Thread: Rants and WTF are you talking about and Coronavirus!
+
Add Report
Results 12,511 to 12,525 of 12549
-
04-12-20 15:09 #39Senior Member

Posts: 743It is happening anyhow
The lockdown varies in severity from country to country, and the people who move about the most and violate the rules tend to be younger. In Switzerland I would say the lockdown is a bit of a joke. The point about a different rule for over 60's and younger people might be optimal but it won't be enforced for political considerations.
Originally Posted by Polyamorist
[View Original Post]
It is more like an all or nothing approach politically. Since the lockdown will not be 100% effective anywhere, what we do have is staggered herd immunity, so that different infectious people are taken out of the pool gradually. So every two weeks a certain segment of potentially infectious people are no longer infectious and so on. There are off course infected people after one two week cycle, but the spread of this is staggered and herd immunity will take ahold anyhow since this is highly infectious, I am not a doctor, but I think this is far more infectious than the flu.
The argument is between staggered and phased herd immunity and the lack of any lockdown. Why won't it work? We don't know for sure but the vast majority of modelling indicates that the ultimate death toll will be far higher with no lockdown at all.
I don't want to predict any dire scenarios or a massive death toll, but many countries that were initially resisting a severe lockdown given the economic cost have decided that the resulting death toll would be at least politically unacceptable, like the UK and the Netherlands and most infamously a certain President.
I think social isolation during 2 or 3 (2 week cycles) could stagger this and potentially do a lot of good. At least in the initial phases, there is good evidence that the lockdown reduces the death toll, in the long run whether the slower development of herd immunity is worth it is anyone's guess, most of the modelling and the medical opinion suggests that it is though. As you know there are countries that are relatively lax, just a few of them, we will know in a month of two what the result of those policies were.
The point is this, very few politicians want to pay the political costs of the economic damage of this lockdown, but in response to the medical advice they have been given, they have chosen to do so. I really do not think that the few dissenting countries know better, I think they are just unwillinng to pay the political price in the short term or worse, have a robotic mind set (I will not say more about this to avoid a flame war).
I will say however that the pseudo nationalistic arguments I hear are not at all convincing to say the least.
If it is true that this mutates very fast or that you can get it more than once like some observations suggest, then herd immunity will not work at all and this has to be snuffed out. I hope to God that that is not true, I hope that herd immunity will gradually take hold.
What you say might work, and I think there is a chance I already had this and my symptoms were very mild. However I will tell you that given the unpredictable nature of the symptoms, even I who is relatively young and quite physically fit would not risk deliberately getting this. I know people who have tested positive for it and recovered with relatively mild symptoms.
Given the fact that so many self interested politicians are advocating a lockdown, what does this tell you? This is more serious than we thought.
-
04-12-20 14:59 #38Regular Member

Posts: 2344Thanks and No problem.
Originally Posted by DeltaIndigo
[View Original Post]
The models keep changing. I remember when the model called for a death toll of millions in the US alone. Then it dropped to 240,000. Then 100 K. Now 60 K.
They're a couple of hot spots festering right now where the populations are already pretty unhealthy to begin with so there is a chance that we'll see another surge of deaths in the upcoming week. That depends on how quickly NYC death rates drop. So long as Detroit and New Orleans areas do not get out of hand, the worst is behind the US.
-
04-12-20 14:47 #37Senior Member

Posts: 158No one is immune, but not everyone is buying into the medias scaremongering.
Originally Posted by Pessimist
[View Original Post]
The most common symptoms of COVID-19 are fever, tiredness, and dry cough. Some patients may have aches and pains, nasal congestion, runny nose, sore throat or diarrhea. These symptoms are usually mild and begin gradually. Some people become infected but don't develop any symptoms and don't feel unwell. Most people (about 80%) recover from the disease without needing special treatment. Around 1 out of every 6 people who gets COVID-19 becomes seriously ill and develops difficulty breathing. Older people, and those with underlying medical problems like high blood pressure, heart problems or diabetes, are more likely to develop serious illness. People with fever, cough and difficulty breathing should seek medical attention.
https://www.who.int/news-room/q-a-de...-coronaviruses#text=symptoms.
-
04-12-20 14:44 #36Senior Member

Posts: 811Serious suggestion
The current policy everywhere of shutting everything down is not sustainable. We will have to reopen the economy at some point. The question is, how.
Originally Posted by DeltaIndigo
[View Original Post]
Here is one professor who does not believe in social distancing, but in herd immunity.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lGC5sGdz4kg
I would suggest the best strategy is:
1. Strict isolation for over-60's and people who are sick of anything.
2. Everybody else carry on as normal.
So most of the under-60's will get COVID-19, but they will have mild symptoms or no symptoms at all. A few will require hospitalization, but not enough to overwhelm the hospitals.
After a couple of months, herd immunity develops, the virus fizzles out, and the elderly can be readmitted into society.
Why wouldn't that work?
-
04-12-20 14:40 #35Senior Member

Posts: 27218Information and I think quite reliable, give more than 8000 deaths for only NY, and about 2000 deaths per day since more than one week in whole US, with more deaths among poor black and Latina people than rich white, even many obesity and diabetic. Doctors and same in France are about how many infected, but we can't really know because most numerous have no symptom, but a French investigation tell 1 infected may give to 3 people who may give to 9 , spreading. From my job, and how I was often asked: You can break, You can clean, you can do as you need, but get result we order you. So I judge how many deaths compare to population. I'm very happy for the so many infected who have no problem, even I know they are dangerous to spread. Of course, no game to compare Italy or Spain with Sweden. I just often take US example because I find interesting how the most powerful country which thought to be above virus, fell on so big trouble. I doubt Trump is able, but I think black Obama ideas about healthcare for all, were a real improvement for the most powerful country. France is not better than US versus virus, but healthcare is for all and even foreigners, and when I'm often mad about my tax when we have highest tax, but I will never complain to pay tax for healthcare for others, or for school. Of course I m a dreamer, but shouldn't everybody have access to healthcare, be able to read and understand world where we live? I would call this fair world.
Originally Posted by DeltaIndigo
[View Original Post]
-
04-12-20 14:12 #34Senior Member

Posts: 6887So you missed out on this article?
Originally Posted by Pessimist
[View Original Post]
https://www.ecodibergamo.it/stories/...of_1347414_11/
That is for Italy, a country which has been fairly good at testing people. With 15.935 tests per 1 M. In Comparison, Germany has 15.730 tests per 1 M. So Italian numbers are more accurate than German numbers. And in Italy, it seems they are only managing to pick up on about 44% of deaths from the virus.
New York for comparison tests 22.478 per 1 M, so figures there are probably a bit more precise. But Spain, UK and France has been very sloppy, so you can probably multiply it by 3-4 in those countries. Meaning for example France now has probably over 50 000 deaths. Hi Sirioja, remembers what we discussed a few days ago?
But of course, make your own number calculations. I will stick to mine. For India for example, with just 137 tests per 1 M, I suspect the real figures can probably be multiplied by 100-150. And Brazil is underepoting by 50+ times. And Africa pretty much doesn't have any testing capacity worth recognizing at all. But US figures shows Africans are 6 times more at risk than whites. Questions is just is that is due to the reasons the officials claim. I personally think the genetic factors play a larger role in all of this, so Africa will be hit harder than anywhere else. They will also face the same 'Hunger Games' scenario India is experiencing. Further increasing the death numbers from other non-corona related deaths. So there are no epicenters any longer its pretty global.
-
04-12-20 14:05 #33Senior Member

Posts: 27218Can you believe virus was not in FKK land, quite impossible it was not, even when was taken temperature at Sharks entry, but most infected don t have any symptom. Isn't also virus spreading in Japan islands towns? And I'm pretty sure virus will be in FKK land when will reopen, with so many guys and girls from all over the world. Anyway, interesting to have Japanese opinion about other Asian countries, but don t You mean North Korea for red, or really South? Russia is not so red anymore, but for sure not land of truth nor real freedom, not yet, not under Putin. Ana would shout about me if she heard me saying this about Putin who gave pride again to Russians from Moscow or Peter or Sotchi, when Russia was falling after the wall. Romania fell, ex DDR was lucky to become Germany.
Originally Posted by MrHo
[View Original Post]
-
04-12-20 13:55 #32Senior Member

Posts: 6887I am kinda going against the flood here and suspect Sweden did the right move in not closing down as much. The only thing they should have done better was to test far more than they have. You cannot test enough in order to get real data.
Because the only way I see it now, is that we have to burn this thing out. Although not destroying the health system, we need to keep it at max capacity in order to burn it out as quickly as possible. Otherwise, the virus will just mutate thousands of times before we reach herd imunity. And the more it mutates, the harder it will get to reach herd imunity. And also, the less effective vaccines will become. Actually, vaccines will be 99.99% useless from day one is my prediction due to the mutation rates some scientists are seing.
So basically, people will just have to die. A lot of people. It is the only way for society to get back to where we were. Otherwise, we'll just be herds in a cage for the rest of our lives. And hell, even Netflix, HBO and others are putting TV shows on hold, and gyms are closed. So this is getting boring fast.
-
04-12-20 13:52 #31Senior Member

Posts: 2073The 2-3 percent difference in coverage you speak of is maybe less problematic under normal circumstances. But when there is a respiratory illness that is highly contagious, these untreated and undiagnosed are going to pose a danger to everybody around them. Illegal brown immigrants are not going to seek treatment for fear of being deported. Also if someone does not receive pay while they are sick (like are beloved WGs), they are more likely to go to work even if they have symptoms. All these factors could accelerate the spread.
Originally Posted by Mursenary
[View Original Post]
Yes perhaps poor diet and fitness is 80 percent of the problem, but the liberals and academics believe that de-facto segregation plays a role in economic outcomes which in turn affects both lifestyle and health outcomes. According to Harvard School of Public Health journal back in 2016:
Originally Posted by Mursenary
[View Original Post]
Being poor, being Black, living in a dangerous community, and seeing negative outcomes for yourself, your friends, and your family affects stress levels:where we live determines opportunities to access high-quality education, employment, housing, fresh foods or outdoor space all contributors to our health.
"Health builds from where we live, learn, work and play and only secondarily in the doctors office.
https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/health-disparities-between-blacks-and-whites-run-deep/.
Black and brown communities are situated in areas with high air and toxic pollution. Black children are 500 times more likely to die from asthma:In fact, merely being black in America triggers exposure to stressors linked to premature biological aging. Research indicates that blacks get sick at younger ages, have more severe illnesses and are aging, biologically, more rapidly than whites. Scientists call this the "weathering effect," or the result of cumulative stress.
https://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/policy-dose/articles/2016-04-14/theres-a-huge-health-equity-gap-between-whites-and-minorities.
These negative health effects just get worse as you get older. Throughout your life, you're accumulating air pollution exposures, says Rachel Nethery, a biostatistician at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health who co-authored the new pre-print. Air pollution exposure in young adults has been linked to abnormal changes in the blood, which can lead to heart disease and high blood pressure later in life, both risk factors for severe and fatal Covid-19 cases. In adults, this has been closely associated with cardiovascular disease and diabetes.
https://www.vox.com/2020/4/11/21217040/coronavirus-in-us-air-pollution-asthma-black-americans
-
04-12-20 13:48 #30Senior Member

Posts: 743Interesting
These projections are in line with what I would expect observing the statistical data thus far. However some of these figures, Bulgaria, Romania and even Poland are highly suspect, the quality of data varies from country to country and the political environment can influence the quality of data in certain countries far more than others, ie the figures in Romania and Bulgaria would be even more suspect due to this.
Originally Posted by Pessimist
[View Original Post]
In Poland, as of now they are still proceeding with presidential elections despite the health implications since the ruling party thinks it can win easily. Some modelling has shown that holding these presidential elections even with many precautions will lead to a further 100,000 infections. I think if these elections go ahead, then the numbers for Poland could spiral. Also many of the most enthusiastic supporters of the ruling party are old people who will come out to vote and younger supporters of the opposition will stay home. That means a disproportionate share of the voting public on election day are vulnerable, what will that do to the death toll?
The one place where this could explode all over the place due to the late lockdown is Metropolitan Tokyo, I really hope not, since I have a vulnerable cousin living there, however this could eclipse the outbreak in NYC.
-
04-12-20 13:42 #29Senior Member

Posts: 743Interesting
You certainly know more about the medical and scientific aspects of this than I do and I think almost anyone else here. So you think it has peaked in the US, I thought that most models had shown otherwise, it might very well have peaked in NYC, but I had thought in the US certainly not, but at most the US is only a few weeks behind Europe anyhow.
Originally Posted by Mursenary
[View Original Post]
All I was doing was interpreting the statistical data and trying to explain it. Most of this is not well understand by quite a few people and their own prejudices factor into their assertions.
What you explained about the implications of treating this illness were illuminating to me, no one, including the news has explained it as well as you have. Thank you for that.
-
04-12-20 12:44 #28Regular Member

Posts: 1381You are delusional if you don't understand that I know much more than you do about the situation in Sweden because, unlike you, I live in Sweden and follow the national news closely. You are just a monger.
Originally Posted by AZNMonger
[View Original Post]
-
04-12-20 12:33 #27Senior Member

Posts: 27218I don't know where you get these figures, but France was already nearly 14.000 deaths yesterday which was first not too many deaths day in this so black week, and when only really sick, but all very sick were treated in our hospitals with highest level equipment, but many couldn't be saved, even under intensive care, and I'm afraid Pistons was right, when I know France medical level, I never thought we would have 20.000 deaths, we lost this war, too many deaths, even much less than 1 % risk if you are less than 70 yo, not fat nor diabetic and no lungs nor heart problems, nor cancer. Confined which will be extended over 15 April, is told to save less than 3000 life since 17 March. Italy extend to 3 May. Spain which is down under think to close borders versus Summer tourism, ready to kill their economy. When UK and US don t really respect confined, when french police give penalties, would be really interesting to see real results for NL and Sweden with no confined, even of course can t compare with Italy and Spain where people live with old parents and killed them loving them. Anyway, french thank their doctors, I don t think many of those who were not saved, could have been, when we even used chloroquine, with few deaths from heart problems. Big shame for some who tried to make money, stealing masks, ventilators, those who write or tell to nurses or firemen or hospitals cleaner to stay away, to leave flat or building, because they are at risk about virus. Wish these shameful will be prosecuted and wish they won t need staff they insult because they don t deserve these insulted staff take risks for them. Some medical or safety staff died in this sad war.
Originally Posted by Pessimist
[View Original Post]
-
04-12-20 12:09 #26Senior Member

Posts: 8450Mongers on Mongers
I agree that one does not necessarily know more than somebody else simply by virtue of their nationality. But, I wish that mongers would stop putting other mongers down precisely because they are mongers (seeing a lot of this lately in several threads). Conversely, somebody doesn't necessarily know less than somebody else simply by virtue of the fact of being a monger. There are many well-traveled, well-educated, intelligent people here from literally all walks of life. I would even bet a few politicians! So, when we have a disagreement with one of our mongering brothers, let us not criticize them for being a monger, and then use that as a basis to discount the legitimacy and validity of what they say. After all. Remember. If you're here, then you are a monger too! So if you show disdain towards somebody else for being a monger, then you show disdain for yourself.
Originally Posted by AZNMonger
[View Original Post]
-
04-12-20 10:46 #25Regular Member

Posts: 1381In Italy 25000 died because of the influenza during the 2015/2016 winter season, no lockdowns then. The focus on deaths made us destroy the economy and we might walk into a new Great Depression. Maybe it would have been better to let nature take it's course as we always have done before in history.
Originally Posted by Pessimist
[View Original Post]

.png)







Reply With Quote


