PDA

View Full Version : Stupid Shit in Kyiv



Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 [19]

Tiny 12
09-08-26, 01:12
I see. Maybe EU will do the same for the Palestinians. So far, no takers. Will EU ask them to work on their factories? We have already seen it during the WWII. This is a pure fascist concept. We want to live in our ancestral land as I assume other peoples do. Donbass will be freed fro AFU soon. Just don't forget that the capital of Donbass is actually Kharkov.You apparently didn't understand what I was intending to convey. My post was satirical and not directed against you. Ukraine would be wise to give up the Donbas if it would bring peace.

Paulie97
09-08-26, 01:20
How much good did sanctions on Cuba, Venezuela, Iran, and Russia do anyway? They mostly hurt the man on the street and lessened the role of the dollar in commerce and as a reserve currency.Sanctions serve as a crucial diplomatic tool designed to impose costs on aggressive behavior without resorting to direct military conflict. While the humanitarian impact on the population is a valid concern, proponents argue that they limit a regime's ability to finance wars, fund terrorism, or develop banned weapons programs. And even when the ideal outcomes are not achieved, the restrictions still hinder a regime's capacity for aggression.

Regarding the dollar, while sanctions do create incentives for countries to explore alternatives, the global dominance of the US financial system makes it difficult to replace the dollar entirely.

Paulie97
09-08-26, 01:23
You apparently didn't understand what I was intending to convey. My post was satirical and not directed against you. Ukraine would be wise to give up the Donbas if it would bring peace.I'm all with you on this one. I'm shocked that Questner thought you could post something against him.

Paulie97
09-08-26, 04:51
Please read the historical documents at the end of the National Security Archives web page.No, I'm not doing all the work here. Retirement is too damned fun. Please make your case as all I've seen so far is assertions which aren't arguments. I've already responded to the arguments those documents are most often used for when operating from the sympathetic to Russia angle. Here it is again.


In your eagerness to support your pal you overlooked my rebuttal to him.

Even though interpretations of such discussions remain contentious it's most noteworthy that such provisions were never written into any formal binding agreement. It's also unreasonable to talk about NATO expansion while ignoring the agency of the former Eastern Block countries that were eager to join.

Historians generally agree that James Baker didn't have the authority to make a binding pledge on behalf of the US regarding NATO expansion. His statements were exploratory while president Bush's administration later made it clear that nations have the right to pursue their own alliances.

And any idea of Russia as a member of the EU and NATO is a stretch to say the least given their dismal record on human rights and lack of adherence to democratic principles.

Sirioja
09-08-26, 08:45
You apparently didn't understand what I was intending to convey. My post was satirical and not directed against you. Ukraine would be wise to give up the Donbas if it would bring peace.What USA tell to fuck Ukraine and suck Putin to make business with him, when after Crimea, Putin doesn't want only Donbass, but whole ex USSR, starting to attack ex DDR in Leipzig. Putin doesn't get Donetsk and his economics is going worse and worse. When robber Trump stopped to help Ukraine, fortunately Europe, not only EU, and Canada keep on helping so courageous Ukrainians who defend their land when Putin and Trump are robbers. Many Russian guys leaving Russia because they don't want to make Putin war, not Russia war, only Putin war, same than Trump with Canada, Greenland, Venezuela and Mexico.

Questner
09-09-26, 02:50
Late yesterday evening, Prosecutor General Ruslan Kravchenko submitted his resignation amid the investigation into the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU) case "Carthage".

The case is about providing cover to multiple scam call centers (Pay 4 Scam).

Xpartan
09-09-26, 04:40
Just don't forget that the capital of Donbass is actually Kharkov.I concur. It's that very Kharkiv where killer whales tear apart poor polar bears.

Every single day.

Poor bears.

Questner
09-10-26, 02:55
https://globalinitiative.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Kyiv-calling-The-scam-call-centre-phenomenon-in-Ukraine-GI-TOC-April-2026.pdf

A further case study on Ukraine examines one of the region's most significant scam call centre ecosystems. It traces the development of a highly networked illicit industry, its links to organized crime actors and corrupt protection, and the ways in which technology and crime-as-a-service may reshape the model in the years ahead. Read alongside the global and Eurasian analyses, the Ukraine report illustrates how locally embedded scam operations can acquire global reach.

Questner
09-10-26, 03:00
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/09/world/europe/ukraine-war-cost.html

Only 27 billion USD is missing from this year Ukrainian budget.

During this week's corruption hearing the prosecution had to repeat to the audience the known Russian proverb (don't worry, everyone in Ukrainian government speaks Russian, and broken synthetic Ukrainian on camera), which was obtained during covert audio recording: 'If to fuck, but the queen, if to steal but the million'.

Paulie97
09-10-26, 07:19
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/09/world/europe/ukraine-war-cost.html

Only 27 billion USD is missing from this year Ukrainian budget.

During this week's corruption hearing the prosecution had to repeat to the audience the known Russian proverb (don't worry, everyone in Ukrainian government speaks Russian, and broken synthetic Ukrainian on camera), which was obtained during covert audio recording: 'If to fuck, but the queen, if to steal but the million'.As is typical Questner refuses to engage while posting a highly biased take. Questner did Alexi Navalny die of natural causes, yes or no?

A shortfall is a spending-rate problem, not a theft problem. Ukraine's burning through cash faster than it arrives — salaries, death benefits, weapons contracts — and the twenty twenty-six allocation ran dry by mid-year. That's a math gap, not a missing pile.

Corruption explains some of it, sure — the one point two billion in procurement fraud is real. But the bulk is just a war that costs more than the budget covers. Russia spends a third of its entire federal budget on defense; Ukraine's doing the same math with a smaller economy and no oil money.

Paulie97
09-10-26, 07:41
https://globalinitiative.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Kyiv-calling-The-scam-call-centre-phenomenon-in-Ukraine-GI-TOC-April-2026.pdf

A further case study on Ukraine examines one of the region's most significant scam call centre ecosystems. It traces the development of a highly networked illicit industry, its links to organized crime actors and corrupt protection, and the ways in which technology and crime-as-a-service may reshape the model in the years ahead. Read alongside the global and Eurasian analyses, the Ukraine report illustrates how locally embedded scam operations can acquire global reach.And here's what Questner leaves out.

Ukraine's own anti-corruption agencies — NABU and SAPO — exposed the call-center protection racket and raided the Prosecutor General's Office itself. The prosecutor general resigned.

Russia's corruption dwarfs it: Kremlin prosecutors seized eighteen point six billion dollars in corruption cases last year alone, and kickbacks in state procurement average twenty-two and a half percent. Russia never polices its own — Ukraine just did.

None of this means hand Ukraine to Putin. A state actively raiding its own top prosecutor's office to break up criminal rackets demonstrates functional checks and balances—the exact opposite of a systemic failure that would justify abandoning support.

Sirioja
09-10-26, 08:26
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/09/world/europe/ukraine-war-cost.html

Only 27 billion USD is missing from this year Ukrainian budget.

During this week's corruption hearing the prosecution had to repeat to the audience the known Russian proverb (don't worry, everyone in Ukrainian government speaks Russian, and broken synthetic Ukrainian on camera), which was obtained during covert audio recording: 'If to fuck, but the queen, if to steal but the million'.And how dictator criminal Putin made building his hidden castle? When millions of Russians are poor from his inflation. Putin and Trump mean inflation for their citizens. Did You see so many Russians running away from Putin. Both are to be eliminated. World would be better.

Tiny 12
09-10-26, 20:06
No, I'm not doing all the work here. Retirement is too damned fun. Please make your case as all I've seen so far is assertions which aren't arguments. I've already responded to the arguments those documents are most often used for when operating from the sympathetic to Russia angle. Here it is again.Hmm, You want me to make my case, but don't want me to spend time posting in political threads in a hoe forum. Could you please provide some guidelines? Like how much effort should I make and how many characters should be in the reply? Please note that the leader of the "free world" spends A LOT more time on social media than I do. He posted over 100 times over labor day weekend!

Briefly though, you're partly right. There wasn't a formal signed document where NATO agreed not to expand eastward. Instead the West Germans, British, French, Canadians and Americans pulled a bait and switch. Again, see the historical documents in the National Securities Archive link.

You're retired, so presumably you're over 60. Were you in a coma from 1990 to 2010? Russia in the 1990's was radically democratizing. If it had been pulled into the western economic and security sphere, things would have been radically different. And in fact initially the West was on board with that. Russia was too, and agreements were signed to create partnerships with NATO and the EU. Putin expressed an interest in joining NATO.

In the late 1990's however, the Clinton Administration pushed NATO to enlarge. George Kennan, one of the chief architects of the cold war, shouted from the rooftop that adding Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic to NATO was madness. The West ignored him. This was followed by the NATO attack on Serbia without consultation with Russia. Then the USA invasion of Iraq. Further enlargement of NATO that included Baltic states. And finally, in 2008, as Blood Red said, NATO hammered the nails in the coffin, with its announcement that Ukraine and Georgia would become members of NATO.

The West crossed a line in the sand with Ukraine.

Tiny 12
09-10-26, 20:53
As is typical Questner refuses to engage while posting a highly biased take. Questner did Alexi Navalny die of natural causes, yes or no?
I'm confused. Didn't you say we shouldn't use whataboutism and red herrings back when you outlined deceptive debating? Just want to make sure I follow the rules, Robert’s Rules of Debate or whatever

Paulie97
09-10-26, 22:06
Hmm, You want me to make my case, but don't want me to spend my time posting in political threads in a hoe forum. Could you please provide some guidelines? Like how much effort should I make and how many characters should be in the reply? Simply offering assertions without arguments while handing me a homework assignment is not only lazy but arrogant.


Briefly though, you're partly right. There wasn't a formal signed document where NATO agreed not to expand eastward. Instead the West Germans, British, French, Canadians and Americans pulled a bait and switch. Yes, no written agreement is the bottom line. Best strategy is not to lose wars, and in that case, the Cold War as the Kremlin wasn't negotiating from a position of strength and Gorbachev knew it. The outcome would have been similar had the roles been reversed. So what were we supposed to do? Keep the Soviet Empire nice and warm for them until they decide they want it back decades later?


You're retired, so presumably you're over 60. Were you in a coma from 1990 to 2010? That's not only irrelevant but ageism. Aren't you the guy who used to complain about ad hominems?


Russia in the 1990's was radically democratizing. If it had been pulled into the western economic and security sphere, things would have been radically different. And in fact initially the West was on board with that. Russia was too, and agreements were signed to create partnerships with NATO and the EU. Putin expressed an interest in joining NATO. In the late 1990's however, the Clinton Administration pushed NATO to enlarge. George Kennan, one of the chief architects of the cold war, shouted from the rooftop that adding Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic to NATO was madness. The West ignored him. This was followed by the NATO attack on Serbia without consultation with Russia. Then the USA invasion of Iraq. Further enlargement of NATO that included Baltic states. And finally, in 2008, as Blood Red said, NATO hammered the nails in the coffin, with its announcement that Ukraine and Georgia would become members of NATO. The West crossed a line in the sand with Ukraine.This whole paragraph is a list of grievances each one with a hole in it. The "radically democratizing" claim is an assumption not a fact. Russia was shelling it's own parliament in '93 and invaded Chechnya in '94. That's not a country NATO was going to vote in, and one member's vote would have killed it anyway. The UK called it farcical in '95. They also weren't getting in the EU. They never applied and there were no invitations. Russia at times wanted partnership with NATO but with veto power, joining the club to run it. Kennan did call the first round madness but he was a minority voice. The senate ratified the first enlarge 80-19 in 1999. Again you completely ignore the agency of these former Eastern Block countries that were eager to join.

As to the failure to consult Russia on Serbia, Russia was bombing Chechnya at the same time, so its moral standing to lecture as usual was zero. And the Kosovo war ended with a UN resolution Russia signed. Iraq was a US-led coalition, not NATO and had nothing to do with expansion. Stop trying to muddy the conversation.

Regarding Georgia and Ukraine, the political promise made in 2008 was in response to their clear desire for protection and integration into Western institutions, even though Germany and France blocked the action plan, meaning it wasn't and still isn't an active path to membership.

P.S. So why has Russia's response to Finland's entry into NATO been so muted? Many analysts argue that Russia's stance on NATO is less about security threats and more about maintaining it's "sphere of influence" with neighbors that want nothing to do with them. While the move of the historically neutral Finland was a direct result of Russia's actions.

Paulie97
09-10-26, 22:35
I'm confused. Didn't you say we shouldn't use whataboutism and red herrings back when you outlined deceptive debating? Just want to make sure I follow the rules, Roberts Rules of Debate or whateverContemporary financial corruption and politically motivated murders in Russia are fair game when discussing the war. I gave details in some recent posts. It's also all fair game when someone brings up the lessor corruption in Ukraine that I've acknowledged. That's not whataboutism, it's a rebuttal.

Whataboutism is ignoring your opponents points while making a beeline to Hiroshima or even 19th see. Manifest Destiny, as we've witnessed from you in the past.

Xpartan
09-12-26, 10:41
Russia spends a third of its entire federal budget on defense; Ukraine's doing the same math with a smaller economy and no oil money.Actually 44% now.

https://defence-blog.com/russias-military-spending-hits-a-record-44-of-its-budget

https://x.com/jakluge/status/2095861691070177525

And that's military spending only. My understanding is that security apparatus spending isn't included in this.

Questner
09-16-26, 21:39
https://spectator.com/article/zelenskys-strategy-is-national-suicide/?edition=us

For Americans who follow the Russian-Ukrainian war, the past few months must look very strange. In the first half of summer, the story from Kyiv – and the many western media outlets that repeated it – was that Ukraine was winning. Then, not long after the NATO summit in July, Kyiv announced it lacked the interceptors to prevent a winter disaster. The country needed 300 missiles to survive, we were told. Even if these 300 missiles arrive, they are unlikely to protect a country as large as Ukraine from the sheer volume of Russian ballistic attacks and glide-bomb strikes. Now it's September, and Ukraine says it's facing a $27 billion shortfall in defense funding. There seems to be a vast difference between the public relations campaign and the reality in Ukraine.

I know a little about that public relations campaign. I was President Zelensky's first press secretary, entering office alongside him in 2019. I left in 2021 and remained sympathetic to the President as he fought the Russian invasion. But by 2025, I'd come to the conclusion that Ukraine will never be able to win this war militarily. The only solution is a negotiated peace.

Under the current Ukrainian regime, the chances of peace seem remote. In late June, President Volodymyr Zelensky approved a 40-day campaign of long-range drone strikes within Russia to force the Kremlin to end the war. It was supposed to be an "influence operation," designed to show the Russian people the true cost of the conflict. But it was Ukrainians who suffered the most. The Kremlin instead escalated, bringing more destruction, more death and none of the negotiations that would ultimately save lives. Russia, it seems, was only emboldened by the attacks. The Kremlin merely reiterated its conditions for ending its aggression.

It is, of course, Russia who started this war. Its forces have tortured, raped, deported and killed Ukrainians. There is no moral symmetry between Kyiv and the Kremlin. Yet it is clear that the Ukrainian heroism of 2022 is long gone. Kyiv's war policies have hardened into permanent mobilization and superficial PR – empty slogans and moral posturing are all that's now offered. The desperate situation in Ukraine's streets is concealed so that the refusal to compromise can be dressed up as courage.

In 2022, when the war began, the whole country stood up to defend itself. Men lined up at recruitment offices, and cities that Moscow tried to seize successfully resisted. All this naturally produced admiration throughout the world – and glorification in the western media and political circles. Today, that same glorification has become an unbearable burden. There is a feeling that the western political establishment would rather see Russia burn than Ukraine saved. Our daily losses are treated as an acceptable price for that end.

Ukraine has lost more than half its population in the 35 years since it declared independence from the Soviet Union. The largest collapse in population has happened since Russia's full-scale invasion. By the most sober estimates, some 20 to 25 million people remain in the territory Kyiv still controls. Roughly half are of retirement age. At most, four million men are of conscription age. Russia can draw on the recruitment pool of approximately 10 times the number of fighting age men. Waging a war of attrition is therefore national suicide, not valor. Yet this is the strategy that the Zelensky government pursues.

The economy tells the same story. Ukraine is now entirely dependent on western aid, which is shrinking. Money that was supposed to be used to rebuild the country is being consumed by war. Public debt has crossed 110 percent of GDP. Russia, by contrast, has not had to borrow anywhere near this scale to wage its war, and it is still selling energy to the European Union. Since 2022, European countries have paid Moscow well over $230 billion for fossil fuels – more than they have given Kyiv in aid of all forms. Despite the innumerable sanctions packages, Russia keeps earning money and has a much stronger fiscal position than most EU states. Meanwhile, Ukraine is being crippled by the death of its people and the destruction of its productive base, while its debts keep accumulating.

Since the "influence operation" this summer, more than 90 percent of Ukrainian warehouses have been hit, our energy system has been torn apart and a humanitarian catastrophe will arrive with the winter snow. In the fifth year of full-scale war, the state's offer to civilians in the worst-affected regions is often simply: leave. People on the front line who have no money and no means are told to go somewhere else.

Every day Ukraine loses more of its people. Those who want their children to have proper healthcare and education are forced to emigrate. The number of people dying in Ukraine is roughly four times the number of births. The nation is perishing, and yet the war grinds on.

Finland lost land after a devastating war, yet it managed to preserve its nation and its future. Ukraine could still become a frontier between the West and Russia: armed, sober and alive. But the present strategy is pushing us down a different path: that of Afghanistan.

The West spent 20 years pouring trillions of dollars into that conflict. All it achieved was flourishing corruption, decades of death and eventually the fall of Kabul to the Taliban. As in Ukraine, there was heavy censorship in western media. Most of those who reported from the region were uncompromising in their support of the Afghan state machine and the war, no matter what.

We see many of the same parallels in Ukraine. Extraordinarily, corruption rivals the war in rankings of public opinion as the biggest national problem. There are those in the Ukrainian government who are making millions of dollars from this war. I have just been sanctioned by the Zelensky government for saying so publicly.

Meanwhile, normal Ukrainian men do not leave their homes for months, for fear of press gangs who hunt them in the streets. There are reports of the disabled being pushed into frontline combat, of men dying mysteriously in recruitment offices, of women fighting to save husbands from being kidnapped in plain daylight. According to the Ukrainian ombudsman, only 2-3 percent of those seized in press gang raids ever reach the frontline. Many pay, sometimes tens of thousands of dollars, to buy their way out. The corruption around this system runs into the billions of dollars annually. I do not blame my people for refusing to fight for a machine they no longer believe in.

If the purpose of this war was to create a path for Ukraine to join NATO, that prospect is already off the table. If the purpose was to recover territory, Ukraine is losing more of it, not taking it back. If it was to protect democracy, then the wartime martial law has already killed it. Freedom of speech has been greatly restricted, institutions have been corrupted, basic political rights suspended, the constitution violated, political opponents persecuted. All of this with a casualness about human life that would be recognized as deeply authoritarian anywhere else.

The war in Ukraine has lost any plausible theory of victory. At this point, it only lines the pockets of a corrupt and narrow circle of elites while the country itself perishes. Ukraine can still choose the Finnish road: stop the bleeding, hold what can be held, restore the economy and a way of life to which people can return. The other road is already visible. It is a road down which we lose land and people every day – and with them, the chance that there will be a Ukraine left to win.

Written by Iuliia Mendel.

Iuliia Mendel is a Ukrainian journalist and the former press secretary of Volodymyr Zelensky.

Sirioja
09-17-26, 10:58
https://spectator.com/article/zelenskys-strategy-is-national-suicide/?edition=us

For Americans who follow the Russian-Ukrainian war, the past few months must look very strange. In the first half of summer, the story from Kyiv and the many western media outlets that repeated it was that Ukraine was winning. Then, not long after the NATO summit in July, Kyiv announced it lacked the interceptors to prevent a winter disaster. The country needed 300 missiles to survive, we were told. Even if these 300 missiles arrive, they are unlikely to protect a country as large as Ukraine from the sheer volume of Russian ballistic attacks and glide-bomb strikes. Now it's September, and Ukraine says it's facing a $27 billion shortfall in defense funding. There seems to be a vast difference between the public relations campaign and the reality in Ukraine.

I know a little about that public relations campaign. I was President Zelensky's first press secretary, entering office alongside him in 2019. I left in 2021 and remained sympathetic to the President as he fought the Russian invasion. But by 2025, I'd come to the conclusion that Ukraine will never be able to win this war militarily. The only solution is a negotiated peace.

Under the current Ukrainian regime, the chances of peace seem remote. In late June, President Volodymyr Zelensky approved a 40-day campaign of long-range drone strikes within Russia to force the Kremlin to end the war. It was supposed to be an "influence operation," designed to show the Russian people the true cost of the conflict. But it was Ukrainians who suffered the most. The Kremlin instead escalated, bringing more destruction, more death and none of the negotiations that would ultimately save lives. Russia, it seems, was only emboldened by the attacks..But Ukrainians dont want to be under dictator Putin, when many Russians leave Russia because of Putin.

Amadeuss
09-17-26, 14:41
Iuliia Mendel. Is she available on a dating app? I would take her. But she must shut up with this political stuff when we fuck.

Reiner Otto
09-17-26, 17:48
https://spectator.com/article/zelenskys-strategy-is-national-suicide/?edition=us

For Americans who follow the Russian-Ukrainian war, the past few months must look very strange. .... Some parts in this article are true. Unfortnately, because of the failed trust in Gods own country.

How about delivery of Patriots, for example?

Shame on that once great country.

Paulie97
09-17-26, 18:27
https://spectator.com/article/zelenskys-strategy-is-national-suicide/?edition=us

Here's my response to the Iuliia Mendel article recently posted by Questner. It's linked again above.

The absurdity of her piece is seen in that she refuses to acknowledge the difference between a "peace deal" and capitulation. Russia has never offered anything less than demilitarization, neutrality, recognition of annexed territory, and army caps that would leave Ukraine unable to defend itself. That's not a border adjustment. It's handing Putin the keys and hoping he doesn't come back for the furniture. I could stop right there but will unravel some of the same arguments Moscow's been making for years, but this time from Mendel, a faux insider with a Ukrainian passport, who stepped down from her post in 2021 before a shot was fired.

She admits Russia started the war, then argues Ukraine should surrender anyway. That's not analysis. That's the invader's script with a press badge. That's while her predictions are tired. The air defense gap is real, but "not enough interceptors" has been the headline for three years and running, and the grid's still up.

The ninety percent figure is real but narrower than she makes it sound. Ukraine's agriculture minister said Russia destroyed about ninety percent of the modern logistics used by food retail chains — the big distribution centers that supply supermarkets. Total Class A and be warehouse space is down roughly fifty percent, not ninety. The rest of the country still has about two point nine million square meters operating. The energy system is damaged, not torn apart. Russia has hit generation and substations hard, and the UN is warning this could be the toughest winter yet. But as of mid-September there are no scheduled outages, gas storage is being filled, and the grid is still running. "Humanitarian catastrophe will arrive with the winter snow" is a prediction, not a fact. The "state's offer is simply leave" line is the emotional closer. Evacuation is offered in the worst-hit zones, and people do leave. That is not the same as the government telling civilians to abandon the country. She's turning a real logistics and energy crisis into proof that surrender is the only option.

The paragraph she devoted to try and downplay the Ukrainian drone attacks is by far the weakest in her piece. The forty-day campaign was real — Zelenskyy announced it in late June twenty twenty-six as an influence operation to pressure Moscow. But the claim that Ukrainians suffered the most is a distortion. The strikes hit Russian oil refineries, airfields, and logistics deep inside Russia. Ukraine hit all eleven of Russia's largest oil refineries with industry loses estimated at 13.5 billion dollars. Refining capacity dropped sharply. Fuel shortages hit dozens of regions. Russia's own fuel exports fell. The damage was real and it was on Russian soil. Russia did escalate its strikes on Ukraine in response, but that's not evidence the campaign failed. It's evidence it worked. You don't escalate against a strategy that's having little effect. And the "none of the negotiations" line is wrong. The strikes were designed to force the Kremlin back to the table by raising the cost of continuing. Calling that a failure because Putin didn't immediately fold is setting an impossible standard. Meanwhile the drones keep coming.

The Afghanistan analogy is a false one. It was a nation building project in a country that had little precedent in the local culture. Ukraine is a sovereign state defending it's own territory from an invasion.

The censorship point is also lazy. Western media did criticize the Afghan war for years, the SIGAR reports, the waste, the corruption. It wasn't a propaganda monolith. She's flattening a messy, debated conflict into a clean cautionary tale so she can say "see Ukraine will end the same way. " It won't because the situations aren't the same.

The numbers she leans on in her economy paragraph are already stale. Russia's military spending hit a record forty-four percent of the federal budget in the first half of twenty twenty-six — over ten point seven trillion rubles, roughly one hundred twenty-five billion dollars. That's more than half of every ruble the government collects. The deficit has already blown past the full-year target. Regions are slashing signing bonuses and, in places like Yakutia, freezing payments to soldiers outright because the money ran out. This isn't a stronger fiscal position. It's a war economy eating itself. Growth has collapsed to under one percent, inflation is still biting, and the civilian sector is being hollowed out to feed the front. Ukraine's debt is high, but it's mostly concessional aid from allies who have a reason to keep it solvent. Russia's "strength" is extraction — oil revenue, forced labor, and a shrinking workforce — with no off-ramp. She's comparing a country fighting for survival to one that chose this war and is now paying for it by cannibalizing its own budget.

On the abuses, corruption, and other challenges with mobilization, the paragraph's real move is the last line: "I do not blame my people for refusing to fight. " That's not analysis, that's a verdict on the war itself, dressed up as sympathy. Every invaded country in history has had a broken mobilization system. France in nineteen forty, the Soviet Union in nineteen forty-one — both had desertion, corruption, men hiding from recruiters. The existence of a broken system doesn't answer the question of whether the fight is worth having. She's using real suffering to smuggle in a surrender argument.

Regarding Russian mobilization, UN special rapporteur put desertions at over fifty thousand since twenty twenty-two — nearly ten percent of the force deployed in Ukraine. Courts have convicted tens of thousands for going AWOL or deserting, and independent estimates put the true number higher, with some projecting up to seventy thousand in twenty twenty-six alone. Corruption is just as entrenched. Men buy medical deferments, fake Category G exemptions, and even full exits for a million rubles or more. Recruiters get bonuses for delivering bodies, and police have been caught planting drugs or threatening charges to force contracts. In the range of one million Russian men fled the country in the opening months of the war.

And the street hunting is real too. In places like Penza this summer, police and plainclothes teams were grabbing men off buses, at checkpoints, and outside workplaces — sometimes with wives screaming from the vans — then dragging them to enlistment offices to sign under threat. Men are now staying indoors, carrying pepper spray, and organizing self-defense groups to avoid it.

Same broken machine, different flavor.

Mendel's credibility is shot. She left the administration in twenty twenty-one, before the full-scale invasion reshaped everything she claims to understand. Her later claims rest on unnamed sources that fact-checkers have flagged as misleading. The Tucker Carlson circuit and the sudden convergence with Moscow's talking points aren't journalism — they're mostly the same script Russia has run for years.

Her casualty math has some accuracy but is incomplete. That while she's recycling the same Russian talking point that's been wrong since 2022, that Ukraine's been running out of men, while the front is still holding. Ukraine's pool of conscription-age men is small — around four million in the territory it still holds — and Russia's is roughly ten times larger. But attrition is not a pure headcount contest. Ukraine has been inflicting disproportionate losses with drones, long-range strikes, and cheaper systems. Russian casualties have run two to three times higher than Ukraine's for most of the war, and in early twenty twenty-six the ratio climbed towards eight to one in some estimates. Russia is also struggling to replace its own losses at the same rate. She's calling for surrender at the exact moment the attrition is working against the side she wants to surrender to.

She got the NATO point backwards. NATO membership was never the war's purpose from Ukraine's perspective. It was Russia's stated grievance. Putin invaded to stop Ukraine from drifting West and it backfired spectacularly. The invasion is exactly what pushed Finland and Sweden into NATO.

She's right that martial law restricts speech and suspends elections. But she's treating emergency powers as proof the war's purpose failed, when they're the predictable cost of being invaded. Every country under attack does this. Britain during World War Two detained citizens without trial through regulation 18 b. The US suspended habeas corpus in Hawaii and locked up Japanese Americans. The question isn't whether Ukraine's democracy is imperfect under siege — it's whether surrendering restores it. It doesn't. Occupation doesn't bring back elections; it brings Russian law, Russian courts, and Russian imposed censorship.

Last but not least, on the matter of fighting on, let's listen to the Ukrainians themselves. A KIIS poll from late Aug to early Sept this year found 77% of Ukrainians say the country should keep fighting. Only 12% would accept Russian demands. Let's not let Ukraine down. If we do then we tell every future aggressor that invading a country and outlasting the world's attention span is a winning strategy.

Paulie97
09-17-26, 20:06
But Ukrainians dont want to be under dictator Putin, when many Russians leave Russia because of Putin.You cut right to the chase. Ukraine is inflicting significant pain on Russia. The overwhelming majority of Ukrainians want to continue doing so with the aim of reaching concessions that preserve their statehood and military capabilities.

Questner
09-18-26, 01:25
"Every day I ask God for forgiveness for helping him come to power. " Mendel called Zelensky an abomination.

Volodymyr Zelenskyy's former press secretary, Yulia Mendel, continues to harshly criticize the president. In a new interview, she called him "a threat to Ukrainian sovereignty" and "an instrument of the Ukrainian nation's suicide. ".

The statements were made in a conversation with blogger Lilia Bagirova. The interview with Mendel appeared on her YouTube channel yesterday evening.

"I think Volodymyr Zelenskyy today is a threat to Ukrainian sovereignty, a threat to Ukrainian existence in general. We are now about to celebrate the 35th anniversary of Ukrainian independence. As a Ukrainian, I ask myself: will there be another 35 years? Our nation is perishing. We simply have no future. The status quo is impossible. Do you understand that there may not be another 35 years? We simply don't have the people. I ask God for forgiveness every day for helping this abomination come to power, to remain in power. Zelenskyy is an abomination," she said.

According to her, Zelenskyy came to power "on promises of peace, but now he's waging the largest war in Europe and constantly finding reasons why it can't be ended. " Mendel claims that it was Zelenskyy who repeatedly insisted on continuing the war, despite opportunities for negotiations.

"There were about seven attempts to end the war. But Zelenskyy's position was the same: the war must continue. The fact that Zelenskyy insisted that the war must continue in 2022 is 100%. Twice. And in 2024," she said.

Reflecting on the consequences of the war, Mendel stated: "Strategically, we've already lost. We've lost people. And we're losing them every day. And territory, too. And yet they continue to brainwash us, telling us about some kind of resilience: we're all unbreakable, we're all invincible. This is simply populism of the highest order."

She is confident that the Kremlin is certainly to blame for the current situation.

"Putin is a real asshole. But Putin isn't to blame for Ukrainian corruption. Putin isn't to blame for the buildings being built near Kyiv. Putin isn't to blame for the scandals that are happening. Putin is destroying the Ukrainian nation. And which one is Zelensky destroying? Tell me," she added.

Mendel also reported that Zelenskyy's "half of his phone (that is, contacts in his address book) are Russians"—people who are in Russia or have ties to the Kremlin.

"For me, he is a traitor," Mendel said.

Also yesterday, Mendel was barred from entering the European Parliament for the German party Alternative for Germany's event " Ukraine: Dare for Peace. Diplomacy Instead of Escalation," where she was scheduled to speak.

Paulie97
09-18-26, 03:57
"Every day I ask God for forgiveness for helping him come to power. " Mendel called Zelensky an abomination.

Volodymyr Zelenskyy's former press secretary, Yulia Mendel, continues to harshly criticize the president. In a new interview, she called him "a threat to Ukrainian sovereignty" and "an instrument of the Ukrainian nation's suicide. ".

The statements were made in a conversation with blogger Lilia Bagirova. The interview with Mendel appeared on her YouTube channel yesterday evening.

"I think Volodymyr Zelenskyy today is a threat to Ukrainian sovereignty, a threat to Ukrainian existence in general. We are now about to celebrate the 35th anniversary of Ukrainian independence. As a Ukrainian, I ask myself: will there be another 35 years? Our nation is perishing. We simply have no future. The status quo is impossible. Do you understand that there may not be another 35 years? We simply don't have the people. I ask God for forgiveness every day for helping this abomination come to power, to remain in power. Zelenskyy is an abomination," she said.

According to her, Zelenskyy came to power "on promises of peace, but now he's waging the largest war in Europe and constantly finding reasons why it can't be ended. " Mendel claims that it was Zelenskyy who repeatedly insisted on continuing the war, despite opportunities for negotiations.

"There were about seven attempts to end the war. But Zelenskyy's position was the same: the war must continue. The fact that Zelenskyy insisted that the war must continue in 2022 is 100%. Twice. And in 2024," she said..Notice you haven't addressed a single point of my rebuttal to the article of hers that you posted. You just dumped more emotional quotes from her. Meanwhile she just got banned from a European Parliament event and was sanctioned by her own government a week ago. She has about as much credibility as Laura Loomer. Come back when you're ready to engage point by point with my rebuttal. It's from today, currently post number 4522 and is linked here:


Here's my response to the Iuliia Mendel article recently posted by Questner. It's linked again above.

Jmsuttr
09-18-26, 05:54
https://kyivindependent.com/ex-zelensky-spokesperson-iuliia-mendel-sparks-outrage-after-tucker-carlson-interview/

Former huge supporters who have decided to do a full about-face to become huge critics and detractors. Whatever arguments they make, it's certainly legitimate to question their personal motivations and agendas. It's similar to how an ex-wife or dumped girlfriend once sang a man's praises but they now see him as evil incarnate.

There are plenty of critics and supporters of both Zelenskyy and Trump who have been consistent over time, which is the norm for people acting on long-held principles. But extreme flip-flopping is not normal behavior, which makes it hard to take such people seriously.

Great clickbait? Sure! Worthy of serious consideration? Not so much (IMO).

Sirioja
09-18-26, 05:57
But Ukrainians dont want to be under dictator Putin, when many Russians leave Russia because of Putin.And Zelensky is still supported by majority of Ukrainians, versus Putin, when more than 60% Americans disagree with Trump and Putin always fuck Russian elections.

Jmsuttr
09-18-26, 23:58
Here's a good analysis of the legal and compliance issues:

https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/congress-sends-a-major-new-russia-and-3483184/

Excerpt from the article:

"Why the Shadow Fleet Provisions May Matter Most.

Senate Foreign Relations Committee ranking member Jeanne Shaheen made a case in a Dear Colleague letter ahead of the House vote that deserves particular attention from compliance officers in the energy and shipping sectors. Shaheen said she and her staff had heard directly from foreign governments that the bill's provisions targeting Russia's shadow fleet would cause foreign energy companies to stop purchasing Russian oil immediately, not gradually and not waiting for the sanctions to actually take effect through formal implementation. Her point was that the mere exposure to potential secondary sanctions liability is often sufficient on its own to change commercial behavior, well before enforcement actually occurs. Shaheen cited an estimated $100 billion in annual Russian revenue tied to shadow fleet oil sales, meaning the shadow fleet provisions alone carry outsized practical significance relative to their portion of the bill's overall text".

Obviously there are a lot of moving parts, not least of which is the ability of Trump (and future Presidents) to waive specific sanctions. But there's no way to know in advance if he will, or may pick and choose, or may use the threat of sanctions in a transactional way. So, as I noted in the title of this post, it's all about monitoring the new variables to see what impacts (if any) they may have.

Also, this post on X makes some good points:

https://x.com/NateSibley/status/2100378760025387467

Alternate link: https://nitter.cf/NateSibley/status/2100378760025387467.

"This legislation codifies into law fairly comprehensive sanctions that could have otherwise been lifted overnight, perhaps as part of a bad deal with Russia. That is its (enormous) value, because even if the admin issues temporary waivers, banks and companies that enforce sanctions know this is permanent US law".

Nobody has a crystal ball, so anyone who thinks they know how things will play out is blowing smoke, IMO. But it certainly bears watching.

Questner
09-19-26, 04:18
https://weltwoche.ch/daily/selenskyj-zerstoert-die-ukraine-seine-ex-sprecherin-julija-mendel-ueber-ihr-land-korruption-in-kiew-und-den-weg-zum-frieden/

Interview in English to Die Welwoche.

Xpartan
09-19-26, 23:25
Notice you haven't addressed a single point of my rebuttal to the article of hers that you posted. That's not how propogandists work.


You just dumped more emotional quotes from her.Now, that's precisely how propogandists work.

Questner
09-20-26, 02:38
There are many speculations about the recent visit of the CIA director to Moscow. One of the items although was disclosed, and it was a note by the US received from the RF to the below events. This time I asked Google AI to sum them up.

In May 2026, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky presided over the high-profile state re-burial of Andriy Melnyk, a prominent WWII-era Ukrainian nationalist leader, and his wife Sofia Fedak-Melnyk. Their remains were exhumed from Luxembourg and transferred to the National Military Memorial Cemetery near Kyiv. This repatriation is part of a broader, state-backed initiative to establish a national pantheon of heroes to honor figures who fought for Ukrainian independence. Melnyk was the leader of a major faction of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN-M). While Kyiv frames him as a historical figure who fought against Soviet oppression, his legacy is deeply controversial due to the OUN's collaboration with Nazi Germany during the war and its links to anti-Semitic rhetoric and the Holocaust. Later in August 2026, the remains of another early OUN leader, Yevhen Konovalets, were similarly repatriated from Rotterdam.

Reaction in Former Allied CountriesThe state honors bestowed upon Melnyk triggered swift and severe backlash from several former Allied nations, sparking diplomatic friction:

Israel: The reaction from Israel was immediate and highly critical. Israel's Foreign Ministry and Yad Vashem issued sharp condemnations, stating that honoring the leader of a movement that collaborated with Nazi Germany "undermines the moral integrity essential to Holocaust remembrance" and compromises historical truth.

Poland: The event, alongside a subsequent decree honoring the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA), ignited fury among Polish political and public figures. The OUN and UPA are historically tied to the wartime massacres of tens of thousands of ethnic Poles and Jews in Volhynia. Polish officials warned Kyiv that elevating figures associated with these massacres to a national pantheon could have severe long-term consequences for Ukraine's ambitions to join the European Union.

Russia: Russia used the event to heavily lean into its wartime propaganda narratives. The Russian Foreign Ministry formally summoned Luxembourg's ambassador to protest the exhumation, calling the state-honored re-burial a sign of disrespect toward millions of victims of Nazi Germany. The decision has highlighted a sharp divide between Ukraine's current wartime efforts to consolidate a fiercely anti-Soviet national identity and the international community's insistence on preserving historical accountability regarding WWII atrocities.

In the United States, the United Kingdom, and France, reactions to the state-honored re-burials of Andriy Melnyk and Yevhen Konovalets were highly nuanced. They were characterized by a sharp divide between official diplomatic silence from governments and vocal criticism from media, historians, and political factions. Because these nations are Ukraine's primary military and financial backers in its ongoing war against Russia, the reactions reflected a delicate balancing act:

1. The United States: Strategic Silence vs. Media ConcernOfficial Stance: The USA State Department and official government channels largely avoided making public statements or formal condemnations. Washington prioritized maintaining a united front with Kyiv amid the ongoing conflict, choosing not to publicly scold an ally over internal domestic memory policies. Media and Public Debate: Major USA Publications, such as The New York Times, covered the re-burials by highlighting the deep contradictions of the event. American media noted that while Ukraine is fighting to defend its democracy and align with Western values, elevating historical figures who collaborated with fascist regimes and held anti-Semitic ideologies creates severe friction with Western historical narratives.

2. The United Kingdom: Press Criticism and Diaspora DynamicsOfficial Stance: Similar to the USA, Downing Street remained officially quiet on the matter to avoid fracturing its robust security partnership with Ukraine. Media and Public Backlash: The reaction was more pronounced in British public discourse and independent media. Right-wing and nationalist-leaning platforms, alongside left-wing anti-fascist organizations, expressed deep unease. Organizations representing European diaspora communities in the UK (such as British-Polish groups) openly questioned whether celebrating OUN leaders with state and church honors risked mainstreaming far-right historical figures.

3. France: Domestic Political WeaponizationOfficial Stance: The French government refrained from issuing official diplomatic protests against Kyiv, viewing the creation of the National Pantheon as a domestic Ukrainian affair. Political Fallout: In France, the event was heavily seized upon by political opposition figures, particularly within the European Parliament. French MEPs, such as Thierry Mariani, publicly slammed the European Union's leadership for staying silent. Critics in France argued that the EU was exhibiting "double standards" by aggressively policing historical revisionism within member states while giving Ukraine a pass on honoring WWII-era collaborators for the sake of geopolitical convenience.

Sirioja
09-21-26, 13:37
USA just suck Putin, wishing for business with him, when he makes business with China. Fortunately EU, UK and Canada to support Ukraine, when Putin threaten with soldiers, people to make them vote for him, dictator fantasying about ex USSR when he was nothing in KGB.

Jmsuttr
09-23-26, 05:22
https://kyivindependent.com/ukraines-true-history-how-nationalist-movements-paved-ukraines-way-to-freedom/

"Obviously, there were anti-Semitic Ukrainians, he said, adding that some Ukrainian nationalists collaborated with the Nazis. But for many Ukrainians, the issue wasn't racial but rather political, Motyl said. The question was: Are they, or are they not, loyal to Ukraine? The nationalists weren't out to exterminate, they were out to combat their political enemies, he said while acknowledging the presence of anti-Semites in the ranks of the OUN. To put it a little crudely, but not inaccurately: Ukrainians were peasants and Jews were kind of the middle class and the upper class were either Poles or Russians, he said".

"Ukraine's nationalist heroes are thus no angels, but their main defining and uniting feature is their unbreakable commitment to the struggle for an independent state, scholars agree. Ukrainians will generally choose heroes that are strong, forceful, and that don't break easily, Shkandrij explained. That's why Bandera, as an unbreakable force, a person who never gave up that's why they would find that fight attractive".

Over Ukraine's history, both Russia and Poland have been enemies, so it's not a big surprise to find that Ukraine has heroes that both those countries don't like. And, especially during World War Two, some nationalist groups allied with the Nazis because Russia was seen as the bigger enemy. One relevant point is that many of Ukraine's nationalists had fought for independence against the USSR after the overthrow of the Tsar. In that context, anything to help fight Russia would not have been rejected.

With respect to collaboration with the Nazis in the arrest of Ukrainian Jews, here's an excerpt from an AI search summary:

"Historical Context: The actions of Ukrainian nationalists during this period are often viewed through the lens of their broader goals for Ukrainian independence, which included the elimination of perceived enemies, including Jews, Poles, and Russians. This complex history continues to be a subject of research and discussion among historians".

As far as the reaction of various countries is concerned, it's laughable how many are ready to throw stones when they live in glass houses. Russia, the UK, and France were all colonial powers and, as such, responsible for numerous violent suppressions of independence (I. E. , nationalist) movements. And Israel? Check out Menachem Begin's actions, labeled terrorism by many, in his nationalist struggle. In the US, take your pick of the heroes and villains from both sides of the Civil War. For anyone who thinks the North were unequivocally the good guys, check out Sherman's scorched earth tactics during his March to the Sea.

The bottom line is that history is rarely black and white, and those who love to point out what they perceive to be the sins of others almost never turn the lens upon themselves.

Sirioja
09-24-26, 03:30
When Putin is kind of Stalin son, but Ukraine was not a country when nazis killed millions of soviets. Stalin Putin fantazies about new USSR and becoming new Tsar, Putin 1, when large majority of Ukrainians hate him and want their independent country, when many Russians ran away, abroad, from dictator who fuck elections and kill who oppose.

Blood Red
09-25-26, 07:20
This is an article from the drugged out clown's former press secretary.

Zelensky's strategy is national suicide.

https://spectator.com/article/zelenskys-strategy-is-national-suicide

For every 1 birth in Ukraine, there are 4 people dying.

Half of Ukraine's population from 1991 is now gone.

For the remaining Ukrainian population, half are over retirement age.

This is the death of a nation.

The collective west that took Ukraine down the primrose path is pure evil.

Paulie97
09-25-26, 09:33
This is an article from the drugged out clown's former press secretary.

Zelensky's strategy is national suicide.

https://spectator.com/article/zelenskys-strategy-is-national-suicide

For every 1 birth in Ukraine, there are 4 people dying.

Half of Ukraine's population from 1991 is now gone.

For the remaining Ukrainian population, half are over retirement age.

This is the death of a nation..Funny how a "dead nation" after all these years is still the one making the Kremlin write opinion pieces instead of victory speeches. 100's of 1000's of casualties later, 40% of the Black Sea fleet down, 45% of your oil refining capacity knocked out, 44% of your budget currently spent on war, while your population is on edge it all remains quite embarrassing for what was supposed to be the second most capable military in the world.

War time consistently craters births while spiking deaths. The 50% figure is false. According to the UN roughly 25% of Ukrainians are over age 60. The rest of your content and much more was addressed here recently in my reply to the Mendel article from the Spectator. You're welcome to try and break down my rebuttal, but heads up, it will require more gray matter than your usual chest thumping, as you repeat the same tired fallacies over and over while completely ignoring the points previously made by your opponents. Here's the link, and it's post #4522.


https://spectator.com/article/zelenskys-strategy-is-national-suicide/?edition=us

Here's my response to the Iuliia Mendel article recently posted by Questner. It's linked again above.

Questner
09-26-26, 02:25
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian%E2%80%93Ukrainian_Friendship_Treaty

The Treaty on Friendship, Cooperation, and Partnership between Ukraine and the Russian Federation, also known as the "Big Treaty", was an agreement signed in 1997 between Ukraine and Russia, which fixed the principle of strategic partnership, the recognition of the inviolability of existing borders, and respect for territorial integrity and mutual commitment not to use its territory to harm the security of each other.

Respect for territorial integrity and mutual commitment not to use its territory to harm the security of each other. The crucial factor. So, what happened between 1998 and 2002 (the year of the first step of an attempt to drag Ukraine into NATO)? Was it a 1998 default? Was it 9/11 and its aftermath? Was it a dawn of Gas Wars? You tell me. I can assure you no Ukrainian at that time discussed it at the kitchen table or begged Rada to join.

Jmsuttr
09-26-26, 02:36
As I posted previously: "There are plenty of critics and supporters of both Zelenskyy and Trump who have been consistent over time, which is the norm for people acting on long-held principles. But extreme flip-flopping is not normal behavior".

For anyone who bothers to follow the Ukrainian press, there is no shortage of criticism of Zelenskyy. Here's my personal checklist for separating the credible from the non-credible:

1. Have a consistent track record. By that I mean that a journalist, or other critic, has a history of published articles or posts laying out the principles they use in evaluating Zelenskyy or other officials.

2. Be willing to debate and defend one's position even in a forum where there is vigorous opposition.

3. Don't be an obvious Russian shill who parrots Kremlin talking points.

4. For anyone who claims to represent a significant segment of the Ukrainian population, rather than simply one's own opinion, provide evidence to back up that claim.

Mendel fails every test, as far as I can tell. She's a flip-flopper, which is the opposite of consistency. Since she's been on her anti-Zelenskyy crusade, I've only heard of appearances on Russia-friendly outlets like Tucker Carlson. In fact, I can't find any recent meaningful interactions (interviews or articles) with Ukrainian media since her Carlson appearance. If she really has the best interests of Ukraine at heart, why is she avoiding the best and most direct ways of speaking to them? And, as far as repeating Russian talking points, the Kyiv Independent article I linked to in my earlier post does a good job of detailing that point. Finally, I've seen no credible evidence that Mendel is speaking for anyone other than herself.

Here's the bottom line: If you're on the jury in a court trial, you're tasked with evaluating the credibility of a witness. Once you find that a witness lacks credibility, what they have to say becomes irrelevant because they've failed the basic test of being believable.

The simple point being that it's a complete waste of time, effort, and bandwidth to try to debate or analyze anything that comes from a non-credible source. There are credible critics out there, but they unfortunately don't fall into the kind of sympathetic echo chamber the pro-Putin crowd would probably prefer.

Paulie97
09-26-26, 19:37
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian%E2%80%93Ukrainian_Friendship_Treaty

The Treaty on Friendship, Cooperation, and Partnership between Ukraine and the Russian Federation, also known as the "Big Treaty", was an agreement signed in 1997 between Ukraine and Russia, which fixed the principle of strategic partnership, the recognition of the inviolability of existing borders, and respect for territorial integrity and mutual commitment not to use its territory to harm the security of each other.

Respect for territorial integrity and mutual commitment not to use its territory to harm the security of each other. The crucial factor. So, what happened between 1998 and 2002 (the year of the first step of an attempt to drag Ukraine into NATO)? Was it a 1998 default? Was it 9/11 and its aftermath? Was it a dawn of Gas Wars? You tell me. I can assure you no Ukrainian at that time discussed it at the kitchen table or begged Rada to join.There was no push to join NATO at that time. Ukraine wanted interoperability — learning to fight and plan alongside NATO forces for peacekeeping and crisis response, not to join the alliance. They joined Partnership for Peace in '94, the first ex-Soviet state to do it. The exercises — Peace Shield, Sea Breeze, Cooperative Partner — were about common tactics, command procedures, and logistics so Ukrainian units could plug into NATO-led missions. They also sent troops to Bosnia and Kosovo under NATO command, which brought money, training, and equipment upgrades Ukraine couldn't afford on its own. Kuchma's multi-vector play: keep Russia close with the Friendship Treaty, keep the West engaged with exercises, and stay out of anyone's exclusive orbit.

What actually brought on Ukraine's quest for NATO membership was the Orange Revolution. Yushchenko took power in 2005 wanting a clean break from Moscow, and in January 2008 he, the prime minister, and the parliament speaker sent a joint letter formally requesting the action plan. Bush backed it; Germany and France blocked it.

P.S. Poland, Hungary, the Czech Republic, the Baltics, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia applied, queued up, wanted in, none were dragged kicking and screaming. Ukraine asked for a membership action plan in 2008 and applied for real in 2022.

Paulie97
09-26-26, 21:24
Ukraine's first push toward NATO membership was actually under Kuchma in 2002 after a policy shift. Efforts post 2004 represented an acceleration. Still in no cases was Ukraine "dragged" by any external forces. The same applies to every other Central and Eastern Euro country that expressed interest in membership.

Jmsuttr
09-26-26, 23:29
There's a lot of time and effort spent arguing about whether or not commitments were made to the USSR, and later Russia, with respect to NATO expansion and whether various countries (such as Ukraine) should be barred from NATO membership.

I would respectfully submit that these discussions overlook two essential points.

1. Russia has had a de facto veto over Ukraine membership in NATO for many years. By its own charter, NATO requires unanimous agreement before a new member can be allowed in. Before Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022, there were a number of NATO members who would absolutely have blocked Ukrainian membership. That includes not only overtly Russia-friendly countries, like Hungary, Slovakia, and Bulgaria, but also countries like Italy, Germany, and France who would have blocked it on "stability" grounds. There are other countries that might have blocked, for their own reasons (like Poland), but the point is that there was essentially zero chance that Ukraine would ever have attained NATO membership. The only way that might have changed would have been if Russia had altered its position.

Another relevant issue is that involvement in unresolved territorial or jurisdictional disputes is a disqualifying factor for NATO membership. By virtue of Russia's occupation and claims in Crimea and Donbas, they have a separate de facto veto over Ukrainian membership in NATO. No resolution = no membership, and Russia directly controls their side of that circumstance. There is little or nothing Ukraine can do unilaterally to affect any of the above.

2. As with unanimous consent being required for NATO membership decisions, a similar unanimity is required for NATO military action. Since its creation in 1949, NATO military forces have been involved in combat primarily during three specific operations (Serbia-Kosovo, Afghanistan, and the no-fly zone around Libya). None of these were a direct threat against either the USSR or Russia. The idea that unanimous consent would ever have been given for NATO military action against Russia is simply ludicrous on its face. Of course, if there is ever a need to defend NATO against direct Russian aggression, that's a different scenario. But the simple point is that there has never been any realistic possibility that NATO would be able to garner unanimous consent for any non-defensive action against Russia. All the same countries as in #1 (above), and probably even more, would never have agreed.

Bottom line: Ukraine by itself has never posed a threat to Russia. It's smaller in size, population, economy, etc. Any claim by nuclear-armed Russia to be fearful of Ukraine is ludicrous on its face. Russia knows this, so it had to construct a paranoid NATO-threat mythology. But Russia's problem is that this myth is completely debunked by all the points above: NATO's multiple unanimous consent requirements + multiple ways Russia (by itself and via proxies) can exercise a de facto veto over Ukraine in NATO and over any NATO military action against Russia. IMO, Russia's real problem with NATO is that it prevents Russia from acting with impunity. At some point Russia might like to take action against the Baltics, for example, and NATO has a deterrent effect that Russia wishes didn't exist.

Paulie97
09-27-26, 00:48
Here's the bottom line: If you're on the jury in a court trial, you're tasked with evaluating the credibility of a witness. Once you find that a witness lacks credibility, what they have to say becomes irrelevant because they've failed the basic test of being believable.

The simple point being that it's a complete waste of time, effort, and bandwidth to try to debate or analyze anything that comes from a non-credible source. There are credible critics out there, but they unfortunately don't fall into the kind of sympathetic echo chamber the pro-Putin crowd would probably prefer.I'll push back a little. Mendel is highly biased yes, but her generic Russian talking points are well circulating in American discourse. It's essentially a free for all, unlike the Cold War years when Soviet propaganda was subjected to a lot of institutional monitoring. Today's angle can move under different banners but the script is the same. The common denominator is the tribal signaling through buzzwords like "deep state" and "military industrial complex. " They rarely attempt to even define those terms or prove any causal relationships between that and the start of any wars, yet we know they've bought the tee shirt. Russia's victimization is embraced, while its own "military-industrial complex" and crimes against its own people are completely ignored. Given how well this all has circulated it needs to be called out with counter information.

I'm going to indulge for a moment and give the super short version of the pleas from the Russia sympathizers:

It's time for Ukraine to take a "peace deal" because they can only put pregnant women and old men with canes out of the battlefield. "Surrender and save yourselves!" That's essentially it. The script has been the same for over four years. The failed predictions are legion.

The rebuttals are partly in my previous post which I'll link again below, and I'll restate some of the content here.

1. Russia has never offered anything less than demilitarization, neutrality, recognition of annexed territory, and army caps that would leave Ukraine unable to defend itself. That's not a border adjustment. It's handing Putin the keys and hoping he doesn't come back for the furniture. That while 77% of Ukrainians want to fight on, only 12% want to give in to Russian demands.

2. Ukraine, a supposed defeated country is doing a lot of damage. Funny how a "dead nation" after all these years is still the one making the Kremlin write opinion pieces instead of victory speeches. Half a million Russian dead later, 40% of the Black Sea fleet down, 45% of Russian oil refining capacity knocked out, 44% of the Russian budget currently spent on war, while the population remains on edge it all remains quite embarrassing for what was supposed to be the second most capable military in the world.

3. Mendel is recycling the same Russian talking point that's been wrong since 2022, that Ukraine's been running out of men, while the front is still holding. Ukraine's pool of conscription-age men is small — around four million in the territory it still holds — and Russia's is roughly ten times larger. But attrition is not a pure headcount contest. Ukraine has been inflicting disproportionate losses with drones, long-range strikes, and cheaper systems. Russian casualties have run two to three times higher than Ukraine's for most of the war, and in early twenty twenty-six the ratio climbed towards eight to one in some estimates. Russia is also struggling to replace its own losses at the same rate. She's calling for surrender at the exact moment the attrition is working against the side she wants to surrender to.

My thorough version is linked here. Click "View original post. " It remains entirely untouched by the Russia sympathizers.


https://spectator.com/article/zelenskys-strategy-is-national-suicide/?edition=us

Here's my response to the Iuliia Mendel article recently posted by Questner. It's linked again above.

Jmsuttr
09-27-26, 05:28
I'll push back a little. Mendel is highly biased yes, but her generic Russian talking points are well circulating in American discourse.Critics are what they are, and Russian sympathizers are what they are. Mendel claims insider knowledge but she left government service in 2021, over 5 years ago. Then, after leaving, she turned into a fierce Zelenskyy critic. That puts Mendel squarely in the same category as an ex-wife, disgruntled former employee, or ex-business associate. And, when such people do a complete 180 turn, flip-flopping from supporter to denigrator, no reasonable person would take anything they say at face value. That's because the very act of flip-flopping is prima facie evidence of a personal agenda and / or vendetta against the person they formerly supported.

So, other critics can stand or fall on the merits of their arguments, or they might stand or fall based on other factors, but Mendel has disqualified herself by her own actions. Just as no reasonable juror would give any credibility to an ex-wife's negative testimony against her ex-husband, absent extremely corroborating evidence, in the same way Mendel is a thoroughly unreliable and non-credible witness. Which, as I stated in the subject line, makes her irrelevant.

Debating an argument's substance, or lack thereof, is a separate matter. But when the very credibility of a witness is the central issue then they haven't even passed the threshold requirements to be taken seriously. Again, IMO, debating anything Mendel-related is a waste of time, effort, and bandwidth. If someone brings up Mendel in a discussion with me, I simply reply that I believe her like I'd believe your ex-wife. It's good for a laugh and it gets the (non-credible = irrelevant) point across.

P.S. Part of the Russian "Firehose of Propaganda" strategy is to put disposable shills out there, like Mendel, and then discard them when they crash and burn, or lose their usefulness. Energy expended against such a shill is energy wasted, as Russia has an unending supply, just like a matryoshka doll.

Xpartan
09-27-26, 06:08
Ukraine has been quietly conducting a successful counterattack since May collapsing Russian onslaught on Liman and Kramatorsk.


For twenty months, Russias 20th and 25th Combined Arms Armies ground toward Lyman, a small city in eastern Ukraine that sits on a critical road and railway juncture. By seizing it, Russia would gain a crucial logistics hub to sustain its campaign to encircle the Fortress Belt, the cities anchoring Ukraines defense in Donetsk. But in May, Ukraines 3rd Corps launched Operation Vivaldi. In just a few weeks, Ukraine collapsed the Russian salient, encircled elements of the 2nd and 14th Motorized Rifle Divisions, and liberated up to 250 square kilometers of land.

The Ukrainian corps performed this masterpiece by achieving drone dominance over Russian forces. Provided with two brigades from Ukraines Unmanned Systems Forces, 3rd Corps saturated Russian rear areas with drones. One Russian military blogger reported how a considerable number of Ukrainian Hornet drones, which operate more than 150 kilometers behind Russian lines, attacked river crossings, disrupted logistics, and prevented reinforcements. These strikes isolated the Russian forces and, as their logistics system collapsed, prevented them from receiving the personnel, parts, and energy needed to effectively operate their own drones.

Remarkably, 3rd Corps reported that its forces neutralized Rubicon, Russias elite drone unit, destroying its logistics, ammunition depots, drone launch sites and newly formed units and killing their experienced drone operators. To prevent its complete loss, Russia withdrew Rubicon from the Lyman axis. Blinded, Russia was vulnerable to the Ukrainian counterattack.AFU acknowledged the operation only in September. The quiet helps because it enables the glorious Russian traditions of never-ever upsetting the boss. Only the victorious reports can find their ways upstairs.


Fortunately for Ukraine, Russian officers overly optimistic reports to their superiors will likely slow Russias response to a breakthrough. False reports of Russian success around Lyman had reached Putin, who bragged about it just as Russian forces there were collapsing. As one Russian source colorfully criticized the Russian chain of command, Is there a guy among youfor f*cks sakewho can tell Uncle Vova (Putin) that his picture isnt actually all that pretty, or are you all just f*cking losers? Ill tell him. Just bring me in, Ill tell him its all gone to sh*t. . . . Were totally f*cked on the Lyman front.An Overture to Victory: Operation Vivaldi and Ukraine's Path to Battlefield Decision.

https://mwi.westpoint.edu/an-overture-to-victory-operation-vivaldi-and-ukraines-path-to-battlefield-decision/

Paulie97
09-27-26, 22:14
Critics are what they are, and Russian sympathizers are what they are. Mendel claims insider knowledge but she left government service in 2021, over 5 years ago. Then, after leaving, she turned into a fierce Zelenskyy critic. That puts Mendel squarely in the same category as an ex-wife, disgruntled former employee, or ex-business associate. And, when such people do a complete 180 turn, flip-flopping from supporter to denigrator, no reasonable person would take anything they say at face value. That's because the very act of flip-flopping is prima facie evidence of a personal agenda and / or vendetta against the person they formerly supported.

So, other critics can stand or fall on the merits of their arguments, or they might stand or fall based on other factors, but Mendel has disqualified herself by her own actions. Just as no reasonable juror would give any credibility to an ex-wife's negative testimony against her ex-husband, absent extremely corroborating evidence, in the same way Mendel is a thoroughly unreliable and non-credible witness. Which, as I stated in the subject line, makes her irrelevant.For starters, your last sentence is the poisoning the well fallacy. You're not only not refuting her claims, but are disqualifying me from engaging with them, while most of her points relate to public information rather than insider knowledge. And it's self-defeating: if Russian propaganda is truly endless and disposable, then ignoring it is exactly what allows it to spread unchallenged. Your angle is also unfalsifiable because it commits the genetic fallacy, as you can dismiss any source you deem tainted out of hand without having to engage with it.

Your courtroom analogy is false. With public political discourse no one's freedom is at stake while there's no proof beyond a reasonable doubt standard. Different rules of engagement apply within vastly different dynamics. No one's freedom, financial future, or custody is at stake while the evidentiary rules don't transfer. The comparison collapses on it's on weight.

To your credit you seem to try and walk it back here, but then started talking out of both sides of your mouth.


Debating an argument's substance, or lack thereof, is a separate matter. Here's the irony though. Since according to you her credibility is zero and thus her arguments carry zero (non-sequitur), then you've wasted a boatload of "bandwidth" recently arguing against arguing. That was very inconsiderate of you. Wink While I said all of that to say, you aren't engaging, you're dodging.

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/Poisoning-the-Well

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/Genetic-Fallacy

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/blog/how-to-spot-the-fallacy-of-false-analogy

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/Non-Sequitur

Paulie97
09-27-26, 22:31
With my post from yesterday you quoted my first two sentences, skipped my whole argument then repeated your same argument over again. That's not engaging, it's dodging. From here try to make a better and more responsible use of your bandwidth. Wink.

Sirioja
09-28-26, 09:52
I'll push back a little. Mendel is highly biased yes, but her generic Russian talking points are well circulating in American discourse. It's essentially a free for all, unlike the Cold War years when Soviet propaganda was subjected to a lot of institutional monitoring. Today's angle can move under different banners but the script is the same. The common denominator is the tribal signaling through buzzwords like "deep state" and "military industrial complex. " They rarely attempt to even define those terms or prove any causal relationships between that and the start of any wars, yet we know they've bought the tee shirt. Russia's victimization is embraced, while its own "military-industrial complex" and crimes against its own people are completely ignored. Given how well this all has circulated it needs to be called out with counter information.

I'm going to indulge for a moment and give the super short version of the pleas from the Russia sympathizers:

It's time for Ukraine to take a "peace deal" because they can only put pregnant women and old men with canes out of the battlefield. "Surrender and save yourselves!" That's essentially it. The script has been the same for over four years. The failed predictions are legion.

The rebuttals are partly in my previous post which I'll link again below, and I'll restate some of the content here..But everybody, except blind Russians and too old senile Trump who likes so much his sperm, know Putin is a liar nobody can trust, like for Crimea, Trump forgot. Putin wants ex USSR, not only Donbass, this is why we have to resist versus a so dangerous criminal dictator and Ukrainians hate him, don t want to live under him, when many Russians left under him. And he tries to fuck many elections abroad, when threatening for voting for him.

Questner
09-29-26, 06:55
Now when you know the past or at least try to know the past, know the status quo, you can extrapolate and see where the puck may land.

Here is my opinion of what Ukraine might have done to avoid the conflict long before the financial crisis.

A) remain non-aligned, non-nuclear b) not seeking EU membership, but enter separate trade and migration agreements with EU c) amend the Constitution and become a federal state like the majority of larger countries.

Now the technical and military situation has changed and the NATO infrastructure should not be tolerated on Ukraine's territory. As EU is on its path to transform itself into a military alliance, Ukraine's EU membership has my doubts as well.

Now, mine are only opinions, they are not official position. Well, you can tell my opinions are wrong, ok, time will tell.

Jmsuttr
09-30-26, 05:37
For starters, your last sentence is the poisoning the well fallacy. You're not only not refuting her claims, but are disqualifying me from engaging with them, while most of her points relate to public information rather than insider knowledge. And it's self-defeating: if Russian propaganda is truly endless and disposable, then ignoring it is exactly what allows it to spread unchallenged. Your angle is also unfalsifiable because it commits the genetic fallacy, as you can dismiss any source you deem tainted out of hand without having to engage with it.

Your courtroom analogy is false. With public political discourse no one's freedom is at stake while there's no proof beyond a reasonable doubt standard. Different rules of engagement apply within vastly different dynamics. No one's freedom, financial future, or custody is at stake while the evidentiary rules don't transfer. The comparison collapses on it's on weight.

To your credit you seem to try and walk it back here, but then started talking out of both sides of your mouth.

Here's the irony though. Since according to you her credibility is zero and thus her arguments carry zero (non-sequitur), then you've wasted a boatload of "bandwidth" recently arguing against arguing. That was very inconsiderate of you. Wink While I said all of that to say, you aren't engaging, you're dodging.

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/Poisoning-the-Well

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/Genetic-Fallacy

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/blog/how-to-spot-the-fallacy-of-false-analogy

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/Non-SequiturSince the entire gist of my post is that Mendel, by virtue of her flip-flopping nature, is non-credible, why would you expect me to engage with her, or her purported arguments, in a substantive way? After my directly saying that she is irrelevant, it would be the height of inconsistency for me to treat her as though she were not.

Also, since you're so quick to level accusations of falsity and fallacious logic, it's fair to point out that your statement that I am somehow "disqualifying you" is both false and a quintessential example of the Straw Man Fallacy. If you re-read my post with a bit more care and a bit less nose-out-of-joint-ness, you might notice that I said absolutely nothing about you. Zero, zilch, nada. My entire focus was on Mendel, why her unique personal qualities render her non-credible, and why attention to a non-credible source is a waste. If you choose to take that personally, that says more about you than it does about me.

https://www.scribbr.com/fallacies/straw-man-fallacy/

You're also quite fond of nit-picking and trying to find distinctions without a difference. To wit:

1. "Most of her points relate to public information rather than insider knowledge". Whether public or insider knowledge, the non-credible flip-flopper categorization remains valid.

2. "If Russian propaganda is truly endless and disposable, then ignoring it is exactly what allows it to spread unchallenged". I never said to ignore it. I said Mendel, herself, is worth ignoring. And I specifically said "Debating an argument's substance, or lack thereof, is a separate matter," which you conveniently gloss over. I do have separate opinions about dealing with Russian propaganda, but the Mendel post was solely focused on her.

3. "Your courtroom analogy is false". Actually, it's not. That's because the credibility of a witness is determined independently of the matter at issue. Whether it's criminal, civil, or even small-claims, once a witness is shown to be non-credible they become irrelevant to the proceedings. But, if you prefer to dispense with jurisprudential niceties, the same principle applies outside a court. If a flip-flopping ex-wife, ex-partner, or disgruntled former employee tried to trash-talk you to others, you'd quite naturally (and rightly) raise the issue of non-credibility. The court scenario was a convenient illustration because of the presumed neutrality of the process, that's all. But the point holds true regardless.

4. Your claim re Genetic and Poisoning-the-Well fallacies assume that I'm making a priori ad hominem statements about Mendel. What you fail to recognize is that I am making a posteriori statements based on her own actions. If her prior actions and behaviors reflect negatively, that's entirely on her. All I am doing is pointing out that behavior, which is factually true and well-established. If anyone wants to treat her as though her personal actions and history don't matter, that's their prerogative. I prefer to (truthfully) call a spade a spade.

But, when all is said and done, everyone is free to give their attention to whomever or whatever they want. Just as I'm equally free to point out why a certain someone or something isn't worth the attention.

Jmsuttr
09-30-26, 06:13
With my post from yesterday you quoted my first two sentences, skipped my whole argument then repeated your same argument over again. That's not engaging, it's dodging. From here try to make a better and more responsible use of your bandwidth. Wink.My post was specifically about Mendel. Your post started with a mention of Mendel, but then quickly expanded into a treatise on Russian propaganda, in general. Because my focus throughout has been on Mendel, personally, and her non-credibility, anything beyond that was outside the original scope of my argument and therefore excluded from my response. And, in fairness, since I was replying to your response to my earlier post, I think I'm quite within my rights (in an argumentation sense) to bring the topic back to the parameters I originally set forth. In fact, if any dodging was going on, try looking in the mirror. It was you who side-stepped the central issue of Mendel's non-credibility and sought to enlarge it to include the much broader topic of Russian propaganda. Since I'm perfectly able to keep those two things separate, I simply chose not to follow you down that rabbit-hole.

So, when closely considered, my choice of quote, and my use of bandwidth, was altogether prudential and responsible. While your kvetching about it is rather questionable. Wink.

Sirioja
09-30-26, 10:23
Now when you know the past or at least try to know the past, know the status quo, you can extrapolate and see where the puck may land.

Here is my opinion of what Ukraine might have done to avoid the conflict long before the financial crisis.

A) remain non-aligned, non-nuclear b) not seeking EU membership, but enter separate trade and migration agreements with EU c) amend the Constitution and become a federal state like the majority of larger countries.

Now the technical and military situation has changed and the NATO infrastructure should not be tolerated on Ukraine's territory. As EU is on its path to transform itself into a military alliance, Ukraine's EU membership has my doubts as well.

Now, mine are only opinions, they are not official position. Well, you can tell my opinions are wrong, ok, time will tell.Yes, we all understood, after Crimea robbery, not respecting what liar Putin signed, and senile too old Trump who forgot what he told, but Ukrainians should have welcome ex FSB criminal, dictator Putin who fuck elections, threaten with army if You don t vote for him, kill if You oppose, but in dreams, giving a better life to Ukrainians, when nothing is better than freedom. Once more, Ukrainians who are brothers with Russians, but hate Putin. Time for Russia to wake up and make a new Ceacescu end.

Paulie97
09-30-26, 18:11
My post was specifically about Mendel. Your post started with a mention of Mendel, but then quickly expanded into a treatise on Russian propaganda, in general. Because my focus throughout has been on Mendel, personally, and her non-credibility, anything beyond that was outside the original scope of my argument and therefore excluded from my response. And, in fairness, since I was replying to your response to my earlier post, I think I'm quite within my rights (in an argumentation sense) to bring the topic back to the parameters I originally set forth. In fact, if any dodging was going on, try looking in the mirror. It was you who side-stepped the central issue of Mendel's non-credibility and sought to enlarge it to include the much broader topic of Russian propaganda. Since I'm perfectly able to keep those two things separate, I simply chose not to follow you down that rabbit-hole.

So, when closely considered, my choice of quote, and my use of bandwidth, was altogether prudential and responsible. While your kvetching about it is rather questionable. Wink.You quoted two sentences and skipped the rest. The argument presented in the first paragraph was three parts: her content is generic Russian propaganda, it's already circulating in American discourse, and it deserves a response to control the spread. Your post never touches any of that. It only attacks her credibility which is a different question. If you had a rebuttal to the substance, you'd have used it.

Paulie97
09-30-26, 18:34
And, when such people do a complete 180 turn, flip-flopping from supporter to denigrator, no reasonable person would take anything they say at face value. That's because the very act of flip-flopping is prima facie evidence of a personal agenda and / or vendetta against the person they formerly supported.
Debating an argument's substance, or lack thereof, is a separate matter. But when the very credibility of a witness is the central issue then they haven't even passed the threshold requirements to be taken seriously.You can't have both. The first quote says nothing she says can be taken at face value. The second says substance is a separate matter, then you're right back to your own contradiction. But if her flip flopping disqualifies everything before you read it, then substance never gets evaluated, so it can't be a separate matter. Pick one.

Paulie97
09-30-26, 20:55
Since the entire gist of my post is that Mendel, by virtue of her flip-flopping nature, is non-credible, why would you expect me to engage with her, or her purported arguments, in a substantive way? After my directly saying that she is irrelevant, it would be the height of inconsistency for me to treat her as though she were not.

Also, since you're so quick to level accusations of falsity and fallacious logic, it's fair to point out that your statement that I am somehow "disqualifying you" is both false and a quintessential example of the Straw Man Fallacy. If you re-read my post with a bit more care and a bit less nose-out-of-joint-ness, you might notice that I said absolutely nothing about you. Zero, zilch, nada. My entire focus was on Mendel, why her unique personal qualities render her non-credible, and why attention to a non-credible source is a waste. If you choose to take that personally, that says more about you than it does about me.

https://www.scribbr.com/fallacies/straw-man-fallacy/

You're also quite fond of nit-picking and trying to find distinctions without a difference. To wit:

1. "Most of her points relate to public information rather than insider knowledge". Whether public or insider knowledge, the non-credible flip-flopper categorization remains valid.

2. "If Russian propaganda is truly endless and disposable, then ignoring it is exactly what allows it to spread unchallenged". I never said to ignore it. I said Mendel, herself, is worth ignoring. And I specifically said "Debating an argument's substance, or lack thereof, is a separate matter," which you conveniently gloss over. I do have separate opinions about dealing with Russian propaganda, but the Mendel post was solely focused on her.

3. "Your courtroom analogy is false". Actually, it's not. That's because the credibility of a witness is determined independently of the matter at issue. Whether it's criminal, civil, or even small-claims, once a witness is shown to be non-credible they become irrelevant to the proceedings. But, if you prefer to dispense with jurisprudential niceties, the same principle applies outside a court. If a flip-flopping ex-wife, ex-partner, or disgruntled former employee tried to trash-talk you to others, you'd quite naturally (and rightly) raise the issue of non-credibility..The "a posteriori" move is your escape hatch. You claim you aren't making an a priori ad hominem, that you're just reporting facts about her behavior. But that's a distinction without a difference. Whether you call it a priori or a posteriori, the conclusion is the same: her history disqualifies her claims before you ever look at them. That's still the genetic fallacy wearing a lab coat.

Your courtroom analogy is still wrong. Witness credibility is assessed against the specific testimony — a witness can be unreliable on one point and credible on another. Mendel's arguments are primarily about public information, policy, documented events, statistics, things anyone can check, along with conclusions based on the same. You wholesale dismissed all that waving the disgruntled ex-employee banner which is the genetic fallacy confirmed yet again, same as the perpetual dodge. You never touched her arguments, only her biography.

Your "I never said to ignore it" line is also a dodge. You said attention to a non-credible source is a waste. That's functionally the same as saying ignore it.

On the straw man, fair enough. Disqualify was the wrong word. The point was that calling her a waste of time dismisses the contributions of anyone who engages with her. That part stands.

You're flailing because you can't defend your position without either abandoning it or doubling down on the fallacy. It's tiresome at this point, not to mention the violence you're committing against the bandwidth.

Blood Red
10-05-26, 17:04
Funny how a "dead nation" after all these years is still the one making the Kremlin write opinion pieces instead of victory speeches. 100's of 1000's of casualties later, 40% of the Black Sea fleet down, 45% of your oil refining capacity knocked out, 44% of your budget currently spent on war, while your population is on edge it all remains quite embarrassing for what was supposed to be the second most capable military in the world.

War time consistently craters births while spiking deaths. The 50% figure is false. According to the UN roughly 25% of Ukrainians are over age 60. The rest of your content and much more was addressed here recently in my reply to the Mendel article from the Spectator. You're welcome to try and break down my rebuttal, but heads up, it will require more gray matter than your usual chest thumping, as you repeat the same tired fallacies over and over while completely ignoring the points previously made by your opponents. Here's the link, and it's post #4522.What is your solution? Do you think Ukraine can win? Do you think Ukraine will ever join NATO?

Paulie97
10-05-26, 18:39
What is your solution? Do you think Ukraine can win? Do you think Ukraine will ever join NATO?Ukraine's solution is to survive — hold the line, keep the economy running, and make every kilometer cost Russia more than it's worth. That's not a slogan, it's what the numbers show: near-zero net Russian gains since March, and Ukraine retook about eight hundred square kilometers this year while Russia took nine hundred. And Ukraine's long range drone campaign has repeatedly hit Russian refineries and logistics, adding real economic costs beyond the front lines. Making every kilometer cost more isn't just about the trenches, it's hitting Russia's war economy directly.

On winning — no, not in the sense of retaking every inch. But Russia isn't winning either. Its theory of victory was that slow advances would collapse Ukraine's defenses, and that theory is failing. So the realistic endgame is a frozen line or a negotiated settlement, not a Russian flag over Kyiv.

On NATO — no, not anytime soon. Even Zaluzhnyi, Ukraine's former top commander, said this summer that Ukraine will never join. Zelensky has already offered to drop the bid in exchange for legally binding security guarantees from the US and Europe. That's the actual state of play.

Back to you, if Russia wanted peace, why does Lavrov's list still demand recognition of annexed territory Russia doesn't even fully control? Considering the same why do they insist that Ukraine reduce it's military to levels where it cannot defend itself? That's handing Putin the keys while hoping he doesn't come back for the furniture.

Sirioja
10-05-26, 23:49
Ukraine's solution is to survive hold the line, keep the economy running, and make every kilometer cost Russia more than it's worth. That's not a slogan, it's what the numbers show: near-zero net Russian gains since March, and Ukraine retook about eight hundred square kilometers this year while Russia took nine hundred. And Ukraine's long range drone campaign has repeatedly hit Russian refineries and logistics, adding real economic costs beyond the front lines. Making every kilometer cost more isn't just about the trenches, it's hitting Russia's war economy directly.

On winning no, not in the sense of retaking every inch. But Russia isn't winning either. Its theory of victory was that slow advances would collapse Ukraine's defenses, and that theory is failing. So the realistic endgame is a frozen line or a negotiated settlement, not a Russian flag over Kyiv.

On NATO no, not anytime soon. Even Zaluzhnyi, Ukraine's former top commander, said this summer that Ukraine will never join. Zelensky has already offered to drop the bid in exchange for legally binding security guarantees from the US and Europe. That's the actual state of play..Putin wants whole Ukraine, after Crimea, and even more, trying to fuck elections abroad, dreaming of back to ex USSR.

Blood Red
10-06-26, 13:01
Ukraine's solution is to survive hold the line, keep the economy running, and make every kilometer cost Russia more than it's worth. That's not a slogan, it's what the numbers show: near-zero net Russian gains since March, and Ukraine retook about eight hundred square kilometers this year while Russia took nine hundred. And Ukraine's long range drone campaign has repeatedly hit Russian refineries and logistics, adding real economic costs beyond the front lines. Making every kilometer cost more isn't just about the trenches, it's hitting Russia's war economy directly.

You're basically saying what the Europeans are saying. Fight until the last Ukrainian so it makes Russia bleed as much as possible. No doubt, Russia is bleeding. But Ukraine will die as a nation. This reminds me what Biden's defense secretary said a while after the Russian invasion in 2022. He said the purpose of supporting Ukraine was to make sure Russia pays a heavy price and is not able to do this again. Basically, he said the same thing as you, to make Russia bleed. He said nothing about Ukraine winning. So going back to what I said earlier, no doubt Russia will bleed but Ukraine will become a dysfunctional rump state with Russia winning an ugly victory. If you are okay with Ukraine paying that price, which you clearly are, all the power to you. But let me ask you this: are you Ukrainian? Or just a European? If either. Just wondering. I'm not a Russian or even a European. I have no horse in this race. I have actually met more Ukrainians than Russians and found them to be very nice people.



On winning no, not in the sense of retaking every inch. But Russia isn't winning either. Its theory of victory was that slow advances would collapse Ukraine's defenses, and that theory is failing. So the realistic endgame is a frozen line or a negotiated settlement, not a Russian flag over Kyiv.Do you have any battlefield experience? Clearly not. This is a war of attrition. Do you know what matters in a war of attrition? I can go into detail if you like. Fact of the matter is, Ukraine cannot and will not win this war. Russia will win in the end. They will see this to the very end, no matter what the cost. And the result will be an ugly Russian victory, Ukraine losing more men and territory and getting completely destroyed.

And I agree with your last para. This will end not with a peace treaty, but a frozen conflict. Russia will take more territory and at some point, the guns will fall silent. All the cities that are currently being fought over (Sloviansk, Kramatorsks, etc), they will all be destroyed. Ukraine will never take back Crimea or any of the territories that Russia has captured.




On NATO no, not anytime soon. Even Zaluzhnyi, Ukraine's former top commander, said this summer that Ukraine will never join. Zelensky has already offered to drop the bid in exchange for legally binding security guarantees from the US and Europe. That's the actual state of play.

Back to you, if Russia wanted peace, why does Lavrov's list still demand recognition of annexed territory Russia doesn't even fully control? Considering the same why do they insist that Ukraine reduce it's military to levels where it cannot defend itself? That's handing Putin the keys while hoping he doesn't come back for the furniture.Fact: Ukraine will never ever join NATO. This not anytime soon is BS. Mark my words. And Zaluzhnyi is correct here. And you also admit that the drugged out clown as offered to drop the bid. So I ask, WTF was all this for? Why was neutrality so bad? And how did this all start? It didn't start on Feb 2022. It started in 2014 with the western backed coup against the elected government in Ukraine.

If that hadn't happened, Crimea would still be with Ukraine. All of Ukranian territory would be intact. So was neutrality so bad?

As for your questions, you know what the Russian conditions are, they haven't changed since the SMO started. They want a Ukrainian withdrawal from the territories they have annexed. You know the other conditions: denazification, demilitarization, etc.

I'm not justifying the Russian demands. But the fact remains, Putin tried very hard to avoid full scale war. This started in 2014. How many Minsk accords did we have? It's well known now that the Europeans and Russians were playing for time to get better armed for the full scale war that did eventually start in 2022. This is all on record. Angela Merkel admitted it.

This is a war that should have never happened, and it wouldn't have had the collective west not pushed NATO down Ukraine's throat. Ukraine as a neutral state was at peace. And look at it now.

Blood Red
10-06-26, 13:04
Putin wants whole Ukraine, after Crimea, and even more, trying to fuck elections abroad, dreaming of back to ex USSR.That is a lie fed to you by the pathetic fake western media you follow. Putin has never ever said he wants to conquer all of Ukraine. Pay attention, he's having a hell of a time trying to conquer 4 oblasts and it's been almost 5 years now. You really think he can conquer all of Ukraine, especially western Ukraine that is so hostile to Russia? So use your brain please.

Also, I love how the collective west wants it both ways. On one end they say Russia is weak, it's losing, they are fighting with shovels, they are getting beat, their economy is in collapse, that Ukraine is winning, blah blah.

Then they tell us that Putin will conquer all of Ukraine and go after the baltic states and eastern european countries next.

So which is it? This shit is hilarious, you can't make it up.

Sirioja
10-06-26, 13:59
That is a lie fed to you by the pathetic fake western media you follow. Putin has never ever said he wants to conquer all of Ukraine. Pay attention, he's having a hell of a time trying to conquer 4 oblasts and it's been almost 5 years now. You really think he can conquer all of Ukraine, especially western Ukraine that is so hostile to Russia? So use your brain please.

Also, I love how the collective west wants it both ways. On one end they say Russia is weak, it's losing, they are fighting with shovels, they are getting beat, their economy is in collapse, that Ukraine is winning, blah blah.

Then they tell us that Putin will conquer all of Ukraine and go after the baltic states and eastern european countries next..Yes, use your brain if You have. Putin is a liar who didn't respect what he signed for Crimea. When he was a nothing in KGB behind the wall, but he dreams of ex USSR again, this is the real truth, when he fuck elections in Georgia, Moldavia, Romania and attack Leipzig in ex DDR where he worked.

Paulie97
10-06-26, 21:43
Ukraine will die as a nation.This isn't an argument, it's a prediction, and it's the same thesis as the Mendel article you posted. I rebutted that article here. It's post number 4522.


Here's my response to the Iuliia Mendel article I challenged you to respond to this rebuttal point by point but you haven't done so. That's a pattern with you, ignore all rebuttals then resurface later recycling the same predictions and fallacious arguments. I again challenge you to go answer it point by point, while the audience can see your refusal.

The weight of military analysis believes Ukraine is in a good position to survive as a nation, by forcing terms that preserve their sovereignty. The West has far greater economic depth than Russia, and Russia's economy is straining under sanctions and labor shortages. Here's some of the war math that I posted in my rebuttal to Mendel. There's some overlap with some content from my prior post to you, but you ignored it.


Her casualty math has some accuracy but is incomplete. That while she's recycling the same Russian talking point that's been wrong since 2022, that Ukraine's been running out of men, while the front is still holding. Ukraine's pool of conscription-age men is small around four million in the territory it still holds and Russia's is roughly ten times larger. But attrition is not a pure headcount contest. Ukraine has been inflicting disproportionate losses with drones, long-range strikes, and cheaper systems. Russian casualties have run two to three times higher than Ukraine's for most of the war, and in early twenty twenty-six the ratio climbed towards eight to one in some estimates. Russia is also struggling to replace its own losses at the same rate. She's calling for surrender at the exact moment the attrition is working against the side she wants to surrender to. It's worth noting that giving into Russia's current demands is tantamount to national suicide, thus 77% of Ukrainians want to fight on if the alternative is to give into Russia's maximalist position. That's their decision. That's in fact the thesis of my rebuttal to Mendel that you choose to ignore.

On your angle that NATO is forcing itself on Central and Eastern Europe, I've answered you on that more times than I can count. Here's the most recent. Of course you ignored the post, then took a month to reappear again. It's post number 4467.


The "not one inch eastward" assurance was verbal, limited to East Germany during unification talks, and never written into the Two Plus Four Treaty or any binding agreement. Also cut the spin BS. Many former Eastern Block countries freely and gleefully expanded into NATO because they reject your way of life.You've also been rebutted from here to Sunday when you call the 2014 removal of Yanukovych a "coup. " And it's the same, you ran off then came back much later repeating the same rebutted claim over again. It's post number 4459.


Yanukovych fled Kyiv after signing an EU deal for early elections. Parliament, including members of his own party, voted three hundred twenty-eight to zero to remove him the next day because he'd abandoned his post. That's not a coup, it's what happens when a president runs away.Below in the only new material in your post, new to me that is so I'll answer it. Though I believe some others here have addressed it before.


I'm not justifying the Russian demands. But the fact remains, Putin tried very hard to avoid full scale war. This started in 2014. How many Minsk accords did we have? It's well known now that the Europeans and Russians were playing for time to get better armed for the full scale war that did eventually start in 2022. This is all on record. Angela Merkel admitted it.

This is a war that should have never happened, and it wouldn't have had the collective west not pushed NATO down Ukraine's throat. Ukraine as a neutral state was at peace. And look at it now.If Minsk was a delay tactic, both sides used it. Merkel's 2022 Der Spiegel interview said the agreements gave Ukraine time to become stronger — that's not the same as admitting a plot to start a war. And Russia spent those same eight years building up its own forces, militarizing Crimea, and training the Donbas proxies.

On 'Putin tried hard to avoid full-scale war' — in December 2021 he handed Biden draft treaties demanding a written guarantee that Ukraine would never join NATO, plus a rollback of NATO forces in Eastern Europe. That's not avoiding war, that's issuing an ultimatum with a hundred thousand troops already massed on the border. And the demand was structurally impossible — NATO membership requires unanimous consent from all thirty members, and no US president can unilaterally amend the NATO charter. He set a condition he knew couldn't be met, then treated the refusal as provocation.

And NATO wasn't shoved down Ukraine's throat. Ukraine repealed its non-alignment law in 2014,303-8, and by February 2022 polling showed about sixty percent of Ukrainians supported joining. That's a sovereign country's choice, not Western coercion.

Your claim to not have a horse in this race is equally disingenuous while you claim that Alexi Navalny died of natural causes. It's also clear that regardless of your agenda, you aren't interested in debating in good faith.

Sirioja
10-06-26, 22:05
Since almost 5 years, Putin showed to the world and Russians how he failed to defeat so courageous Ukrainians, despite Russian meat for his war, same than Trump failed versus Islamist Iran.

Paulie97
10-07-26, 00:44
That is a lie fed to you by the pathetic fake western media you follow. Putin has never ever said he wants to conquer all of Ukraine. Pay attention, he's having a hell of a time trying to conquer 4 oblasts and it's been almost 5 years now. You really think he can conquer all of Ukraine, especially western Ukraine that is so hostile to Russia? So use your brain please.

Also, I love how the collective west wants it both ways. On one end they say Russia is weak, it's losing, they are fighting with shovels, they are getting beat, their economy is in collapse, that Ukraine is winning, blah blah.

Then they tell us that Putin will conquer all of Ukraine and go after the baltic states and eastern european countries next.

So which is it? This shit is hilarious, you can't make it up.While debate over Putin's long range aspirations remains open, no one serious argues that Russia is currently out to annex all of Ukraine. The claim is he wants to subjugate it, which he's clear about with his "demilitarization" demand. He's already taken nineteen percent. And a wounded Russia is still dangerous. That's why the Baltics worry. Cyber attacks, sabotage, assassinations, GPS jamming, and disinformation. That's the toolkit with no invasion required.

And your paragraph about the shovels and collapsed Russian economy is a straw man caricature, while your "which is it?" is a false dilemma. No one serious argues that Russia is currently capable of conquering it's former allies, nor are they claiming that the Russian economy has collapsed. These are more examples as to why few here waste time with you. You substitute hostility for substance, calling Zelensky a clown while silent about the fact that Putin is a dictator and murderer that kills and imprisons dissent. You usually just ignore the points of your opponents, but when you decide to try and tackle them you twist them first. Objective readers on the thread can clearly see that you are losing big.

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/Strawman-Fallacy

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/False-Dilemma

For any interested in the current state of the decidedly strained Russian economy, here's a paragraph from my Mendel rebuttal, that BR has thus far chosen to completely avoid.



The numbers she leans on in her economy paragraph are already stale. Russia's military spending hit a record forty-four percent of the federal budget in the first half of twenty twenty-six over ten point seven trillion rubles, roughly one hundred twenty-five billion dollars. That's more than half of every ruble the government collects. The deficit has already blown past the full-year target. Regions are slashing signing bonuses and, in places like Yakutia, freezing payments to soldiers outright because the money ran out. This isn't a stronger fiscal position. It's a war economy eating itself. Growth has collapsed to under one percent, inflation is still biting, and the civilian sector is being hollowed out to feed the front. Ukraine's debt is high, but it's mostly concessional aid from allies who have a reason to keep it solvent. Russia's "strength" is extraction oil revenue, forced labor, and a shrinking workforce with no off-ramp. She's comparing a country fighting for survival to one that chose this war and is now paying for it by cannibalizing its own budget.

Questner
10-07-26, 03:06
MP Skorokhod proposed amending the Constitution and abandoning Ukraine's NATO affiliation.

Member of Parliament Anna Skorokhod submitted a bill to the Verkhovna Rada to amend the Constitution to enshrine Ukraine's neutral status.

The document appeared on the parliament's website.

"Consolidating Ukraine's neutral status, which consists of guarantees of non-entry into any military alliance and confirmation of the absence of any desire to commit aggression against any country," the proposed amendment states.

Of the Ukrainian Constitution's policies for joining NATO and the European Union established during Petro Poroshenko's presidency, Skorokhod proposes retaining only the EU aspirations, removing any mention of the North Atlantic Alliance.

It should be noted that Ukraine's neutral status is one of the Russian Federation's demands within the framework of a peaceful settlement.

Blood Red
10-07-26, 08:27
You failed miserably to answer my post and had to resort to selective quoting. I gave you a chance for a serious debate but clearly you are not up for it and weaseled out.

Blood Red
10-07-26, 20:00
While debate over Putin's long range aspirations remains open, no one serious argues that Russia is currently out to annex all of Ukraine. The claim is he wants to subjugate it, which he's clear about with his "demilitarization" demand. He's already taken nineteen percent. And a wounded Russia is still dangerous. That's why the Baltics worry. Cyber attacks, sabotage, assassinations, GPS jamming, and disinformation. That's the toolkit with no invasion required.

And your paragraph about the shovels and collapsed Russian economy is a straw man caricature, while your "which is it?" is a false dilemma. I'm just repeating what the western mainstream media and europeans have said. The whole non sense that Russians are running out of missiles, drones, they are using parts out of washing machines, you name it. So tell me, are the Russians stupid, weak, running out of ammo, getting defeated or are they actually such badasses that they will conquer all of Ukraine and then go after Eastern Europe and the Baltics?


No one serious argues that Russia is currently capable of conquering it's former allies, nor are they claiming that the Russian economy has collapsed. Good, so we are on the same page here. Please tell that to some of the silly folks on here, like this Siroja individual.


These are more examples as to why few here waste time with you. You substitute hostility for substance, calling Zelensky a clown while silent about the fact that Putin is a dictator and murderer that kills and imprisons dissent. When have I ever said Putin isn't a dictator? He is. And Zelensky is a corrupt clown.


You usually just ignore the points of your opponents, but when you decide to try and tackle them you twist them first. Objective readers on the thread can clearly see that you are losing big.


For any interested in the current state of the decidedly strained Russian economy, here's a paragraph from my Mendel rebuttal, that BR has thus far chosen to completely avoid.

It was you that ignored all of my previous posts because you couldn't address anything I posted and resorted to selective quoting.

Blood Red
10-07-26, 20:03
MP Skorokhod proposed amending the Constitution and abandoning Ukraine's NATO affiliation.

Member of Parliament Anna Skorokhod submitted a bill to the Verkhovna Rada to amend the Constitution to enshrine Ukraine's neutral status.

The document appeared on the parliament's website.

"Consolidating Ukraine's neutral status, which consists of guarantees of non-entry into any military alliance and confirmation of the absence of any desire to commit aggression against any country," the proposed amendment states.

Of the Ukrainian Constitution's policies for joining NATO and the European Union established during Petro Poroshenko's presidency, Skorokhod proposes retaining only the EU aspirations, removing any mention of the North Atlantic Alliance.

It should be noted that Ukraine's neutral status is one of the Russian Federation's demands within the framework of a peaceful settlement.The main reason for this tragic war was the USA and the west pushing NATO into Ukraine. Putin warned that this was the brightest of red lines as far back as 2008, if not even before that. Georgia tried the same foolish move and look how that ended for them in 2008. The collective west took Ukraine down the primrose path. They are pure evil. As long as it's Ukrainians dying, they are okay as long as Russia bleeds. Monsters I swear.

Blood Red
10-07-26, 20:05
Since almost 5 years, Putin showed to the world and Russians how he failed to defeat so courageous Ukrainians, despite Russian meat for his war, same than Trump failed versus Islamist Iran.Why did you add in the 'Islamist' before Iran? Racist much?

The Cane
10-07-26, 22:20
Why did you add in the 'Islamist' before Iran? Racist much?It's not a race. Nor is Judaism for that matter. They are religions.

Paulie97
10-07-26, 22:47
I'm just repeating what the western mainstream media and europeans have said. The whole non sense that Russians are running out of missiles, drones, they are using parts out of washing machines, you name it. So tell me, are the Russians stupid, weak, running out of ammo, getting defeated or are they actually such badasses that they will conquer all of Ukraine and then go after Eastern Europe and the Baltics? That's precisely your false dilemma as you leave out a third option. Russia can at present be a grinding, attritional force that holds territory without being either stupid or unstoppable, and that's precisely what the evidence shows.

My rebuttals are a few posts back, two separate posts. Other than to admit Putin is a dictator, you haven't answered a single one.

And I'm still waiting on your point by point reply to my Mendel rebuttal. You after all reposted her article so you should welcome the challenge.


Here's my response to the Iuliia Mendel article recently posted by Questner. It's linked again above.

Sirioja
10-08-26, 00:54
Why did you add in the 'Islamist' before Iran? Racist much?Aren't Islamists? Who lead Iran?

Questner
10-08-26, 02:49
The main reason for this tragic war was the USA and the west pushing NATO into Ukraine. Putin warned that this was the brightest of red lines as far back as 2008, if not even before that. Georgia tried the same foolish move and look how that ended for them in 2008. The collective west took Ukraine down the primrose path. They are pure evil. As long as it's Ukrainians dying, they are okay as long as Russia bleeds. Monsters I swear.And what has been done on the same day of the proposed amendment? NATO sent a full member states delegation to Kiev and the prosecution opened the alleged bribery case against that member of Rada.

In 2021 Ukraine chose Plan be, jacked up salaries to attract people into the AFU, took arms from the Biden administration even when explicitly it was asked not to do so in Summer of 2021. By February 8, 2022 the negotiations collapsed and March 8 was set as intrusion by the AFU into Donetsk. Given no choice Russia acted preemptively with ill devised haste plan and only about 80,000 active troops.

Remember, Ukraine will always choose a loose-loose scenario over win-win one. The national motto is 'You die today, I die tomorrow'.

Paulie97
10-08-26, 03:00
The main reason for this tragic war was the USA and the west pushing NATO into Ukraine. Putin warned that this was the brightest of red lines as far back as 2008, if not even before that. Georgia tried the same foolish move and look how that ended for them in 2008. The collective west took Ukraine down the primrose path. They are pure evil. As long as it's Ukrainians dying, they are okay as long as Russia bleeds. Monsters I swear.Repeating these emotionally charged falsehoods over and over while ignoring all the rebuttals presented to you over your time here will never make them true. NATO enlargement was never forced on Ukraine — it was Ukraine's own sovereign choice to seek membership, repeatedly reaffirmed through its elected governments and written into its constitution, and no country has a veto over another's alliance choices. Framing Putin's invasion as a justified response to a "red line" erases that Russia launched a full-scale invasion of a non-threatening neighbor, which is the actual proximate cause of the deaths — not Western policy. And the claim that the West wants Ukrainians dying to "bleed Russia" ignores that Ukraine itself chose to fight rather than surrender, and the West is the one supplying the aid keeping Ukraine's defense possible at all.

Also, if NATO is the primary threat then why the muted response to Finland joining? But the issue isn't NATO at all, but in Russia's desire for a sphere of influence and particularly resources that belong to Ukraine.

Sirioja
10-08-26, 09:56
NATO, EU and even USA with crazy Trump, never threatened to attack any part of Russia, not even robbed Crimea. This war is only Putin war, not even Russians who are just blind meat.

Paulie97
10-09-26, 16:25
You failed miserably to answer my post and had to resort to selective quoting. Selective quoting is standard practice for focusing on substance, especially when cutting through repetitive claims and personal distractions. I identified and refuted your key points. The audience can verify that themselves by linking back to your post through mine. Here's my post again if you decide to try and tackle it.


This isn't an argument, it's a prediction...

Sirioja
10-11-26, 18:27
Ukraine should focus shooting Russian gas factories for no diesel for shameful Trump. USA stopped versus Iran because they miss bullets.

Paulie97
10-11-26, 22:08
This reminds me what Biden's defense secretary said a while after the Russian invasion in 2022. He said the purpose of supporting Ukraine was to make sure Russia pays a heavy price and is not able to do this again. Basically, he said the same thing as you, to make Russia bleed. He said nothing about Ukraine winning.This one was so ridiculous I skipped it, but let's expose it anyway for grins. BR wants us to believe that the West doesn't care if Ukraine prevails or not, as long as the poor little victim Russia bleeds.

But here's Defense Secretary Austin's quote in full, from that April 25, 2022 press conference in Poland: "We want to see Ukraine remain a sovereign country, a democratic country able to protect its sovereign territory. We want to see Russia weakened to the point where it can't do things like invade Ukraine. " Therefore BR pulls out one half of a quote then runs with a wholly false framing.

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/blinken-austin-return-from-visit-to-ukraine-say-russia-is-failing-in-war-efforts

That while you wrenched my quote about Russian suffering out of context. The aim of Russian suffering is of course to encourage them to back off their maximalist demands and settle for terms that preserve Ukrainian defense capability and sovereignty.

You also have another false dilemma going, as wanting Russia weakened while also wanting Ukraine to win their sovereignty aren't incompatible goals. And even from a cold strategic standpoint a Ukraine that survives is in our national interest.

Sirioja
10-11-26, 23:00
Ukrainians still support Zelensky versus shameful Trump who wants to give money to Putin to kill Ukrainians.

Paulie97
10-12-26, 23:17
I have no horse in this race.Right buddy, how's that for a gem of a selective quote?

Paulie97
10-13-26, 00:41
I'm heading to Europe for a month this week. I don't do online politics and the like during vacation time but will deal with any replies as time permits. Here's a list of Kremlin state media talking points that have been regularly posted here for years. They're actually few, simple, easy to present, but tough to defend. That's why their advocates rarely try.

Below that you'll find links to my recent posts that contain rebuttals to the same and more. The same posts were either responded to with dodges or completely ignored, usually the latter. Those that publish Kremlin talking points rarely want to engage. They publish, dodge or disappear, then come back posting the same already refuted content. The pattern is clear.

Pro-Russian talking points:

1. NATO eastward expansion involved coercion against the nations who joined. Official govt records, parliamentary debates, and formal applications from the countries involved say otherwise.

2. The 2014 Ukrainian popular uprising that ended with the removal of the pro-Russian president who fled in a 328-0 parliamentary vote was a "coup. " Definitions of the word coup be damned on this one.

3. Russia is justified in "red lines" that lead to invading neighbors when the same in their sovereignty seek to join NATO.

4. Putin bent over backwards to avoid war in 2022, even though he knew that his demand for NATO to change it's open door policy effectively banning Ukraine while closing up shop and committing to no further expansion would never get any serious consideration.

5. The West doesn't care about Ukraine, or even if they prevail or not as long as Russia is made to suffer and weaken. Ukrainian agency and will to defend their land is completely ignored, as are Western interests in seeing a sovereign Ukraine.

6. The insistence that Ukrainians are fools for fighting rather than surrendering has been constant since the start. The slogan "fight to the last Ukrainian" is misconstrued as a death wish. It's obviously Ukrainian resolve rhetoric, or "we'll fight as long as it takes. " This kind of lazy and cheap straw man tactic is the norm.

Russian victory is deemed inevitable and certain while the weight of current war analysis gives Ukraine a real chance of survival as a sovereign nation, especially if substantial Western aid levels persist.

7. The Ukrainian government is called Nazi, as are their national heroes stretching back to the 1940's. The Russians and their bedfellows claim to love Ukrainians while calling their national heroes, and by extension the Ukrainians themselves, "Nazis. " Consistency isn't mandatory. Zelensky's Jewishness is always ignored, as are the Russian Nazi groups fighting in Ukraine.

8. Ukrainian govt corruption is emphasized while the much greater levels of the same in Russia are completely ignored.

Besides all of that there's bare predictions, crystal ball stuff like Ukraine will never join NATO that don't warrant a response as they're typically only blusterous assertions without arguments.

Here's the links to many of my posted rebuttals over the last two months or so that were never answered. There were a few attempted answers with dodges but most of the posts were completely ignored. The last one is from yesterday, so in fairness there hasn't been much opportunity to reply to that one.


Yanukovych fled Kyiv after signing an EU deal for early elections.


The "not one inch eastward" assurance was verbal...


Zelensky is serving under martial law as elections are suspended during wartime.


Bandera wasn't a Nazi.


You rarely make any "points" to address. Calling something irrelevant, a coup, or Nazi doesn't make it so.


You say you respect the Ukrainian people but call their government Nazi.


Enjoy your 22 out of 100 rating (Russia) in...


As is typical Questner refuses to engage..


And here's what Questner leaves out.


This whole paragraph is a list of grievances each one with a hole in it.


Here's my response to the Iuliia Mendel article...


Funny how a "dead nation"..


There was no push to join NATO at that time.This one below includes a correction to the above.


Ukraine's first push toward NATO membership was actually under Kuchma...


This isn't an argument, it's a prediction...


That's precisely your false dilemma as you leave out a third option.


Repeating these emotionally charged falsehoods...


Selective quoting is standard practice...


This one was so ridiculous I skipped it, but...

Sirioja
10-13-26, 07:18
With all his Russian meat, but Putin was not able to win, after 4 years and half. Fortunately, Europe help more Ukraine than shameful Trump who prefers to suck and be fucked deeply in the ass by Putin who doesn't want to make peace, just a liar like Trump.

Xpartan
10-13-26, 07:43
6. The insistence that Ukrainians are fools for fighting rather than surrendering has been constant since the start. The slogan "fight to the last Ukrainian" is misconstrued as a death wish. It's obviously Ukrainian resolve rhetoric, or "we'll fight as long as it takes. " This kind of lazy and cheap straw man tactic is the norm.I don't know. The way Russians have been dying lately, it very well may be Puting fighting to the last Russian.


According to estimates reported by Bloomberg and NATO officials, Russia suffered more than 50,000 casualties in September 2026, marking its highest monthly loss rate of the year.

Key Breakdown of September 2026 Casualties

NATO / Bloomberg Estimates: Over 50,000 total Russian casualties (killed or wounded), with up to 28,000 killed.
Ukraine's General Staff Figures: Reported 46,230 Russian personnel losses (killed and wounded) for the month, an increase of nearly 46% compared to January 2026 (31,710).
Single-Day High: UK Defence Intelligence recorded a peak single-day loss of 2,090 Russian casualties on September 29, 2026.
Ukrainian Losses (Comparison): NATO and Ukrainian sources estimated Ukrainian forces suffered around 5,000 casualties during the same period.Clearly Russia is a much larger country, but not 10 x larger. The meat will run out one day.

Sirioja
10-13-26, 09:52
In 4 years and half, with so many deaths and injured, Putin won less than 60 kms in Donbass and not Donetsk, for his war, he is only responsible, dreaming of becoming new Tsar of ex USSR. Competing for megalomania with Trump who wants to moonwalk in White House or Kennedy center, when so dirty image compare to JFK.

Blood Red
10-15-26, 10:59
That's precisely your false dilemma as you leave out a third option. Russia can at present be a grinding, attritional force that holds territory without being either stupid or unstoppable, and that's precisely what the evidence shows.So you agree that all this talk about Russia going on to take the Baltics and Eastern Europe is all propaganda by the EU and the west. That's good, we are on the same page then with respect to that.




My rebuttals are a few posts back, two separate posts. Other than to admit Putin is a dictator, you haven't answered a single one.

And I'm still waiting on your point by point reply to my Mendel rebuttal. You after all reposted her article so you should welcome the challenge.You ignored all my questions and resorted to selective quoting, all can see that.

As for Mendel, I just posted what she said. I don't know if what she said is 100% accurate. But I do agree with her that Ukraine is committing suicide and at the end of this war, Ukraine will die as a nation and will be left a dysfunctional rump state that will never ever join NATO (another thing you also agree with me about).

Blood Red
10-15-26, 11:00
Aren't Islamists? Who lead Iran?It's called the Islamic Republic of Iran. Islamic and Islamist aren't the same thing. Please educate yourself.

Blood Red
10-15-26, 11:15
Repeating these emotionally charged falsehoods over and over while ignoring all the rebuttals presented to you over your time here will never make them true. NATO enlargement was never forced on Ukraine it was Ukraine's own sovereign choice to seek membership, repeatedly reaffirmed through its elected governments and written into its constitution, and no country has a veto over another's alliance choices. What you fail to understand is that great powers have certain doctrines or red lines. What the fuck do you think the United States would do if Mexico joins a Chinese military alliance? Sit and twiddle their thumbs? The USA also has the Monroe Doctrine. Read up on it. Russia was never going to allow Ukraine into NATO or to not be neutral. You may disagree with that and so can Ukraine. But any person who knew anything knew that Ukraine seeking to join NATO would result in it getting wrecked, which is happening now. What's sad is that you yourself admit that Ukraine will never join NATO. Even the drugged out clown is resigned to that fact. So again I ask, was neutrality so bad for Ukraine?



Framing Putin's invasion as a justified response to a "red line" erases that Russia launched a full-scale invasion of a non-threatening neighbor, which is the actual proximate cause of the deaths not Western policy. And the claim that the West wants Ukrainians dying to "bleed Russia" ignores that Ukraine itself chose to fight rather than surrender, and the West is the one supplying the aid keeping Ukraine's defense possible at all.Are you really this dishonest that you cannot admit that the EU wants to use Ukraine to make Russia bleed? If they really want to help Ukraine "win", why don't they put their own boots on the ground? They are happy that it's Ukrainians dying and not their own soldiers, which is disgusting and immoral and pure evil.



Also, if NATO is the primary threat then why the muted response to Finland joining? But the issue isn't NATO at all, but in Russia's desire for a sphere of influence and particularly resources that belong to Ukraine.Are you really this thick? I have said many many times so pay attention again. UKRAINE joining NATO was the brightest of red lines. Not Finland. Hell, even Georgia was. See how their little stint at trying to join NATO turned out in 2008.

Blood Red
10-15-26, 11:16
Selective quoting is standard practice for focusing on substance, especially when cutting through repetitive claims and personal distractions. I identified and refuted your key points. The audience can verify that themselves by linking back to your post through mine. Here's my post again if you decide to try and tackle it.You must resort to selective quoting when you want to weasel out of answering my questions. Everyone can see that.

Blood Red
10-15-26, 11:20
This one was so ridiculous I skipped it, but let's expose it anyway for grins. BR wants us to believe that the West doesn't care if Ukraine prevails or not, as long as the poor little victim Russia bleeds.

But here's Defense Secretary Austin's quote in full, from that April 25, 2022 press conference in Poland: "We want to see Ukraine remain a sovereign country, a democratic country able to protect its sovereign territory. We want to see Russia weakened to the point where it can't do things like invade Ukraine. " Therefore BR pulls out one half of a quote then runs with a wholly false framing.

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/blinken-austin-return-from-visit-to-ukraine-say-russia-is-failing-in-war-efforts

That while you wrenched my quote about Russian suffering out of context. The aim of Russian suffering is of course to encourage them to back off their maximalist demands and settle for terms that preserve Ukrainian defense capability and sovereignty.

You also have another false dilemma going, as wanting Russia weakened while also wanting Ukraine to win their sovereignty aren't incompatible goals. And even from a cold strategic standpoint a Ukraine that survives is in our national interest.The west does want Ukraine to win, but Ukraine cannot and won't win. I think the ones with brains know that. Once again, if the EU really wants Ukraine to win, let them join in and put BOOTS ON THE GROUND. Why don't they do that?

As for the Austin quote, as I said, he made no mention of Ukraine winning and defeating Russia and regaining the territory they lost. Because he knew that won't happen. The goal was and is to make Russia bleed, using poor Ukrainians as a battering ram. If you cannot admit that, then you are clearly dishonest. Ukraine will never regain the territory they have lost, and will lose more territory the longer this goes on.

Blood Red
10-15-26, 15:20
And what has been done on the same day of the proposed amendment? NATO sent a full member states delegation to Kiev and the prosecution opened the alleged bribery case against that member of Rada.

In 2021 Ukraine chose Plan be, jacked up salaries to attract people into the AFU, took arms from the Biden administration even when explicitly it was asked not to do so in Summer of 2021. By February 8, 2022 the negotiations collapsed and March 8 was set as intrusion by the AFU into Donetsk. Given no choice Russia acted preemptively with ill devised haste plan and only about 80,000 active troops.

Remember, Ukraine will always choose a loose-loose scenario over win-win one. The national motto is 'You die today, I die tomorrow'.The Russian plan or objective was to quickly get a peace deal. And that almost happened in Istanbul in March 2022, until the British and Americans hijacked it. If you consider the Russian peace terms back then and what they would offer now, the difference is day and night. But that's okay for the EU. As long as it's Ukrainians dying. Remember what Lindsey Graham said? All these people are monsters.

Paulie97
10-15-26, 20:34
So you agree that all this talk about Russia going on to take the Baltics and Eastern Europe is all propaganda by the EU and the west. That's good, we are on the same page then with respect to that. I see you are still trying to prop up your straw man. I said analysts debate Russia's long term goals, while no serious ones argue that Russia is in a position to expand beyond Ukraine anytime soon. I never said the Baltics talk is all propaganda. You invented that. Western media argues with itself. Russian state media can't.


You ignored all my questions and resorted to selective quoting, all can see that. This says the guy who just got caught red handed lying about a quote from Defense Secretary Austin to erect a straw man argument. And yes I ignored your questions about my personal background, my nationality and where I live. Those were distractions that had nothing to do with the discussion.

Selective quoting is standard practice in online debate. Misuse is the issue, not the method. This below is the post you completely dodged whining about "selective quoting. " There's a load of content rebutting BS you are still repeating as if you've never been refuted. You won't answer the post because you can't. Do you really think you are fooling anyone here?


This isn't an argument, it's a prediction


As for Mendel, I just posted what she said. I don't know if what she said is 100% accurate. But I do agree with her that Ukraine is committing suicide and at the end of this war, Ukraine will die as a nation and will be left a dysfunctional rump state that will never ever join NATO (another thing you also agree with me about).On Mendel it's hilarious that you want to try and disassociate yourself from her now since it's obvious you can't answer my rebuttal. Why post her article if you didn't think it was very valuable? She has the same prediction as you. Where's she better is, as unlike you, she tried to defend it and I rebutted her with facts, analysis, and reasoning. Do you really think that no one notices that you refuse to answer my posts?


Here's my response to the Iuliia Mendel article...Predictions aren't arguments.

You do have some bedfellows in the US, guys who publish on YT like Mearsheimer, Macgregor, and Napolitano. All have been constantly predicting the imminent demise of Ukraine since the start of the war. Ukraine keeps proving you and them wrong. You keep rehashing a failed script.

On NATO I said "No, not anytime soon" which is obvious. Ukraine would never get 32 votes at this time. That's a timing claim, not a prophecy.

Paulie97
10-15-26, 22:11
What you fail to understand is that great powers have certain doctrines or red lines. What the fuck do you think the United States would do if Mexico joins a Chinese military alliance? Sit and twiddle their thumbs? The USA also has the Monroe Doctrine. Read up on it. Russia was never going to allow Ukraine into NATO or to not be neutral. You may disagree with that and so can Ukraine. But any person who knew anything knew that Ukraine seeking to join NATO would result in it getting wrecked, which is happening now. What's sad is that you yourself admit that Ukraine will never join NATO. Even the drugged out clown is resigned to that fact. So again I ask, was neutrality so bad for Ukraine? First, the Mexico analogy actually backfires if you push it — Mexico joining a Chinese alliance would be Mexico's sovereign choice, and if the US used military force to stop it, that would be rightly condemned as imperialism, not justified as doctrine. Citing the Monroe Doctrine as precedent doesn't defend Russia's invasion, it just proves great powers have a history of bullying smaller neighbors, which is what you're trying to excuse.

Second, the "it was going to get wrecked anyway" line is a justification problem. Predicting that defiance would lead to punishment doesn't make the punishment moral — that's just restating that might makes right. Nobody accepts "she knew she'd get hurt if she didn't comply" as a moral defense in other contexts.

Third, Zelensky's made early-war offers to declare neutrality — and Russia kept escalating demands. That suggests NATO was the pretext, not the actual cause.

Fourth, it's a big stretch to say that Russia is even entitled to a sphere of influence with an economy about the size of Texas. Losing wars like the Cold War have consequences. You aren't a great power, and can't even subjugate Ukraine.


Are you really this dishonest that you cannot admit that the EU wants to use Ukraine to make Russia bleed?You are in fact really so dishonest as to continually lie about the content that others post. You'd never do any of that with me sitting in front of you. This is your whole game, which is to create straw man caricatures, attach them to your opponent then knock them down. Eventually the opponent gets tired of the bad faith style, leaves, then you can claim victory, while everyone following along half way closely knows better. Yes the West wants Russia to bleed so they'll change their mind about their maximalist demands. I've stated that many times. And if anyone is being used it's the West. Ukraine wants to fight for their country and we are helping them. Your continual refusal to acknowledge Ukraine's agency won't make it disappear.


If they really want to help Ukraine "win", why don't they put their own boots on the ground? They are happy that it's Ukrainians dying and not their own soldiers, which is disgusting and immoral and pure evil. This is another round of emotionally charged tripe that completely ignores that Ukraine wants to fight. What is "disgusting, immoral, and evil" is the country that invaded Ukraine, deported their children, and has engaged in constant terror tactics and other war crimes against civilians. Putin is wanted in the Hague. Why not talk about that as opposed to constantly calling Zelensky a clown, a guy with balls a keyboard clown like yourself can only dream about. Offering aid to allies at war without committing troops is a most common practice is geopolitics, think Cold War, Iran and it's proxies, US and Israel. It's hilarious that you call anyone "thick. " You shouldn't have slept through all your history classes.


Are you really this thick? I have said many many times so pay attention again. UKRAINE joining NATO was the brightest of red lines. Not Finland.You're still a fish flopping around on the shore. Since there's no complaints about Finland then it's not about NATO proximity or borders with the same but sphere of influence, including theft of Ukrainian land for economic advantages.

Paulie97
10-15-26, 22:25
You must resort to selective quoting when you want to weasel out of answering my questions. Everyone can see that.The receipts are right here.


Below that you'll find links to my recent posts that contain rebuttals to the same and more. .

Paulie97
10-15-26, 22:32
It's called the Islamic Republic of Iran. Islamic and Islamist aren't the same thing. Please educate yourself.Please explain how calling Iran Islamic or Islamist either one is "racist. " Iran's govt is theocratic by design while none of that has anything to do with race.


Why did you add in the 'Islamist' before Iran? Racist much?

Sirioja
10-15-26, 23:07
It's called the Islamic Republic of Iran. Islamic and Islamist aren't the same thing. Please educate yourself.Iran is led by mollahs. Aren't they extremist Islamists? Learn a bit about Iran since many years, after Pahlavi.

Paulie97
10-15-26, 23:09
The west does want Ukraine to win, but Ukraine cannot and won't win. I think the ones with brains know that. Once again, if the EU really wants Ukraine to win, let them join in and put BOOTS ON THE GROUND. Why don't they do that?.Here you go again with the predictions that keep failing. And again, about the whole Cold War was fought through proxies so I guess no one wanted to win then either. Regardless I'm glad we did. Wink.


As for the Austin quote, as I said, he made no mention of Ukraine winning He certainly did. Here's the quote again:

"We want to see Ukraine remain a sovereign country, a democratic country able to protect its sovereign territory. We want to see Russia weakened to the point where it can't do things like invade Ukraine. ".

It's a win for Ukraine if they remain a sovereign and democratic country. And earlier in the same speech he emphatically said what you insist he never said:

"The first step in winning is believing that you can win," Austin said. "We believe that they can win if they have the right equipment, the right support, and we're going to do everything we can. To ensure that gets to them. ".

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/blinken-austin-return-from-visit-to-ukraine-say-russia-is-failing-in-war-efforts

Just be a man, rather than a gutless keyboard weasel and admit that you stepped on your dick, but you can't do that, just isn't in your DNA. This is my final reply. You've had every chance to engage with the actual points. The receipts are still here, while more gaslighting and fallacies was exposed in my posts today.


Below that you'll find links to my recent posts that contain rebuttals to the same and more. .

Paulie97
10-15-26, 23:27
I don't know. The way Russians have been dying lately, it very well may be Puting fighting to the last Russian.

Clearly Russia is a much larger country, but not 10 x larger. The meat will run out one day.Yes, or at least to the last Russia willing to fight.

Paulie97
10-16-26, 00:14
The Russian plan or objective was to quickly get a peace deal. And that almost happened in Istanbul in March 2022, until the British and Americans hijacked it. If you consider the Russian peace terms back then and what they would offer now, the difference is day and night. But that's okay for the EU. As long as it's Ukrainians dying. Remember what Lindsey Graham said? All these people are monsters.You of course leave out the military cap demands = hand Putin the keys and hope he doesn't come back for the furniture.

Sirioja
10-16-26, 03:42
When we are not under Putin propaganda, Putin didn't respect what he signed and robbed Crimea, now wants Donbass and try to fuck elections in Georgia, Moldavia, Romania, attacked Leipzig, try in Poland, Baltics, but all is because of others, for blind. And Putin is a criminal and dictator in Russia. Just facts.

Paulie97
10-16-26, 05:18
The first time BR quoted Defense Secretary Austin he plainly asserted that he said "nothing about Ukraine winning," then went on with his usual rambling predictions.


This reminds me what Biden's defense secretary said a while after the Russian invasion in 2022. He said the purpose of supporting Ukraine was to make sure Russia pays a heavy price and is not able to do this again. Basically, he said the same thing as you, to make Russia bleed. He said nothing about Ukraine winning. So going back to what I said earlier, no doubt Russia will bleed but Ukraine will become a dysfunctional rump state with Russia winning an ugly victory. Then once called out he changed his claim as to what Austin never said to "winning and defeating Russia and regaining the territory they lost. " Caught red handed he then shifted to a much narrower claim. That while any concern for Ukraine at all contradicts his refrain that the West just wants to see Russia bleed. Even the big goalpost shift doesn't save his larger argument.


As for the Austin quote, as I said, he made no mention of Ukraine winning and defeating Russia and regaining the territory they lost. But this twit wants to accuse others of evasion and dishonesty as he's caught lying about what he said the first time. You see the receipts. ROFL.

Here's the actual April 2022 Austin quotes again:

"We want to see Ukraine remain a sovereign country, a democratic country able to protect its sovereign territory. We want to see Russia weakened to the point where it can't do things like invade Ukraine. ".

"The first step in winning is believing that you can win," Austin said. "We believe that they can win if they have the right equipment, the right support, and we're going to do everything we can. To ensure that gets to them. ".

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/b...in-war-efforts

Paulie97
10-16-26, 21:27
The working link is found in this post, post number 4595.


Here's the quote again.