Thread: Stupid Shit in Kyiv
+
Add Report
Results 3,046 to 3,060 of 4602
-
01-06-23 00:15 #1557Senior Member

Posts: 540Some developments to look out for in the coming weeks
1. The equipment situation: Ukraine will soon be getting IFVs (infantry fighting vehicles) from France, Germany, and the US. Because of their firepower, and other characteristics, the AMX-10 RC, Marder, and Bradley have been described by some as "light tanks," but they have wheels, not tracks. Despite not being a true tank, they will provide a significant upgrade for Ukraine's mobile infantry offensive capability. Will they be a HIMARS-style game changer? Only time will tell and, of course, much will depend on the numbers provided and how well Ukraine handles the new logistics demands.
Ukraine will also be receiving Patriot missile batteries from the US and Germany. One attribute that hasn't received much attention, from what I've seen, is the extremely powerful radar system that comes with that package. I read an analyst's comment that it has the capability of being leveraged to make Ukraine's other air defense assets more effective. If that turns out to be true, then future missile and drone strikes by Russia may be substantially de-fanged. Again, only time will tell.
On the Russian side, the main question is to what degree they'll be able to replace equipment they've already lost. It's hard to assess to what degree sanctions, and the workforce lost to mobilization, are having an effect. One recent report pointed out that a destroyed Russian T-90 tank was a model designed for export rather than the model reserved for Russia's own military. While it's anecdotal evidence, it does raise the question as to Russia's stockpiles (or replacement capability) for that particular piece of equipment.
2. The ammunition situation: Only Russia knows the full extent of their stockpiles. But the rate of artillery fire by Russian forces is drastically reduced (by about two-thirds) from what it was during the summer. There are also reports that Russia has depleted the stores of ammunition held by Belarus, and has also been looking to acquire ammunition from North Korea, which would indicate that they're actively looking both to conserve and to replenish from non-Russian sources. Similarly, heavier reliance on Iranian drones may indicate issues with Russia's supply of missiles.
For Ukraine, the challenge is to manage a dual-supply chain that includes ammo for their legacy systems as well as newly acquired NATO weapons. Ukraine was running low on legacy ammo but captured significant stockpiles during the Kharkhiv offensive. They've also reportedly reconstituted a portion of their domestic ammo production capability. Supplies of ammo for NATO systems will depend on Western deliveries. But, as important as quantity is, quality and accuracy (ex. HIMARS) are also relevant factors. With respect to the situation for both sides, it will be important to focus on what's happening on the battlefields, rather than anything that's being said.
3. The mobilization and training situation: Russia is reportedly planning another large mobilization effort. Whether it will be formally announced, or more low key, remains to be seen. The last mobilization round had quite a few problems and was widely criticized, even by Putin himself. Mobilization also tends to increase outbound migration, unless border restrictions are imposed, as well as drain resources from the civilian workforce. All those mobilized will require training if they're not merely to be thrown at the front line for "cannon fodder" purposes. In the earlier mobilization it appears some were held back for training while others were quickly sent to Ukraine to plug holes in defensive lines. That latter group has understandably suffered a high rate of casualties. Russia's capacity (or inability) to train and equip newly mobilized troops will be something to take note of. Ukraine, meanwhile, continues to benefit from training provided by various Western countries. But what's yet untested is whether Ukraine's forces have the capability to launch the kind of offensive campaign that will be needed to retake significant territory. The Kharkhiv scenario had a number of unique factors that are unlikely to be repeated. If Ukraine wants to move beyond the current battle of attrition, it'll need to raise things to a new level. That being said, Ukraine has been the better side when it comes to using surprising and unexpected tactics. So we'll just have to wait and see what cards are next to be played.
4. The infighting situation: Right now there's a major power struggle between Prighozin (allied with Kadyrov) and the MoD duo of Shoigu and Gerasimov. One way that's manifested is that Russia's regular forces aren't giving normal levels of support to Wagner PMC as they battle in the area of Bakhmut. Prighozin is trying to show that his private army is better and the regular army's leadership will be happy to see him fail. How this plays out and who (if anyone) prevails is anyone's guess. But it's worth watching as power struggles can have significant consequences, even if they're hard to predict. Will Kremlin elites start to take sides? Will Putin swing to one side or the other? Stay tuned!
On the Ukrainian side, the infighting takes the form of debate about supporting Ukraine and in what form and amounts that support should happen. So far those critical of support, like Hungary and Serbia, have been in the minority. But there are no guarantees and situations can always change. Ukraine has done a better job of managing the information war, so far, and it's helped that Russia continues to engage in behavior that sparks outrage in the West.
Non-factors (so far): The China-Russia relationship has essentially been a nothingburger. China is naturally cautious, their economic reliance on Western markets is substantial, and it doesn't help Russia that, to this point, their record on the battlefield is one of losses, rather than gains. Nobody wants to back a loser and China will not want to hitch their wagon to a lame horse. And those China factors don't begin to take into account the significant problems China's experiencing with COVID and economic issues. Comrade Xi is devoting his time, attention, and resources to steady his own ship. Also, the energy weaponization tactic has pretty much fizzled. That could be as a result of warmer than normal temperatures, or it might be the result of good adaptation by European economies. We're not through the winter yet but to this point it certainly hasn't paid the dividends expected by Russia.
The war's not over, the jury's still out, but just wanted to post about the developments I'll be looking out for.
-
12-22-22 16:43 #1556Senior Member

Posts: 2225I agree with you that the EU will work to bring Western values to the Ukraine. Of course, there is some level of graft in every country. It's inevitable.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
All one has to do is look at Turkey. The EU has put Turkish membership on hold for a long time. Turkey's NATO membership is the result of geographic and strategic reasons.
-
12-22-22 07:26 #1555Senior Member

Posts: 540The corruption canard is a pseudo-argument, at best, a distraction at worst.
Fuck the so-called corruption issue. It's total BS because it fails to address (at least) three key issues:
Originally Posted by DramaFree11
[View Original Post]
1. Anyone who is attacked has the right to defend themselves, full stop. And that right has nothing to do with how good or bad that person is or how good or bad others think they are. That right is absolute and remains whether a person is a saint, a devil, or something in between. Even the worst convicted criminal, after having done his time and been released, has the right to defend himself if attacked. Hell, he retains that right even while in prison! So, whether Zelensky, or anyone else in Ukraine, is corrupt or not, they're not obliged to lay down and let a Russian tank run over them.
2. The so-called corruption argument nearly always ignores, or severely downplays, the EXTREME corruption perpetrated by Putin and his Kremlin cronies for DECADES. Assuming, for the sake of argument, that there's corruption in both sides, any fair balance would tilt immeasurably against Russia. It's not even a serious debate because there's so much more money sloshing around Russia and they've been stealing it for so long.
3. In forward-looking terms, Ukraine has ambitions of joining both the EU and NATO. As they go through those membership processes they will be under all sorts of scrutiny and will be required to pass laws, change systems, and put in safequards. And what that means is that Ukraine is moving toward becoming a country that works to root out corruption, rather than tolerate it. Meanwhile Russia continues to be a kleptocratic sewer.
For all the above reasons, and I'm sure people will think of more, accusations of corruption are a total red herring. Here's a hypothetical for ya, if Zelensky was found guilty of corruption and removed from office, it wouldn't change Ukraine's absolute right to defend their country and their lives. Not one iota.
-
12-22-22 03:58 #1554Senior Member

Posts: 2892Ukraine may want to look internally when it comes to corruption. Maybe they could start eliminating corruption in their own county, just a thought.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
Pres. Z. could say that he will not tolerate that behavior, but why stop now.
-
12-21-22 07:15 #1553Senior Member

Posts: 2745Never happened.
"We" have never ever explicitly or otherwise "promised" anyone that we wouldn't expand Nato eastward.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
There is no treaty or agreement promising anything to that tune. While the assurances to the USSR were discussed during the negotiations, there has never been an agreement of any kind.
Not even a "gentleman" understanding that this was to happen.
Every participant in the intense diplomatic negotiations of that time from Baker to Gorbachev to Shevarnadze has debunked that myth.
P'utin and his American allies like Candace Owen can keep lying till they're blue in the face.
https://web.archive.org/web/20220222...ics_111767.htm#c203.
https://hls.harvard.edu/today/there-...-enlarge-nato/
-
12-21-22 06:08 #1552Senior Member

Posts: 540You mean the FSB infiltrated branch of the Orthodox Church?
https://genevasolutions.news/ukraine...he-ukraine-war
Originally Posted by Golfinho
[View Original Post]
Oh yeah, funny how there's no outrage about it in Orthodox Ukraine. That's because Ukrainians want to rip every last vestige of corrupt Russia out of their country. And it didn't have to be that way, but Putin has single-handedly turned all of Ukraine against anything that even smells like Russia.
BTW, I hope they sell every "church" property where they found New Russia flags and give the proceeds to REAL charitable organizations.
-
12-20-22 18:10 #1551Senior Member

Posts: 2225Certain things are inevitable in conflict and war. I would say the Russian-Ukrainian conflict was inevitable going back to Putin's installation in 1999.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
I'm also not sure the promises to limit NATO expansion eastward were that explicit. In any event, the Ukraine is not in NATO. NATO as expected supported the Ukraine in a war with Russia. I think more than likely Putin thought Russia was in a good position militarily, politically and economically to attack the Ukraine. In other words, he overplayed his hand.
As far as the DMZ discussion, you could have a hard DMZ like Korea where neither party dares cross it or you can have a situation like Vietnam where there are insurgents active behind the border. Knowing Putin, one would think he would still try to foment unrest within the Ukraine long after a hot war is over.
This leads to an important point about the Korean Conflict and the Vietnam War. It's easy to look back and say the United States needlessly entered these conflicts. The results were also mixed. One however could argue the Pacific Rim is more secure because of allies such as South Korea and other nations that were once threatened by Communist-supported encroachment.
-
12-20-22 17:46 #1550Senior Member

Posts: 2225This occurs all over the world with USA Foreign aid. Wherever you find USA Aid, you will find well-educated people in smart suits who don't have any discernible skill other than doling out the cash. I suppose their skill is networking and getting into these NGOs.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
This is the problem with a massive Federal bureaucracy and seemingly endless amount of borrowing.
I don't know if it is a reason to not support the Ukraine though. Billions and billions have been flowing into Eastern Europe since the fall of the Iron Curtain and the Soviet Union.
-
12-19-22 20:26 #1549Senior Member

Posts: 4854Wyatt, you raise a good point. What is the end game? All these dolts talking about winning cannot envision what that means. If Ukraine does take back Eastern Ukraine where so many Russians reside, do you think that those Russians will be on equal footing with the Ukrainian citizens? I don't. I think there will be treated like the Palestinians are. And the same goes for the Ukrainians there if Russia keeps that territory.
Originally Posted by WyattEarp
[View Original Post]
I have a feeling that wherever the lines are drawn there is also going to have to be some kind of DMZ zone.
Then there is the point about not trusting Putin. Well, we promised we would not expand NATO eastward after the USSR fell, and we went back on our word. And now Ukraine is going to be in NATO?
-
12-19-22 20:14 #1548Senior Member

Posts: 4854The Twitter files expose has been jaw dropping and shows our government engaged in horrific censorship. It also shows how Twitter tried to influence the USA into supporting Ukraine in this war. Look at this tweet: https://twitter.com/SamParkerSenate/...673152/photo/1.
Originally Posted by Jmioffe
[View Original Post]
Matt Taibbi first alerted me to this foreign aid scam a decade or so ago. You petition for foreign aid to a country, get it billions, and those who lobbied for it are given millions by the country which got the money. This is EXACTLY what the Bidens did in Ukraine, and to be fair, I am sure both parties have done this.
With Ukrainegate, I saw how much Democratic party NGOs were actually running Ukraine. You think those NGOs are hurting right now with all that cash flowing in?
-
12-19-22 16:36 #1547Senior Member

Posts: 2225A relatively peaceful period and then another Russian attack in the future is a concern in my mind.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
Territorial concession or no territorial concession what kind of security assurances will the Ukraine have in a post-war environment. Would the West arm the Ukraine to the teeth so that it would be like poisonous prey to borrow a reference from nature? Or would NATO step up and place the Ukraine under the NATO security umbrella?
Obviously, time will work to the benefit of the Ukraine. Russian nationalists die off. Putin dies or is deposed. Russians lose interest in controlling the Ukraine. There just will be a very tense period in the immediate aftermath. It's hard to see otherwise.
-
12-19-22 14:32 #1546Senior Member

Posts: 2379What the Ukrainians can 'withdraw' is their zionazi government. Now that ziolensky has revealed his true colors in attacking the Orthodox Church it's obvious to all.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
-
12-19-22 12:52 #1545Senior Member

Posts: 623I agree. This is Julian Assange's most famous quote, and while he was talking about Afghanistan a decade ago, it still applies to Ukraine today.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
"The goal is to use Afghanistan to wash money out of the tax bases of the US and Europe through Afghanistan and back into the hands of a transnational security elite. The goal is an endless war, not a successful war".
https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status...642688?lang=en
The scam doesn't change since it works so well. Only the victims do. Why do you think they've been so aggressive pursuing him?
-
12-19-22 07:46 #1544Senior Member

Posts: 2745P'utin's word play doesn't mean shit. Kyiv was supposed to be taken within 3 days, Ukraine in whole (Russian troops on the Polish border) by mid August. Before the invasion, Kadyrov had been tasked with assassination of Zelensky and his team.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
If that's not a full-blown war, then you're a ballerina.
I did read that clumsy horseshit that Frau Merkel -- the main P'utin's enabler in the world -- said in a futile attempt to undo the damage to her legacy.
Originally Posted by BloodRed
[View Original Post]
Ain't going to help her, the damage is done.
-
12-19-22 07:34 #1543Senior Member

Posts: 2745Sounds like a threat. Quite dumbfounding to me given the forum where it's issued. Why tell us?
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
On the other hand, sounds like bullshit too, so whatever.
1. Hindsight is a beautiful thing.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
2. I presume an illegal annexation of Crimea was one of these lines.
1. That's strange coming from a "local and a veteran. " You people seem to whine incessantly about HIMARS. To the point of claiming that you're fighting against the whole Nato and the "collective West. ".
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
2. Where does that ridiculous request for 31 "divisions" come from? A link would be nice.
3. That's some cryptic gibberish. Other air defense systems are helping them just fine, why not Patriot?
There are 6 Americans who are known to have died fighting for Ukraine, but nice try anyway.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]

.png)







Reply With Quote


