Thread: Stupid Shit in Kyiv
+
Add Report
Results 2,911 to 2,925 of 4601
-
03-02-23 05:25 #1691Senior Member

Posts: 1749https://youtu.be/nlDLGQadxLk
'I've been with you only for the sake of democracy'.
-
03-02-23 02:03 #1690Senior Member

Posts: 750Pincers Closing in Bakmut
Z and his cronies need to be rounded up for this human tragedy.
-
03-01-23 12:11 #1689Senior Member

Posts: 451Both feet in your mouth all the time.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
-
03-01-23 05:35 #1688Senior Member

Posts: 540Pathetic personal jibes won't improve Russia's pitiful military performance
But I guess it'll help you get over the terminal butthurt of having your Black Sea flagship unceremoniously 'promoted' to the rank of submarine. Who would have thought the prophetic words "Russian warship, go fuck yourself!" would have come to pass so soon?
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
-
03-01-23 04:23 #1687Senior Member

Posts: 1749https://youtu.be/FAqyx5Kr_3c
One foot in the grave once, one foot in the grave twice.
-
03-01-23 00:54 #1686Senior Member

Posts: 2743Of course, nothing is predetermined. My "vision" is based on the inevitability of the final breakup of Russian empire and the mere fact that the Kremlin won't take it lying down. I'm afraid the civil war in Russia is inevitable -- as for severity of it, well, let's hope it won't involve the nukes.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
As for China, again I agree that they crucially depend on the West, but so was Russia. Unfortunately, in a battle between logic and totalitarianism the logic always lose.
Seriously, just think how crazy it was for Saddam to go to war against America or for Putin to go to war against the world. And yet, here we are.
-
03-01-23 00:40 #1685Senior Member

Posts: 540Puzzling post
For two reasons:
Originally Posted by Nrlmus
[View Original Post]
1. In the post you replied to, I listed three possible outcomes. In your reply you quoted two of them and completely ignored the third. Which is puzzling, since it was exactly that scenario that's most relevant to what your reply discusses. Here's outcome #3, from my original post, that you left out:
"Something in between #1 and #2, like a partial withdrawal by Russia. But, whether they withdraw to pre-invasion borders or something else, this has no possibility of forming the foundation of any kind of lasting peace. Whether it's a hot war, cold war, ceasefire, or other arrangement, Ukraine will never concede an inch of their territory (as defined by the post-Soviet internationally recognized border) to Russia. Which means that any partial outcome is likely to be nothing more than a lull before the next storm. Just like Russia's invasion in 2014 was a precursor to this one, anything less than a comprehensive peace will contain the seeds of the next conflict. Oh, and all the above elements, like sanctions, war preparations, and so forth, will likely continue".
With respect to your response, one thing you don't address is the qualitative difference between the current situation and those from the past. It's specifically BECAUSE of Russia's past aggressions that the current anti-Russia alliance, including a mix of sanctions and support for Ukraine, exists. Countries that didn't involve themselves before are now fully engaged. Why else would Sweden and Finland change from decades of non-alignment to seeking NATO membership? Why else would Poland and the Baltics be boosting defense spending to previously unseen levels? The simple and obvious reason is that they look at all the examples of Russian aggression you just listed, and the light bulb has finally switched on. They realize that Russia will not stop of its own volition. And they realize that a frozen conflict is just hitting the pause button, and that they are likely next on Russia's shopping list. And most of the rest of Europe, even if they're not on Russia's borders, now understand that, unless they deal with Russia now, they're likely to have a less stable Europe that is constantly under threat.
BTW, your use of Hitler and Napoleon as historical examples is right in line with Russian "great power" propaganda. But it completely fails as an analogy because in both cases Russia was fighting a defensive war, on home soil, and the aggressors had to deal with the logistics required for an invasion. In today's situation, Russia is the aggressor, fighting on foreign soil, and they're struggling mightily with logistics. Maybe if Hitler or Napoleon had systems like HIMARS things might have been different. Oh, and if you think the USSR would have stopped Hitler without MASSIVE amounts of Western aid (look up lend-lease + Soviet Union), I have a bridge over the Kerch Strait that's for sale.
Again, I'm puzzled why you completely sidestepped the one scenario I outlined that was specifically on point.
2. You talk a lot about China (and COVID) yet I didn't mention it in any one of my three scenarios. In fact, my only mention was toward the very end where I pointed out that any help from China is likely to come at a very high cost for Russia. Other than that simple and relatively uncontroversial assertion, I have zero inclination to follow you down your China (and COVID) rabbit-hole.
-
02-28-23 18:06 #1684Senior Member

Posts: 2223China's strength is overstated. If you are saying the Chinese helped the World get out of the 2008-2009 financial crisis, their over-investment with a lack of corresponding domestic consumption put pressure on the global economy and still does. Initially, they helped consume and stockpile some commodities, but they still needed a home for their manufactured goods. The commodity boom didn't last long and started to deflate in 2014.
Originally Posted by Nrlmus
[View Original Post]
It's easy to think of the country with huge trade surpluses in a position of strength. In reality, it's more of a dependency on the World economy and the USA In particular for end markets. The USA Is already diversifying its manufacturing base.
I don't think helping Russia substantially is currently in their best interests. Hedging their bets is in their best interest.
-
02-28-23 17:25 #1683Senior Member

Posts: 2223I've always been concerned the war becomes a long slog that the Russians just continue to fight when rational minds might say time to pack it up and go home. As many observers have noted, Russia historically fights a long game where it's size, manpower and willingness to bear ridiculous losses give them an advantage. Yes, Russia will be isolated and her economy will suffer. However, this was Russia throughout the twentieth century.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
Now that doesn't translate into a Russian victory per se, but it doesn't give the Ukrainians a great outcome. A very satisfying victory might elude both sides.
-
02-28-23 13:45 #1682Senior Member

Posts: 1956So true
There's a whole crew of you here though some user names may be sock puppets.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
-
02-28-23 08:42 #1681Senior Member

Posts: 111I think for most likely outcome one should look at late history: Georgia, Chechnya, etc. Still going on. A little colder, a little hotter. The Russian troops are forever there to keep the fire smoldering. Still there in Abhazia, still there in Ossetia, still there in Transdnestria. That's the way Russia fights. It outlasts you. Napoleon, Hitler. All went through the same routine. Donbass was in military limbo for 7 years before Russia took the next step. The Blitzkrig against Ukraine didn't work so Russia is settling to what it's accustomed to. The idea is let's see what happens in a few years time.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
China. The way it appears to me China is daring the US to impose sanctions on it. Not the Trump tariffs. Serious sanctions. Unlike Russia China has plenty of ways to fight back and that's why meeting between the US Secretary of State and the Chinese foreign minister never seem to go beyond shouting matches. 2006-2008 crisis: if it wouldn't be for China who knows what would've happened in the US. China knows that.
Covid: I believe that it was a reconnaissance by force. No proof, just a hunch. Maybe initially it wasn't meant to be that but wow talking about a present to the Chinese military planners. Covid was gold! China is used to pandemics, you know. SARS1, West Nile, Blue Nile, Green Nile, Bird, Swine, Cow, Sheep, Dog, Moon. They had them all. Compared to SARS1 Covid was not such a big deal. The difference is that SARS1 and Swine flu stayed in China only, while Covid took a spin around the world. Chinese saw how the world reacted. Chinese took notes. China also believes that in the real trade war the Chinese people would be able to handle hardships that such a war would inevitably bring on both sides much better than the Americans and the Europeans would. I know my Americans. I see the reaction to the darn balloon. I think the Chinese are right.
At this point I think the US is afraid of China more China is afraid of the US. Will Chinese supply Russia with ammunition? I'd say they will. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if they are already doing that. I may be wrong but I have a feeling that I'm right.
It's not in the Chinese interests for the Ukraine to prevail IMHO. If Ukraine is seen as a victor it would farther boost West and would inevitably seed doubts in the Chinese ability to prevail against Taiwan (or anybody else for that matter) both domestically and abroad while providing an incredible motivational shot in the arm to Taiwan. We all know that the invader is always in disadvantage as is, no matter who the invader is and now if the potential invader is not as sure in its ability to prevail as it was before. Houston, we have a problem.
China needs Russia to prevail over Ukraine and I think it's ready to play a more active part in the conflict. Obviously not as overtly as NATO does but hey. It shares a long woody border with Russia. Who know what crosses it and when, where and how. Obviously it would be stupid for the Chinese to meet Zelensky over their 'peace proposal' and give Zelensky such a huge additional platform to showcase his professional skills. Xi wouldn't even agree to a phone call with Biden why would he want to speak to wonderful and funny Mr. Z.
BTW, very very very funny Mr. Z. I speak Russian and Portuguese fluently and this guy was a top dog. I think I saw most of his clips. Not as funny as Brazilian Porta dos Fundos mind you (few things are) but still very funny.
-
02-28-23 07:43 #1680Senior Member

Posts: 1052The US and NATO have contingency options for rapidly moving response forces to secure nuclear stockpiles in other countries in the event their governments topple. That's all I can say.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
-
02-28-23 07:22 #1679Senior Member

Posts: 451That's right, there's at least 3 of you here. Not sure how you escaped the circus, but here you are regular as clockwork.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
-
02-28-23 06:58 #1678Senior Member

Posts: 540They poisoned him.
Which explains his problems. What's your excuse?
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
-
02-28-23 04:07 #1677Senior Member

Posts: 1749The former Georgian President, a buffoon who chewed on his tie, is now a hospitalized mental case. As we say 'clowns never die they just change each other at the scene'. Clowns are like cockroaches, there is never only one.

.png)







Reply With Quote


