Thread: American Politics
+
Add Report
Results 11,806 to 11,820 of 22490
-
10-19-22 23:03 #10685Senior Member

Posts: 1945That is a shockingly poor take. Firstly, the stat is clearly based around the USA as its benchmark bcos everything is in USD. So other countiries's median income is exposed to whatever rate of excha is prevailing at the time. Plus it does not account properly for cost of living. For example, in the USA, bcos the government just pays out its tax receipts in helping the rich and buulding bombs, the USA people need to pay for their own health care, pay for continued education, pay for pizzas at USD 15+ a pop.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Furthermore it says nothing about WHERE the USA has come from. After World War 2 the USA owned half of the world's wealth. Now it is being overtaken by China. The USA middle class were much better off at all times during the past 70+ years than they are now.
You also say "If you exclude small countries and petrostates", and then you go on to use "Switzerland, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Ireland" as examples to support your point. You can't have it both ways.
"Smaller government produces better results. ".
Not at all. All it does is lead to stats like this. Sure the US citizens need higher incomes. BCOS THEY HAVE TO PAY FOR EVERYTHING (health / education etc) and at hihg prices due to neo -liberalism and lack of state support.
-
10-19-22 20:07 #10684Senior Member

Posts: 2560The only way you'd come up with the USA being as unequal as Colombia or Brazil is by ignoring taxes and transfer payments, a common trick of Progressives. See my wikipedia link in the post you're responding too. Median, by definition the middle of the middle class, per capita income in the USA after transfers and taxes is higher than just about any place. If you exclude small countries and petrostates, the only countries with per capita GDP comparable to the USA, are also countries like the USA where government expenditures as a % of GDP are low: Switzerland, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Ireland. Smaller government produces better results. It's preferable IMO to leave more money in the hands of the people and businesses, instead of devoting larger and larger resources to our wasteful and inefficient federal government. The private sector is the engine of economic growth, not government.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
As to public utilities and public transport and the rest, I believe New York City and California and all other progressive cities and states should be free to spend as much of THEIR money as they want on public services and public welfare. Have at it. As to shocking public services my ass. Maybe where you live. Where I live things work better than in Europe. We have efficient city, state and county government, and I don't begrudge paying taxes to support them one bit. The politicians in Washington D.C. though who want to enforce their priorities on us should go f*ck themselves.
The USA doesn't subsidize the rich per se. It's the opposite. See the reply to Xpartan below, where I partly address your points about inequality. The federal government does give away lots of corporate welfare, to farmers, agribusiness, green companies and the like. And that should stop. I agree with you about the poor and shit wages, and believe it makes sense for many cities and states to raise minimum wages. There should be additional support for poor single mothers and children. And better education.
You're right that real median wages and household income haven't increased enough since the late 1970's. But will point out that they really started to take off in 2019 before COVID hit. I'd attribute part of that to the CORPORATE tax cut and deregulation. You'd undoubtedly poo poo that. The stagnation of wages is a result mostly of improvements in technology and globalization though. There's not a lot you can do about that, unless you want to go back to horses and buggies, or paying lots more for goods. Which I guess does fit with the Progressive goal of making everyone more equal without giving a f*ck whether everyone becomes poorer in the process. Progressive Democrats should focus on improving the lot of the poor instead of dragging down the rich.
-
10-19-22 19:36 #10683Senior Member

Posts: 4846[Deleted by Admin]
EDITOR'S NOTE: This report was redacted or deleted to remove sections of the report that were largely argumentative. Please read the Forum FAQ and the Forum's Posting Guidelines for more information. Thank You!
-
10-19-22 18:14 #10682Senior Member

Posts: 4043Joe the Scrooge that stole Christmas and all the other 364 days of the year
-
10-19-22 18:03 #10681Senior Member

Posts: 2560Unfair Taxation
Xpartan, I'm going to try to address a couple of JustTK's points about inequality here too, so this is going to get a little off topic from your post. Also, I agree with you, the middle class isn't lavished by the government. Rather, in the U.S.A., it pays in less compared to what it gets out of the system compared to the rich, at the federal level in particular. And poor here don't receive the level of help they get in many European countries. To lavish the middle class with government benefits, you'd have to raise taxes a lot on the middle class, as explained by Peter Whiteford below.
Originally Posted by Xpartan
[View Original Post]
We already have the most progressive tax system in the OECD. Again, see.
http://gregmankiw.********.com/2011/03/what-nation-has-most-progressive-tax.html
(Replace *'s by be l o g s p o t. See o m if you want to read.).
Look at the table. While it's from the mid 2000's, if anything our tax system has become more progressive, with the expiration of the Bush tax cuts. And, more importantly, read Peter Whiteford's comments. Whiteford is the OECD economist who did the seminal work on tax progressivity. Here's the relevant part, in bold text.
As others have pointed out this measure includes all direct taxes on individuals so it includes income taxes and employee social security contributions, but not employer payroll taxes. It also doesnt include sales taxes, but these are much heavier in most other OECD countries, and not as progressive as direct taxes, so if you added indirect taxes in through some sort of modelling it is almost certain that the USA would still have the most progressive overall tax system.
However, as the OECD report points out, progressivity is not the same as redistribution. Progressivity measures how the distribution of the tax burden is shared, while redistribution measures how much the tax system reduces inequality. Redistribution is influenced both by the progressivity of taxes and the level of taxes collected.
In fact, the US system of direct taxes actually reduces inequality more than any other country as well. But overall, the USA reduces inequality a lot less than most other countries, because the other thing that you need to take into account is what taxes get spent on.
Now the US system of social security and cash benefits reduces inequality by less than any other OECD country except Korea. The US social security system is marginally less progressive then the OECD average, but the level of spending is very low only Mexico and Korea spend less in the OECD.
So while the US tax system is progressive and reduces inequality, the US welfare state is much less effective at reducing inequality. And because the US has a very unequal distribution of income from capital and a much wider wage distribution than many other OECD countries, it ends up as a relatively unequal country after taxes and benefits.
If you look at Nordic countries, they all have much less progressive tax systems than the USA, but they collect a lot more in taxes (including in VAT). They then spend this much higher tax revenue on social security and services, and it is this side of the equation that is most important in reducing inequality.
So the implication is not that the USA either needs to increase or reduce the progressivity of the tax system. If you want to reduce inequality, you need to increase the level of taxes collected and spend it more effectively.
When you look at graphs of tax rate versus income for countries, you'll see the USA System is quite progressive. European welfare states actually have regressive tax systems, because of their large, regressive VAT taxes:
https://graphics8.nytimes.com/images...ec-blog480.jpg
I will note that in a book I'm reading by Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman, advisors to Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren, there's a graph that shows the poor and the rich paying much higher tax rates than the middle class, which is partly why I said the middle class gets a better deal than the poor too. I'll also note that even Saez and Zucman, who go out of their way to present data in a way favorable to the Progressive manifesto, show higher income Americans progressively paying higher and higher tax rates at higher income levels, until you get to the top 0. 01%. They attribute that, the lower rates for the top. 01% versus, say, the top 10%, to be the billionaires ravaging America. I'd attribute it to people making a lot of money when they, for example, sell a business that they've owned for a lifetime.
-
10-19-22 15:46 #10680Senior Member

Posts: 1945I don't agree with anything you wrote. In fact I would go as far to say it's absolute BS. Real wages have not increased in the USA since the 1970's. Yet productivity has increased massively. So where has this extra money gone? To the oligarchs and super-wealthy. The middle classes, just like in all neo-lib countries, are being squeezed out / strangled.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/19/here...n-america.html
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tan...d-for-decades/
All the real assets of the country are being bought out by the wealthy and charged on to the lower and middle classes. USA is one of the most unequal societies in the world – it has the same profile as a developing country like Brazil, or Colombia.
https://inequality.stanford.edu/publ...ne-should-know
The politicians do not really care about the middle classes; they do not need to bcos neither of the corrupt options does. They just through them a bone and see who wins – the middle class can decide which bone they prefer. But the real winners are always the wealthy bcos the political system in the USA is totally corrupt – bought out by the wealthy.
The USA also has shocking public services – again, equal to a typical developing country. And that includes lack of support for the poor. Lack of public health, public transport, public utilities, continued education – all bankrupting the young, squeezing families, stopping young people from having children, causing health crises – and all to the benefit of the wealthy.
Yes, shlt-paid jobs, like pathetic labour jobs in McDonalds or Amazon warehouses, where you slave for cents so that the wealthy can get richer. That's why there is a record number of people searching for decent jobs – there aren't any. The industrial sector and its jobs has been moved offshore. Why? You guessed it, so the wealthy can get richer.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
10-19-22 07:35 #10679Senior Member

Posts: 2743What other developed countries? Please enlighten us. Of course, we'd need to define what the middle class really is. Can be anything from hand-to-mouth homeowners to the independently wealthy. The term has become as ambiguous as so-called "small business."
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
I personally don't feel that the middle class in America is "lavished" by the government. If anything, all governments are using the middle class as a milk cow. For one thing the middle class can't afford power lobbyists. It also doesn't have time for activism. A sitting duck for unfair taxation.
-
10-19-22 05:50 #10678Senior Member

Posts: 8041Speaking of Social Security and Medicare
For those who don't think forcing workers to save 37% of every paycheck until age 55, as is apparently done in Singapore, would be a fine plan to replace Social Security and Medicare (yeah, let's wait for the vote count on that one), here comes more help from MSM for Repubs poised to gut Social Security and Medicare to win the midterm elections.
Including Morning Joe on MSNBC:
Republicans promise to sunset Social Security and Medicare and the mainstream media doesn't report that!
https://crooksandliars.com/2022/10/m...l-security-and
Here is Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman's recommendation for how to deal with the Repub's inevitable attempt to blackmail Dems into helping them gut those programs and once again plunge the World into another Great Repub Crash by refusing to pay deadbeat Repubs' bills:Corporate media outlets are mostly ignoring a Republican ploy to use the debt ceiling fight to gut Social Security and Medicare if the GOP regains control of Congressa plot that one leading watchdog on Friday called "perhaps the single most consequential story" of the midterm elections.
Preparing for Republican Debt Blackmail
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/17/o...al-budget.html
Why would refusing to raise the debt limit blow up the economy? In the modern world, U.S. debt plays a crucial role: It is the ultimate safe asset, easily converted into cash, and there are no good alternatives. If investors lose confidence that the U.S. government will honor its obligations, the resulting financial storm will make the recent chaos in Britain look like a passing shower.
So what should be done to avert this threat? If Republicans do gain control of one or both houses in November, Democrats should use the lame-duck session to enact a very large rise in the debt limit, enough to put the issue on ice for years. Republicans and pundits who dont understand the stakes would furiously attack this move, but it would be far better than enabling extortion - and would probably be forgotten by the time of the 2024 election.
If for some reason Democrats dont take this obvious step, the Biden administration should be prepared to turn to legal strategies for bypassing the debt limit. There appear to be several loopholes the administration could exploit minting trillion-dollar platinum coins is the most famous, but there are others, like issuing bonds with no maturity date and hence no face value.
-
10-19-22 05:47 #10677Senior Member

Posts: 2560Apologies, it must have been Spidy or PVMonger. I agree with you about Trump conning money out of gullible political contributors.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
So, darn it, we have nothing to argue about here.
-
10-19-22 05:06 #10676Senior Member

Posts: 8041When did I make that argument? Was it a detail mentioned or buried somewhere in a link I provided?
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
I have said it is likely Trump's conning hillbilly suckers out of large portions their entitlement income checks in order to stay financially afloat is the most "honest" money he has ever made. Is that what you're talking about?
-
10-19-22 04:17 #10675Senior Member

Posts: 2560BTW Tooms, there's an article in this week's Economist that makes mince meat of your argument that Republicans receive more campaign donations.
https://www.economist.com/graphic-de...ate-candidates
Democratic Senate candidates in closely contested elections are receiving LOTS more than the Republicans this year. Some of it is probably people not wanting to support 2020 election deniers. But I'm sure part of it is from green energy companies and the like looking for payback come 2023.
-
10-19-22 04:05 #10674Senior Member

Posts: 2560Thanks for your homilies.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
I don't know what a neoliberal is. I'm the opposite of a neoconservative so I guess that makes me a neoliberal.
I don't know where you live. But in the USA, the federal government, compared to governments of other developed countries, screws the rich and the poor and showers the middle class with more than its fair share. Why do the politicians favor the middle class? Well, to paraphrase Willie Sutton, that's where the votes are.
The MEDIAN American household, after taxes and transfers, is better than just about any in the world:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispos..._capita_income
I agree more needs to be done for the poor in the USA. But that would cut into the middle class' take, so I'm not sure that will happen.
As to your other point, there are lots of well paid jobs in the USA. There are in fact a lot more jobs than there are people looking for jobs:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LMJVTTUVUSM647S
And https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS13100000.
-
10-19-22 03:56 #10673Senior Member

Posts: 2560You conveniently omit the rest of my post, including this:
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
If the USA had a system like Singapore's, employees and employers would have to put aside 37% of wages, at least until the age of 55. That along with a safety net and major medical insurance provided by government pays for retirement, medical expenses, and if the beneficiary chooses, college and a downpayment on a home. Instead of a share of a semi-Ponzi scheme like social security or Medicare, people have personal accounts.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Undoubtedly you'd argue that Americans living paycheck to paycheck can't afford the payroll deductions for a proper retirement and medical care in their old age. That's bull shit, as I shall show in a minute when I lambast JustTK. Or agree with him, I'm not sure which. It's kind of hard to understand what he's getting at.
-
10-19-22 01:41 #10672Senior Member

Posts: 1945What neo libs always over look is this:
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
1. There are only a small number of well paid jobs. That means there are always guaranteed to be a majority of losers in a neo lib state. Whatdo you plan to do with them? Yeah, I see. Let them build tented homes under bridges.
2. Neo lib economics also creates a class of people dependent on the state. But in the case of neo liberalism, its bail outs for the rich, and austerity for the poor.
Sounds a really great solution, this right wing BS.
-
10-18-22 22:29 #10671Senior Member

Posts: 8041You really don't know why?
Do you honestly think it is cheaper and better for a national economy to have mom, dad, grandma, grandpa, spinster auntie and drunk uncle who didn't save enough on the side untouched for decades to fund an apartment and cover all medical costs in their old age to move in with the 30-40 something family members and leave it to them to provide 100% expenses for those things than the national insurance programs we have now?
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
And how will they manage to do that and afford to have kids of their own to keep that all-important Labor Force Participation Rate going into the next generation?
Or is the idea that they just quietly put them to death when they are no longer employable? You think the homeless population on the street is bad now. Wait until you get your plan to convert the USA into a Third World slum gets going.

.png)







Reply With Quote


