Thread: Stupid Shit in Kyiv
+
Add Report
Results 2,806 to 2,820 of 4601
-
03-28-23 10:20 #1796Senior Member

Posts: 451There is actually no war at all, the Ukrainians are being mind controlled. They want their children stolen and women raped by Orcs like you. In fact the whole squirrel eating world is jealous of the Orc life, living without washing machines and shitting outside.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
-
03-28-23 07:01 #1795Senior Member

Posts: 540Russia invaded Ukraine in 2014.
Putin seized Crimea and the Donbass by using a mix of Russian-backed (armed, supplied, financed) militias and regular Russian troops. The myth that Russian forces weren't directly involved is pure fiction, and has been exposed as such.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
All of which means that the current war is merely an extension of the hostilities that began with Russia's 2014 invasion. No invasion = no hostilities = no deaths. Once again, the responsibility lands squarely on the murderous, imperialist thug called Putin.
-
03-28-23 04:46 #1794Senior Member

Posts: 1956Your post was a bit of a launching pad.
Agreeing that McGregor is an ass while I took a bit of time to, for the 100th time on this thread, correct the three or four fallacious, canned pro-Russia talking points pitched by the American far right. So why for the 100th time? Have had too much free time on my hands the last few days I suppose. Wink It's sad that their nonsensical isolationism has devolved them into becoming Putin buttboys and essentially enemies of America. But after January 6th, 2021 nothing should surprise us.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
New Republic / Free Repubic, was a simple error is all. Have fun. I'll drop back in sometime in the near future.
-
03-28-23 04:35 #1793Senior Member

Posts: 1749In the top right corner of the attached collage are ages of ch. killed in Donbass mainly in 2014 to 2015 by the regular Ukrainian army. The Ukrainian army used tanks, artillery and airplanes against own civilians. Hundreds of cases of such crimes are in prosecution. This is why now it's the army and not only the nationalist gangs is viewed as the legitimate target.
-
03-27-23 23:44 #1792Senior Member

Posts: 2223Elvis, this was a more balanced post that wasn't entirely appreciated by the hardcore Ukraine crowd.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
However, I don't think Russia's advantages in bodies matters a whole lot with today's state of military technology. I've heard a lot about global food production including the climate catastrophe crowd proclaiming that the world is running out of food. To paraphrase Mark Twain, "The reports of worldwide famine is greatly exaggerated. " Russians trying to force food shortages only further weakens their global standing. The point about Western financial weakness, is just that. It will be resolved with the usual financial restructuring that always begets some criticism about the winners and losers. However, the West's enormous physical economic power will support the rebuilding of the Ukraine.
By now, you're probably wondering what I appreciate about your post. For one, I appreciate you're not trying to look at the world through the eyes of a psychopathic Russian. More importantly, I appreciate this comment despite its termination with a preposition (wink):
"My question about this war has always been: what is victory for Ukraine? That is what everyone pro-Ukrainian keeps talking about, and I do not get what that means. I do get what victory is for American defense contractors and that is perpetual war and to me, that seems to be where we are at. ".
Well, we're likely going to see a Western reassessment after the coming Ukrainian counteroffensive. If it is successful, this will force the Russians to come to the table and the Ukraine's position will have more support from the global community. If we are still in a long, grinding war after the offensive, the West will likely force a resolution that doesn't go back to pre-2014 borders.
-
03-27-23 18:45 #1791Senior Member

Posts: 540The fallacy of following opinion in a fact-based environment.
It's clear from all the links posted to this opinion writer, or that analyst, that many in this forum have favorites they follow. That's fine, as far as that goes, but it can potentially stray into the fallacy of believing those opinions are any kind of a substitute for facts. No matter how knowledgeable (real or feigned) the pundit, or how eloquent the writing, it's still just opinion.
And, while the opinion of true experts have value, they also have their limits. The sheer number of variables, known and unknown, in a constantly changing environment means that any expert should be clear about how much they don't know. In fact, if I don't see that kind of admission, or something similar in the way of humility, I tend to discount what that author has to say. One look at all the 'expert opinion' that has already been proven wrong tells the story.
A real expert can be useful if they point out issues and factors you otherwise might not have considered. Or if they can discern facts you might not have realized were there. But it's only with 20-20 hindsight that we'll truly know who had their shit together and who was pulling opinions out of their ass.
It's a bit like a card-counter at a casino who has demonstrated expertise with one or two decks. Add many more decks, and throw in a bunch of wild cards, and their expertise fades pretty quickly. And anyone who follows that expert, and places bets thinking they have better than random chance odds, is likely to lose their shirt.
As for me, one ounce of fact is worth more than a pound of opinion. And that's what I'm looking for in whatever I read or hear re Ukraine, reality-based observations and factual nuggets.
-
03-27-23 17:44 #1790Senior Member

Posts: 540Unclear if you're agreeing, disagreeing, or something else.
Firstly, the link I posted wasn't from the New Republic, so I have no idea what your reference to that publication has to do with what I posted.
Originally Posted by Paulie97
[View Original Post]
The purpose of my posting the freerepublic link was simply to illustrate the various failed MacGregor predictions. There were a number of sources I could have used but I chose that one because it was short and to the point. And I didn't scroll down to read any of the comments because I frankly don't give a shit about uninformed opinion.
And therein lies my beef with MacGregor (also Ritter, etc.) and his acolytes. They claim to have expertise and yet, not only are they repeatedly and demonstrably wrong with their predictions, they're also transparently biased in favor of Russia.
Bias, in and of itself, isn't unexpected. But it's incumbent on the analyst to be up front about it. For example, retired generals Ben Hodges (USA) and Mick Ryan (Australia) both firmly support Ukraine but still do their best to analyze the military situation from a professional soldier's viewpoint. One can agree or disagree with their analyses, but the only standard that counts is judging what they say against what actually transpires on the battlefield.
And it's those real-world results that expose MacGregor for the fraud and shill he is.
-
03-27-23 14:54 #1789Senior Member

Posts: 2379You're confused. When jews don't like what another jew is saying, they call him a self-hating jew. It's an important distinction as the term you used -- jew hater -- is one that can be used on any goy at any time.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
-
03-27-23 09:32 #1788Senior Member

Posts: 451The guy is a Jew hater, a shill, an apologist etc.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
-
03-27-23 08:00 #1787Senior Member

Posts: 1956?
The New Republic huh? It's sad that the far right in America is consistently a mouthpiece for Putin's propaganda, and you'll find McGregor defended in the comments section of your link. They blame the failed predictions of a rapid end to the war on NATO intervention, but in the early going there was no time to add much support. The failures are clearly attributed to poor planning and execution. And the predictions were just what traitorous McGregor wanted to see happen regardless of what was actually happening on the ground.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
Now the traitors just go on excuse mongering for Russia, the country where they need to go live, blaming NATO for everything. The usual 1000 times already refuted claims follow, that the West near the end of the Cold War promised not to expand NATO but the context at the time only related to East Germany, nowhere else, plus the Warsaw Pact was still intact. Gorbachev, who was present, has flat stated recently that the agreement Putin alleges never took place. Or that NATO pushed itself into Eastern Europe while ignoring the fact that these countries came to love freedom and asked for integration. Their agency cannot be ignored. Or that the US orchestrated a "coup" in Ukraine when in fact their brutal and cowardly leader was removed constitutionally by the duly elected legislature. But these folks can't be bothered with research beyond conspiracy theory pushing far right rags, as they've been brainwashed into thinking that everyone else is lying to them. Thus we get the parroting of Russo propaganda right from our own shores.
Anyway here's an interesting and balanced opinion piece from the WSJ. Writer has solid credentials.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/putin-w...tions-7ca7f128
-
03-27-23 06:56 #1786Senior Member

Posts: 540It's hugely amusing to see so many try to overcomplicate a rather simple situation.
In 1991 the USSR collapsed and various former Soviet republics declared their independence. It was a chaotic time of transition, to be sure, but the end result was a set of internationally recognized borders for Russia, Belarus, Ukraine, etc.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
Those borders stood unchallenged for about 13 years until the 1st Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2014. And, as a direct result of the world's tepid reaction to that initial act of naked aggression, Putin saw no reason to hold back from invading a 2nd time. Much to his surprise, the reaction was quite different.
Putin's M. O. Is to stir up shit and then use that as an excuse to impose his own solution by force. He's done it in Moldova and Georgia and he's gotten away with it until now.
It's not complicated. Putin is a murderous, imperialist thug who won't stop unless he's forcibly stopped by others. And that's what's in the process of happening now.
-
03-27-23 04:04 #1785Senior Member

Posts: 2742No need indeed.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
-
03-27-23 03:25 #1784Senior Member

Posts: 1749The Ninth Anniversary of the Ukraine War
By Jeff Sachs. No need to portray him as a Jew hater, a shill, an apologist etc. This article actually touches upon some cornerstone facts, in my view, to understand the origins of this conflict.
https://www.jeffsachs.org/newspaper-...mt4dlr4z2dpe2s
'Dying is easy' - the cartoon below:
-
03-27-23 03:16 #1783Senior Member

Posts: 1749https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/...report-ENG.pdf
Report on human rights.
-
03-27-23 03:11 #1782Senior Member

Posts: 1749https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/...t-POWs-ENG.pdf
A few video records circulate, seem to be original, and all horrific as this conflict.

.png)







Reply With Quote


