Thread: American Politics
+
Add Report
Results 11,446 to 11,460 of 22487
-
11-22-22 02:10 #11042Senior Member

Posts: 2560The Republican constituency is mostly covered by medical insurance and Medicare, and is rightfully concerned that government will take a bad system and make it even worse. The Democrats' approach last time around to expand coverage with the Affordable Care Act was doubling down on a failed system, that costs way too much and delivers comparatively poor results. I do give them credit however for finally making Medicare negotiate drug prices.
Originally Posted by Xpartan
[View Original Post]
Only about 10% of Americans are uninsured. So yes, while we should have universal care, it's even more important to bring down the cost and improve outcomes. Maybe the federal government should allow states to opt out of Medicare, Medicaid, etc. , and instead receive cash payments from the Federal government. Then those that chose to do so could come up with their own systems. One might opt for "nationalizing" the system while another might try to incentivize competition while providing a safety net. Presumably whatever works would be adopted by other states. Just an idea, probably a bad one, but just about anything would work better than what we have now.
-
11-21-22 23:51 #11041Senior Member

Posts: 2560JustTK, what your analysis misses is that a large share of health care costs in the USA is paid by private employers to private insurance companies, and the value of those payments is not included in adjusted disposable income. When you take that into account, how you equalize shouldn't make a significant difference. Employer payments in the USA make up for higher health care costs.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
Apologies in advance if I'm repeating what you already know. In the USA, most employees are covered by employer sponsored health insurance. And most (but not all) of their health care costs are effectively paid by their employers. The federal government pays for Medicare for people over 65 and some of the disabled, Medicaid for the indigent, and Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) subsidies apply to others.
Also, please note from your link, "Information is also presented for gross household disposable income including social transfers in kind, such as health or education provided for free or at reduced prices by governments and not-for-profit organisations. This indicator is in US dollars per capita at current prices and PPPs. In the System of National Accounts, household disposable income including social transfers in kind is referred to as 'adjusted household disposable income. ".
Private employers are not governments or not-for-profit organizations, so presumably their contributions to health care are not included in adjusted disposable income.
Per capita health consumption expenditures in the USA are about $12,000 per year, compared to $6,700 per year in Germany:
https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/...e-countries-2/
I'm kind of pulling numbers out of the air, but of the $12,000 per year, perhaps $5,000 is paid by employers, $5,000 by the USA Government, and $2,000 by individuals. So, for this example, maybe you could say USA Adjusted disposable or median income should be reduced by $2,000 per person. BUT, I imagine that there are health care costs in Germany that are paid by individuals directly too, so you'd need to reduce German per capita income too.
What's amazing to me is that the USA has a ridiculously inefficient and costly health care system, spends lots of money on defense, and is a very large country. Still it's the most prosperous country in the OECD, in terms of disposable income per capita adjusted for purchasing power. If you kick out Luxembourg (population 640,000), which is small, and Norway, which is a petrostate, the difference is very large. I believe the most important reason for our prosperity is small government as a % of GDP. Sounding like a broken record, more money stays in the hands of the people. And in the private sector, which is the engine of economic growth and jobs.
Have you spent a significant amount of time in both the USA and Europe? If you do that, I suspect your beliefs would change, from observing people's comparative standard of living.
Did you come up with this idea on your own? If so, Kudos, the renowned left wing economists Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman came up with a similar argument. I believe they largely abandoned it when confronted with my argument above, which is not original -- I read it some place. Now instead Saez and Zucman are arguing that employer payments for health care in the USA actually constitute a regressive tax! Incredible! The hoops they have to jump through.
-
11-21-22 22:31 #11040Senior Member

Posts: 2742I think TK has got something there. Our healthcare system that favors only the very poor and the very rich is an atrocious embarrassment. No other industrial nation in the world denies its citizens universal care. It's just mind-blowing how successfully Republicans have trained their constituency to vote against their own basic interests.
Originally Posted by PVMonger
[View Original Post]
Of course, his reasoning is uber simplified, because that German healthcare for example isn't made possible due to the lower average income, but higher average taxes. Still, there is no denial that our healthcare system is both the worst and most expensive in the civilized world.
-
11-21-22 20:27 #11039Senior Member

Posts: 1945I don't know if I should continue to communicate with you. I increasingly think you belong in the ignore category as Spartenbrain and Spiderbrain.
Originally Posted by PVMonger
[View Original Post]
One more try. I DID NOT COMPLAIN. I merely stated that USA is used as the benchmark and that it influences the outcome.
My example is bogus, is it? For one it is a hypothetical as I stated in my prev post, I didn't claim any facts. Secondly you do not understand the implications behind the costs. The costs of healthcare in the USA IS NOT the same as the cost in Germany. It costs far more in the USA for the same healthcare.
-
11-21-22 15:44 #11038Senior Member

Posts: 1604What point?
You are complaining that using the USA as a benchmark influences the statistics. Your opinion.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
Your example, BTW, of Germany and the USA is bogus. Why? Because if the "value" of the healthcare in the US is $20 K, the same "value" for German healthcare is also $20 K. You are entitled to your own opinion but not your own facts.
-
11-21-22 15:19 #11037Senior Member

Posts: 406Sick Around the World
Sick Around the World is a Frontline / PBS documentary that investigates healthcare throughout the world of a few technically and industrially advanced countries. It is interesting and informative and the USA is definitely not the benchmark in Health Care. I watched it in a college class about ten years ago.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
P.S: I'm not a youngster. I went back at age 54 and graduated at age of 60 from a Big Ten University while still working full time. Anyone really interested in healthcare will learn a lot and many will be surprised and disappointed in how the USA compares to the others.
-
11-21-22 13:18 #11036Senior Member

Posts: 1945Let me give you a hypothetical example to illustrate why the benchmark selection is important.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Lets say in USA avge income is USD 50.000, but that avge health costs is USD 20.000.
And in Germany avge income is USD 35.000, but that avge health costs provided by the state is USD 10.000.
So equalising to USA. USA is 50.000, Germany is 45.000 - so USA is nr 1.
But by equalising to Germany. USA is 30.000, Germany is 35.000 - so Germany is nr 1.
This is bcos by using USA as benchmark, its high health costs are ignored, whereas by using Germany as benchmark, the USA high health costs are accounted for.
-
11-21-22 03:38 #11035Senior Member

Posts: 2742Right, Pilger. Pro-Trump, pro-Russia, anti-America, anti-Israel.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
Sigh.
-
11-21-22 02:16 #11034Senior Member

Posts: 1945Read John Pilger.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
11-21-22 02:13 #11033Senior Member

Posts: 1945What does that have to do w the price of eggs? You clearly missed my point. Again. This is a bad habit you have.
Originally Posted by PVMonger
[View Original Post]
I was not complaining that USA was used as the benchmark. I was simply saying that it was used and that it influences the outcome of the stats.
-
11-21-22 02:10 #11032Senior Member

Posts: 2560Unadjusted for purchasing power, the GDP of the USA is 60% higher than #2 China, which doesn't have a freely convertible currency. Also we've had the predominant reserve currency in the world, and the predominant currency used for international trade. And in terms of GDP per capita and personal income per capita adjusted for purchasing power, we're number 1 for any country with a population of greater than 10 million. Or at least I'll go on believing that's the case unless JustTK comes up with more convincing evidence.
Originally Posted by PVMonger
[View Original Post]
So yes, why not use the US as the benchmark?
Now at some point this may change. After adjusting for purchasing power, China has the world's largest economy. The use of sanctions by the USA has some other nations anxious to hold their reserves and conduct trade in other currencies. But for now, and for the foreseeable future, for better or worse, the USA is the king of the hill.
-
11-20-22 22:32 #11031Senior Member

Posts: 1945John Pilger. The truth teller
Nice little interview w John Pilger one of the best journalsists of modern times, one of the last truth seekers.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u9pEotvlW-s
His book Tell Me No Lies: Investigative Journalism That Changed the World. Was a real eye opener and one of the best media books I have read. It's a collection of his favourite pieces of hoeroic jounalism from around the world at key moments on modern history. Its not his writing, apart from the chapter intros. But reading it, just shows what we as members of the public, are up against when we seek the truth.
-
11-20-22 20:44 #11030Senior Member

Posts: 1604Sheesh
Why is English the defacto language for flight communications? Why not use French? Or German? Or Russian? Or Spanish? Especially Spanish since there are more Spanish-speakers than any other language other than Mandarin Chinese?
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
If France was the benchmark you talk about above, every other country in the world would say "Why not use US as the benchmark?" The same with Germany. Or Spain, etc. The USA is the third most populous country in the world behind China and India. That's why they're used.
-
11-20-22 15:54 #11029Senior Member

Posts: 1945I have no idea why or if. You would need to ask them that Q.
Originally Posted by PVMonger
[View Original Post]
-
11-20-22 05:01 #11028Senior Member

Posts: 1604Well then
If undocumented people aren't included, then why have Repubs been lying all this time? Members of the Moron Brigade swear that there are 20 million to 30 million undocumented immigrants in the US. It seems a logical impossibility that they can count all of these undocumented immigrants, right?
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
I guess the Repubs have been lying all of this time because there are clearly no undocumented immigrants living in the US.

.png)







Reply With Quote


