Thread: Stupid Shit in Kyiv
+
Add Report
Results 3,061 to 3,075 of 4602
-
12-19-22 03:23 #1542Senior Member

Posts: 1751Given the lamentable situation at the US border and separation of the families, would you believe anyone who claims the border agents set up torture chambers to interrogate children? Of course, not. The sad reality is enough unfortunate children have become orphans and some both orphans and disabled and found foster families or been adopted during this conflict. We know of the majority of people on the payroll, their names, phone numbers, and addresses in Kiev who work daily in disinformation effort.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
The war was predictable since about February 2008 and you can read it in a US embassy in Moscow cable communication. Myself I clearly knew it in 2015 that the red lines had been crossed. I'm a local and a veteran.
The other mistake is to think that there is some magic weapon or system that might turn the scales of the conflict. I won't go into details of the Patriot (angles, speeds, altitudes etc), but Ukrainians ask for 31 divisions. They just don't exist and won't help them, and not only because air defense is a system.
To this date hundreds of Americans already died there. I don't post pictures of bodies, coffins and remains out of respect. We don't fight the dead. But I can tell you that we are at the highest risk since June 1982 - March 1983 period.
-
12-19-22 02:14 #1541Senior Member

Posts: 540Glad you have a crystal ball. Please provide lottery numbers.
As I've said before, I wish I had a dollar for every Ukraine-Russia prediction that's fallen flat on its face. Write this down.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
-
12-19-22 02:10 #1540Senior Member

Posts: 540Who gives a shit about what Merkel says? She's been thoroughly deflated and nobody is paying attention. She's yesterday's news, as are the Minsk Accords and the Budapest Memoranda, and trying to pretend otherwise is another exercise in obfuscation. Nobody is seriously looking at the past for answers to the current situation. To the extent the past is referenced, it's usually as a lame attempt to justify the position of one side or the other. This war is dependent on battlefield outcomes and those are yet to be fully seen.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
Oh yes, the famous Russian tactical retreat, or is it a Goodwill gesture? I get them mixed up since Putin seems to use them interchangeably whenever his forces are getting fucked over. And, as far as I'm concerned, if Putin was truly so weak-minded as to be provoked into an unwise attack, that's just fine as it gives the West a chance to bleed him dry. A strong, smart, and savvy leader wouldn't have taken such obvious bait. So, whether he's smart or stupid, the practical results are the same. By any objective measure, militarily, diplomatically, geopolitically, or other, Russia is greatly diminished as compared to its pre-Feb 24th state. And, looking forward, it's hard to see how Russia emerges from this without long-lasting damage. Hell, just the millions who have left to avoid conscription constitute a brain-drain of monumental proportions. Hey North Korea, hold my vodka!
As far as info that comes out of interviews, it's ridiculous to offer any kind of analysis without taking the interviewees agenda into account. It's absolutely in Zaluzhny's interest to talk up the threat. Whether it's that Russia is mobilizing for another big offensive or that Belarus is getting ready to join the war, Ukraine benefits by amplifying those points. Not only does it help keep the attention level high but it's also useful in the ongoing efforts to get more weapons and financial support.
This war isn't going to be determined by what's on the pages of The Economist, or any other publication. In fact, since there are ongoing propaganda efforts from BOTH sides, I would argue such accounts should be either completely ignored, or viewed with extreme skepticism, unless and until they're confirmed by facts on the ground.
Also, since you're so fond of accusing Kyiv of corruption, what kind of a blatant hypocrite you must be to repeatedly refuse to acknowledge what is arguably the most corrupt group that has ever existed, namely Putin and his Kremlin cronies. Your finger-pointing is so obviously biased and contorted that you end up sticking it in your own eye. It's so transparent that it's actually pretty funny.
-
12-19-22 01:12 #1539Senior Member

Posts: 540Special Military Operation? Give me an 'effin break!
If your neighbor, with whom you've had long-standing disputes, knocks down your fence, drives onto your lawn, and starts shooting your family members, do you really give a fuck what they call it? Whether Putin's SMO bullshit verbiage was meant for internal consumption, or to try to give it a false veneer of legitimacy, is completely irrelevant. An invasion by hostile foreign forces, crossing internationally recognized borders, is an act of war. You can probably count the people who try to deny that fact on the fingers of one hand. It's pretty hard to take anything you say seriously when you can't even bring yourself to admit the blindingly obvious.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
And it's similarly obvious that the corruption allegation can point both ways. Putin's gargantuan personal palace on the Black Sea didn't get built on a civil servant's salary, did it? You may not have noticed, but I've never specifically defended Zelensky. Whether he's a bad guy or not isn't a justification for invasion. If it were, then there's an even stronger case for taking out Putin, who has elevated corruption and kleptocratic rule to stratospheric levels.
I would assert that it's been full scale war for Ukraine since Day One. They haven't been fooled by Putin's BS verbal judo. And I'm also not hung up on the niceties of what's a legitimate military target and what isn't. I'm not surprised Putin is bombing infrastructure, and nobody should have been surprised by the Kerch Bridge strike. That bridge, and more specifically the rail line across it, was the primary conduit of military equipment into Crimea and from there into Kherson. It was always a target, appropriately so. The only surprise was that Ukraine was able to be so effective in disabling it. Kudos to them as it was probably the precipitating factor in Russia's withdrawal from the west bank of the Dnipro.
But you persist in trying to complicate the simple. Russia invaded, full stop. You can't credibly claim that Putin is a strong and savvy leader if you simultaneously assert that he was duped, or lured, or otherwise forced. He has always done EXACTLY what he wanted, and he wanted to invade Ukraine.
Does it make a shred of difference that Putin is corrupt and a bad guy? Nope. Does it make a shred of difference if Zelensky (per your assertion) is corrupt and a bad guy? Nope. The war (that's W-A-R) continues. Also, if Zelensky dropped dead or was removed, Ukraine would continue to defend itself. If Putin dies or is replaced, it's unclear what his successor would do. I'm not making any prediction but rather an observation that people who believe they're fighting for their homes, and very lives, have a different motivation than those who are fighting on foreign soil (and have the option of going home).
You might be surprised to hear that I actually agree with you about the point of NATO and the West giving less than full support. Maybe it's to make Russia bleed as long as possible, or maybe it's to ensure that Ukraine doesn't win too quickly and comprehensively, or maybe there are other motivations. Ukraine would certainly like more weapons like ATACMS, F-16's, modern tanks, etc. But those haven't been forthcoming.
But the salient point is that every external source of influence and support can only affect things so much. For example, it seems that Xi Xingping has influenced Putin to tone down his nuclear rhetoric, but that's not an absolute guarantee because Putin is going to do whatever he decides is best. Similarly, any influence on Zelensky to either make concessions, or refrain from making them, will not prevent him from making his own decision. In fact, I would argue that Zelensky is more constrained by Ukrainian public opinion than anything else. If he was pushed to accept concessions, while most of his people were vehemently against it, I think he'd be promptly replaced.
So, no matter how loud the noise and BS gets, and no matter how hard people try to put the focus on tangential, rather than central issues, we're still left with a full scale war. I won't make any predictions, as there are too many known and unknown variables at play. You apparently lean toward the Russian position, while I come down squarely in favor of Ukraine. But who really cares since all that matters is what happens on the battlefield? To this point, Russia's performance has been woeful. Could that change? Possibly, although I wouldn't put long odds on that happening. The next few months will be an important phase of the war. And, of the two sides, it's been the Ukrainian armed forces who have, at least so far, made the bolder and more effective moves. Let's see who does the better job of dealing with General Winter.
-
12-18-22 09:56 #1538Senior Member

Posts: 1931Your solution is unrealistic I'm afraid.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
This will be resolved (temporarily of course and then turn into a frozen conflict of sorts) on the battlefield with the defeat of Ukraine. Write this down.
-
12-18-22 09:55 #1537Senior Member

Posts: 1931Ukraine was preparing for war, read what Angela Merkel said the other day. They were never serious about implementing the Minsk accords. Ukraine would have acted militarily in my opinion, Putin said this himself, he just pre-empted it. And which of my assertions are incorrect? The conflict really started in 2014. Minsk was an attempt to find a solution, that didn't happen. NATO was arming Ukraine to the teeth since 2014. Also, every country has its red lines. Remember the Cubain missile crisis in 1962? That was an American red line. Ukraine joining NATO (something which the cunts in the West knew was not going to happen but they kept talking about it to antagonize Russia) is / was a Russian red line.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
Yes, Putin did miscalculate, see my earlier post. He thought the special military operation would be enough to get Ukraine to negotiate. And Russia is failing on the battlefield? Keep believing that fiction the western media is propagating. Yes, Russia RETREATED TACTICALLY from Kherson and Kharkov, but their army is intact. The mobilization went well, read the interview in the Economist that Zaluzhny gave. They have over 200 K reserves ready and armed to join the fight. Let's see what happens in the next 2 to 3 months. I am not a war monger. This war is a terrible tragedy for the Ukrainian people and didn't need to happen. You can clearly see who is benefiting from the war. The American military complex, and the corrupt lot in Kiev that is bagging billions.
-
12-18-22 09:47 #1536Senior Member

Posts: 1931What you fail to understand is that Putin didn't declare a full war on Ukraine on Feb 24,2022. That is why it was called a Special Military Operation. It was a limited operation with set goals with limited manpower. Putin didn't set out to destroy Ukraine, because he knew these are fellow Orthodox Slavs. Why do you think he didn't touch the Ukrainian critical infrastructure until the terrorist attack on the Crimea bridge? All that changed when the West forced Elensky to not negotiate, like he was ready to do in March 2022. Read his interviews from back then, you will know that he was ready to discuss neutrality, Crimea under Russia and the borders for the Donbass. Then Boris Johnson went to Kiev and hijacked it, that's the real tragedy. Plus, Elensky is corrupt, he's getting richer everyday with billions. It's the ordinary Ukrainian people that are suffering.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
Now the gloves are off, it's a full scale war. Read what Zaluzhny said in the interview to the economist the other day. He clearly sees the writing on the wall. Unless NATO intervenes militarily, which they won't because as I said, the aim is to make Russia bleed for as long as possible, not for Ukraine to win.
-
12-18-22 08:00 #1535Senior Member

Posts: 757All Putin had to do was not invade Ukraine in 2014. I blame Putin and his stooge Yanukovich and of course all the corrupt oligachs who support hime.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
-
12-18-22 05:20 #1534Senior Member

Posts: 540About 3 years between Zelensky's election and Russia's invasion.
The idea that, after the passage of three years, some critical event happened that precipitated the Feb-24th invasion, giving Putin no choice, is ludicrous on its face. Countries have disputes all the time but they rarely choose war. As a major geopolitical player, he had many cards he could have played, but he explicitly chose military action.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
Oh, and Angela Merkel has been rapidly losing face, from both sides of the issue. I don't see many quotes or references about her other than as an example of someone for whom the substance didn't match the image. And, whenever she's discussed, the reactions generally range from disappointment to anger.
Also, by any metric you use to judge Ukraine (fascism, Nazism, corruption, totalitarianism, etc.), Russia's scores will be off the charts. It's quite amusing to read people's criticism of Ukraine while they make moon-eyes at the Russian kleptocracy. But I guess any Russian citizen who doesn't like the system can just leave, right? Except, that if they're a prominent dissident, they'd be wise to avoid windows on high floors, and politely refuse any offer of polonium-laced tea.
-
12-18-22 04:47 #1533Senior Member

Posts: 540Putin bears the blame
All the pre-invasion geopolitical circumstances were in existence long before February 24th. None of then sprang up overnight. Putin, as the leader of a country boasting of (everyone thought) a powerful military and nuclear arsenal, had a wide variety of cards he could have played. And, diplomatically speaking, he had a number of key allies and supporting countries. Let's take one supposed provocation as an example, the possibility that Ukraine might join NATO. Pre-Feb 24th, there were plenty of NATO members who would have vetoed any such proposal, some because they didn't want to provoke Russia, others because they thought Ukraine was unsuitable, and others for different reasons. Now, however, it wouldn't surprise me in the least to see Ukraine in NATO in the near-to-midterm future.
Originally Posted by DramaFree11
[View Original Post]
All the geopolitical influence and all the status Russia had prior to the invasion has now been flushed down the toilet. And, adding insult to injury, Russia's military has been exposed as a corrupt paper tiger.
Putin didn't invade because he was forced and it's hilarious to hear some people, those who say how strong and savvy he is, simultaneously try to say that he was duped or lured or forced. Anyone who says that is essentially denying Putin's personal agency and turning him into a puppet, with strings being pulled by others. What nonsense! He did it because he believed his own internal propaganda and thought it was an opportune time to get a quick and decisive victory. Unfortunately, all his FSB butt-boys were telling him that Ukraine was ripe for the picking, not because it was true, but because it was what the FSB chain of command wanted to pass up the line. Nobody in that system wants to be the bearer of bad (or realistic) news.
And, about ending the war, I repeat my earlier suggestions for a simple solution. 1. Russia willingly stops fighting. 2. Russia unwillingly stops fighting. The issue of prosecuting Putin is a post-war matter that will be dealt with, or not, when the time comes. Nobody is talking about invading Russia, so that's a red herring. The proposed solutions, either 1 or 2, can happen without invasion.
-
12-18-22 04:07 #1532Senior Member

Posts: 540Simple solution: Russia withdraws and goes home.
Ukraine can't withdraw since they're fighting on home soil. And, if they unilaterally stop fighting, most of the country will end up looking like Bakhmut or Mariupol.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
But Russia can stop whenever it chooses to. And yes, it "Takes Two to Tango," but it only takes one to start a fight. One can decline an invitation to dance, but declining to defend yourself when attacked is an invitation to an early grave.
War is a crime against humanity: Check.
Bad guys (arguably) on both sides: Check.
No winners: Check.
Everyone is losing: Check.
Possible Solution 1: Russia willingly stops fighting.
Possible Solution 2: Russia unwillingly stops fighting.
-
12-18-22 03:38 #1531Senior Member

Posts: 540So many known and unknown variables
As usual, I'm reluctant to play the prediction game. But, following along the "existential battle" theme, it's possible that the more grinding the war gets the more Ukrainians will be resolved to continue. It's paradoxical, I know, but think of it as kind of a Battle of Britain scenario. In other words, no matter how tough things get, they won't change their minds unless there's an acceptable alternative. And, post-2014 and Crimea, it's hard to imagine any territorial concession that won't be seen as merely an opportunity for Russia to re-arm and attack again in the future.
Originally Posted by WyattEarp
[View Original Post]
Again, too many variables in play to see very far ahead. Right now, as you correctly point out, the next phase of play is making it through the winter.
-
12-18-22 03:17 #1530Senior Member

Posts: 540Nobody held a gun to Putin's head
For the sake of argument, let's assume all your assertions are true. Whatever wrongs he felt needed to be corrected, Putin made the specific choice to use force. Once he did that, all other doors slammed shut. Any concessions Ukraine might have considered early in the war evaporated once it was clear the West would be supporting Ukraine and especially once Russia experienced setbacks like the retreat from near Kyiv. Nobody negotiates with an enemy who is failing on the battlefield. Putin's problem is that he miscalculated with respect to the resistance he would encounter from both Ukraine and beyond. He's now reaping the results of that miscalculation.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
-
12-18-22 03:06 #1529Senior Member

Posts: 540Wish I had a dollar for all such predictions
Do you have a copy of what Putin wrote down before Feb 24th? Do you have copies of all those who wrote down that Russia would win handily and quickly? It's ok if your copies are in Cyrillic or other non-English scripts, we can use Google Translate.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
Just thought it would be a useful exercise to gather all the failed predictions in one spot.
-
12-17-22 18:32 #1528Senior Member

Posts: 4854That "idiot" actually predicted this war would happen.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]

.png)







Reply With Quote


