Thread: American Politics
+
Add Report
Results 10,066 to 10,080 of 22509
-
06-08-23 20:11 #12444Senior Member

Posts: 2560
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
You picked up your mistake for Bush before I posted. I didn't know it, because your posts are moderated. So kudos for that.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Why didn't you divide the 11.2% gain, calculated using Tooms' Math, by the 2. 37 years which have elapsed since Biden became president? You're smart, you know better. The only thing I can figure is that your partisanship led you to consciously or unconsciously do that.
The combination of "Tooms' Math", the mistakes for Bush and Biden, and the fact that any correlation between the party of the President and S&P 500 returns should be spurious or close to it made it hard to take your earlier posts seriously.
-
06-08-23 20:01 #12443Senior Member

Posts: 2560No, of course not. If an S&P 500 Index fund or any other fund calculated per annum gains the way you do, the SEC would be on their ass in a flash. Joel Anderson, who wrote the article in Yahoo Finance, has an educational background in film. He's not necessarily better at math than you are. But he'd probably calculate annual returns the same way I do. And if he didn't, his editor would catch it and make him do it.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Here's an illustration. Say you have a closed end fund (or stock index) that had a value of 100 thirty years ago. It grows to have a value of 3100 today. What's the annual growth? The correct answer is 12.12%. That's a very respectable return. Here's what you get using your method:
(3100 - 100)/100 = 3000% gain, divided by 30 = 100% per year.
That's misleading. And in fact ridiculous. You invest $100,000 at 100% per year and you'd have 107 trillion dollars in 30 years.
-
06-08-23 10:12 #12442Senior Member

Posts: 8046The same math
You mean like being the first one here to finally point out to the desperate Repub Trumpsters that they ought to abandon their love affair with the Dow and citing Trump's "over 50% gain" in that Index when the S&P 500 Index is far more accurate and representative of the broad stock market, preferred on Wall Street and, oh look, their boy's gains by that measure is dramatically better than in the Dow to boot?
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Why didn't you point that out to them after all these years?
Ok. Here is a breakdown of the stock market performance results during every presidency going back to McKinley:
https://finance.yahoo.com/news/stock...220026422.html
Warning: the numbers are different from mine because they used the Dow as the measure instead of the S&P 500 Index and that is because the Dow is an Index that goes back that far. The S&P 500 Index does not.
Well, the financial folks at Yahoo! Finance must not know math any better than I do because they calculated each president's performance exactly the same way I did; by simply calculating the percent of gain or loss from the closing number on a president's first day in office until the last day in office with no regard whatsoever for how that first year "Grew exponentially" relative to the year before it, the one before that and so on. Just the raw closing numbers. I'm guessing every financial analysis site does it that way.
However, they do a disservice to the reader in that they don't provide a simple mention of what that stated gain or loss was on Average Per Year to achieve that overall gain or loss as I did. You know, to indicate at a glance how each president's performance result compared to the others on a per year basis.
Unfortunately, without that reasonable courtesy highlighted, the casual reader might be misled into concluding a president whose performance result was, say, 80% gain was a better steward of that aspect of the economy than one whose performance result was 60% even though the former was in office 8 years and the latter was in office only 2 years.
As a hypothetical example.
They should have made it more easily accessible for the casual reader to make that comparison without dividing by a president's years in office by breaking it down to the Average Annual Gain / Loss for them already, as I did.
Wouldn't you agree?
-
06-08-23 07:24 #12441Senior Member

Posts: 2560To be clearer, you consciously or subconsciously made grade school math errors that favor Democrats.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
06-08-23 07:17 #12440Senior Member

Posts: 8046No calculation will improve the reality Repubs' disastrous stewardship results
Then you can't even agree that the gains per presidential tenure based on the January 19/20 starting and ending closes in the S&P 500 Index are as follows, right?
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
And neither would any financial analyst or anyone with a background in math sufficient to understand exponential growth and decline because, after all, none of those starting numbers were determined relative to its exponential growth or decline from the prior year.GHW Bush, 286 to 433 = 52% gain.
Bill Clinton, 433 to 1342 = 210% gain.
GW Bush, 1342 to 805 = -40% "gain".
Barack Obama, 805 to 2271 = 182% gain.
Donald Trump, 2271 to 3851 = 69.5% gain.
Joe Biden, 3851 to 4284 yesterday = 11.2%.
Oh, and the prior year's result also needs to be calculated based on its growth or decline relative to the year before that, right?
And on and on.
-
06-08-23 05:53 #12439Senior Member

Posts: 2560Dang Tooms, not only are you cherry picking time periods, you're also re-inventing mathematics and financial analysis. No financial analyst would quibble with my presentation of the numbers. Nor would anyone with a background in math sufficient to understand exponential growth and decline. They would have a problem with what you're doing, and find your calculation of the per year return during the Biden and George W Bush administrations, well... I'm searching for the right word and can't think of one that's not insulting. You’re turning even math into a partisan exercise.
Why would I be "itching to penalize the far superior gains by Obama and likely other Dems" when I believe a correlation between the party of the president and the S&P 500 is spurious?
-
06-08-23 05:32 #12438Senior Member

Posts: 8046Ah, correction time for me too
Me:
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
I see I mistakenly divided W's total tenure "gain" of -40% by only 4 when he blessed us with 8 years of sterling classic Repub stewardship.GW Bush, 1342 to 805 = -40% "gain", divided by 8 = -10%.
Therefore, his Average Annual "Gain" in the Index was -5%, not -10% as I had posted.
Still, that won't zoom him to the top of the Presidential Stock Market Gain Championships and plunge Bill Clinton or Barack Obama to the bottom unless someone comes up with a twisted pretzel formula to show how one kindly Repub investor meant and tried to buy $20 Trillion in stocks in the second week of January 2009 but fell asleep, didn't make that purchase and then forgot all about it later. So many sad and negative variables working against those poor unlucky Repub presidents.
Let's wait to see if some determined pro Repub Bothsider / Neithersider tries to pull that one off.
-
06-08-23 04:40 #12437Senior Member

Posts: 8046Oh really? What about investors who were busy in January 2021, forgot all about the date of the inauguration and didn't happen to make any buying or selling until the day after? Or made their move the day before so they could watch every minute of it on TV without phoning their broker?
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
That one day either way might screw up your entire calculation and could very well move W to the top of the Stock Market Championships and sink Bill Clinton to the bottom.
BTW, why limit your calculations to "Per Annum" Growth when you might get a whole new set of conclusions with a "Per Administration" Growth calculation?
We can see you are itching to penalize the far superior gains by Obama and likely other Dems for taking over from Repubs during typical deep Repub declines and elevating the results for Repubs since they never take over from Dems in the midst of economic disaster as though there is some non math-related Law of Anti Gravity for the stock market that it must zoom back up nicely and regularly within weeks or months after it hits an unknowable bottom no matter who is in the White House proposing and enacting their recovery plans. Nevermind the Herbert Hoover lesson on that, of course.
So why not apply your formulas to factor in Growth from full presidential administration to administration rather than merely from "Annum" to "Annum"?
-
06-08-23 03:54 #12436Senior Member

Posts: 8046I wasn't talking about or citing "Per Annum Growth."
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
I was talking about and citing Average Annual Gain for their time in office since two of the Repubs in question were only in office for four years and not eight.
Your Per Annum Growth calculations might have mattered to someone who put a dollar in an S&P 500 Index Fund on January 20,1989 and neither added to it nor subtracted from it until today. If you know of such a person.
But even that would not have changed the overall gains in the Index per each presidential tenure, would it? You can play with bizarro world math and views of it all you want after that.
What about adjusting for inflation in each and every month since January 20,1989 for that originally invested dollar? That ought to keep you busy for a while. Who knows, maybe GW Bush will come out as the All Time Champion Stock Market Gainer if you did that!
-
06-08-23 03:48 #12435Senior Member

Posts: 2560Good deal, it sounds like you're right on schedule with what the CDC would recommend. I got the bivalent booster back in October and might be looking at getting another about now if not for what I've been reading.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
-
06-08-23 03:46 #12434Senior Member

Posts: 2560That's not the way you should look at it. The results of the election were known late on November 3. The change from November 3 to November 4 was 2.2%. That's a very good one day move. It wouldn't surprise me if part of that was indeed due to a seemingly clear Biden victory. (Little did we know).
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
As to performance between the election and the inauguration, I'd chalk it up to good economic numbers. GDP was growing at a healthy clip and inflation was subdued. That's an ideal situation as far as the market is concerned. It correlates with higher corporate earnings and low interest rates. Of course, Biden and the Democrats screwed that up, the inflation part, with the stimulus provided in the American Rescue Plan in March, 2021.
-
06-08-23 03:30 #12433Senior Member

Posts: 2560The correct percentage for Biden is 4.6%/year BTW, using your beginning and end numbers. I can see why Cali Guy is not impressed.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
-
06-08-23 03:25 #12432Senior Member

Posts: 2560Damn it Tooms, after fellow board members read this exchange, they're going to think neither one of us has a life. Or at least that's what they'll think about me. Your "real world" life is amply illustrated in the Bangkok threads.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
We're actually using exactly the same numbers except for the number at the end of the Trump administration. I was using 3841.
Here's the formula for per annum growth,
Per annum growth = (e ^ ((ln(Pf)-ln(Pi))/t)-1
where e = exponential constant = 2.718
^ = "raised to the power of"
ln = natural logarithm
Pf = S&P price at end of period
Pi = S&P price at beginning of period
t = time in years between beginning and end
Unless you do this calculation all the time like I do, it may take some time to calculate or set up in a spreadsheet. But the per annum rates are easy to check. Take George H. W. Bush as an example. The index grew from 286 to 433. I calculated 11% per year:
286 x 1.11 x 1.11 x 1.11 x 1.11 = 434
That is, at 11% per annum growth, the index would be 286 x 1.11 = 317.5 at the end of year 1. Then at 317.5 x 1.11 = 352.43 at the end of year 2, etc.
Why is Bush any more responsible for the 2008 recession, and consequent fall in the S&P 500, than Bill Clinton or Barney Frank? Yeah, if Bush and his Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson and regulators they appointed were omniscient, maybe a recession would have been avoided. But it's unlikely Democrats would have done better. Most of the blame should go to the banks and other financial institutions, and people who thought they could buy $500,000 houses with $50,000 annual income and no money down. And the Fed which probably should have more aggressively cut rates early on. But Bush was a bit player.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
I believe, as you know, that is pretty wild. Trump could not have prevented a pandemic.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
-
06-08-23 02:55 #12431Senior Member

Posts: 8046Uh. Nope.
I was fully invested in the stock market all through the Trump years; 80-90% of my equity holdings in a very low cost, beautifully diversified Total Stock Market Index Fund and 10-20% in a very low cost Global Equity Fund.
Originally Posted by CaliGuy
[View Original Post]
Dollar for dollar I made far less money in the stock market under GW Bush and Trump than under Clinton and Obama, as the historical data and prices table for that broad market measure shows for all to see.
Except for one thing; I accurately identified the top of the market for one of GW Bush's Bear Market Crashes, acted on it to get out of the market and into a safe haven Money Market Fund for the duration of the decline. Then I accurately identified the exact day of the bottom in the market, acted on that to buy right back into it and made a shitload on those two near perfectly timed sell and buy moves.
As the historical data shows, anyone who simply had money in the broad market without making sharp moves in and out at opportune times since at least the late 1980's or so would have done poorly under the Repub presidents relative to doing very well under the Dem presidents.
I would say that is probably true going all the way back 100 years or so. But I have not put pen to paper on it going back 100 years to give exact numbers on it.
And, yeah, I include Biden in that assessment. Had a Repub been in office since 2021, all historic precedence and evidence is he / she would have proposed and done just about everything imaginable wrong to have turned Trump's Bear Market decline into a deep and prolonged market and economic Crash we would still be struggling to recover from with little or no light on the horizon.
LOL. Just imagine how fucked up the Trump's Pandemic vaccine distribution and administration would have been if Trump or any other Repub had been presiding over it since January 2021. Lolol.
-
06-07-23 20:38 #12430Senior Member

Posts: 8046Thanks
Thanks for your concern but I had zero negative reaction to any of the shots I've taken. I took the Astra-Zenicas because they were the first acceptable ones imo available here. Then I took the Modernas when they were available here because I had already pre-paid for them before I got the call from one of the best hospitals here to come on in for the free Astra-Zenica shots.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
I did get the recent Moderna shot more than a year after my previous shots only because it was adapted for the lastest known variants and would not have bothered to get it otherwise.

.png)







Reply With Quote


