another story.
Gentlemen, In light of developments today, has your prognosis for an end to the war improved? Or do you think peace is as far away as ever? Thanks in advance.
Gentlemen, In light of developments today, has your prognosis for an end to the war improved? Or do you think peace is as far away as ever? Thanks in advance.Unfortunately for poor Ukrainians, after Trump sucked Putin dick for months when Putin has Trump balls in his hand, now Putin just makes fun of the old senile telling white today and black tomorrow, without even understanding difference. I m afraid Crimea and probably other parts are lost for Ukraine and Putin doesn t respect agreements. Only way to stop this war is never Trump, but only making broke Russia, then maybe blind Russians will wake up and make same than to Ceacescu, when almost same dictator. Russia would live better without criminal dictator Putin, when nobody want to attack Russia, but only his paranoiac business. Same for criminal Netanyahou making his war business with everybody, to avoid prosecution and supported by so shameful Trump. All 3 would be prosecuted if they didn t make their business to avoid it. Poor world with such criminals.
Gentlemen, In light of developments today, has your prognosis for an end to the war improved? Or do you think peace is as far away as ever? Thanks in advance.No, I remain very pessimistic. The war has not yet started.
No, I remain very pessimistic. The war has not yet started.When crazy Putin, but he showed to the world his army is quite weak, after more than 3 years.
No, I remain very pessimistic. The war has not yet started.Do you mean you expect the war to expand and directly involve other countries besides Russia and Ukraine?
Your link to the National Securities Archive back in May, which I read a couple of years ago, explains why Russia could be so upset with the West's broken promises that this could spread.
Do you mean you expect the war to expand and directly involve other countries besides Russia and Ukraine?
Your link to the National Securities Archive back in May, which I read a couple of years ago, explains why Russia could be so upset with the West's broken promises that this could spread.Yes, I do. In respect to short and medium range missiles treaty of 1988 which I witnessed first hand we are back to square one. Any intervention on the part of NATO into Ukraine, any impediment of maritime traffic in the Baltic Sea, any action in Tiraspol all may broaden the conflict to disastrous outcomes.
Again, with the US being the main architect of the conflict, the US Administration has now the chance to close the Ukrainian project, to restore balance, to improve the relationship between the countries and then other issues will be resolved.
The Wall Street Journal is reporting that Russia's willing to agree to a ceasefire if Ukraine cedes all of Donetsk and Luhansk, and if the world recognizes Russia's claim to the Donbas and Crimea. From there details become sketchy. Zaporizhzhia and Kherson might be divided up along the current lines of control or Ukraine might end up with all of the two oblasts. A third possibility is that there might be a land trade for some part of Zaporizhzhia or Kherson currently under Russia's control for land in Donetsk controlled by Ukraine.
I'm only seeing this right now in the WSJ. Other media sources aren't reporting on it.
This could be good news.
Yes, I do. In respect to short and medium range missiles treaty of 1988 which I witnessed first hand we are back to square one. Any intervention on the part of NATO into Ukraine, any impediment of maritime traffic in the Baltic Sea, any action in Tiraspol all may broaden the conflict to disastrous outcomes.
Again, with the US being the main architect of the conflict, the US Administration has now the chance to close the Ukrainian project, to restore balance, to improve the relationship between the countries and then other issues will be resolved.
Thanks Questner, you’re insightful as always
Poor Ukrainians who may be fucked by senile Trump sucking Putin who hold his balls, in Alaska. Since 1991 , Crimea did belong to Ukraine and same for other places now invaded, when Putin who was just nothing in 1988 , is an invader. And Trump criticized on his first election Crimea invaded, but he is too senile now. Criminal Putin can t travel all over the world now, so he needs his criminal friends to receive him. Same for Netanyahou.
No, I remain very pessimistic. The war has not yet started.Russia has a bigger vision.
The Wall Street Journal is reporting that Russia's willing to agree to a ceasefire if Ukraine cedes all of Donetsk and Luhansk, and if the world recognizes Russia's claim to the Donbas and Crimea. From there details become sketchy. Zaporizhzhia and Kherson might be divided up along the current lines of control or Ukraine might end up with all of the two oblasts. A third possibility is that there might be a land trade for some part of Zaporizhzhia or Kherson currently under Russia's control for land in Donetsk controlled by Ukraine.
I'm only seeing this right now in the WSJ. Other media sources aren't reporting on it.First of all WSJ is anti-Trump and publishes mostly deliberate nonsense with respect to the conflict. Ignore it.
Ukraine can withdraw troops from 4 regions, but can't cede it without changes in the Constitution. Big difference mass media does not emphasize it to you.
Ceasefire can be only temporary, limited and conditional and by all means it should leave no chance to NATO's direct intervention.
It's up to individual countries to recognize the facts, like Nicaragua did recently, but it can't added to the treaty. The US can recognize, but I don't see how Congress passes it.
It's hard to comment about 2 regions, Zaporozhye and Kherson, the only thing is don't believe any news who may claim the RF promised to cede them.
Trump's efforts are laudable, but we discount them in the long term. It's our land for millennium and we will get it one way or another and unite the country.
Even if some technical details may be complicated, the general picture of the conflict is rather simple, and I don't know why some lack mental acuity to get it.
Russia has a bigger vision.Russian meat for war, or criminal dictator Putin?
Sir Tony Brenton had an interesting take on the meeting on CNN this afternoon. Brenton is a career British civil servant and old Russia hand who served as Britain's ambassador to Russia from 2004 to 2008, during Labour Party administrations.
Witkoff said today Russia was willing to accept security guarantees from the USA And other nations, akin to NATO's Title 5. Title 5 states that an armed attack against one NATO member is an attack against them all. Conversations between the Trump administration and European officials appear to confirm that Russia has agreed to accept robust security guarantees for Ukraine.
Brenton said Russia didn't and won't agree, under any circumstances, to Ukrainian membership in NATO. But a guarantee like what Witkoff described is just as good.
Brenton in fact believes the two countries now have a good path towards peace. And the meeting this Friday may be the beginning of the end. The security guarantee was the most problematic stumbling block.
That said, I'd trust Questner's forecast of what's to come over Brenton's, and Questner believes this has farther to go. Questner, I hope you're wrong this time. It would be great to see Russia, Ukraine, the United States, and Europe on the same page. And maybe with time they'll all be friendly, as they should be.
Peace and love.
Tiny.
Sir Tony Brenton had an interesting take on the meeting on CNN this afternoon. Brenton is a career British civil servant and old Russia hand who served as Britain's ambassador to Russia from 2004 to 2008, during Labour Party administrations.
Witkoff said today Russia was willing to accept security guarantees from the USA And other nations, akin to NATO's Title 5. Title 5 states that an armed attack against one NATO member is an attack against them all. Conversations between the Trump administration and European officials appear to confirm that Russia has agreed to accept robust security guarantees for Ukraine.
Brenton said Russia didn't and won't agree, under any circumstances, to Ukrainian membership in NATO. But a guarantee like what Witkoff described is just as good.
Brenton in fact believes the two countries now have a good path towards peace. And the meeting this Friday may be the beginning of the end. The security guarantee was the most problematic stumbling block..The membership in NATO is not acceptable as it means NATO's infrastructure and Participation of Ukraine herself in the block. Now, Russia has to able to enforce the neutrality: trust but verify but enforce. How this is going to be achieved is a mystery to me.
The second issue is dealing with many military bi-lateral agreements that Ukraine has signed recently. They all have to go. That 100 year agreement with the UK is one of them.
Any type of a guarantee resembling Article 5 is meaningless. Not only no one can profit from it now, it won't become any impediment to restart the conflict any time in future should the need come, and believe me Ukraine will be blamed for the restart.
Finally, unless the total re-balance is achieved and the relationships are improved between the EU, the US and the RF, this treaty may become short lived and be forgotten soon once the current leadership change. This is why I am pessimistic and expect a large scale conflict in years to come soon.
Too old, senile Trump sucking so good criminal Putin on red carpet, now want to give him Crimea when he criticized while invasion, and Dombass when Putin was never able to defeat Donetsk. Putin just waiting to cum in Orange mouth and dirty red carpet. Trump is just a sucker clown, not reliable, fucking stupid Americans and trying with our world.
PaulInZurich
08-18-25, 15:54
The Alaska summit was a shit show.
Putin got everything he wanted and gave nothing in return.
The level of incompetence in US foreign policy is astounding. First Witkoff gives 3 different statements what was agreed before and what will be confirmed at the summit. Of course, the outcome was the 4th version, because like with the trade negotiations, anything that was discussed without Trump present means exactly zero. That is just for starters.
In foreign policy symbolism matter. So let's start with that image with US soldiers literally on their knees rolling the red carpet towards the Russian government plane. The Russian (dis) information space had a great time with that one. I am old enough to remember the weeks with endless hours on TV with people clutching their pearls when Obama saluted a marine with a coffee cup in his hand or when he was wearing a tan suit. Then you have Trump waiting for Putin on the red carpet, then suddenly all smiles and clapping, yes, like a circus seal, clapping for a murderous thug. He looked like a freshman who gets to meet the star quarterback. The fact that they didn't have the common meal and the press conference after their meeting shows you that even Trump knows that it was a disaster. Of course, he can't admit that, so know the spin machine is revving at high speed. My explanation why the meeting was cut short is that Putin said "Donnie, the blowjob in your car was enough, no need for a second one. I am in a rush to get back, I have an appointment with my hair dresser".
From what came out so far, Putin asks for Ukraine to give up Donbass entirely, the areas that have the best Ukrainian fortifications. All he offered is that he doesn't ask for 100% of Zaporishia and Kherson. As long as these regions stay in the Russian constitution he can come back later and argue that well, actually. Then there is the vague "root causes of the war" which for him mean a pro Russian government and a severely reduced Ukrainian army.
Elvis 2008
08-18-25, 17:04
Sir Tony Brenton had an interesting take on the meeting on CNN this afternoon. Brenton is a career British civil servant and old Russia hand who served as Britain's ambassador to Russia from 2004 to 2008, during Labour Party administrations.
Witkoff said today Russia was willing to accept security guarantees from the USA And other nations, akin to NATO's Title 5. Title 5 states that an armed attack against one NATO member is an attack against them all. Conversations between the Trump administration and European officials appear to confirm that Russia has agreed to accept robust security guarantees for Ukraine.
Brenton said Russia didn't and won't agree, under any circumstances, to Ukrainian membership in NATO. But a guarantee like what Witkoff described is just as good..Yeah, I think it is different this time too. Trump had made a campaign promise on fixing the Ukraine war in 24 hours and Putin used that to his advantage. He kept saying all the right things to Trump but doing all the wrong things by pushing for more territory and ramping up the drone fights.
Interestingly, it was Melania Trump who got the Don to see the light on how he was being played by Putin. That is when Trump got pissed. He smoothed things over with Zelensky and told the Russians he was really going to clamp down on things and by clamping down, that meant taking Russian oil tankers via the USA Navy and increasing LNG shipments massively to Europe. With a reduction and oil and gas income, Russia is dead in the water.
The war mongers were all saying that Russia was coming from Europe. Russia has 110 million inhabitants versus 449 million in the EU. When I read this, I was laughing at the war monger deep state types that were pushing this Russia is coming for Europe narrative. They always want these forever wars and the checks that come with them.
And while there may have been popular support on both sides at the start of the war, that support has gone to nothing. Everyone on both sides is sick of this shit.
I am still not sure the USA should be in NATO, but one nice side effect of this war is Europe has stepped up their defense spending, and they have cut down on their idiotic green energy spending that left Spain and Portugal in the dark.
Trump did an amazing job with Israel and Iran which was something I worried about. I thought Trump was just going to have us doing Israel's bidding, but he blasted both Israel and Iran when the cease fire was violated, and things have calmed there. He deserves great credit for how he handled that situation, and I think we will see the same here.
Thing is even if he brings peace to Ukraine, the Democratic douches will still find something new to gripe about with Trump.
John Clayton
08-18-25, 18:12
...Trump did an amazing job with Israel and Iran ...Thing is even if he brings peace to Ukraine, the Democratic douches will still find something new to gripe about with Trump.For a perspective, read Frank Bruni's column in the NYT: "Give Trump the Nobel!
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/08/18/opinion/trump-nobel-peace-prize.html
From what came out so far, Putin asks for Ukraine to give up Donbass entirely, the areas that have the best Ukrainian fortifications. All he offered is that he doesn't ask for 100% of Zaporishia and Kherson. As long as these regions stay in the Russian constitution he can come back later and argue that well, actually. Then there is the vague "root causes of the war" which for him mean a pro Russian government and a severely reduced Ukrainian army.You obviously haven't been paying attention to anything Putin has been saying since forever. The root cause of this conflict was NATO expansion into Ukraine. That was Putin's red line and will never be allowed. Ukraine will have to be neutral along the lines of the Austrian model.
Gentlemen, In light of developments today, has your prognosis for an end to the war improved? Or do you think peace is as far away as ever? Thanks in advance.Let's see what happens today in DC.
Considering what is currently only being talked about and nothing agreed:
Ukraine giving up the entire Donbas, Russia freezing the contact line in Zap and Kherson, recognition of Crimea being Russian and no NATO in Ukraine.
I still find it a bit hard to believe that Putin would agree not to capture all of Zap and Kherson as they are now according to the Russian constitution a part of Russia. But then when I look at the whole picture and the geography, Russia would get the entire Donbas and would get to keep the land bridge to Crimea, get recognition of Crimea and there would be no Ukraine in NATO. Throw in some bits about Russian language and church rights, and you get some sanctions lifted, I think it is still a pretty good deal and a huge win IMHO.
Thoughts?
P.S I think the Europeans are going to try their hardest to get the corrupt illegal dictator of Ukraine with no mandate to walk away to keep this tragedy going. If that happens, I really hope Trump and the United States step aside. Then it will be settled on the battlefield of course with a comprehensive Russian victory and Ukraine losing not just 4 but possibly 4 more Oblasts. Ukraine really should take this deal to save what is left.
Europe don t trust Trump, when we know Putin is stronger than him, too old senile, playing for everything like in casino.
Couple of points to emphasize again.
This one for EU and UK leaders: Russia expects Ukraine to be neutral, non-aligned and non-nuclear. One of the goals of the SMO is demilitarization of Ukraine, I. E. Russia will not allow the current AFU forces to remain forward. Why would a peaceful neutral state want a million men army armed to the teeth?
Humanitarian aspect: All rights of Russian speaking and the Ukrainian Orthodox Church should be restored.
I can't imagine Rada voting for the above and the current government implementing the comprehensive agreement of this nature.
Remember, as I posted before, 'loose-loose' is a prevailing rural mentality that always shapes the policy and actions in Ukraine.
Couple of points to emphasize again.
This one for EU and UK leaders: Russia expects Ukraine to be neutral, non-aligned and non-nuclear. One of the goals of the SMO is demilitarization of Ukraine, I. E. Russia will not allow the current AFU forces to remain forward. Why would a peaceful neutral state want a million men army armed to the teeth?
Humanitarian aspect: All rights of Russian speaking and the Ukrainian Orthodox Church should be restored.
I can't imagine Rada voting for the above and the current government implementing the comprehensive agreement of this nature.
Remember, as I posted before, 'loose-loose' is a prevailing rural mentality that always shapes the policy and actions in Ukraine.When Putin is a liar and not respecting agreements, Ukraine and Europe have to protect versus such international criminal. He is crazy, but we know now his army is weak, when he was not even able to defeat Donetsk in 3 years and half. But he is stronger than too old Trump, so Europe can t trust them both.
Elvis 2008
08-19-25, 18:13
For a perspective, read Frank Bruni's column in the NYT: "Give Trump the Nobel!
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/08/18/opinion/trump-nobel-peace-prize.htmlThe last South Park episode skewered Trump and Kristi Noem and I laughed my ass off. Republicans were polled, and they liked it too. It was actually funny, and I thought Trump's spokesperson and Noem's response were pretty lame.
That some NYT columnist wrote the trash that he did ranks up their with Deniro's fuck Trump speech, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ceQ0Zb1G8Io. If you thought that editorial or Deniro were great, you are in a cult.
I think the reason one is funny and the other two are not is South Park is using satire and exaggeration and the NYT and Deniro just come across as bitter losers.
And the timing is terrible. Trump is on the verge of something historic, and you Democratic douche cultists cannot stand to see him have any success even if it means saving millions of lives.
Trump could cure cancer, and you all would still find something to gripe about.
John Clayton
08-19-25, 21:30
...Trump is on the verge of something historic...Wondering what that would be?
Now that a lot of the BS from the Trump administration is out of the way, it's clear the Russians never explicitly said they would let go of the parts of Zaporizhya and Kherson they still don't control in exchange for full control of Donetsk. All this talk about security guarantees and the non-sense the Europeans are spewing (article 5 guarantees, European troops in Ukraine, seriously what planet do these warmongers live on?) are also non starters.
Putin will never meet the so called President of Ukraine with no mandate. That clown just wants a photo op and to try to look tough with Putin. Putin isn't stupid to meet with this corrupt actor with no solid agenda and stuff ready to sign.
So unfortunately, as I predicted months ago, this will be decided on the battlefield, and the result will be a Russian victory of course.
Now that a lot of the BS from the Trump administration is out of the way, it's clear the Russians never explicitly said they would let go of the parts of Zaporizhya and Kherson they still don't control in exchange for full control of Donetsk. All this talk about security guarantees and the non-sense the Europeans are spewing (article 5 guarantees, European troops in Ukraine, seriously what planet do these warmongers live on?) are also non starters.
Putin will never meet the so called President of Ukraine with no mandate. That clown just wants a photo op and to try to look tough with Putin. Putin isn't stupid to meet with this corrupt actor with no solid agenda and stuff ready to sign.
So unfortunately, as I predicted months ago, this will be decided on the battlefield, and the result will be a Russian victory of course.Russia weak army was not able to win and take Donetsk in 3 years and half and Zelensky is more supported by Ukrainians than criminal dictator Putin by Russians, when he can t even travel in the world. When we can t trust Trump show and business, our world have to make Russia broke, to make Russians eating Putin from starvation, when already big inflation in Russia. And same in USA with Trump taxes. All my support to Ukraine versus Putin and Trump, even Crimea is lost and probably part of Donbass, but not Donetsk yet.
Good points by all. A week's time has shown Questner and Blood Red were correct in their skepticism. We're back to where we were months ago.
It's a pity. This situation needs to be settled, for the benefit of all involved. Certainly Russia has plenty of good reasons to be aggrieved, going back to the broken promises made to Gorbachev. Certainly if the tables were turned the United States wouldn't sit still if Mexico were on track to become a member of the Warsaw Pact.
But why can't the sides fast forward and take this to an end before there are a million more casualties? Russia and Europe and Ukraine and the USA should be on the same side. Imagine the effect on the prosperity of the countries if they could, say, each cut defense expenditures by 2% or 3% of GDP. And if trade, like Russian gas flows to Europe, resumes. Sanctions need to go. Unfortunately, they have a way of dragging on forever, like Cuba. Look at Iran. That country was dragged into penury and remains there. Admittedly Russia has weathered sanctions much better, but they're still a drag.
With Trump in the United States presidency, there's a good chance they would be lifted if the fighting stops. Also Trump would appear to be more sympathetic to Russia's positions than most western leaders. There's about a 3-1/2 year window before Trump leaves office during which relations can be righted. I hope the various sides take the steps to make that happen.
And you know Elvis, yes you have to give Trump credit for at least trying. I hope he doesn't give up.
Good points by all. A week's time has shown Questner and Blood Red were correct in their skepticism. We're back to where we were months ago.
It's a pity. This situation needs to be settled, for the benefit of all involved. Certainly Russia has plenty of good reasons to be aggrieved, going back to the broken promises made to Gorbachev. Certainly if the tables were turned the United States wouldn't sit still if Mexico were on track to become a member of the Warsaw Pact.
But why can't the sides fast forward and take this to an end before there are a million more casualties? Russia and Europe and Ukraine and the USA should be on the same side. Imagine the effect on the prosperity of the countries if they could, say, each cut defense expenditures by 2% or 3% of GDP. Sanctions need to go. Unfortunately, they have a way of dragging on forever, like Cuba. Look at Iran. That country was dragged into penury and remains there. Admittedly Russia has weathered sanctions much better, but they're still a drag.
With Trump in the United States presidency, there's a good chance they could be lifted. Also Trump would appear to be more sympathetic to Russia's positions than most western leaders..Fortunately, Europe support much more Ukraine than robber senile Trump who forgot what he told about Crimea invasion years ago. When Ukraine became independent, Putin was only nothing in FSB, not even known by dogs. Now we have Putin and Trump for liars, Ukraine and Europe can t trust.
Elvis 2008
08-24-25, 19:43
Good points by all. A week's time has shown Questner and Blood Red were correct in their skepticism. We're back to where we were months ago. And you know Elvis, yes you have to give Trump credit for at least trying. I hope he doesn't give up.I do not agree we are back where we were. A ceasefire is easy to agree to, but Putin and Trump both said they were not going to do a ceasefire. There is a helluva lot stuff to hammer out. All the players have had their input. They need to work out details. Whether a deal is done is up in the air, but Russia has been able to sell their oil and gas with relative ease despite the so called sanctions. If that stops, and Trump has been bullshitted by Putin for months now and wants to get serious, then I think you can call this a failure.
I do not agree we are back where we were. A ceasefire is easy to agree to, but Putin and Trump both said they were not going to do a ceasefire. There is a helluva lot stuff to hammer out. All the players have had their input. They need to work out details. Whether a deal is done is up in the air, but Russia has been able to sell their oil and gas with relative ease despite the so called sanctions. If that stops, and Trump has been bullshitted by Putin for months now and wants to get serious, then I think you can call this a failure.Stopping war in 1 day, orange clown bad joke, when he is fucked deeply in the ass and even more since Alaska, since months. Only way to stop Putin is to make him broke and Russia under starvation to eat him, when already inflation.
I think what is happening here is Trump washing his hands off slowly and as much as he can. He knows this can't be settled via negotiations, the gaps are too wide and you just can't square that circle. Hence why Trump said let Putin and Zelensky meet. He knows that is not going to happen.
So yes, IMHO, we are back to square one and this will be settled on the battlefield with an ugly Russian victory and a frozen conflict.
I think what is happening here is Trump washing his hands off slowly and as much as he can. He knows this can't be settled via negotiations, the gaps are too wide and you just can't square that circle. Hence why Trump said let Putin and Zelensky meet. He knows that is not going to happen.
So yes, IMHO, we are back to square one and this will be settled on the battlefield with an ugly Russian victory and a frozen conflict.But Trump who told to stop in 1 day, is just ridiculous now, fucked by Putin who shoot US company in West Ukraine, despite MAGA sucked a lot criminal dictator Putin and also supporting other criminal Netanyahou.
Elvis 2008
08-26-25, 18:01
I think what is happening here is Trump washing his hands off slowly and as much as he can. He knows this can't be settled via negotiations, the gaps are too wide and you just can't square that circle. Hence why Trump said let Putin and Zelensky meet. He knows that is not going to happen.
So yes, IMHO, we are back to square one and this will be settled on the battlefield with an ugly Russian victory and a frozen conflict.Sigh. Yeah, you are right. Thing is with all the slop in journalism these days you often do not who to listen to. As such I trust the guys I pay for on Substack.
Seymour Hersh seems to have better contacts than anyone in government. He had Biden blowing up Nordstream and I was laughing my ass off at the cover story of a bunch of drunken Ukrainian divers taking out Nordstream. OMG was that a terrible story. He also got the USA bombing Iran story right days before it happened.
Anyway, here is what he has said about the summit: The much anticipated summit earlier this month in Anchorage was a flop: Putin rebuffed Trump's request for a ceasefire, and the woefully unprepared Trump seemed more intent on finding a way to earn a Nobel Peace Prize than striking a realistic bargain on Ukraine.
That is sad. It cracks me up when we people who like Trump get bashed as cultists. We know who he is and his flaws. I do not like the whole Russiagate bullshit narrative, but I do think that Putin knows how to kiss Trump's ass the right way and push Trump's buttons. South Park did a hilarious bit about the line of international and domestic leaders who lined up in the White House to kiss Trump's ass and give him gifts. That is sad but true. Trump gets disarmed by flattery.
So I do not know what we in the USA do at this point. We have most of the crap that went on from Russiagate. It is clear that the Democrats made Putin into this Hitleresque like character to distract from all the shit they were doing.
Thing is the old USSR had half of Germany. What is the big deal to the USA if Russia has the Eastern part of Ukraine that is mostly Russian? Why is that the end of the world?
The bullshit is always the same with war. If you do not stop him in Ukraine, then it is onto all of Europe and the USA! I am sick of it. I want our budget balanced. We cannot afford these forever wars anymore.
The big difference between Hitler and Putin is the German people suffered after WW One. The Germans were humiliated, bankrupted, and stabbed in the back. The Russian people have had it pretty good lately. It was rough in 2000 or so, but things had been going well for them.
I remember the videos of the Russian soldiers in the gas pipelines in the Kursk region of Russia. They were not happy and were cursing Putin by name.
I watched that documentary on Chernobyl, and if it was accurate, the workers were hardly in lockstep with the government. They were pissed at being asked to do what the government wanted. They did it but they were pissed.
So yeah, you can sell the Russian people on their own being abused in Ukraine, but I do not think you can go more than that. You will lose the support of the Russian people. I think the Russians have lost somewhere between half a million and a million men and how many more have been disabled? And it is not like people are not suffering at home as well. Ukraine has been taking out many Russian facilities and there have been casualties there as well.
So yeah, I agree with you, Bloodred. The Russians will continue to grind it out and take the parts of Ukraine they want, and we are just going to be throwing money down the drain trying to stop that.
I agree with you. Sadly, I cannot see this stopping until the Russians get what they want.
Sigh. Yeah, you are right. Thing is with all the slop in journalism these days you often do not who to listen to. As such I trust the guys I pay for on Substack.
Seymour Hersh seems to have better contacts than anyone in government. He had Biden blowing up Nordstream and I was laughing my ass off at the cover story of a bunch of drunken Ukrainian divers taking out Nordstream. OMG was that a terrible story. He also got the USA bombing Iran story right days before it happened.
Anyway, here is what he has said about the summit: The much anticipated summit earlier this month in Anchorage was a flop: Putin rebuffed Trump's request for a ceasefire, and the woefully unprepared Trump seemed more intent on finding a way to earn a Nobel Peace Prize than striking a realistic bargain on Ukraine.
That is sad. It cracks me up when we people who like Trump get bashed as cultists. We know who he is and his flaws. I do not like the whole Russiagate bullshit narrative, but I do think that Putin knows how to kiss Trump's ass the right way and push Trump's buttons. South Park did a hilarious bit about the line of international and domestic leaders who lined up in the White House to kiss Trump's ass and give him gifts. That is sad but true. Trump gets disarmed by flattery.
So I do not know what we in the USA do at this point. We have most of the crap that went on from Russiagate. It is clear that the Democrats made Putin into this Hitleresque like character to distract from all the shit they were doing.
Thing is the old USSR had half of Germany. What is the big deal to the USA if Russia has the Eastern part of Ukraine that is mostly Russian? Why is that the end of the world?
The bullshit is always the same with war. If you do not stop him in Ukraine, then it is onto all of Europe and the USA! I am sick of it. I want our budget balanced. We cannot afford these forever wars anymore.
The big difference between Hitler and Putin is the German people suffered after WW One. The Germans were humiliated, bankrupted, and stabbed in the back. The Russian people have had it pretty good lately. It was rough in 2000 or so, but things had been going well for them.
I remember the videos of the Russian soldiers in the gas pipelines in the Kursk region of Russia. They were not happy and were cursing Putin by name.
I watched that documentary on Chernobyl, and if it was accurate, the workers were hardly in lockstep with the government. They were pissed at being asked to do what the government wanted. They did it but they were pissed.
So yeah, you can sell the Russian people on their own being abused in Ukraine, but I do not think you can go more than that. You will lose the support of the Russian people. I think the Russians have lost somewhere between half a million and a million men and how many more have been disabled? And it is not like people are not suffering at home as well. Ukraine has been taking out many Russian facilities and there have been casualties there as well.
So yeah, I agree with you, Bloodred. The Russians will continue to grind it out and take the parts of Ukraine they want, and we are just going to be throwing money down the drain trying to stop that.
I agree with you. Sadly, I cannot see this stopping until the Russians get what they want.Inflation for Russians under war and even less freedom. They would live better if they got rid of Putin.
Anyway, here is what he has said about the summit: The much anticipated summit earlier this month in Anchorage was a flop: Putin rebuffed Trump's request for a ceasefire, and the woefully unprepared Trump seemed more intent on finding a way to earn a Nobel Peace Prize than striking a realistic bargain on Ukraine.He won't get a noble peace prize for Ukraine since it will be settled on the battlefield. Credit to Trump for at least talking to the Russians though. And one more thing to remember. Let's say Trump agrees to the Russian demands, there are still 2 other parties that need to agree and won't. The Europeans and especially the Zelensky regime.
The bullshit is always the same with war. If you do not stop him in Ukraine, then it is onto all of Europe and the USA! I can't believe some people actually buy into this horseshit. And what is funny is this. On one hand, we hear the collective west say Russia is weak, their army is shit, they are suffering such huge losses, the situation on the ground is a stalemate, blah blah blah. And then they tell us that Russia will go after Poland, the Baltic republics, etc afterwards. Laughable.
So yeah, I agree with you, Bloodred. The Russians will continue to grind it out and take the parts of Ukraine they want, and we are just going to be throwing money down the drain trying to stop that.
I agree with you. Sadly, I cannot see this stopping until the Russians get what they want.The best deal the Ukraine will get is the one on the table now, no matter how bad it looks. If this goes on for a couple of more years and there is a collapse of AFU (possible for sure), then expect the Russians to take 4 more Oblasts including Odessa. And then what, Ukraine becomes a land locked country.
What a needless tragedy.
He won't get a noble peace prize for Ukraine since it will be settled on the battlefield. Credit to Trump for at least talking to the Russians though. And one more thing to remember. Let's say Trump agrees to the Russian demands, there are still 2 other parties that need to agree and won't. The Europeans and especially the Zelensky regime.
I can't believe some people actually buy into this horseshit. And what is funny is this. On one hand, we hear the collective west say Russia is weak, their army is shit, they are suffering such huge losses, the situation on the ground is a stalemate, blah blah blah. And then they tell us that Russia will go after Poland, the Baltic republics, etc afterwards. Laughable.
The best deal the Ukraine will get is the one on the table now, no matter how bad it looks. If this goes on for a couple of more years and there is a collapse of AFU (possible for sure), then expect the Russians to take 4 more Oblasts including Odessa. And then what, Ukraine becomes a land locked country.
What a needless tragedy.Fortunately Europe resist to clown Trump, to support Ukraine, when MAGA clown wants to fuck them. Shame to MAGA.
John Clayton
08-28-25, 06:00
...The best deal the Ukraine will get is the one on the table now, no matter how bad it looks...What a needless tragedy.No thanks. In spite of duplicitous / traitorous Trump, Ukraine is winning. As an aside, I love the (surprising) videos of the little Bradley IFV'l raging through the Russians. Pure pleasure.
No thanks. In spite of duplicitous / traitorous Trump, Ukraine is winning. As an aside, I love the (surprising) videos of the little Bradley IFV'l raging through the Russians. Pure pleasure.Yes, Ukraine is winning. I have been saying this since day 1.
Fortunately Europe resist to clown Trump, to support Ukraine, when MAGA clown wants to fuck them. Shame to MAGA.International criminal killing mothers and babies Putin really fuck too old orange MAGA who wants to rob Ukraine.
Any hope for peace gentlemen, now that the two sides are talking face-to-face? Zelensky is saying this is just about the land now. If that's true, and unfortunately I doubt it is, it would seem they would be in striking distance of a settlement.
Any hope for peace gentlemen, now that the two sides are talking face-to-face? Zelensky is saying this is just about the land now. If that's true, and unfortunately I doubt it is, it would seem they would be in striking distance of a settlement.Remember vampire or zombie movies where a severed hand drags on and clenches back onto a host? So we will attach the right shoulder back to body but the rotten severed right hand will remain unhealed unattached dead dragging and poisoning everything for long time. That is Ukraine. The outcome of the settlement will be seen only when time passes. The only natural long lasting natural and balancing solution is the unification. Everything else will lead to more war and more destruction ahead.
Any hope for peace gentlemen, now that the two sides are talking face-to-face? Zelensky is saying this is just about the land now. If that's true, and unfortunately I doubt it is, it would seem they would be in striking distance of a settlement.Zelensky can't decide on his own for lands, but Ukrainian constitution, and Putin loves too much war, killing Russian meat since he was in KGB and FSB. Only way to stop this war is to take Russia money, to make them broke. Trump only playing bad stupid clown show, DT sucking criminal Putin since 1 year, to make business with him.
Good news: Russia economics is falling and big inflation with more poverty. Many are leaving Russia of Putin, so he needs immigration from Sri Lanka, India. And now, our world have proof criminal dictator Putin poisonned Navalny. I wish all this will help to make Putin stopping this war after 4 years to be so crual with Ukrainian population, even in cold winter. I really wish for Ukrainians, my first wish for this year, even before free riding fall then die I love and climbing legends I want also.
Tomorrow will be 4 years of crimes of dictator Putin versus Ukraine who are courageous heroes to resist since so long and without heating in the cold, from Putin cruelty. This, after he already robbed Crimea and trained hard for criminal in FSB, killing so many to become what he is. I love Russia, so I can only hate Putin and when shameful Trump doesn't help Ukraine since 1 year, but Europe do, I really wish better times for Ukrainians. Best way to stop Putin is to take all Russia money, for reason of war criminal, when Trump would prefer to make business with Putin, he likes to support criminals like also Netanyahou.
I hope, after four years of (this phase of) the war, you'll come to realize how futile your efforts have been. Whether pro-Ukraine or anti-Ukraine, those who write the narratives and clickbait headlines have had you dancing to their tune.
I haven't posted in this forum for years, once I realized that allowing myself to get swept up with every wave and ripple was an exercise in futility. The real forces are tidal in nature, powerful yet nearly imperceptible. And, while I favor Ukraine and disfavor Russia, I don't have a crystal ball to tell me when or how matters will resolve. But one doesn't need a crystal ball to predict that the cherry-picking armchair analysts will continue making fools of themselves.
Slava Ukraini!
I hope, after four years of (this phase of) the war, you'll come to realize how futile your efforts have been. Whether pro-Ukraine or anti-Ukraine, those who write the narratives and clickbait headlines have had you dancing to their tune.
I haven't posted in this forum for years, once I realized that allowing myself to get swept up with every wave and ripple was an exercise in futility. The real forces are tidal in nature, powerful yet nearly imperceptible. And, while I favor Ukraine and disfavor Russia, I don't have a crystal ball to tell me when or how matters will resolve. But one doesn't need a crystal ball to predict that the cherry-picking armchair analysts will continue making fools of themselves.When big inflation in Russia, if Russia didn't have enough money anymore to pay for Putin war, then he couldn't keep on his own war, same than Netanyahou in Gaza. I wish Israel will get rid of their criminal and Russia will fall broke, with Russians waking up and eating their criminal dictator, when Russians would live so much better without him, when nobody never planned to attack Russia, just Putin bullshits for his war, dreaming to make again CCCP like when he was just nothing in KGB.
The failed comedian aka the illegal President of Ukraine met with the ISIS leader and terrorist President of Syria.
The failed comedian aka the illegal President of Ukraine met with the ISIS leader and terrorist President of Syria.So did the failed comedian president of the United States, and he's even more comedic because he doesn't realize he's a clown while everyone else does.
So did the failed comedian president of the United States, and he's even more comedic because he doesn't realize he's a clown while everyone else does.Yes, he sure did.
So did the entire EU leadership. I guess once the you. S takes a path, all the EU and Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and South Korea fall in line like good boys. And these people preach about human rights to Russia while welcoming the head chopper.
The failed comedian aka the illegal President of Ukraine met with the ISIS leader and terrorist President of Syria.Why illegal? When not a dictator like criminal ex FSB and KGB Putin, and according to Ukrainian constitution, no election under war, so Putin just made him staying longer, when attacking Ukraine, when, out of corruption, Zelensky is fully legal according to constitution, at least till end of war. And, when only way to stop Putin is to make Russia broke, not anymore able to pay for war Putin started, but his crazy friend Trump with his war attacking Iran, gave money to Putin to keep on killing Ukrainian women and children. Putin, like Netanyahou are ranked war criminals and Trump should also be after killing more than 150 Iranian little girls at school, shame on USA and really no MAGA versus Iran, even I don t support at all mollahs and Islamists, but Trump had no other reason than supporting Netanyahou and trying to make problems to Chinese economics, but his total failure, when China and his friend Putin are behind Iran, helping them for war.
Yes, he sure did.
So did the entire EU leadership. I guess once the you. S takes a path, all the EU and Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and South Korea fall in line like good boys. And these people preach about human rights to Russia while welcoming the head chopper.Fortunately, EU, UK and some others don't follow Trump craziness and keep on helping Ukraine versus criminal Putin, when Trump stopped and is more interested to rob them, like Greenland. I really wish Iranians will be free in democracy one day, but I wish for Trump failure for this war for no reason for USA. USA under Trump are not anymore a real democracy, when he already fucked US constitution, when Zelensky is still president according to Ukrainian constitution.
Bloomberg's reporting that Kyrylo Budanov, Ukraine's top negotiator with Russia, believes there will be peace before long. Here's the Bloomberg article, which may or may not be behind a paywall.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-04-10/zelenskiy-s-top-aide-sees-ukraine-nearing-a-deal-with-putin
If you can't read it, try this.
https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/ukraine-russia-move-towards-potential-peace-deal-bloomberg-reports-2026-04-10/
Bloomberg's reporting that Kyrylo Budanov, Ukraine's top negotiator with Russia, believes there will be peace before long. Here's the Bloomberg article, which may or may not be behind a paywall.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-04-10/zelenskiy-s-top-aide-sees-ukraine-nearing-a-deal-with-putin
If you can't read it, try this.
https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/ukraine-russia-move-towards-potential-peace-deal-bloomberg-reports-2026-04-10/Peace for Orthodox Easter, but Putin loves so much to kill, when he was so frustrated to be nothing in KGB under CCCP.
Elvis 2008
04-11-26, 06:51
Yes, he sure did.
So did the entire EU leadership. I guess once the you. S takes a path, all the EU and Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and South Korea fall in line like good boys. And these people preach about human rights to Russia while welcoming the head chopper.Yeah, but the reason for that is energy. With China cutting off exports of refined products, nations like Australia are scrambling, https://ieefa.org/resources/its-time-australia-reduce-its-oil-demand
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/mar/23/petrol-stations-australia-fuel-crisis
That is what the climate change nuts have wrought. They moved refining capacity from Australia and California to China and then brag about China being an electrostate while patting themselves on the bad for cleaning up the local environment. Those chickens are coming home to roost now.
Europe has always wanted a gas pipeline through Syria from the Persian Gulf countries, and that is why Russia had been fighting there, to stop those projected natural gas pipelines.
It is just amazing what the climate change nuts have done to Europe: https://www.decouple.media/p/europe-forgot-the-lesson-the-1970s
The European response to the OPEC embargo in 1973 was an impressive mobilization that moved decisively and pragmatically taking advantage of the unique conditions available throughout the bloc.
The results of this collective mobilization were visible by the mid-1990's in a set of numbers worth holding in mind. Europe consumed around 32 EJ of hydrocarbons annually and produced around 15 EJ domestically. Roughly 8 EJ of Russian oil and pipeline gas, operating under long-term contracts with a generally reliable delivery history, functioned as quasi-domestic supply despite transiting through the iron curtain. Effective external import dependence was around 30 percent of consumption.
Today the continent consumes roughly 38 EJ against only 6 EJ produced domestically, with Russian supply now largely severed and Russian LNG under a 2027 phase-out deadline. This represents an extraordinary inversion of insecure hydrocarbon import dependency form 30% in 1995 to 80% in 2026.
The gap between what Europe consumes and what it can produce has widened from something manageable to something genuinely precarious. End of link.
So now you know why so many nations have to meet with the head chopper.
It is pretty obvious to me that Trump is making moves in the energy market when he took out Maduro and is going after Iran. The race to "win" the AI battle is really a race to see who can generate the most electricity to supply data centers. On that front, Europe is a distant third and China is the clear #2.
With Trump talking about taking Iran's oil, I have to wonder if Russia felt that NATO was trying to do likewise with its oil and gas and felt the need to intervene once NATO was on its border. It sure seems like the Ukraine war, war on Iran, and "war" in Venezuela all have to do with energy.
Why illegal?The failed comedian's term ended a long time ago. Try to keep up, mate.
Reiner Otto
04-11-26, 09:13
The failed comedian's term ended a long time ago.Bullsh.
"Law of Ukraine "On the Legal Regime of Martial Law" (2015) prohibits the holding of elections during martial law and the Electoral Code of Ukraine (2019) ordains suspension of all elections during such period. ".
Ref. https://verfassungsblog.de/ukraines-constitution-in-wartime/.
Do not just fail into Putlers desinformation, mate. Or is he your employer?
The failed comedian's term ended a long time ago. Try to keep up, mate.No, read Ukrainian constitution, Zelensky is still fully legal. Putin attacking Ukraine makes him staying longer. If Russians were really free for voting, I wonder if dictator Putin would be elected?
Bullsh.
"Law of Ukraine "On the Legal Regime of Martial Law" (2015) prohibits the holding of elections during martial law and the Electoral Code of Ukraine (2019) ordains suspension of all elections during such period. ".
Ref. https://verfassungsblog.de/ukraines-constitution-in-wartime/.
Do not just fail into Putlers desinformation, mate. Or is he your employer?Many countries have held elections during war time. But the little corrupt dictator refuses to do so because he knows he will be shown the door.
Many countries have held elections during war time. But the little corrupt dictator refuses to do so because he knows he will be shown the door.He is fully legal according to Ukrainian constitution and great he resist to criminal dictator Putin and robber Trump, when Ukrainians don t want to become blind Russians or to be robbed by shameful USA under Trump. I wish robber Orban will be kicked off today, when Hungarians would be much better without him who built such castle with their money. Also wish for criminal Netanyahou soon.
Reiner Otto
04-12-26, 16:22
Many countries have held elections during war time. Which ones? OK, the US, without foreign soldiers on own soil, and far from any real fighting. Opposed to Soviet Union, which postponed elections during WW II.
No elections in GB, during the war, too. Anyway, Rada in UA confirmed the no elections during wartime. Which are impractical, anyway, as long as Putler occupies part of the country and holds hostage the population.
Very sad for what Russia make in Mariopol, people must become Russian, not by choice, but to live in their land, or they have to leave as thousands. Shame on Russia to act like this, no freedom, no human rights. Very sad for children losing their roots, what is in their blood, to be allowed to go to school, to make activities, like all children. Despite Russian behavior, I hope they will never forget their origins, where they are from. Resist in mind, never forget.
Do you know his nickname? It's 'mother's pie' that is pussy. Technical changes impact the front line each month. Last month it was new communication systems to replace Starlink. Soon you will see new automated antidrone systems. The changes on the political side came with realization that EU may turn into a military alliance which in turn means open objection to Ukraine path into EU. No peace as I see it.
Orban the Obstructionist got his ass kicked out of office. Analysts are divided about whether his main problem was his Putin sycophancy or just garden-variety corruption. Either way, the opposition gained a supermajority and will be cleaning out Viktor's rat's nest in short order.
Orban the Obstructionist got his ass kicked out of office. Analysts are divided about whether his main problem was his Putin sycophancy or just garden-variety corruption. Either way, the opposition gained a supermajority and will be cleaning out Viktor's rat's nest in short order.Orban built a big castle with EU money.
Which ones? .Don't be lazy and do your homework. The corrupt dictator Zelensky wants perpetual martial law so his reign of corruption continues. I can't wait for the day the brave Ukrainian people show him the door. But I'm sure he will be living a luxurious life overseas with all this stolen money rather than face justice.
Very sad for what Russia make in Mariopol, people must become Russian, not by choice, but to live in their land, or they have to leave as thousands. Shame on Russia to act like this, no freedom, no human rights. Very sad for children losing their roots, what is in their blood, to be allowed to go to school, to make activities, like all children. Despite Russian behavior, I hope they will never forget their origins, where they are from. Resist in mind, never forget.You are completely brainwashed. Geo politics isn't your forte. Stick to punting. And watch something other than Fox news or Sky news or the BBC. Try to watch some independent media. Eastern Ukraine has always been Russian. Putin saved the lives of those children by removing them from the front line. The kidnapping children BS is old now, give it a rest.
The EU and the west do not give a rats ass about Ukrainian children or any children for that matter. If that weren't the case, they wouldn't have been complicit in a genocide in Gaza where tens of thousands of children were slaughtered.
Mariupol is being rebuilt. There are videos of new Mariupol on the internet. Google it.
Don't be lazy and do your homework. The corrupt dictator Zelensky wants perpetual martial law so his reign of corruption continues. I can't wait for the day the brave Ukrainian people show him the door. But I'm sure he will be living a luxurious life overseas with all this stolen money rather than face justice.Putin is a well known dictator, not Zelensky. Read Ukrainian constitution. I don't say no corruption in Ukraine, but do You swear no corruption in Russia, when Putin who was in FSB made killing many to become what he is.
You are completely brainwashed. Geo politics isn't your forte. Stick to punting. And watch something other than Fox news or Sky news or the BBC. Try to watch some independent media. Eastern Ukraine has always been Russian. Putin saved the lives of those children by removing them from the front line. The kidnapping children BS is old now, give it a rest.
The EU and the west do not give a rats ass about Ukrainian children or any children for that matter. If that weren't the case, they wouldn't have been complicit in a genocide in Gaza where tens of thousands of children were slaughtered.
Mariupol is being rebuilt. There are videos of new Mariupol on the internet. Google it.Do you only listen to Pravda? Joke for such name. Did you forget 1989/1991? Putin already stole Crimea and now Donbass which did belong to Ukraine after 1991. Yes, now rebuilding Marioupol he destroyed, when people and children there were Ukrainians. I would not like to have no other choice than becoming Russian, then I would not feel Russian at all and would hate Putin for this, stealing my identity.
Do you only listen to Pravda? Joke for such name. Did you forget 1989/1991? Putin already stole Crimea and now Donbass which did belong to Ukraine after 1991. Yes, now rebuilding Marioupol he destroyed, when people and children there were Ukrainians. I would not like to have no other choice than becoming Russian, then I would not feel Russian at all and would hate Putin for this, stealing my identity.Are you Ukrainian? Just curious.
Crimea has always been Russian. Google it. The vast majority of their population identify as Russians. Crimea was taken without even a fire being shot. Why do you think that is? And the Crimean people voted to join Russia.
The EU set the precedent with Kosovo and that referendum they had. You reap what you sow.
Putin is a well known dictator, not Zelensky. Read Ukrainian constitution. I don't say no corruption in Ukraine, but do You swear no corruption in Russia, when Putin who was in FSB made killing many to become what he is.There is corruption in both Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine is the most corrupt country in Europe. Both Putin and Zelensky are dictators. At least I'm consistent. And Putin is extremely smart, Zelensky is just a corrupt clown.
John Clayton
04-15-26, 20:17
...Crimea has always been Russian. Google it. ...Okay, I did. You're regurgitating pure Russain propaganda. The history of Crimea has been that of Russian conquest and continued suppression of ethno nationalists for the last 250 years.
Reiner Otto
04-15-26, 21:53
Don't be lazy and do your homework. This is typical for (Russian) trolls, not to provide proof for their "alternative truth". When Putler stops his war, then you will get your elections in UA.
Until then, the president of the UA during wartime does the same as Stalin during the war: No elections.
Are you Ukrainian? Just curious.
Crimea has always been Russian. Google it. The vast majority of their population identify as Russians. Crimea was taken without even a fire being shot. Why do you think that is? And the Crimean people voted to join Russia.
The EU set the precedent with Kosovo and that referendum they had. You reap what you sow.I love Russia, so I can only hate criminal dictator Putin ranked as war criminal. Crimea did belong to Ukraine from 1991, don't you know?
As the saying goes: Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but not their own facts.
In any conflict it's understandable that each side will push the narratives they believe best serve their interests. And those narratives can span the spectrum from sincerely held beliefs to blatant lies. Whatever the case, anyone who accepts either side's narrative without doing their own research to verify and confirm (or debunk) is either a shill, troll, or fool.
As one example, the Russian narrative is that Zelenskyy has somehow improperly or illegally held on to power. The counterpoint from Ukraine is that elections are prohibited during times of martial law. From (non-Ukrainian) sources I've checked, the Ukrainian prohibition on elections during wartime was enacted in 2015, which was before Zelenskyy took office. Additionally, martial law needs to be affirmatively renewed by the legislature every 90 days. Since the war has been going on for 4 years, that's around 16 renewals. One may not like it, or agree with it, but Zelenskyy is following a process created before he assumed office.
It's also quite interesting to observe the hyper-projection of anti-Ukraine sentiment onto the person of Zelenskyy. There's zero evidence that his absence from the scene would result in any changes in Ukraine's attitude or position. In fact, if Zelenskyy vanished tomorrow, the favorite to replace him is former Commanding General (and current Ambassador to the UK) Zaluzhnyi.
Whatever one's feelings about Zelenskyy, to myopically focus on him is an intellectually lazy position.
As the saying goes: Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but not their own facts.
In any conflict it's understandable that each side will push the narratives they believe best serve their interests. And those narratives can span the spectrum from sincerely held beliefs to blatant lies. Whatever the case, anyone who accepts either side's narrative without doing their own research to verify and confirm (or debunk) is either a shill, troll, or fool.
As one example, the Russian narrative is that Zelenskyy has somehow improperly or illegally held on to power. The counterpoint from Ukraine is that elections are prohibited during times of martial law. From (non-Ukrainian) sources I've checked, the Ukrainian prohibition on elections during wartime was enacted in 2015, which was before Zelenskyy took office. Additionally, martial law needs to be affirmatively renewed by the legislature every 90 days. Since the war has been going on for 4 years, that's around 16 renewals. One may not like it, or agree with it, but Zelenskyy is following a process created before he assumed office.
It's also quite interesting to observe the hyper-projection of anti-Ukraine sentiment onto the person of Zelenskyy. There's zero evidence that his absence from the scene would result in any changes in Ukraine's attitude or position. In fact, if Zelenskyy vanished tomorrow, the favorite to replace him is former Commanding General (and current Ambassador to the UK) Zaluzhnyi.
Whatever one's feelings about Zelenskyy, to myopically focus on him is an intellectually lazy position.What is sure is Russian official medias tell what Putin wants they tell and a ex actor resisting to him from KGB and FSB who made being killed so many, is kind of humiliation. Despite doubts of corruption, but Putin built beautiful castles, not anymore kolkhozes, no riot in Ukraine or in medias. Ukr versus Zelensky and at least he tries to defend Ukrainians versus Putin who attacked them and robbed them Marioupol and other parts of Donbass, after Crimea. Putin is ranked as a war criminal, same than Netanyahou.
Elvis 2008
04-23-26, 16:27
Seymour Hersh is someone I do not always agree with but I am astonished at his contacts and how he has gotten facts right before anyone else, and this post shocked the crap out of me.
Russia's stalled War in Ukraine, The conflict's turning into a drone war has turned the tide.
The war in Ukraine, which began with Russian President Vladimir Putin's invasion in February 2022, has gone on longer than the Soviet war against Nazi Germany. With its huge army and population, Russia seemed in the early years to be on the verge of winning only to have Putin, behaving like the irrational czars of the past, reject peace plans that gave him control of some of the territory his troops had taken inside eastern Ukraine. And now, I have been told, a war that Russia seemed to be winning has turned in the last year into an economic and military nightmare for Putin and the Russian army led by General Valery Gerasimov, the battle-tested commander who is one of three men in Russia with access to the nation's nuclear codes.
The war is now a war of drones, in the view of one military expert who has toured the front under cover, with Ukraine holding a distinct edge. Bedraggled Russian soldiers at the front find themselves under deadly drone attack the moment they crawl out of their bunkers. "Ukraine has a vast drone surveillance network that is picking off Russians as soon as they appear," the expert told me. He added that he was repelled by the horrid living conditions for all the soldiers on both sides of the front lines.
One fix to the growing Russian battlefield losses was to offer potential recruits a bonus of hundreds of thousands or millions of rubles to sign up. The bonus is not fully paid out in most cases, I was told, until the recruits finish their basic training and get to the front. Once there, the corruption reaches new heights because officers demand payments to keep the new recruits from being sent to combat zones at the front, where death by drone awaits.
The result of the corruption and the intense Ukrainian drone surveillance, the expert told me, is that the Russian army "is no further along in its invasion than it was two years earlier. They can't move—have no offensive capability. This is the same army that went from Moscow to Berlin in World War II. Now the army has gone only one hundred kilometers into Ukraine. No real progress at all."
Another sign of Russia's, and Putin's, fall from military and political dominance in the region, the expert added, was the decision of Finland, which shares a 830-mile border with Russia, and Sweden, which shares a maritime border, to join NATO. In general, the official noted, the losing war, the rise of NATO, and the nation's economic downturn—as measured by economists around the world—has undone Russia's long held strategy of maintaining regional dominance and diminishing the import of NATO. "This was an incredible defeat for the Russians," the official told me. It has also freed up Putin's critics to become more outspoken.
One person who has been more vocal in his private conversations about Russia's demise is General Gerasimov, who as chief of staff has had repeated contacts with his peers in the US and British armed forces about theater-wide military issues. He is kept up to date on various peace talks involving Americans and other nations eager for a political settlement to the Russian war with Ukraine.
The expert told me that Gerasimov has always seen the Russian army as the people's army, and not that of the czars—an obvious reference to Putin. The general, the expert said, "wants to end the Ukraine war with honor—to save Russia. Only the poor with no money and no education stay" to fight.
The expert said that in speaking out about the corruption and the lack of the best available Russian soldiers being in the war Gerasimov is being true to his oath of office and to the army. "And the army respects him for it," the expert told me.
Meanwhile, the much criticized Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukraine's president since his election in 2019, widely thought to participate in the corruption that has tarnished Ukraine for decades, has emerged from the war as a respected leader who never lost faith, even in the worst of days, in the ability of Ukraine's army to defeat Russia. By contrast, Putin has destroyed any reputation he had as a sagacious world leader by irrationally resisting any settlement of the war as his army and his economy crumbles.
A few questions remain.
Will Putin ever allow Gerasimov to tell the truth to the Russian people about the costs to the Russian army and Russia's standing in the world of their president's decision to attack Ukraine?
And is there any senior officer in the US military willing to do the same about the leadership in the White House and Pentagon in the aftermath of the vital decisions about the Middle East that are now being made in Washington and Tel Aviv?
Will it happen in Russia and not in America? If so, what does that tell us?
End of link.
Yeah, the American and Israel stuff I think is nonsense. It was interesting though that the counter to manpower was drones. At this point, if you are Putin, you have to wonder what the point of fighting is anymore. At this point, all you are doing is killing your young people.
The other part I found interesting is how during the Iran war, the USA was using these million dollar interceptors to shoot down these thousand dollar drones while Ukraine has been building massive amount of thousand dollar drones and how Ukraine of all places was the most advanced nation in the world with regard to cheap drone warfare.
But I am a lot more optimistic about the Iran war than this one. Putin seems to have dug in and is incapable of admitting he made a mistake whereas the Iranian leadership is new with the old guard wiped out. You have to wonder if those close to Putin are thinking about putting him out of misery. Even Hitler had an assassination attempt.
At Elvis 2008 As I posted once, you should do better. Why to post the compiled nonsense? Just look at how have you ended the post. Yes, corruption is a centuries old issue in Russia. Yes, drones present very serious problem now. Everything else in the article is crap, and I can deconstruct it piece by piece. I wonder who was the intended audience of the article? I guess nobody, because no one in Ukraine or Russia would take such cheap crap. 'The expert', just pathetic.
Enter The V
04-24-26, 14:05
So this overrated ass War that never escalated to anything! Has lasted longer than WW2 LOL.
At Elvis 2008 As I posted once, you should do better. Why to post the compiled nonsense? Just look at how have you ended the post. Yes, corruption is a centuries old issue in Russia. Yes, drones present very serious problem now. Everything else in the article is crap, and I can deconstruct it piece by piece. I wonder who was the intended audience of the article? I guess nobody, because no one in Ukraine or Russia would take such cheap crap. 'The expert', just pathetic.But Putin showed to the world his huge army with many Russian meats, but so many left Russia of Putin, is not performing, not able to defeat poor Ukrainians since 2022, when Ukrainians adapted their army, now advising even USA about drones. I'm happy no more Orban. Hu, so EU will help Ukraine with 90 billions €, when inflation and the fall for economics for Russia, even Trump helped Russia when blocking Ormuz and don t help Ukraine since his election. He would prefer to make business with Putin. Fortunately, EU help Ukraine and I m very proud about this, even agreeing to pay tax for this, versus criminal dictator Putin ranked as international war criminal.
Reiner Otto
04-24-26, 16:34
You have to wonder if those close to Putin are thinking about putting him out of misery. Somebody told me, a $1 B bounty would solve the issue very fast. . And relatively cheap.
It's always interesting, whenever someone advances historical arguments about this place or that belonging to a certain country or people, to observe what point in time they choose as their reference. This is especially true in areas of the world where territory has changed hands many times. For example, Israelis and Palestinians both tend to cherry-pick the historical record to maximize their own claims and minimize the other. Irrespective of which narrative one prefers, however, there are historically established facts that any intellectually honest position needs to acknowledge. It's beyond rational dispute that there was an ancient kingdom of Israel, based in Jerusalem, which fact Jews see as central to their claim. It's also well-established that there were periods in history when there was little or no Jewish presence in the area and Arab groups were dominant. Any honest debate, at a minimum, needs to refrain from twisting history to fit their own narrative.
Similarly, Crimea has been under the rule of the Roman, Byzantine, Ottoman, and Russian empires, followed by the USSR. Of all those, the Byzantines ruled longest by far from Istanbul (800+ years) and arguably have a strong claim. It's also historically relevant that the indigenous Crimean people, the Tatars, endured periods (esp under Stalin) in which they were removed from Crimea and replaced by people from more Slavic areas of Russia. Whatever one thinks about an empire's right to move its population around, it does muddy the waters when making history-based claims.
Even the Russian heartland has issues, since its existence derives from Kyivan Rus, which preceded Moscow by hundreds of years. And then the Mongols took over the neighborhood for another couple of hundred years. Eventually the Mongols faded and Moscow began its own territorial expansion. That expansion and growth, however, doesn't alter their origin story, just as Brazil, larger by far, still acknowledges its Portuguese beginnings.
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Rurik-dynasty
For most empires, their borders were redrawn after defeat in war (ex. Ottoman and Austro-Hungarian) and their former territories were either claimed by the victors or went their own way. The Russian Empire didn't fall to an external power but was taken over from within by way of revolution. Territories that tried to break away at that time were forcibly pulled back in. The Soviets inherited the empire's territories and ruled until dissolution in 1991. That historical inflection point can certainly be argued to be the functional equivalent of an empire losing territories by defeat or collapse, as it's certainly the case that many of the former Soviet Republics declared independence and went their own way. After 1991 the leadership in Moscow signed numerous agreements with the newly independent countries (incl with Ukraine) acknowledging the new territorial reality. I'm not sure about other former Soviet Republics, but I know Ukraine held a vote in which every region, including Crimea, voted to separate from Russia.
In one sense the 1991 breakup can be viewed as a contentious divorce in which one party (Russia) is unhappy with the settlement and wants to change things by force. Putin has often relied on historical arguments, although obviously from a perspective that favors the Russian narrative.
https://historyguild.org/why-does-putin-insist-ukranians-and-russians-are-one-people-the-answer-spans-centuries-of-colonisation-and-resistance/
IIRC, he made a speech a couple of years ago referring to himself as the modern day equivalent of Peter the Great, with a mission to regather Russian lands. The only problem is that all of those former territories are now independent. Not just Ukraine, but Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, the Baltics, etc. So where does one fix the historical reference point? It's pretty clear where Putin places it, but others would beg to differ. Mongolia anyone? Byzantium calling?
It's always interesting, whenever someone advances historical arguments about this place or that belonging to a certain country or people, to observe what point in time they choose as their reference. This is especially true in areas of the world where territory has changed hands many times. For example, Israelis and Palestinians both tend to cherry-pick the historical record to maximize their own claims and minimize the other. Irrespective of which narrative one prefers, however, there are historically established facts that any intellectually honest position needs to acknowledge. It's beyond rational dispute that there was an ancient kingdom of Israel, based in Jerusalem, which fact Jews see as central to their claim. It's also well-established that there were periods in history when there was little or no Jewish presence in the area and Arab groups were dominant. Any honest debate, at a minimum, needs to refrain from twisting history to fit their own narrative.
Similarly, Crimea has been under the rule of the Roman, Byzantine, Ottoman, and Russian empires, followed by the USSR. Of all those, the Byzantines ruled longest by far from Istanbul (800+ years) and arguably have a strong claim.In 1991, Putin was nothing and about decision with Crimea and Donbass belonging to new Ukraine. Many years after, Putin decided to make his own war.
It's always interesting, whenever someone advances historical arguments about this place or that belonging to a certain country or people, to observe what point in time they choose as their refere.
..................
In one sense the 1991 breakup can be viewed as a contentious divorce in which one party (Russia) is unhappy with the settlement and wants to change things by force. Putin has often relied on historical arguments, although obviously from a perspective that favors the Russian narrative.Let me just add that Putin's claims to Crimea and the rest of Ukraine are not only criminal but illiterate. No honest historian would take them seriously. It was Yeltsin who initiated and conspired with Ukraine and (back then) Belorussia to dissolve the USSR. Why? Only to deny Gorbachev the way to return to power after the defeat of the 1991 coup. With an exception of the Baltic states, the big Soviet breakup was not a result of anti-colonial movements from the former Soviet Republics; it was Yeltsin's way to usurp all the power in Russia by taking away Gorbachev's job since he couldn't afford to take away Gorby himself.
Certainly, the peaceful dissolution of the USSR was a blessing. It prevented the Yugoslavia's scenario in a nuclear country. But it wasn't Russia's motivation at the time. Their motivation was power. Easy-peasy.
With petrol increasing rate because of blocking Ormuz, Trump is making big gift, more than 250 billions, to his criminal dictator friend Putin. No MAGA, when a shameful loser leading USA.
https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/05/01/sacked-russian-deputy-minister-flees-to-us-amid-fraud-probe-sources-say-a92663
The curious part isn't that a Deputy Minister would flee to avoid prosecution, that's understandable. But, if the report is accurate, he traveled Moscow to Minsk to Tblisi to the US. So, the curious part to me is why flee to America? Once clear of Russia's borders he could have gone to any place from which extradition would be unlikely, Turkey and UAE come to mind (among others).
It's my understanding that visas for Russian citizens are not currently being issued by the US. Pre-approved diplomatic visits are another matter, but that would require coordination between the US State Department and the Russian Foreign Ministry. That's unlikely, for at least three reasons: First, because of the unusual trip routing; Second, because there's no official reason for a Deputy Environmental Minister to visit right now; and Third, as someone under investigation, he would obviously not want to tip his hand about wanting to leave Russia and it's doubtful he'd be allowed to leave.
In view of the above, and considering how quickly he was allowed entry into the US, the clear implication is that he had some channel of communication with the US that didn't go through (and wasn't known by) the Russian government. One possibility is that he was a US asset, and another is that this was part of a contingency plan laid out in advance. There might be other explanations, but those are two that come immediately to mind.
What I'll be watching for now is whether he stays in the US for an extended period (or permanently) or whether he continues on to take up residence in another country. Also, since the Kremlin is obviously not going to be happy, hopefully he's got access to enough money to pay for robust security!
https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/05/01/sacked-russian-deputy-minister-flees-to-us-amid-fraud-probe-sources-say-a92663
The curious part isn't that a Deputy Minister would flee to avoid prosecution, that's understandable. But, if the report is accurate, he traveled Moscow to Minsk to Tblisi to the US. So, the curious part to me is why flee to America? Once clear of Russia's borders he could have gone to any place from which extradition would be unlikely, Turkey and UAE come to mind (among others).
It's my understanding that visas for Russian citizens are not currently being issued by the US. Pre-approved diplomatic visits are another matter, but that would require coordination between the US State Department and the Russian Foreign Ministry. That's unlikely, for at least three reasons: First, because of the unusual trip routing; Second, because there's no official reason for a Deputy Environmental Minister to visit right now; and Third, as someone under investigation, he would obviously not want to tip his hand about wanting to leave Russia and it's doubtful he'd be allowed to leave.I don't know if diplomatic visits really need to be pre-approved. Plenty of Russian bigwigs have diplomatic passports, including sanctioned oligarchs, and use them as they see fit: https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2024/11/14/russias-elites-family-and-friends-travel-abroad-on-diplomatic-passports-the-insider-a87018
Or he might have US or other citizenship allowing him to travel to the US. It's amazing how many of those "Collective West" haters do.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/insight/russian-deputy-minister-defects-as-kremlin-fears-elite-coup/gm-GMD9BAA403
Obviously one article is not definitive proof, but there are literally no articles (as in zero) that take the position that this is in any way a normal or routine trip.
- On the diplomatic side of things, there are at least three issues to consider:
First, since the beginning of Russia's invasion, I'm not aware of any visits to the US by Russian diplomats that haven't had a nexus to negotiations to try to end the war. The delegation to the United Nations is an obvious exception. But we are simply nowhere near a "normal" diplomatic environment.
Second, even in normal times, a Deputy Minister traveling solo would be highly irregular. A Deputy Minister might accompany the Principal Minister as an aide, or travel as part of a larger delegation. That's not what happened here. In fact there's nothing in this account that's consistent with routine diplomatic travel.
Third, any normal diplomatic endeavor would require the involvement of the Russian government. Every indication and report is that he slipped away because he was being investigated and feared arrest. Had the Russian government known in time, it's likely he would have been arrested or at least prevented from traveling. Also, his choice of Belarus as his initial destination would be the least likely to raise a red flag.
- On the personal side of things, he either traveled on a Russian passport or that of a third country. Either way presents problems:
With his personal Russian passport, he would absolutely need a visa. That would require an application at the US Embassy and a personal interview. It's hard to imagine anything like that happening without the FSB knowing. In fact, it's a pretty good bet the FSB is aware of every Russian who has any contact whatsoever with the US Embassy or Consulates. And that's especially true with respect to government officials.
If he has a third-country passport, he would almost certainly not have used it when boarding his Moscow to Minsk flight, as that would raise questions. Also, if he used it for Minsk to Tblisi, that could also be problematic as airport officials usually want to see an entry stamp before they'll process an exit stamp. And Belarus is still not safe territory, so he'd be sent back to Russia should any irregularity be spotted. So, if we assume a third-country passport, Tbilisi is where he would most likely to have started using it, but would still have to deal with lacking an entry stamp.
Even assuming the most favorable circumstances (third-country passport with no visa required for BOTH the US and Georgia), he's still not the clear. DHS gets a copy of the passenger manifest for every flight scheduled to arrive in the US. There's no way Butsayev, no matter what passport he used, could escape being flagged as a Russian government official. Once flagged, it's virtually certain he would be detained at the arrival airport and questioned. He would not be viewed as a casual visitor, irrespective of what passport he was using. And DHS would also be aware of his unusual Moscow to Minsk to Tblisi to USA trip routing.
Of course, if everything was worked out in advance, through a confidential back-channel or intermediary, then easy-peasy and no problem! So, while more details will certainly help clear things up, at this point in time it's safe to say that all available indications are that this was not a regular, routine trip (personal or diplomatic). More details would certainly be nice but, if this truly is a defection, we may not get many. Also, no matter how you slice it, the Kremlin can't be happy that they let him slip away.
Similarly, Crimea has been under the rule of the Roman, Byzantine, Ottoman, and Russian empires, followed by the USSR. Of all those, the Byzantines ruled longest by far from Istanbul (800+ years) and arguably have a strong claim. It's also historically relevant that the indigenous Crimean people, the Tatars, endured periods (esp under Stalin) in which they were removed from Crimea and replaced by people from more Slavic areas of Russia. Whatever one thinks about an empire's right to move its population around, it does muddy the waters when making history-based claims.Crimean Tatars, and residents of Crimea in general, overwhelmingly would prefer Crimea being part of Russia instead of Ukraine. Now and in 2014 after the referendum.
Roman Blazduk
05-06-26, 20:59
Crimean Tatars, and residents of Crimea in general, overwhelmingly would prefer Crimea being part of Russia instead of Ukraine. Now and in 2014 after the referendum.The Tatars are Turkish / Mongol in origin and have no affinity to the Russian empire. They consider themselves to be the Cossacks of the Crimean peninsula.
Reiner Otto
05-06-26, 21:20
Crimean Tatars, overwhelmingly would prefer Crimea being part of Russia instead of Ukraine. Now and in 2014 after the referendum.Yep, because having no other choice, after the occupation. They dearly love Russians, because of being deported to Siberia under Stalin and allowed to come back to Crimea, the home country.
In 1988.
Elvis 2008
05-06-26, 21:44
More details would certainly be nice but, if this truly is a defection, we may not get many. Also, no matter how you slice it, the Kremlin can't be happy that they let him slip away.Nah, JM, the defections are happening on the front in mass. While Ukraine is grabbing young men off the street, the Russians at first glance were more humane. They were paying young people big $ to go to the Ukraine front. Thing is as soon as the recruits got there, the senior officers made the recruits pay them all that they have received. According to an article from Seymour Hersh, if you did not pay all that you got, you were sent to the front or just tied to a tree and shot and killed.
The Ukraine war reminds me of what a driver's ed teacher of mine said decades ago. "When there is a deadly accident, does it really matter who is at fault? Both parties probably lost. "
When you are at war this long, it no longer is about the nation or pride or security, the troops just want to get out alive. They have no allegiance to anything but that.
If I had to deal with seeing a friend hunted down by a drone and his guts splattered all over me, I would drink, smoke dope or shoot heroin to cope. Wouldn't you?
Whatever land has been won or lost pales in comparison to the addictions and PTSD that is going to affect the soldiers of both these nations for decades. If you are in a forever war, you have not just lost high ranking government officials, you have lost the troops.
Unless you win a war quickly and decisively, you have lost. At that point, your declaration of victory is really saying the other side lost more than you did. Well, is that victory or was not ending the war sooner the smart move?
One distinct difference between Trump and Biden was Trump used to be so anti-war. He bragged endlessly how the Ukraine war would have never happened had he been president, so what does he do? He gets in a forever war with Iran. Yeesh.
Anybody sitting at their keyboards picking sides in a forever war needs to go down to the front and put their money with their mouth is. The defections then will continue until this stupid war is over.
The Tatars are Turkish / Mongol in origin and have no affinity to the Russian empire. They consider themselves to be the Cossacks of the Crimean peninsula.
Yep, because having no other choice, after the occupation. They dearly love Russians, because of being deported to Siberia under Stalin and allowed to come back to Crimea, the home country.
In 1988.You're absolutely right about Tatars and I'm showing off my cultural illiteracy. I was confusing Tatars with Cossacks in the Donbas. The ex-business partner of a work colleague comes from a town there that's been bitterly fought over for a couple of years now. His family is Russian speaking Cossack and Ukrainians have been persecuting them.
You're absolutely right about Tatars and I'm showing off my cultural illiteracy. I was confusing Tatars with Cossacks in the Donbas. The ex-business partner of a work colleague comes from a town there that's been bitterly fought over for a couple of years now. His family is Russian speaking Cossack and Ukrainians have been persecuting them.Until 2014 Ukrainians were persecuting Russian speaking people in Donbas maybe with stupid jokes or some prejudice but the borders to Russia were open and everybody could visit everybody and nobody had anything to gain from a war (save for rackets and thugs and a weak leader who saw no other way to stay in power than to go complete his transition into a real dictator).
It's a world of confusion, isn't it? Crimean Tatars have nothing to do with this current conflict. Yes, they were at the receiving end of Stalin's regime (do not equal with 'Russian), as other interned Japanese or Italians in the US and Canada, for example.
For his personal war, ranked as war criminal and dictator Putin just doesn't care about citizens roots, but from unknown in KGB, became to try to rebuild USSR, when thousands Russians prefer to leave Russia of Putin. But he feels threatened now and need to increase security around him.
PaulInZurich
05-07-26, 17:07
I wouldn't have believed when the Russian invasion started that Ukraine will manage to bring the war to a stalemate. Incredible how the war changed, from a blitzkrieg to a stalemate where there is a death zone of 50 km all along the frontlines, where anybody who sticks their head out has a drone on their head. Both Russia and Ukraine innovated a lot, the other countries must be paying attention.
Reiner Otto
05-07-26, 17:32
It's a world of confusion, isn't it? Crimean Tatars have nothing to do with this current conflict. Yes, they were at the receiving end of Stalin's regime (do not equal with 'Russian), as other interned Japanese or Italians in the US and Canada, for example.First, both Italy and Japan participated in the war. Tartars did not. Second, in the camps for Italiens or Japanese, there was some support. Not to compare with the "support" in the Siberian camps.
Third, Putlers invasion of UA to be justified, because Adolf also did it, for example.
Defection, from Russia to the USA, looking to be a likely scenario (IMO).
Neither the US or Russian governments have said a word about this. From Russia, no outrage or demands for the return of their official who is under investigation. From the US, absolutely nothing at all that I could find. No acknowledgement of the matter, nothing!
So, if it's a true defection, makes me wonder what info he has to trade in exchange for permission to stay and (probably) some level of protection from an angry and embarrassed Kremlin.
Primary link:
https://x.com/Gerashchenko_en/status/2052367063184724229
Alternate link:
https://xcancel.com/Gerashchenko_en/status/2052367063184724229
No direct confirmation as of yet, but certainly interesting if true. Not sure how the FSB would be unaware since they almost certainly have a file on most (all?) government officials.
Still no direct comment from either government. Curiouser and curiouser!
Primary link:
https://x.com/Gerashchenko_en/status/2052367063184724229
Alternate link:
https://xcancel.com/Gerashchenko_en/status/2052367063184724229
No direct confirmation as of yet, but certainly interesting if true. Not sure how the FSB would be unaware since they almost certainly have a file on most (all?) government officials.
Still no direct comment from either government. Curiouser and curiouser!You're thinking about FSB as an embodiment of ruthless efficiency. It isn't. It's a pale shadow of the KGB. The whole mother Russia is incompetent to the core, their economy is in the gutter, the war at the stalemate, 1.5 million are dead or crippled, and you're surprised the FSB let one guy off the hook?
I don't give two shits about Butsayev. So he stole a few shekels and lived to tell the story. Good. The Russian corruption is a great Ukrainian ally. Let them steal everything, they have my blessing.
Disasters provide opportunities.
Political discussions are actually unwanted on a monger forum!
But how about the pussies in Kiev? Are they hungry and easy to catch? Any monger to report?
I'm so happy French associations help Ukraine to block Russian drones.
Disasters provide opportunities.
Political discussions are actually unwanted on a monger forum!
But how about the pussies in Kiev? Are they hungry and easy to catch? Any monger to report?Another thread: Kiev, for this, when under war of Putin for the fifth year. Wish will finish soon.
While he's one notch below the highest (ministerial) level of the Russian government, he couldn't have reached that post without the endorsement and backing of a strong patron. Putin runs Russia like a Mafia state, and one firm requirement for reaching the upper levels is absolute loyalty to the Don. Also, while principal Ministers can be figureheads, their deputies are often the ones actually running the department. That generally means they have some degree of competence and also knowledge about what goes on behind the scenes. Butsayev's prior government positions included significant leadership roles in both Belgorod and Moscow Oblasts, so he's been around a while and moved around within government.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denis_Butsayev
The main point is simply that he was a "made man," a trusted lieutenant, just below the top tier of the hierarchy. Such individuals are not afforded the luxury of leaving voluntarily as they know too much. The FSB, regardless of how effective or efficient one believes them to be, is tasked with maintaining the hierarchy, enforcing discipline, "disappearing" problems, etc. A quick web search reveals some of their (alleged) handiwork.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspicious_Russia-related_deaths_since_2022
One of the biggest dangers to any Strong Man form of government is displaying weakness. That's true not only for the leader himself, but also for those parts of the government (like the FSB) used as the leader's enforcement arms. The fact the FSB failed in this instance puts a dent in the perception of strength and control. It's not so much about Butsayev, as an individual, as it is about the cracks in the system that allowed him to escape.
Will there be others? Hard to say and only time will tell. But what's clear is that Butsayev showed it's possible, and I have no doubt there are some in Russia who are working on their own "just in case" escape plan. And, speaking of the perception of strength, it can't be helpful for Putin that this year's Victory Day parade was a shadow of its former versions. It was quite literally the worst in Soviet and Russian history!
Bottom line: A system failure undeniably occurred, a crack in the system. Will it be repaired? Will others try to take advantage? Can the perception of strength be restored? Will there be lasting damage? All questions open to different opinions and worthy of debate (IMO).
Elvis 2008
05-12-26, 02:33
Will there be others? Hard to say and only time will tell. But what's clear is that Butsayev showed it's possible, and I have no doubt there are some in Russia who are working on their own "just in case" escape plan. And, speaking of the perception of strength, it can't be helpful for Putin that this year's Victory Day parade was a shadow of its former versions. It was quite literally the worst in Soviet and Russian history!
Bottom line: A system failure undeniably occurred, a crack in the system. Will it be repaired? Will others try to take advantage? Can the perception of strength be restored? Will there be lasting damage? All questions open to different opinions and worthy of debate (IMO).The one thing you can always count on with a military is they are filled with experts who have fought the last war. Ukraine has better drones than Russia does, and Iran is making drones for Russia. That more than anything should tell you how badly Russia is failing.
Peter Zeihan said the Russians would fight like they always had, using their superior number of troops and sacrificing the lives of those men, and Zeihan said the war was Russia's to lose. Well, unmanned drone warfare has stopped the Russians in their tracks. All that is going on now is the two nations are blowing up each other's infrastructure. What is the point of the war now? Putin has lost his troops, his government officials, and his country, and this desertion is the first of many. At least the Ukrainians can say they are defending their home land though I imagine fighting a forever war has sapped their morale as well.
And Trump caught this war-is-easy bug too. The Iranians did more damage with drones and missiles than anyone thought they could. Israel is all focused on Iran not having nukes when Iran could have wiped Israel off the map by destroying its desalination plants, but Iran did not do so even when attacked.
So now we have Trump, Netanyahu, and Putin all in the same boat. The only question is which will be the first to get their head out of their ass and realize they are fighting unwinnable wars.
Despite all his daily bullshits and when he thought could be good to fight China economics, but after spending 30 billions for 0 result, 1 mollah killed, 10 new who want to become martyr, and after failing for peace in Ukraine, Trump was told he lost war versus Iran, just killing Americans for nothing. Criminal Netanyahou is nothing without Trump, if no weapons and no support. Only way to stop Putin is to make Russia broke, what tried EU, but Trump made a big gift to Putin with petrol inflation, making more money for his war. When Americans are really not when electing again Trump, but poor Ukrainians are clever, learning a lot under war, adapting their army, becoming now the reference for drones, better than USA, Russia and China, when Russia and China support Iran versus Trump, when Trump suck Putin versus Ukraine. Cuckold Trump who is too old senile to understand reality of our world, but for sure not able for MAGA, but wars rather than peace and messe with inflation and lost jobs. Just a loser.
When stupid Trump make big gift to his criminal friend Putin with petrol increasing rate, billions for his war, but Ukrainians are fucking Russian petrol production with their best drones. When David became more clever than Goliath. Well played Ukrainians, fuck Russian petrol, gaz and bridges, make Russians go home. Then, could may be the end of dictator Putin and a better life for Russians when thousands ran away.
I know everyone has an opinion about Trump, Netanyahu, Zelenskyy, and Putin. But, IMO, excessive focus on those individuals misses some crucial issues.
Take Netanyahu, for example, no matter how one feels about him it's relevant to ask whether any Israeli leader would have acted in a significantly different way in the aftermath of the October 7th attack? From the Israeli point of view, Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Houthis are all doing Iran's bidding. So, while Hamas (in isolation) is one level of problem, adding Iran (and others) to the mix makes it an existential threat. Whether you agree or not doesn't matter and whether you love or hate Netanyahu doesn't matter. That's how Israel views the situation and any Israeli leader would need to act accordingly.
With respect to Trump, the most important question is whether one thinks Iran has been trying to achieve a level of nuclear weapons technology that would make them pretty much untouchable, similar to North Korea? Biden and Obama arguably just looked the other way, or swept the issue under the rug. So, assuming one believes Iran has actual (and dangerous) nuclear ambitions, criticizing Trump misses the point. The more important question is what would another president do if they weren't willing to look the other way?
About Zelenskyy, if he dropped dead or resigned tomorrow, it's virtually certain that his replacement would be someone equally (or more) resistant to the Russian invasion. In fact, one of the leading candidates would probably be General Zaluzhnyi, former armed forces chief and current ambassador to the UK. The idea that Zelenskyy, as an individual, is the problem is missing the forest for the trees. Ukraine sees the conflict as an existential struggle and they don't believe Russia will be satisfied with just the Donbas. Viewing this as an existential threat (similar to how Israel views Iran), any Ukrainian leader would need to act accordingly.
Finally, Putin is probably the best candidate for individual focus. That's because he personally ordered the invasion and he could personally order it to stop. But the bigger question is what happens after? It's certainly possible that Putin could be pushed out of office, especially if he's viewed as weak and a failure. If that happens, his replacement has two choices: First, blame Putin for everything and try to repair the damage. Second, double down on the war against Ukraine. That last choice would probably involve going into full Stalin mode.
But my main point remains. Any focus on the above individuals needs to also consider them in comparison to other alternatives. And those alternative choices would be shaped by the reality of their situations, not by things as we might wish them to be.
I know everyone has an opinion about Trump, Netanyahu, Zelenskyy, and Putin. But, IMO, excessive focus on those individuals misses some crucial issues.
Take Netanyahu, for example, no matter how one feels about him it's relevant to ask whether any Israeli leader would have acted in a significantly different way in the aftermath of the October 7th attack? From the Israeli point of view, Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Houthis are all doing Iran's bidding. So, while Hamas (in isolation) is one level of problem, adding Iran (and others) to the mix makes it an existential threat. Whether you agree or not doesn't matter and whether you love or hate Netanyahu doesn't matter. That's how Israel views the situation and any Israeli leader would need to act accordingly.
With respect to Trump, the most important question is whether one thinks Iran has been trying to achieve a level of nuclear weapons technology that would make them pretty much untouchable, similar to North Korea? Biden and Obama arguably just looked the other way, or swept the issue under the rug. So, assuming one believes Iran has actual (and dangerous) nuclear ambitions, criticizing Trump misses the point. The more important question is what would another president do if they weren't willing to look the other way?
About Zelenskyy, if he dropped dead or resigned tomorrow, it's virtually certain that his replacement would be someone equally (or more) resistant to the Russian invasion. In fact, one of the leading candidates would probably be General Zaluzhnyi, former armed forces chief and current ambassador to the UK. The idea that Zelenskyy, as an individual, is the problem is missing the forest for the trees..I don't agree: If Zelensky is not anymore, then Putin would try to fuck new elections in Ukraine, same like in Georgia, Armenia, Romania, Hungary. May have corruption, but Zelensky really fight for Ukraine, when Trump prefer to suck Putin. With his war business to avoid jail, not respecting peace agreements, war criminal Netanyahou makes almost everybody now hating Israel, not Israelians but Tsahal murderers, same like USA under Trump, not American citizens, but actions of USA led by crazy dangerous Trump. Netanyahou and Putin were judged as war criminals and Trump should be, after killing more than 150 Iranian girls at school, when he started this war, when CIA told 0 risk from Iran nuclear. But too old, schizophrene megaloman needs to feel he is the center of the world. Fortunately, many resist to his daily bullshits and lies.
The main point of my previous post is that it's a mistake to put too much focus and attention on individual persons, rather than the underlying geopolitical issues and dynamics.
Taking Zelenskyy as the easiest example, it's irrelevant whether one likes him or hates him. The more relevant question is what, if anything, would substantially change if he was no longer on the chessboard? My argument is that the bigger underlying issue is that Ukraine sees itself in an existential struggle. Therefore, if Zelenskyy was not in the picture, the dynamics within Ukraine would mandate that any chosen leader reflect that same (existential struggle) view, and act accordingly. And that also means Ukraine would not tolerate anyone as leader who might lean toward accommodating or appeasing Russia. This means that those who love to criticize Zelenskyy are missing the point because, at this moment in time and under the current set of circumstances, any other leader would almost certainly take a similarly hard line.
I could go on to construct similar examples using other leaders, but I won't, because I want to keep this clarification as simple as possible. Again, for anyone who puts most or all of their focus on the personalities involved, you are looking at the individual trees and are very likely missing the (bigger picture) forest.
Today, EU, UK and Canada still keep on supporting so courageous Ukrainians, welcoming Zelensky actions, versus war criminal dictator Putin, this in front of Trump who can't oppose, even he would prefer business with his friend Putin and rob Ukraine, like he also tries with Venezuela and Greenland. Russia is a wonderful country I love, but not under Putin, when nobosy never threatened Russia, despite Crimea robbery, even Trump condemned while his first election but forgot as senile. Same like Iran never threatened with nuclear, as reported by CIA, but Netanyahou needs wars business to avoid jail and lies rather than peace for Trump. Pity for Russia under Putin, when most beautiful women of the world and so good in bed, when many prefer than vodka drunk guys.
I know everyone has an opinion about Trump, Netanyahu, Zelenskyy, and Putin. But, IMO, excessive focus on those individuals misses some crucial issues.
>>
With respect to Trump, the most important question is whether one thinks Iran has been trying to achieve a level of nuclear weapons technology that would make them pretty much untouchable, similar to North Korea? Biden and Obama arguably just looked the other way, or swept the issue under the rug. So, assuming one believes Iran has actual (and dangerous) nuclear ambitions, criticizing Trump misses the point. The more important question is what would another president do if they weren't willing to look the other way?If only were it that easy.
What other president would jump into war with Iran in the election year? Or if such other president were an exceptionally gutsy leader, would they have allowed cretin Hegseth to cook a military campaign that didn't account for the PROBABILITY of Iran's closure of Hormuz? Of course, no one BUT Trump would've made the aforementioned cretin the head of Pentagon in the first place, but that's another story.
As a result, our brilliant aerial blitz quickly descended into a disastrous diplomatic defeat because no president of a country that still remains slightly democratic (for now) can ignore monetary pains of us the people, at the gas stations. Not in the election year. So here we go: Mr. TACO at his best.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/jd-vance-has-just-confirmed-our-worst-fears-about-trump-s-iran-deal/ar-AA25KPK3
Conclusion: Only Trump. Another president wouldn't start this war or would be smarter about it.
About Zelenskyy, if he dropped dead or resigned tomorrow, it's virtually certain that his replacement would be someone equally (or more) resistant to the Russian invasion. In fact, one of the leading candidates would probably be General Zaluzhnyi, former armed forces chief and current ambassador to the UK. The idea that Zelenskyy, as an individual, is the problem is missing the forest for the trees. Ukraine sees the conflict as an existential struggle and they don't believe Russia will be satisfied with just the Donbas. Viewing this as an existential threat (similar to how Israel views Iran), any Ukrainian leader would need to act accordingly. Your point works today, but would it have worked in Feb 2022? Put any other Ukrainian into the office today, and yeah, sure. With Ukraine making real gains on the battlefield and lighting up Russian infrastructure AT WILL, any president would keep fighting.
But today is not Feb 2022. If it hadn't been for Zelensky, Ukraine would've been a different place. Most likely, any other president would've negotiated a humiliating peace with Putin. Massive swaths of Eastern and Central Ukraine would've been currently occupied. The Russians might have chosen not to occupy Kyiv, but its army would've stationed right across the river training their big guns on the capital. The UAF would've been reduced to the mostly decorative National Guards. I'm not saying Ukraine would've been decisively defeated. More likely a gorilla war would've been raging on against the occupiers, but Zelensky's staying in Kyiv in Feb 2022 made all the difference in the world. No one else would have.
Conclusion: Only Zelensky. No other president would've successfully keep at bay the monster, the size of Russia.
Finally, Putin is probably the best candidate for individual focus. That's because he personally ordered the invasion and he could personally order it to stop. But the bigger question is what happens after? It's certainly possible that Putin could be pushed out of office, especially if he's viewed as weak and a failure. If that happens, his replacement has two choices: First, blame Putin for everything and try to repair the damage. Second, double down on the war against Ukraine. That last choice would probably involve going into full Stalin mode.What is full Stalin's mode? Let's not forget that Stalin failed to occupy tiny Finland. Twice, actually, during the Winter War and the Continuation War. Of course, Finland had to make big concessions, but it stayed free. Stalin, with all his monstrosity, was nothing but flexible.
Putin started this pointless war for 3 reasons. He hated Ukraine, he wanted to keep Ukraine as a client state, and he thought it would be easy. When he realized it wouldn't be easy, he kept digging down because he was and still is convinced that not achieving something that can be framed as a victory would spell the end for him. Not unreasonably, by the way. Now he's a hostage to this war. As long as the bullets are flying, he's alive and in power.
Conclusion: Only Putin. No one else would've started that war or kept at it for 4+ years knowing it can't be won.
If only were it that easy.
What other president would jump into war with Iran in the election year? Or if such other president were an exceptionally gutsy leader, would they have allowed cretin Hegseth to cook a military campaign that didn't account for the PROBABILITY of Iran's closure of Hormuz? Of course, no one BUT Trump would've made the aforementioned cretin the head of Pentagon in the first place, but that's another story.
As a result, our brilliant aerial blitz quickly descended into a disastrous diplomatic defeat because no president of a country that still remains slightly democratic (for now) can ignore monetary pains of us the people, at the gas stations. Not in the election year. So here we go: Mr. TACO at his best.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/jd-vance-has-just-confirmed-our-worst-fears-about-trump-s-iran-deal/ar-AA25KPK3
Conclusion: Only Trump. Another president wouldn't start this war or would be smarter about it.
Your point works today, but would it have worked in Feb 2022? Put any other Ukrainian into the office today, and yeah, sure. With Ukraine making real gains on the battlefield and lighting up Russian infrastructure AT WILL, any president would keep fighting..Yes, maybe corruption, but Zelensky has big balls like many Ukrainians, when Putin is just a crazy dangerous guy killing a lot of Russian meat. Ukrainians learned to become best experts for drones, for new way for war. Kind of smart David resisting to dumb Goliath. I wish best future to so courageous Ukrainians who give a lesson to our world, for Greenland, Cuba, Venezuela. Stop robbers.
If only were it that easy.
What other president would jump into war with Iran in the election year? Or if such other president were an exceptionally gutsy leader, would they have allowed cretin Hegseth to cook a military campaign that didn't account for the PROBABILITY of Iran's closure of Hormuz? Of course, no one BUT Trump would've made the aforementioned cretin the head of Pentagon in the first place, but that's another story.
As a result, our brilliant aerial blitz quickly descended into a disastrous diplomatic defeat because no president of a country that still remains slightly democratic (for now) can ignore monetary pains of us the people, at the gas stations. Not in the election year. So here we go: Mr. TACO at his best.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/jd-vance-has-just-confirmed-our-worst-fears-about-trump-s-iran-deal/ar-AA25KPK3.Mmmhmm yessir that's the point.
The main point of my previous post is that it's a mistake to put too much focus and attention on individual persons, rather than the underlying geopolitical issues and dynamics.
Taking Zelenskyy as the easiest example, it's irrelevant whether one likes him or hates him. The more relevant question is what, if anything, would substantially change if he was no longer on the chessboard? My argument is that the bigger underlying issue is that Ukraine sees itself in an existential struggle. Therefore, if Zelenskyy was not in the picture, the dynamics within Ukraine would mandate that any chosen leader reflect that same (existential struggle) view, and act accordingly. And that also means Ukraine would not tolerate anyone as leader who might lean toward accommodating or appeasing Russia. This means that those who love to criticize Zelenskyy are missing the point because, at this moment in time and under the current set of circumstances, any other leader would almost certainly take a similarly hard line..Could go either way or no way.
I've seen the claims here about 500,000 Iraqi children dying from US sanctions and around 40,000 Venezuelan deaths from sanctions pop up here as whataboutisms before. Both numbers have been thoroughly debunked by later research. For Iraq, post 2003 surveys found no big sustained rise in child mortality during the sanctions period. The original 1999 UNICEF figure was heavily manipulated by Saddam's govt. Key paper is Dyson and Cetorelli in BMJ Global Health.
For Venezuela, the bulk of the humanitarian collapse and excess deaths happened before the 2017 sanctions. Brookings had a good piece on how these earlier numbers overstated the sanctions' role.
Happy to share the links if anyone's interested.
https://gh.bmj.com/content/2/2/e000311
https://www.lse.ac.uk/news/latest-news-from-lse/iraqi-government-misreported-child-mortality-lse-research-finds
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/revisiting-the-evidence-impact-of-the-2017-sanctions-on-venezuela/
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/chavismo-is-the-worst-of-all-sanctions-the-evidence-behind-the-humanitarian-catastrophe-in-venezuela/
I've seen the claims here about 500,000 Iraqi children dying from US sanctions and around 40,000 Venezuelan deaths from sanctions pop up here as whataboutisms before. Both numbers have been thoroughly debunked by later research. For Iraq, post 2003 surveys found no big sustained rise in child mortality during the sanctions period. The original 1999 UNICEF figure was heavily manipulated by Saddam's govt. Key paper is Dyson and Cetorelli in BMJ Global Health.
For Venezuela, the bulk of the humanitarian collapse and excess deaths happened before the 2017 sanctions. Brookings had a good piece on how these earlier numbers overstated the sanctions' role.
Happy to share the links if anyone's interested.
https://gh.bmj.com/content/2/2/e000311
https://www.lse.ac.uk/news/latest-news-from-lse/iraqi-government-misreported-child-mortality-lse-research-finds
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/revisiting-the-evidence-impact-of-the-2017-sanctions-on-venezuela/
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/chavismo-is-the-worst-of-all-sanctions-the-evidence-behind-the-humanitarian-catastrophe-in-venezuela/Okay the sad truth is just unfortunate.
Given the name of thread and to revitalize it a bit, here is an excerpt from today's Ukrainian press: "Famous Ukrainian blogger and tarot reader, finalist of the "Battle of Psychics", Maria Tykha, claimed that she "strapon fucked" one of the Ukrainian ministers. According to her, she was offered 30 thousand dollars for this type of sex. Tykha also claims that one of the representatives of Ukraine's political elite suggested that she "perform a brown shower on him."
Given the name of thread and to revitalize it a bit, here is an excerpt from today's Ukrainian press: "Famous Ukrainian blogger and tarot reader, finalist of the "Battle of Psychics", Maria Tykha, claimed that she "strapon fucked" one of the Ukrainian ministers. According to her, she was offered 30 thousand dollars for this type of sex. Tykha also claims that one of the representatives of Ukraine's political elite suggested that she "perform a brown shower on him."What does it change about war criminal, dictator Putin attacked Ukraine on beginning of 2022 when nobody threatened huge Russia, after he didn't respect what he signed for Crimea. This must be more important than hardcore sexual fantasy. I think Putin has Trump photos with prostitutes in Moscow, while his first election?
I cannot believe you still want to talk about this. It is fine to criticize a study for its methodology if the results are way out of line with others and to criticize the funding source, but they were not. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(20) 30244-9/ fulltext.
For example, some countries are able to invest resources into contact tracing and containing the spread through quarantine and isolation of infected or suspected cases. In Singapore, where these measures have been implemented, the CFR of 631 cases (as of March 25,2020) is 03%.
The trend in mortality reporting for COVID-19 has been typical for emerging infectious diseases. The case fatality rate (CFR) was reported to be 15% (six of 41 patients) in the initial period,1 but this estimate was calculated from a small cohort of hospitalised patients. Subsequently, with more data emerging, the CFR decreased to between 43% and 110%,2,3 and later to 34%. 4 The rate reported outside China in February was even lower (04%; two of 464). 5.
I cannot believe how dumb you are then. You are quoting numbers when there was not proper screening of the whole population to see how many people had been infected with Covid and thinking those early values were real. And this lancet paper was from July 2020. Do you know how to read?
I cannot believe you still want to talk about this. It is fine to criticize a study for its methodology if the results are way out of line with others and to criticize the funding source, but they were not. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(20) 30244-9/ fulltext.
For example, some countries are able to invest resources into contact tracing and containing the spread through quarantine and isolation of infected or suspected cases. In Singapore, where these measures have been implemented, the CFR of 631 cases (as of March 25,2020) is 03%.
The trend in mortality reporting for COVID-19 has been typical for emerging infectious diseases. The case fatality rate (CFR) was reported to be 15% (six of 41 patients) in the initial period,1 but this estimate was calculated from a small cohort of hospitalised patients. Subsequently, with more data emerging, the CFR decreased to between 43% and 110%,2,3 and later to 34%. 4 The rate reported outside China in February was even lower (04%; two of 464). 5.
I cannot believe how dumb you are then. You are quoting numbers when there was not proper screening of the whole population to see how many people had been infected with Covid and thinking those early values were real. And this lancet paper was from July 2020. Do you know how to read?Well since Questner wanted to refresh the thread, I was recently looking through a couple of old posts I missed and decided a couple of replies would be fun.
Elvis the guy is your source, not mine. You're quoting an economist with an MD who never completed a residency to lecture on epidemiology, while carrying an obvious bias and lowballing the fatality rate? You might want to check your own clown make up before calling anyone else dumb.
Ok fine, here is a quote from your POS paper. "In terms of COVID-19 related deaths, red and blue states in 2020 did not differ significantly" and "COVID-19 deaths in 2020 did not significantly correlate with mitigation efforts. " So the paper that tossed you a bone is a POS? It's tough to have it both ways. They were correct on that point but missed the nuance. Deaths were higher in blue states in early 2020 because of spread in urban areas, but higher in red states later in the year likely with weak mitigation efforts as a real factor. Regardless, the effectiveness of masks and social distancing isn't measured when compliance is weak, no matter the voting patterns.
Here's a point you persistently dodge, and likely will continue to do so, why aren't you insisting that doctors and nurses stop wearing masks in hospitals since you are convinced that they do not work? Folks remember this, the strongest points like this one are always the ones that are completely ignored.
Meta analysis after the Covid epidemic showed none of the interventions you swore by worked. https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD006207.pub6/full. This is BS. The results were inconclusive.
https://www.cochrane.org/about-us/news/statement-physical-interventions-interrupt-or-reduce-spread-respiratory-viruses-review
What is clear is that Sweden with it's much more liberal approach to mitigation efforts had much higher pre-vaccine death rates than their logistically and culturally similar Nordic neighbors. So what do you want to do with that, make a beeline for Peru again? LOL Non-compliance and crowded households were the obvious problems there.
Zelensky, you need any more money?That guy has balls a slippery keyboard weasel like you can only dream about.
But 2021 is the year of the vaccinated, and blue states had more vaccinated people than red states. This from your study, "In terms of COVID-19 related deaths, red and blue states in 2020 did not differ significantly. COVID-19 deaths in 2021, however, were significantly less in blue compared to red states. ".See Elvis? Suck it, we Dems were way smarter than you Republican retards. That is science baby. Uh, well.Yea, in this most rare case that you get around to making a concession, we must really be onto something.
If you use the same lame analysis as the fools in your paper did, the vaccine was killing people in the UK under 60.
Then you get to Germany, and the same pattern emerges. https://dailysceptic.org/2023/02/12/the-link-between-german-excess-mortality-and-the-covid-vaccines/?highlight=covid. Daily Skeptic, really? I guess we're all lucky the link doesn't work. Why no Zero Hedge? LOL.
From the beginning of April 2021 onwards the start of the vaccination campaign excess mortality suddenly increases continuously up to the youngest age groups and the number of stillbirths is increasing. Nine months later, a massive and sustained decrease in live births is observed. When did 3% become "massive?" LOL This is a correlation equals causation fallacy. While this even if true lags well behind the excess deaths caused by selfish and irresponsible behavior in red states. A Yale study found no correlation between vaccines and still births.
https://medicine.yale.edu/news-article/study-finds-no-association-between-covid-19-vaccines-and-stillbirths/
In fact getting Covid while pregnant increased the risk of still births. Also the increased infant mortality in 2022 followed racial and socio-economic lines consistent with people less likely to get the vaccine.
The risk of death from Covid for 70 year olds is about two orders of magnitude greater than that for 30 year olds, and is about three orders of magnitude greater than that for 20 year olds. This means you need to vaccinate about a thousand 20 year olds to save the same number of lives as vaccinating one 70 year old. For 20 year olds who've already had Covid, it's probably closer to a million. The primary purpose of vaccinating young people was to protect others.
Uh, why the fuck would anyone as of today be stupid enough to defend vaccinating young men, women of child bearing age, and the absolute most fucking stupid, pregnant women? Not looking good, Paulie. At best, you dumb Democratic douches were saving a few fossils while bumping off newborns. This is more pure distortion from you. The data never showed vaccines were "bumping off newborns. " In fact studies consistently found the opposite: pregnant women who got vaccinated had lower rates of stillbirth and preterm birth than unvaccinated ones. Getting Covid during pregnancy was the real factor for complications, not the vaccine.
Vaccinating younger people wasn't just about "protecting fossils. " The vaccine cut transmission rates which reduced spread to high risk groups and kept hospitals from collapsing. "Save one grandma, kill a baby. " That framing is pure distortion.
As for the UK data, like with the red and blue state analysis, in 2021, there is a clear showing of decreased death in the elderly being vaccinated. Okay, Elvis, that is it. We lowered the death rate. Yeah, problem is you did not dive deeper. One paper did and concluded that based on the UK data, you cannot say that the vaccines prevent death, even in the elderly. As to why, there is this, https://www.normanfenton.com/post/simple-evidence-showing-the-ons-data-on-mortality-by-vaccine-status-is-systemically-flawedNotice What could possibly explain a 60% increase in non-covid deaths in 2022 among the unvaccinated and a 5% drop in non-covid deaths among the vaccinated? If the vaccine worked, there should be a lot more deaths in the unvaccinated group when there was a Covid spike, and there was not. There should also be a similar number of non-Covid deaths in the vaccinated and unvaccinated, and once again, there was not.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/357778435_Official_mortality_data_for_England_suggest_systematic_miscategorisation_of_vaccine_status_and_uncertain_effectiveness_of_Covid-19_vaccination At first glance the ONS data suggest that, in each of the older age groups, all-cause mortality is lower in the vaccinated than the unvaccinated. This conclusion is cast into doubt upon closer inspection of the data due to a range of fundamental inconsistencies and anomalies in the data. Okay, so when the heat is on, don't run to Peru. Let's run to the UK. That ONS data has been heavily criticized by statisticians, including the Office for Statistics Regulation for exactly this reason. The categories are messed up by classification. When people got vaccinated there was often a delay in updating the system, thus if they died during those few weeks after the shot they were counted as unvaccinated. Also healthier people were more likely to get vaccinated.
So which is the bigger Democratic douche fuckup, Covid or Ukraine? Well you've been consistently reminded that many many Repubs from day one have signed off on aid for Ukraine, yet you still call it a Democrat war. Are you forgetful or just dishonest? Why are you so slow to criticize Putin?
As to what we can file under completely ignored, we have:
1. Elvis cannot tell us why he isn't criticizing doctors and nurses for wearing masks in hospital settings. Since in his mind they do not work, it's a complete waste of time and resources while sacrificing comfort.
2. Also Elvis has ignored all the data that demonstrates that Covid-19 was much more deadly than the flu and common cold.
This sentence in my first paragraph prior post should read as follows:
Death rates were higher in blue states in early 2020 because of spread in urban areas, but higher in red states later in the year likely with weak mitigation efforts as a real factor.
Deaths is replaced with death rates.
So the paper that tossed you a bone is a POS? It's tough to have it both ways. They were correct on that point but missed the nuance. Deaths were higher in blue states in early 2020 because of spread in urban areas, but higher in red states later in the year likely with weak mitigation efforts as a real factor. Regardless, the effectiveness of masks and social distancing isn't measured when compliance is weak, no matter the voting patterns.
Here's a point you persistently dodge, and likely will continue to do so, why aren't you insisting that doctors and nurses stop wearing masks in hospitals since you are convinced that they do not work? Folks remember this, the strongest points like this one are always the ones that are completely ignored.
This is BS. The results were inconclusive..There is a lot to be learned here.
Newton York
08-03-26, 01:49
Why don't Ukraine babes get to Thailand and become escorts? They'd be making bank while enjoying beaches and getting away from war. It's a no brainer.
I guess they'd rather be nearby like in Germany or the Czech Republic, but plenty of guys would be wanting to pay for some blonde pussy in Thailand, not that Thai pussy is bad, but variety is the spice of life after all.
Ukraine has hardly any interceptor missiles. The last few strikes on Kiev have seen zero interception. But hey, as long as Ukraine strikes civilian targets like beaches and Wildberries, it means Ukraine is winning right? This is a death sentence for Ukraine. The illegal president of Ukraine thinks he can escalate. Let him. The Russians will destroy Ukraine, and I mean destroy it. And that is an enormous tragedy. Just imagine if the EU / USA had not staged that coup in 2014. Crimea would be part of Ukraine. Donbas would be part of Ukraine. There would be no war.
Reiner Otto
08-05-26, 19:05
No war, in case UA would not have trusted the lies of USA, RF, GB regarding their territorial integrity, when releasing the atomic weapons for destruction.
They should have kept the warheads; then no aggression by Putler.
Why don't Ukraine babes get to Thailand and become escorts? They'd be making bank while enjoying beaches and getting away from war. It's a no brainer.
I guess they'd rather be nearby like in Germany or the Czech Republic, but plenty of guys would be wanting to pay for some blonde pussy in Thailand, not that Thai pussy is bad, but variety is the spice of life after all.A lot of German men have been wifing up beautiful Eastern European women for a long time now.
A hot Ukrainian woman has a shot at a comfortable life with the right European man.
But you're right. Why not enjoy a year-long stay in Thailand?
I would say Thai escorts are so inexpensive and abundant. I'm not sure if it's worthwhile competing with them.
No war, in case UA would not have trusted the lies of USA, RF, GB regarding their territorial integrity, when releasing the atomic weapons for destruction.
They should have kept the warheads; then no aggression by Putler.This I agree with. But in all fairness, those nukes belonged to the SU and Russia was the inheritor, which is why Belarus, Kazakhstan, etc also returned the nukes to the rightful owner, which was Russia.
Reiner Otto
08-05-26, 20:25
This I agree with. But in all fairness, those nukes belonged to the SU and Russia was the inheritor, which is why Belarus, Kazakhstan, etc also returned the nukes to the rightful owner, which was Russia.The memoranda, signed in Patria Hall at the Budapest Congress Center with US Ambassador Donald M. Blinken amongst others in attendance, prohibited Russia, the United States, and the United Kingdom from threatening or using military force or economic coercion against Ukraine, Belarus, and Kazakhstan, "except in self-defence or otherwise in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations". As a result of the memorandum and other agreements, between 1993 and 1996, Belarus, Kazakhstan, and Ukraine gave up their nuclear weapons.
Why was this agreement necessary for the "inheritor", then?
May be, Kazakhstan now is afraid, of Putler, too.
UA had the tech, not the money, though, at that time, to deploy the warheads with missiles, built in UA. Like the ones, which were intended to be stationed on Cuba.
No need for Russian controls. Only the fissible material of the warheads was required for UA.
Ukraine has hardly any interceptor missiles. The last few strikes on Kiev have seen zero interception. But hey, as long as Ukraine strikes civilian targets like beaches and Wildberries, it means Ukraine is winning right? This is a death sentence for Ukraine. The illegal president of Ukraine thinks he can escalate. Let him. The Russians will destroy Ukraine, and I mean destroy it. And that is an enormous tragedy. Just imagine if the EU / USA had not staged that coup in 2014. Crimea would be part of Ukraine. Donbas would be part of Ukraine. There would be no war.Zelensky is not illegal according to Ukrainian constitution and despite corruption, Ukrainians know he has balls since more than 4 years versus war criminal and dictator Putin. Incredible how Ukraine is resisting versus big powerful Russia of Putin who loves deaths.
It would've been wise for Ukraine to have stayed neutral like Austria. But the EU and the collective west made sure that didn't happen, and now you have the death of Ukraine in front of you. Funny thing is, Ukraine will never ever join NATO.
Zelensky is not illegal according to Ukrainian constitution and despite corruption, Ukrainians know he has balls since more than 4 years versus war criminal and dictator Putin. Incredible how Ukraine is resisting versus big powerful Russia of Putin who loves deaths.Ukraine will get destroyed while 'resisting'. I guess the EU and the collective west is okay with that.
Until the last Ukrainian, right?
Reiner Otto
08-07-26, 22:05
Funny thing is, Ukraine will never ever join NATO.But Finlands (now NATO) border with RF is longer than UAs.
Thus, Putler "succeeded" already to extend Russias borders with NATO members.
Or will he attack Finland, next, because of joining NATO?
But probably he remembers Russias imperialistic fights against them in the past, and how hard that was.
Why is the kremlin wasting the money it doesn't have to keep disseminating ridiculous two-bit lies?
I think four reasons.
1. the kremlin is dumb. Like really, seriously dumb. Something, the Rusophiles here and everywhere simply can't comprehend.
2. The worse their 4. 5-year-old idiotic war is going (remember Kyiv in three days, LOL?) -- the more needs to scare the "collective West".
3. Six weeks till their so-called elections.
4. Upcoming fall mobilization is coming right after the elections. More distractions are needed so the meatballs don't roll away before they come for them.
But why would they pay their dedicated propacondoms to spread their BS on the fucking mongering forum, of all places, you ask?
Number 1 is why.
Ukraine will get destroyed while 'resisting'. I guess the EU and the collective west is okay with that.
Until the last Ukrainian, right?You prefer Ukraine under dictator, criminal Putin? But Ukrainians don t, when they are so courageous.
But Finlands (now NATO) border with RF is longer than UAs.
Thus, Putler "succeeded" already to extend Russias borders with NATO members.
Or will he attack Finland, next, because of joining NATO?
But probably he remembers Russias imperialistic fights against them in the past, and how hard that was.I said Ukraine will never join NATO and you bring up Finland. Ukraine joining NATO is what brought this whole tragic war on. And Ukraine will end up a destroyed dysfunctional rump state that never joins NATO. So why was neutrality so bad? If Ukraine had stayed neutral, if the collective west hadn't imposed the coup in 2014, Ukraine would be intact. Crimea would be with Ukraine. All of the Donbas and Kherson and Zaporizhia would be with Ukraine. There would be no war.
if the collective west hadn't imposed the coup in 2014, Ukraine would be intact. Crimea would be with Ukraine. All of the Donbas and Kherson and Zaporizhia would be with Ukraine. There would be no war.Yanukovych fled Kyiv after signing an EU deal for early elections. Parliament, including members of his own party, voted three hundred twenty-eight to zero to remove him the next day because he'd abandoned his post. That's not a coup, it's what happens when a president runs away.
John Clayton
08-10-26, 05:34
I said Ukraine will never join NATO and you bring up Finland. Ukraine joining NATO is what brought this whole tragic war on. And Ukraine will end up a destroyed dysfunctional rump state that never joins NATO. So why was neutrality so bad? If Ukraine had stayed neutral, if the collective west hadn't imposed the coup in 2014, Ukraine would be intact. Crimea would be with Ukraine. All of the Donbas and Kherson and Zaporizhia would be with Ukraine. There would be no war.This is pure Russian disinformation. Every statement in this is a lie. The poster is paid by Russian IRA or ASD.
This is pure Russian disinformation. Every statement in this is a lie. The poster is paid by Russian IRA or ASD.You have no argument.
I said Ukraine will never join NATO and you bring up Finland. Ukraine joining NATO is what brought this whole tragic war on. And Ukraine will end up a destroyed dysfunctional rump state that never joins NATO. So why was neutrality so bad? If Ukraine had stayed neutral, if the collective west hadn't imposed the coup in 2014, Ukraine would be intact. Crimea would be with Ukraine. All of the Donbas and Kherson and Zaporizhia would be with Ukraine. There would be no war.Putin dream to make again USSR. He didn't respect what he signed. We can t trust him, same than for Trump.
Reiner Otto
08-10-26, 11:32
Ukraine joining NATO is what brought this whole tragic war on. Sounds like you are paving the path for aggression of Russia towards Finland, because it gave up neutrality.
Oh, but Finland now in NATO, thus Putin might buckle down. UA was not fast enough to join NATO, obviously.
Sounds like you are paving the path for aggression of Russia towards Finland, because it gave up neutrality.
Oh, but Finland now in NATO, thus Putin might buckle down. UA was not fast enough to join NATO, obviously.Nice selective quoting.
Read up on history. How many times did NATO expand post 1991? How many expansions did the Russians tolerate, despite the assurance that there would be no NATO expansion before the SU collapsed?
What were the red lines? Clearly Georgia was one. Look what happened to Georgia in 2008. Today there are 2 independent republics in Georgia, and the government in power now is smart and realizes the mistake that was made in the past. Russia clobbered Georgia in 2008.
The brightest of all red lines was Ukraine joining NATO. That would have meant war and that's exactly what happened. So I don't know why you like to bring up Finland. Pay attention to what the red lines were.
And like I said, Ukraine will never ever join NATO.
So again I ask, was all this worth it for Ukraine? Can any Pro Ukrainian here honestly answer that?
You prefer Ukraine under dictator, criminal Putin? But Ukrainians don t, when they are so courageous.I have nothing but respect for Ukrainians. They are brave and fight valiantly with honor and dignity. I am opposed to the filthy Nazi regime in Kiev and the beggar in Kiev whose term has long expired.
I would like to see a neutral, prosperous Ukraine, like it was before the western backed coup in 2014. When Ukraine was intact. When Crimea was with Ukraine. When there was no war.
Reiner Otto
08-10-26, 12:09
Can any Pro Ukrainian here honestly answer that?No. Only the Ukrainian citizen can. And they do it with rifles in their hands.
Only minor difference between Hitler and Putin:
When Hitler brought Sudetenland to Germany, the Wehrmacht was greeted with flowers.
Nice selective quoting.
Read up on history. How many times did NATO expand post 1991? How many expansions did the Russians tolerate, despite the assurance that there would be no NATO expansion before the SU collapsed The "not one inch eastward" assurance was verbal, limited to East Germany during unification talks, and never written into the Two Plus Four Treaty or any binding agreement. Also cut the spin BS. Many former Eastern Block countries freely and gleefully expanded into NATO because they reject your way of life.
I have nothing but respect for Ukrainians. They are brave and fight valiantly with honor and dignity. I am opposed to the filthy Nazi regime in Kiev and the beggar in Kiev whose term has long expired.Zelensky is serving under martial law as elections are suspended during wartime. This is a common practice that is consistent with the Ukrainian constitution. It's also ironic that you question legitimacy while Putin has murdered or jailed his most credible political opposition.
And calling Ukraine's government Nazi is pathetic. Zelensky is Jewish, and his family lost members in the Holocaust. Azov is a fringe group, and polls show Ukrainians strongly support their government and president. Russia has its own Nazi problem, with groups like Rusich fighting in Ukraine.
Also the "I respect the people but not the government" line is a lazy false dichotomy. The Ukrainian people strongly support their government, so your fake respect is just empty words typed from safety.
I have nothing but respect for Ukrainians. They are brave and fight valiantly with honor and dignity. I am opposed to the filthy Nazi regime in Kiev and the beggar in Kiev whose term has long expired.
I would like to see a neutral, prosperous Ukraine, like it was before the western backed coup in 2014. When Ukraine was intact. When Crimea was with Ukraine. When there was no war.I would also prefer peace for Ukrainians, but we all know Putin attacked them, after he robbed Crimea, not respecting what he signed, so we can't trust him, when I and millions don t see Zelensky as a nazi, but we see Putin as a dictator and war criminal, when I love beautiful Russia, but hate Putin.
Putin dream to make again USSR. He didn't respect what he signed. We can t trust him, same than for Trump.When he was a just nothing in KGB under USSR, he fantazy to create again, being the new Staline.
The "not one inch eastward" assurance was verbal, limited to East Germany during unification talks, and never written into the Two Plus Four Treaty or any binding agreement. Also cut the spin BS. Many former Eastern Block countries freely and gleefully expanded into NATO because they reject your way of life.You have to resort to selective quoting because you cannot address the points I make.
As I said, the brightest of red lines regarding NATO expansion was Ukraine. Keep bringing up Finland or other irrelevant stuff.
Ukraine will NEVER join NATO. Write this down.
Zelensky is serving under martial law as elections are suspended during wartime. This is a common practice that is consistent with the Ukrainian constitution. It's also ironic that you question legitimacy while Putin has murdered or jailed his most credible political opposition.
And calling Ukraine's government Nazi is pathetic. Zelensky is Jewish, and his family lost members in the Holocaust. Azov is a fringe group, and polls show Ukrainians strongly support their government and president. Russia has its own Nazi problem, with groups like Rusich fighting in Ukraine.
Also the "I respect the people but not the government" line is a lazy false dichotomy. The Ukrainian people strongly support their government, so your fake respect is just empty words typed from safety.Fringe group. Yeah. Do you know who Stephan Bandera is? Do you know he is a national hero in Ukraine?
As for how popular the corrupt failed comedian / actor is, let him hold free and fair elections and we shall find out.
I would also prefer peace for Ukrainians, but we all know Putin attacked them, after he robbed Crimea, not respecting what he signed, so we can't trust him, when I and millions don t see Zelensky as a nazi, but we see Putin as a dictator and war criminal, when I love beautiful Russia, but hate Putin.I get it. You don't like Putin but like Russia. I despise the Nazi regime in Kiev but I have nothing but love and respect for the ordinary Ukrainian people dying and struggling.
Fringe group. Yeah. Do you know who Stephan Bandera is? Do you know he is a national hero in Ukraine?
As for how popular the corrupt failed comedian / actor is, let him hold free and fair elections and we shall find out.Bandera wasn't a Nazi. He was a Ukrainian nationalist who briefly saw the Nazis as a temporary ally against the Soviets, but they later imprisoned him in Sachsenhausen. His movement was fractured, and while some factions committed atrocities, that's not the same as Nazi ideology. And Ukraine's current government, led by a Jewish president whose family lost members in the Holocaust, doesn't reflect 1940's nationalism.
Folks take note that Blood Red completely ignored my points about Nazi groups in present day Russia, some of which are fighting in Ukraine.
He also ignored the point that election postponement is common during war, while he ignored my points about Putin's murders and imprisonment of his political opponents. He in the past has insisted here that Alexi Navalny died of natural causes.
Blood Red cries about "selective quoting" but completely ignored the majority of my points. That's quite hypocritical.
Current polls show Zelensky's approval rating at about 56% which is strong support.
You have to resort to selective quoting because you cannot address the points I make.
As I said, the brightest of red lines regarding NATO expansion was Ukraine. Keep bringing up Finland or other irrelevant stuff.
Ukraine will NEVER join NATO. Write this down.You rarely make any "points" to address. Calling something irrelevant, a coup, or Nazi doesn't make it so. Prognostications aren't "points. " You don't even know the difference between points and assertions.
I get it. You don't like Putin but like Russia. I despise the Nazi regime in Kiev but I have nothing but love and respect for the ordinary Ukrainian people dying and struggling.You say you respect the Ukrainian people but call their government Nazi. Yet their national hero that you call Nazi, Bandera, has seventy-four percent approval. And he wasn't even a Nazi, but an ulta nationalist who was ultimately imprisoned by the Nazis. You can't have it both ways. Why do you "love and respect" all these "Nazi" lovers?
As with many things, Russia has a variety of propaganda narratives, crafted for different audiences, but all designed to provide "justification" for what they were going to do anyway. For those inclined to be persuaded by historical arguments, they have a narrative ready to go. For those persuadable by the "de-Nazification" trope, they've got that covered. Same with those who might be sympathetic to narratives centered around Russia as the defender of traditional values against the decadent West. Oh, and I'd be remiss in leaving out the dreaded specter of NATO encroaching on what Russia views as its geopolitical personal space.
Russia really doesn't care if reality and empirical evidence contradict any of these narratives because they can easily switch between them, or play "mix and match" as needed. Just taking history, as one example, if you go back far enough you can make the argument that all of Russia belongs to Mongolia as Moscow was a vassal under Genghis Khan. In addition, Kyiv predates Moscow by centuries, and Ukrainian language, tradition, and culture are senior to those of Russia. Even the name "Russia" itself is derived (some would say appropriated) from the older Kyivan Rus.
During the Age of Empires national borders changed with every significant war and alliance (often by marriage between royal families). Arguably that age came to an end after the World Wars of the 20th Century, although Russia either didn't get the memo or refused to acknowledge it. After the fall of the Tsar and the end of the Russian Empire, Ukraine declared independence and the newly empowered Bolshevik rulers of the USSR (Russian Empire with new branding) fought to pull them back in. Then, after the fall of the Soviet Union, Ukraine declared independence again, but this time Russia lacked either the strength or the will to prevent it. Chechnya was tragically not as fortunate.
From 1991 to 2014, Russia had ample opportunity to lay out any supposed legal or historical claims they may have had with respect to portions of the newly independent Ukraine. Those claims could have been raised in any number of forums, not least the United Nations itself. In stark contrast, there were a number of international agreements and documents in which Russia explicitly recognized the borders of the independent post-1991 Ukraine. In fact, it's telling that Russia entered into a lease agreement with Ukraine that allowed them to maintain a naval presence in Sevastopol. One doesn't lease one's own property. The execution of a lease agreement is an explicit recognition, factually and legally, that the property is owned by another.
One further quick narrative debunking: the so-called NATO impingement and implied threat. It's remarkable that so many who should know better simply swallow Russia's baseless assertion that Ukraine was on the cusp of joining NATO. That assertion ignores the fact that it takes unanimous consent of every existing NATO member to admit a new country. Before Russia's act of aggression in their invasion of Ukraine, they had a firm clique of NATO countries that could be relied upon to block membership. Again, you have to think back to the pre-invasion geopolitical landscape. France and Germany would probably have blocked Ukraine to prevent "destabilization" while Russia-friendly countries like Hungary, Bulgaria, and Slovakia would have blocked membership just because Moscow asked them to. There were other factors weighing against Ukraine but, without needing to get into those weeds, suffice it to say that the whole "Ukraine in NATO" narrative is one giant red herring.
Bottom line: Russia wants Ukraine because that's the only way they can start reconstituting their lost Empire. Belarus is a de facto client state and, if they can get Ukraine, then the Baltics would most likely be next on the agenda. Because the Imperial Mindset is alive and well in Russia, and not just with Putin, it was only a matter of time until the attempt to conquer Ukraine was made. In the Russky Mir view, Russia is entitled to whatever it can take (or retake) by force. Unfortunately for Putin, his sycophants overestimated his strength and underestimated that of Ukraine. That miscalculation may very well result in the downfall of Putin himself and may also be the final nail in the coffin of Russian Imperialism.
Can't happen soon enough, IMO.
P.S. And let's not forget that China is standing by ready to pick up any juicy pieces that might fall their way in a Russian collapse!
I get it. You don't like Putin but like Russia. I despise the Nazi regime in Kiev but I have nothing but love and respect for the ordinary Ukrainian people dying and struggling.Maybe too much corruption, but is Zelensky who has balls to fight versus Putin and Trump, a nazi? And he is still fully legal according to Ukrainian constitution and supported by majority, when Ukrainians know no other would have resisted since more than 4 years. In Russia, most Russians are so blind, fucked by Putin, paying inflation and counting dead, same than Americans fucked by Trump, when not Russia war but only Putin war, same than Trump in Iran. Putin just dreaming of USSR again when he was a nobody in KGB, like Trump wants Greenland, Venezuela and others. 2 dangerous megaloman.
Reiner Otto
08-17-26, 09:04
And let's not forget that China is standing by ready to pick up any juicy pieces that might fall their way in a Russian collapse!I am still expecting China to occupy Russian territory in the Far East, claiming it to be "historically Chinese" . Like Putler did with Crimea.
AntonySun1996
08-18-26, 15:28
I am still expecting China to occupy Russian territory in the Far East, claiming it to be "historically Chinese" . Like Putler did with Crimea.Russian Far East is already basically taken over by China economically, so I highly doubt that move would be necessary.
Last time I went to Vladivostok every working girl was taken good care of by Chinese guys.
Now this project was named Forrest Gump in honour of Forrest who was dumb but knew how to run.
Since audio and video files of the project were released as the case of the previous Midas, they send chills along the spine of everyone who reads and hears them in native Russian.
https://www.politico.eu/article/volodymyr-zelenskyy-fires-top-aide-after-anti-corruption-investigators-search-office-iryna-mudra/
Operation Forrest Gump: Anti-corruption raid heaps pressure on Zelenskyy.
Ukraine's president fires a top aide after the National Anti-Corruption Bureau alleged a group of top officials laundered money to pay a former minister's bail.
August 19,2026 3:35 pm CET.
By Veronika Melkozerova and Milena Wälde.
KYIV — Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy fired Iryna Mudra as deputy head of his office Wednesday, hours after anti-corruption watchdogs searched her workplace as part of a sweeping probe into an alleged criminal organization.
"Iryna Romanivna Mudra is hereby dismissed from the post of Deputy Head of the Office of the President of Ukraine," Zelenskyy said in a decree published Wednesday. The one-line order gave no reason for her removal.
The firing adds to a turbulent stretch for Zelenskyy. Former Defense Minister Mykhailo Fedorov called Tuesday for wartime elections and denounced corruption and a systemic governance crisis, weeks after his ouster triggered prolonged street protests.
Earlier Wednesday, Ukraine's National Anti-Corruption Bureau, or NABU, announced a new operation targeting an alleged criminal organization involving current and former lawmakers and senior officials in Zelenskyy's office. The bureau said it was carrying out searches with the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office, or SAP.
The investigation, dubbed Operation Forrest Gump, alleges the group laundered around 150 million Ukrainian hryvnia, equivalent to roughly $3 million, through state-owned Sense Bank to fund bail for former Energy Minister German Galushchenko, a key figure in last year's $100 million Midas corruption scandal.
Writing on Facebook, Mudra said: "I will defend my name in a legal manner – calmly and consistently. ".
NABU did not name Mudra directly in its video statement, referring only to a deputy head of the president's administration, but searched her office.
Ukraine's corruption watchdog released recordings in which a woman identified in the video only as a deputy head of the president's office can be heard saying: "Fighting corruption is a wrong approach. Corruption has to be systemized and controlled. " NABU did not identify the woman by name.
This article has been updated with a comment from Iryna Mudra.
Now this project was named Forrest Gump in honour of Forrest who was dumb but knew how to run.
Since audio and video files of the project were released as the case of the previous Midas, they send chills along the spine of everyone who reads and hears them in native Russian.
https://www.politico.eu/article/volodymyr-zelenskyy-fires-top-aide-after-anti-corruption-investigators-search-office-iryna-mudra/
Operation Forrest Gump: Anti-corruption raid heaps pressure on Zelenskyy.
Ukraine's president fires a top aide after the National Anti-Corruption Bureau alleged a group of top officials laundered money to pay a former minister's bail.
August 19,2026 3:35 pm CET.
By Veronika Melkozerova and Milena Wlde.
KYIV Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy fired Iryna Mudra as deputy head of his office Wednesday, hours after anti-corruption watchdogs searched her workplace as part of a sweeping probe into an alleged criminal organization.
"Iryna Romanivna Mudra is hereby dismissed from the post of Deputy Head of the Office of the President of Ukraine," Zelenskyy said in a decree published Wednesday..Do you know the huge castle of Putin? When millions of Russians are poor and suffer from his inflation, when he was educated in ex USSR, but he forgot kolkhozes and sovkhozes. Good point is not anymore much petrol in huge Russia, less money for Putin wars and hackings.
Putin just dreaming of USSR again when he was a nobody in KGB, like Trump wants Greenland, Venezuela and others. 2 dangerous megaloman.It's interesting how Putin cherry picks the aspects of the USSR that fit his agenda. He seems to like the authoritarian part but he seems a little light on ideology. At least the USSR pretended to follow a doctrine. I read an interesting article yesterday in the WSJ dealing with the Russian Army's destruction of Ukrainian libraries. Talk about cancelling a culture!
It's interesting how Putin cherry picks the aspects of the USSR that fit his agenda. He seems to like the authoritarian part but he seems a little light on ideology. At least the USSR pretended to follow a doctrine. I read an interesting article yesterday in the WSJ dealing with the Russian Army's destruction of Ukrainian libraries. Talk about cancelling a culture!I meant USSR only to invade countries which did belong to, but not to share his money of course, when he is fully capitalist with his hidden huge castle.
https://meduza.io/en/feature/2026/08/25/hackers-published-a-sberbank-memo-war-gaming-eight-endings-to-the-war-in-ukraine-one-source-in-russia-s-financial-market-thinks-a-chatbot-wrote-it
No way to conclusively establish its authenticity, but the eight scenarios it outlines certainly make for some interesting discussion points.
FWIW, the Black Mirror hacking group has been around for a while and has leaked documents before (Rostec files in 2025, etc).
She's putting the probability this will result in a breakthrough or the restart of sustained negotiations at 65%. That's probably high but who knows. The third-party-controlled demilitarized free-trade zone in the part of Donetsk still controlled by Ukraine may be a sticking point.
I think the proposal Witkoff and Kushner are carrying is probably an updated version of the framework that the USA, Ukraine and Europeans were quietly working on in August, rather than an entirely new plan. Zelensky said on August 25 that a one-page set of ideas had already been drafted with USA And European officials, including a ceasefire and an American idea for a third-party-administered free economic zone in the Donbas. 65532;.
My best estimate of what they will propose is:
1. An immediate or very rapid ceasefire, essentially freezing the military line close to where it is when the agreement takes effect. I would put about a 75% probability on this being the centerpiece. Ukraine and its European partners have publicly advocated an immediate ceasefire using the current line of contact as the starting point.
2. A special arrangement for the portion of Donetsk that Ukraine still controls, rather than simply transferring it outright to Russia. This is where I think the August "free economic zone" idea becomes important. My guess is something like: Ukrainian forces withdraw from some disputed area; Russian forces do not immediately enter it; it becomes demilitarized or specially administered; economic activity resumes under some international / USA -backed mechanism. I would give roughly a 5565% probability that something resembling this is in today's proposal. Zelensky has explicitly confirmed that Washington proposed a Donbas free-economic-zone concept administered by a third party.
3. Russia keeps de facto control of most territory it currently occupies, without Ukraine being required to legally recognize Russian sovereignty over it. That distinction could be crucial. The earlier Trump framework contemplated USA De facto recognition of Russian control over Crimea, Luhansk and Donetsk and freezing Kherson and Zaporizhzhia along the front. Ukraine and Europe subsequently pushed back strongly against legal recognition of territorial conquest.
4. Ukraine effectively gives up NATO membership for the foreseeable future, probably without being required to surrender its EU path. NATO itself has acknowledged that Ukrainian membership is not presently on the table, while the earlier USA Proposal went considerably further and called for a constitutional commitment by Ukraine not to join NATO. My guess is that today's version uses softer languagesomething like NATO membership being indefinitely deferredbecause that is easier for Kyiv to swallow.
5. Strong Western security guarantees for Ukraine in exchange for the territorial / NATO concessions. This could be the principal inducement to Zelensky. The USA And European states have already developed plans for postwar guarantees, potentially including an Article-5-like response if Russia attacks again and a multinational force operating inside Ukraine after hostilities stop.
6. Phased sanctions relief for Russia, probably tied to implementation rather than all sanctions disappearing on day one. That has been part of previous Trump proposals. I would expect Moscow to seek broader reliefincluding access to frozen assets and normalization of economic relationswhile Washington may offer enough initially to give Putin an economic reason to accept the deal.
7. A large humanitarian packagePOW exchanges, return of civilian detainees and Ukrainian children, perhaps restoration of Black Sea commercial arrangements. Those are relatively easy items on which both sides can claim progress and appeared prominently in the earlier USA Framework.
8. A Putin-Zelensky-Trump summit if Moscow and Kyiv accept the basic architecture. CIA Director John Ratcliffe reportedly raised exactly such a three-way summit during his Moscow trip last month.
The single most important question, in my view, is what the plan says about the Ukrainian-held portion of Donetsk. Putin wants the entirety of Donbas and believes Russia's battlefield position is improving; just this week he again emphasized Russian military advances while saying he was open to substantive discussions with Trump's representatives.
I therefore suspect Witkoff and Kushner are trying to construct a compromise that permits Putin to say that Ukraine has relinquished its claim to recover Donbas militarily without forcing Zelensky to formally hand the remaining Ukrainian-held cities to Russia. A demilitarized / free-economic-zone arrangement is almost tailor-made for that purpose.
My rough probability distribution for the trip would be 15% chance of a genuine breakthrough, 50% chance they narrow the differences enough to restart sustained negotiations, and 35% that little changes. The fact that they are going Moscow first and Kyiv second is significant: I expect them to present Putin with a USA Framework today, determine precisely what he would accept, and then take a modified version of it to Zelensky tomorrow. Trump has publicly described what they are carrying as a "concrete proposal," but neither the White House nor the parties have disclosed its terms.
If I had to make one fairly specific prediction, it would be: ceasefire near the present line + Ukrainian withdrawal from at least part of its remaining Donetsk positions into a demilitarized / free-economic-zone arrangement + no NATO membership + substantial USA / European security guarantees + phased Russian sanctions relief. That strikes me as the package most consistent with everything that has leaked over the past several months.
Many Russian guys are leaving their country to escape dictator Putin, when they don t want to be meat to kill for his crazy war, but USA suck him good till he finish in their mouth. Only making broke Russia will stop his war.
Enjoy.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/06/world/europe/ukraine-war-weapons-fraud-corruption.html
https://www.wsj.com/world/europe/ukraine-considers-legalizing-porn-industry-to-fund-its-war-chest-53b525bf?mod=hp_trendingnow_article_pos2
By the way, soon all those in higher posts in Kiev to be detained for corruption start cooperating with the prosecution since no longer be bailed out by the Regime in Kiev (yes, they even parading now in black t-shirts with a slogan 'Kievan Regime' on them). Why, because before they were bailed out with dirty money and the revolving doors worked.
At Tiny12 below:
No, we don't need exotic free-trade zones. Europeans were not invited to Moscow and we don't need them. Since the regime in Kiev won't sign anything and since whatever plan or agreement to be entertained will be a useless piece of paper, only our two friends can help us, our Army and Navy.
Read up on history. How many times did NATO expand post 1991? How many expansions did the Russians tolerate, despite the assurance that there would be no NATO expansion before the SU collapsed?
Ultimately much of the blame for the current conflict lies with western neoconservatives and the western military/defense-industry establishment. If not for them, Russia and Ukraine might just both be members of the EU and NATO today. Please see the historical documents at the end of this web page.
https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017-12-12/nato-expansion-what-gorbachev-heard-western-leaders-early
At Tiny12 below:
No, we don't need exotic free-trade zones. Europeans were not invited to Moscow and we don't need them. Since the regime in Kiev won't sign anything and since whatever plan or agreement to be entertained will be a useless piece of paper, only our two friends can help us, our Army and Navy.The civilian population of Ukrainian-controlled Donetsk is less than 100,000. How about if the Europeans buy them all villas in the south of France, move them there, and pay them generous allowances for the rest of their lives? If they did everyone would come out ahead. According to Gemini Pro, deaths due to the conflict currently run 140,000 per year and global economic costs run about $1 trillion per year.
Ultimately much of the blame for the current conflict lies with western neoconservatives and the western military/defense-industry establishment. If not for them, Russia and Ukraine might just both be members of the EU and NATO today. Please see the historical documents at the end of this web page.
https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017-12-12/nato-expansion-what-gorbachev-heard-western-leaders-earlyIn your eagerness to support your pal you overlooked my rebuttal to him.
The "not one inch eastward" assurance was verbal, limited to East Germany during unification talks, and never written into the Two Plus Four Treaty or any binding agreement. Also cut the spin BS. Many former Eastern Block countries freely and gleefully expanded into NATO because they reject your way of life.Even though interpretations of such discussions remain contentious it's most noteworthy that such provisions were never written into any formal binding agreement. It's also unreasonable to talk about NATO expansion while ignoring the agency of the former Eastern Block countries that were eager to join.
Historians generally agree that James Baker didn't have the authority to make a binding pledge on behalf of the US regarding NATO expansion. His statements were exploratory while president Bush's administration later made it clear that nations have the right to pursue their own alliances.
And any idea of Russia as a member of the EU and NATO is a stretch to say the least given their dismal record on human rights and lack of adherence to democratic principles.
Upon further review this all was you. We all know you are heavily invested in your anti-US, anti-war agendas, but would you like to take time to walk some of this back?
I've seen the claims here about 500,000 Iraqi children dying from US sanctions and around 40,000 Venezuelan deaths from sanctions pop up here as whataboutisms before. Both numbers have been thoroughly debunked by later research. For Iraq, post 2003 surveys found no big sustained rise in child mortality during the sanctions period. The original 1999 UNICEF figure was heavily manipulated by Saddam's govt. Key paper is Dyson and Cetorelli in BMJ Global Health.
For Venezuela, the bulk of the humanitarian collapse and excess deaths happened before the 2017 sanctions. Brookings had a good piece on how these earlier numbers overstated the sanctions' role.
Happy to share the links if anyone's interested.
https://gh.bmj.com/content/2/2/e000311
https://www.lse.ac.uk/news/latest-news-from-lse/iraqi-government-misreported-child-mortality-lse-research-finds
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/revisiting-the-evidence-impact-of-the-2017-sanctions-on-venezuela/
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/chavismo-is-the-worst-of-all-sanctions-the-evidence-behind-the-humanitarian-catastrophe-in-venezuela/
Here's the link to his anti-war drama built into an "essay" he wrote for me. This is all debunked, and was so well before his post so he simply failed to do his homework.
As to deterrence, perhaps you have a point, with respect to China for example. But at what cost? Sanctions kill a lot of people. UNICEF estimates over 500,000 Iraqi children died by 1999 because of sanctions. The CEPR attributes 40,000 Venezuelan deaths to USA Sanctions in 2017 and 2018 alone.
The front lines are effectively in a stalemated state, as both sides have been able to use drones to degrade logistics and prevent (most) maneuvers. The ubiquity and range of drones makes massing medium-to-large troop gatherings problematic, as they're targeted promptly and disrupted. There may occasionally be some adjustments to front-line positions, but neither side seems currently able to conduct any breakthrough operations. However, since Russia's goal is to advance, while Ukraine's is to hold their defensive positions, the front line situation is more in line with Ukrainian goals (IMO).
With the front line being stalemated, the primary effort from each side is to inflict losses on the other by means of attrition aimed at infrastructure and deep-rear targets. At this point, neither side has been able to gain a decisive advantage. Russia thinks it can grind Ukraine down, even with Western support. IMO, the Kremlin believes (rightly or wrongly) that Russia can tolerate more pain and hardship than the other side. From many reports I've seen, they will likely focus on energy targets during this upcoming winter. Ukraine, OTOH, is counting on refinery and oil storage strikes to create problems for both Russia's economy and military operations. Ukraine believes (rightly or wrongly) that they can create real problems for Russia this way.
While Western support has had its ups and downs, every indication is that it's likely to continue to the level that at least keeps Ukraine functioning. While the West appears unwilling to give Ukraine the kinds and amounts of weapons that might lead to a possible victory, they're also unwilling to allow Ukraine to fail. On the Russian side, I think the same argument can be made with respect to the aid from China and North Korea.
But there are some wild cards to keep an eye on. If Ukraine can produce a better interceptor system, capable of dealing with jet-powered drones and cruise-type missiles, then that could help them get through the winter with much less damage. And, if they're able to produce home-grown ballistic missiles with sufficient range, that puts Russian infrastructure at much greater risk. On the Russian side, the possibility of a wider mobilization effort, after the upcoming elections, is something to watch.
Bottom line for me is that any so-called "peace talks" are just theater. That's because neither side has changed their fundamental positions and each side thinks they're in a decent position. Only time will tell, but I'm expecting this winter to be mostly more of the same. What I'll be watching is the wild cards I mentioned above, or maybe some other development that might give one side more of an advantage. Whichever side comes through the winter better will be in a stronger position come next spring.
P.S. Of course, there is always the possibility of a black- or gray-swan event, like Putin's death or ouster, but that's an outlier case.
P.P.S. Nobody in Russia or Ukraine really gives a shit about historical or other arguments. When two people are in the middle of a fist-fight, neither side cares why it started. The main goal is to win, or at the very least not to lose. Whoever wins will most likely write the postscript.
Enjoy.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/06/world/europe/ukraine-war-weapons-fraud-corruption.html
https://www.wsj.com/world/europe/ukraine-considers-legalizing-porn-industry-to-fund-its-war-chest-53b525bf?mod=hp_trendingnow_article_pos2
By the way, soon all those in higher posts in Kiev to be detained for corruption start cooperating with the prosecution since no longer be bailed out by the Regime in Kiev (yes, they even parading now in black t-shirts with a slogan 'Kievan Regime' on them). Why, because before they were bailed out with dirty money and the revolving doors worked.Enjoy your 22 out of 100 rating (Russia) in Transparency International's Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) while Ukraine is at 36. Neither is good but yours is beyond dismal. BTW do you believe that Alexi Navalny died of natural causes? Blood Red has signed off on that but Comrade Tiny 12 refuses to. Good on you Tiny 12. Please continue to break ranks.
The civilian population of Ukrainian-controlled Donetsk is less than 100,000. How about if the Europeans buy them all villas in the south of France, move them there, and pay them generous allowances for the rest of their lives? If they did everyone would come out ahead. According to Gemini Pro, deaths due to the conflict currently run 140,000 per year and global economic costs run about $1 trillion per year.I see. Maybe EU will do the same for the Palestinians. So far, no takers. Will EU ask them to work on their factories? We have already seen it during the WWII. This is a pure fascist concept. We want to live in our ancestral land as I assume other peoples do. Donbass will be freed fro AFU soon. Just don't forget that the capital of Donbass is actually Kharkov.
Upon further review this all was you. We all know you are heavily invested in your anti-US, anti-war agendas, but would you like to take time to walk some of this back?Walk back what? I don't recall claiming any of that.
Here's an estimate of more than 4. 5 million excess deaths from post 9/11 wars in which the USA had a hand. Admittedly many of the deaths were not attributable to the USA, particularly in Pakistan, Yemen and Syria. Still.
https://costsofwar.watson.brown.edu/papers/how-death-outlives-war
Edit: Your posts must be delayed. Apparently I did say that. You probably did a good job of debunking my sources. Im too lazy to read all that to know. Which is going to make my next post particularly hypocritical.
How much good did sanctions on Cuba, Venezuela, Iran, and Russia do anyway? They mostly hurt the man on the street and lessened the role of the dollar in commerce and as a reserve currency.
In your eagerness to support your pal you overlooked my rebuttal to him.
Even though interpretations of such discussions remain contentious it's most noteworthy that such provisions were never written into any formal binding agreement. It's also unreasonable to talk about NATO expansion while ignoring the agency of the former Eastern Block countries that were eager to join.
Historians generally agree that James Baker didn't have the authority to make a binding pledge on behalf of the US regarding NATO expansion. His statements were exploratory while president Bush's administration later made it clear that nations have the right to pursue their own alliances.
And any idea of Russia as a member of the EU and NATO is a stretch to say the least given their dismal record on human rights and lack of adherence to democratic principles.Please read the historical documents at the end of the National Security Archives web page.
Edit: Your posts must be delayed. Apparently I did say that. You probably did a good job of debunking it. Im too lazy to read all that to know. Which is going to make my next post particularly hypocritical.Well as is normal you're not too lazy to get to my posts before the ink is dry. Wink.
Though seems you may have squeezed in some vacation time recently. That's never a bad thing and I hope all is well.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.4 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.