|
|
This blog is moderated by Admin
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 3301
 Originally Posted by CheckMate1
[View Original Post]
While I agree with your assessment that it is not the end of the world with how the decision came about, I will say that it is a miss to not close the loop of future "legal' briberies and corruptions, and criminal deeds.
Also, the decision to remand back to district court to determine if the allegations are within the boundaries of official acts that took 90 days to determine is a collosal waste of time. This court seems to be scared of making tough decisions.
248 years of presidents not going anywhere near the criminal court system, and yet the office "needs" this in order to perform its duty. Thomas Jefferson's Louisiana purchase; Lincoln's civil war; FDR A-bomb drops; Iran-Contra debacle; GW Bush's Iraq war; yet this guy is the one that says, if the president doesn't have absolute immunity then no one will be able to do the job of the president.
Misinformed, misguided fool!
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 8447
Check!
 Originally Posted by CheckMate1
[View Original Post]
Also, the decision to remand back to district court to determine if the allegations are within the boundaries of official acts that took 90 days to determine is a collosal waste of time. This court seems to be scared of making tough decisions. 248 years of presidents not going anywhere near the criminal court system, and yet the office "needs" this in order to perform its duty. Thomas Jefferson's Louisiana purchase; Lincoln's civil war; FDR A-bomb drops; Iran-Contra debacle; GW Bush's Iraq war; yet this guy is the one that says, if the president doesn't have absolute immunity then no one will be able to do the job of the president.
Correct, the court doesn't have the cajones to make hard decisions. And in case you haven't noticed. Things have changed over the 248 years you've mentioned. There's never been a Donald Trump before in our entire history! And so here and now is the inflection point where the issue must be addressed head on. Further, you also misstate what the court said. Nobody said a darn thing about "absolute immunity". It's immunity for "official acts". That's a critical distinction that must not be glossed over. And it isn't "me" who said it. The Supreme Court said it. I just happen to agree with them on this. Checkmate!
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 192
The sky is not Falling. Agree
 Originally Posted by TheCane
[View Original Post]
Look man. You guys have got to stop being myopic and get real about this. Remember that one day there will be a Democratic President in office. And do you want lying, mean-spirited, assholes going after that person for everything they do while in office? Presidents, both Democratic and Republican, need to have immunity for their official acts. Otherwise, they will be hamstrung to do anything is office. We have a system of checks and balances and equal powers between the branches, and immunity for official presidential acts is a way to preserve that. Same with appointing judges for life. Otherwise, you have ex-Presidents being thrown in jail because somebody didn't like their policies or judges being jailed because somebody didn't like their rulings. Now that would be a sad day for America. We may as be some place that's less than who we've been on this from our founding, like Brazil or some shit.
Now, you're damn right Trump needs to be held accountable! But not allowing immunity for officially performing the job is not the way. Again, remember that no immunity would apply to both Republican and Democratic presidents. So, the question becomes what's an official act and what isn't? The Supreme Court remanded the case back to the lower courts to consider that question. Like Tiny said, Trump is nowhere off the hook. Think about it. When he took all of those classified documents to his house, he was no longer President of the United States. He was a private citizen. As such, in my view he was not acting in an official capacity. Which means he wasn't entitled to take all that stuff (even if he was classified info has to be properly handled which he didn't do). Of course, you know his lawyers will come up with all kinds of bullshit arguments about why it was in an official capacity, but the government will have all kinds of arguments for why it wasn't. It will all have to be litigated, and I think the government will win. The government has a pretty good record of kicking Trump's fat ass when things finally do get into court. He loses court cases on the merits again and again and again, including in civil court. Terrible client to represent!
In short, the sky is not falling because Presidents (not just Trump) have been granted immunity for their official acts. The granting of immunity for certain types of officials acting in their official capacities in nothing new in American jurisprudence. And indeed, given the nature of man (mean-spirited, petty, vindictive you name it), it's a necessary tool to allow the system to function. Regarding Trump himself, I think some incredibly strong arguments can be made that he did plenty wrong that falls outside of an "official act". The absolute worst thing that can happen is if he wins again. Then he can just wipe stuff away. Seems so wrong! But, I'm a big believer that what goes around comes around. Which means that one way or another? He's going to get what he deserves! This is high stakes!
While I agree with your assessment that it is not the end of the world with how the decision came about, I will say that it is a miss to not close the loop of future "legal' briberies and corruptions, and criminal deeds.
Also, the decision to remand back to district court to determine if the allegations are within the boundaries of official acts that took 90 days to determine is a collosal waste of time. This court seems to be scared of making tough decisions.
248 years of presidents not going anywhere near the criminal court system, and yet the office "needs" this in order to perform its duty. Thomas Jefferson's Louisiana purchase; Lincoln's civil war; FDR A-bomb drops; Iran-Contra debacle; GW Bush's Iraq war; yet this guy is the one that says, if the president doesn't have absolute immunity then no one will be able to do the job of the president.
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 2001
A chip off the ol' Trump "Gish Gallop daddy-block"
 Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Elvis' perfect example of Trumpian Repub MAGA Gish Gallop in text.
Any one of the true pro America, pro democracy Patriots here could and has destroyed every one of Elvis' total BS points in that post, right?
...
Thank you, Elvis, for providing the perfect example of how your Trumpian Repub MAGA's Gish Gallop rhetorical chnique works even in text form.
 Originally Posted by The Cane
[View Original Post]
Then prove it! That disbarred dolt Guiliani couldn't do it. But maybe you can then ay? Either put up or shut up with something that can stand up in a court of law, or for once and for all shut up! ...
...If there were true facts that would hold water in a court of law you and your ilk for sure would have produced them already. But you can't because there aren't any. So you engage in this around and around "gish gallop" as Tooms puts it...
I often love to the phase "...great minds think a like, and weak minds seldom differ", knowing people will often lose sleep and struggle trying to figure out, of which "minds" they really are in the quote...but I digress.
Anywho, I couldn't help but fall outta my chair laughing when you both applied EihTooms' article on "gish gallop" to Elvis 2008, as that's who immediately came to mind (...kkkk!), when I initially read the article, that EihTooms posted (a few days ago), here:
 Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Everyone noticed the flurry of lies coming out of Trump's pie hole at the Presidential Debate Quiz Show. It was no different from what we have all been hearing coming out of his pie hole since 2015.
But at this quiz show he kept coming back to a few favorite Trump Big Lies regarding Immigration, crime, the economy under him vs Biden, etc. I suspect because, even though he knows his only way to survive the kind of "Trump policy" scrutiny the debate threatened to provide required him to use the Gish Gallop technique, it was much easier for him to simply keep repeating a few favorite Trump Lies over and over again rather than come up with a variety of new ones for every question and response.
And, of course, he and his handlers knew that was an especially effective technique to use against a stutterer opponent. I also suspect he knows Biden will be much more prepared for it next time. If Trump is willing to risk a next time.
What Is Gish Gallop and What Does It Have To Do With Thursdays Debate?
https://bearingdrift.com/2024/06/29/...rsdays-debate/
Earlier I wanted to post, that the "Gish Gallop" article, sounded eerily similar to a tactic employed by our resident QAnon/MAGA conspiracist, INCEL and misogynist, Elvis 2008, but you guys beat me to the punch!
Well, one thing is definitely clear, the upstart "Gish Gallop" fledgling, is just a chip off the ol' Trump "Gish Gallop daddy-block" (....kkkk!)
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 4845
 Originally Posted by DCups
[View Original Post]
Elvis, my man! You are spot on! I wonder when the dumb fuckers will finally realize that Biden and Company are responsible for the tanked economy, rise in crime and the whole woke thing. Bring it on, dumbocrats! Your days are numbered!
Well, I admit it that Biden has been good for jobs creation and he had to be because now you have to work three jobs to pay your rent.
Seriously though, there has been no increase in jobs with native born Americans since 2018 and they are not distinguishing between part time and full time jobs. There is a huge discrepancy between unofficial and official surveys on employment.
And if you listen to Looney Tooms from Thailand, it is okay to go walking around East LA flashing cash. There is no crime under Biden.
As I am sure you know, half the cities are no longer reporting crime because there is so much of it they cannot keep up.
But if you listen to Loony Tooms, all those homeless folks are law abiding citizens. All that needle use is treatment for diabetes.
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 4845
 Originally Posted by Spidy
[View Original Post]
When in reality (IMHO) nothing could be further from the truth. So given the fact, we have a corrupt 2/3 conservative SCOTUS (aka. MAGA 6) and they would have the final say, on what they feel, is and isn't immunity, for a president (supposedly, no matter the party affiliation)...doesn't really past the smell test, for me.
And this is why I call you guys douches. You have a fucking president in office right now who is a Democrat, and you douches are griping that presidents have immunity and how this is all about Trump. You cheer on a 100% democratic jury, Democratic judge, and Democratic the in fucking New York that is trying to make decisions for the whole country, and you gripe about 2/3 of a jury being Republican. Wah! You douches whine and say it is not fair.
You, Xpartan, and Tooms need to move to China or Russia where there is one party rule because that is what you want and is the only way you are going to be happy.
And where is your "rule of law" bullshit now? Oh, I see when the law does not favor you, you whine like stuck pigs.
And again, you do not understand how judges and courts operate. SCOTUS hears 1% of cases petitioned to them. When it comes time for SCOTUS to makes a ruling, it is like a teacher with a red pen that marks something wrong and sends it back to the lower courts. They are going to let the lower courts make decision on what is official and what is not unless it is outrageous.
But here we go again with you douches and your fucking lame stream media. The media was saying SCOTUS lets presidents do whatever they want so Biden should assassinate Trump. You douches read whatever you think hurts you and then whine about it being so unfair. You fucking douches literally tried to win this election in the courts and now you are whining that you did not get away with it.
How dare any court have a Republican majority versus being 100% Democrat!
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 8447
Disagreements
 Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Yes, agreed, he has. Likewise I'm going to stop calling him "My Partisan Democrat Friend" and start calling him "My Democrat Friend."
Well, it's better if we all can disagree without being disagreeable hahaha!
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 2001
Corrupt 2/3 conservative SCOTUS (aka. MAGA 6)....doesn't pass the smell test?
 Originally Posted by The Cane
[View Original Post]
Look man. You guys have got to stop being myopic and get real about this. Remember that one day there will be a Democratic President in office. And do you want lying, mean-spirited, assholes going after that person for everything they do while in office? Presidents, both Democratic and Republican, need to have immunity for their official acts. Otherwise, they will be hamstrung to do anything is office. We have a system of checks and balances and equal powers between the branches, and immunity for official presidential acts is a way to preserve that. Same with appointing judges for life. Otherwise, you have ex-Presidents being thrown in jail because somebody didn't like their policies or judges being jailed because somebody didn't like their rulings. Now that would be a sad day for America. We may as be some place that's less than who we've been on this from our founding, like Brazil or some shit.
...
In short, the sky is not falling because Presidents (not just Trump) have been granted immunity for their official acts. The granting of immunity for certain types of officials acting in their official capacities in nothing new in American jurisprudence. And indeed, given the nature of man (mean-spirited, petty, vindictive you name it), it's a necessary tool to allow the system to function. Regarding Trump himself, I think some incredibly strong arguments can be made that he did plenty wrong that falls outside of an "official act". The absolute worst thing that can happen is if he wins again. Then he can just wipe stuff away. Seems so wrong! But, I'm a big believer that what goes around comes around. Which means that one way or another? He's going to get what he deserves! This is high stakes!
Overall a good post on presidential immunity, much of it I've never disagreed with.
However, I think what your post failed to realize, state or mention, is the one distinction, I clearly empathized in my post (see below and EihTooms' "tongue in cheek" post), was that, no matter which "KING" sits a top the throne at the White House, ultimately, said "Kingly Powers" (aka. presidential immunity), won't be the same for a Dem vs. a Repub president, with a corrupt 2/3 conservative SCOTUS, that could and would preside and make these immunity decisions, as 2/3 conservative majority, for several decades to come.
 Originally Posted by Spidy
[View Original Post]
...And while President Biden, may now have "King like powers", rest assured that may not translate as well, under a corrupt 2/3 conservative SCOTUS, where the rules of law, "suddenly shift", according to partisanship politics and who's in the White House. Meaning those "King like powers" in all likelihood, would look, feel and convey something very different, than if say, a narcissist, lying, cheater, racist, fascist, dictatorial "Project 2025" president were in office and a 2/3 conservative SCOTUS is presiding.
 Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
As long as the King takes any silly threat of indictment all the way up to the Repub MAGA 6 in the SCOTUS for The Ultimate Ruling on it, it is 100% certain the King will prevail.
Now, I hope nobody is suggesting the highly principled, Federalist, Original-ist, non political Repub MAGA 6 would rule any question of criminality differently for, say, a King Biden vs a King Trump!
Or a King Gaetz.
Or a Queen Greene.
Perish the thought!
Look, while Repubs would have you think, this ruling is no big deal, "nothing to see here"...it is every bit a huge deal. Just like the far reaching implications, with the overturning of Roe v. Wade, by this very same corrupt 2/3 conservative SCOTUS (aka. MAGA 6), the immunity ruling decision, comes with its own set of far reaching implications.
And while the sky may not be falling...today, let's not get blinded or lulled by Repub rhetoric, and not see "the bigger picture" at work here. Again, think the overturning of Roe v. Wade!
With a fascist conservative doctrine like "Project 2025", that seek to chip-away at our democracy, equalities and freedoms, it is very easy to think, that this type of decision, "equally" enables and supports immunity for a Dem president, as it does for Repub president.
When in reality (IMHO) nothing could be further from the truth. So given the fact, we have a corrupt 2/3 conservative SCOTUS (aka. MAGA 6) and they would have the final say, on what they feel, is and isn't immunity, for a president (supposedly, no matter the party affiliation)...doesn't really past the smell test, for me.
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 8036
Hey, good for you! That was just a Trot, not a Gallop!
 Originally Posted by DCups
[View Original Post]
Elvis, my man! You are spot on! I think I will call him Loony Tooms, too. He used to use Smoothie as a handle but things got all jumbled up or maybe too rough, apparently. Anyway all the dumbocrats on this board are freaking out now because their shit is hitting the fan. Even the media types so you know it is bad for them. I wonder when the dumb fuckers will finally realize that Biden and Company are responsible for the tanked economy, rise in crime and the whole woke thing. Bring it on, dumbocrats! Your days are numbered!
See, now short and sweet bursts of Repub MAGA lies like that are manageable. Thanks for keeping it at a Gish Trot instead of a Gish Gallop:
1. I have never had a user name on this site other than the one you see now.
2. The economy never tanked under either Obama-Biden or Biden-Harris. Both were astoundingly positive recoveries, expansions and jobs creation presidencies compared to the adjacent Repub administration.
Meaning, if you want to cite historic economic tanking, that would be the GW Bush economy and the Donald J. Trump economy. Don't even bother looking for a Dem economy for that over the past 100 years.
3. Crime is at decades' long lows under Biden after a couple of shocking upward spikes under Trump.
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 2742
You must be blind if you can't see that this BS was designed for only one person.
 Originally Posted by TheCane
[View Original Post]
Look man. You guys have got to stop being myopic and get real about this. Remember that one day there will be a Democratic President in office. And do you want lying, mean-spirited, assholes going after that person for everything they do while in office? Presidents, both Democratic and Republican, need to have immunity for their official acts. Otherwise, they will be hamstrung to do anything is office.
Right. God only knows how this little pathetic country has managed to get anything done for 2+ centuries without a presidential immunity. Gee, that was close.
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 2560
 Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
LOL. Cane, you keep making sensible posts like this and I am going to have to stop calling you douche. This was a shocker.
Yes, agreed, he has. Likewise I'm going to stop calling him "My Partisan Democrat Friend" and start calling him "My Democrat Friend."
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 4845
 Originally Posted by TheCane
[View Original Post]
Look man. You guys have got to stop being myopic and get real about this. Remember that one day there will be a Democratic President in office. And do you want lying, mean-spirited, assholes going after that person for everything they do while in office? Presidents, both Democratic and Republican, need to have immunity for their official acts. Otherwise, they will be hamstrung to do anything is office. We have a system of checks and balances and equal powers between the branches, and immunity for official presidential acts is a way to preserve that. Same with appointing judges for life. Otherwise, you have ex-Presidents being thrown in jail because somebody didn't like their policies or judges being jailed because somebody didn't like their rulings. Now that would be a sad day for America. We may as be some place that's less than who we've been on this from our founding, like Brazil or some shit.
Now, you're damn right Trump needs to be held accountable! But not allowing immunity for officially performing the job is not the way. Again, remember that no immunity would apply to both Republican and Democratic presidents. So, the question becomes what's an official act and what isn't? The Supreme Court remanded the case back to the lower courts to consider that question. Like Tiny said, Trump is nowhere off the hook. Think about it. When he took all of those classified documents to his house, he was no longer President of the United States. He was a private citizen. As such, in my view he was not acting in an official capacity. Which means he wasn't entitled to take all that stuff (even if he was classified info has to be properly handled which he didn't do). Of course, you know his lawyers will come up with all kinds of bullshit arguments about why it was in an official capacity, but the government will have all kinds of arguments for why it wasn't. It will all have to be litigated, and I think the government will win. The government has a pretty good record of kicking Trump's fat ass when things finally do get into court. He loses court cases on the merits again and again and again, including in civil court. Terrible client to represent!
In short, the sky is not falling because Presidents (not just Trump) have been granted immunity for their official acts. The granting of immunity for certain types of officials acting in their official capacities in nothing new in American jurisprudence. And indeed, given the nature of man (mean-spirited, petty, vindictive you name it), it's a necessary tool to allow the system to function. Regarding Trump himself, I think some incredibly strong arguments can be made that he did plenty wrong that falls outside of an "official act". The absolute worst thing that can happen is if he wins again. Then he can just wipe stuff away. Seems so wrong! But, I'm a big believer that what goes around comes around. Which means that one way or another? He's going to get what he deserves! This is high stakes!
LOL. Cane, you keep making sensible posts like this and I am going to have to stop calling you douche. This was a shocker.
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 4845
 Originally Posted by TheCane
[View Original Post]
Then prove it! That disbarred dolt Guiliani couldn't do it. But maybe you can then ay? Either put up or shut up with something that can stand up in a court of law, or for once and for all shut up! And stop blaming black folks for shit that anybody with a real brain knows you can't prove because it didn't happen.
LOL. We got douches screaming all day about SCOTUS and now you have total faith in courts. You douches kill me!
A federal judge can always dismiss any case he does not want to hear by saying the person suing lacks standing, and that is what happened with all the court cases. The case has to be accepted by a judge before depositions begin so either you know this and are full of shit or you are ignorant.
So a judge has to grant the person filing suit has standing before any depositions are heard, and you cannot prove anything without depositions.
So in Georgia where they pulled out a bunch of ballot boxes from under tables after Republicans left, and a douche like you says, "The judges said it is fine" is lying.
My understanding was Georgia was actually the one state where Trump had the right to a trial with the right to depose. Like in the federal courts, the Georgia courts wormed out of hearing the cases even though they were legally required to do so.
The judges did not dismiss the election challenges then because they lacked merit, but you douches keep lying and say that was the reason.
And you are out of your fucking mind if you think there was no cheating in 2020.
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 3301
 Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
I am going to have to start calling you Loony Tooms. You realize we are not in a TV debate right? That you have more than 2 minutes to respond?
And you are doing the Alinsky thing. Trump called out Biden for his being a liar. Trump did not have to win the debate. He just had to appear sane. And his two biggest blows were laughing off Biden's handicap and saying, "I do not know what he said, and I think he does not know what he said. ".
Biden took 9 days off while being paid by taxpayers to prep for the debate. Taxpayers should get a refund.
And the whole Biden is honest and Trump is a liar schtick is like Biden, it is getting very, very old.
Elvis, my man! You are spot on! I think I will call him Loony Tooms, too. He used to use Smoothie as a handle but things got all jumbled up or maybe too rough, apparently. Anyway all the dumbocrats on this board are freaking out now because their shit is hitting the fan. Even the media types so you know it is bad for them. I wonder when the dumb fuckers will finally realize that Biden and Company are responsible for the tanked economy, rise in crime and the whole woke thing. Bring it on, dumbocrats! Your days are numbered!
-
Senior Member
 Posts: 4043
Whomp whomp whomp
 Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
I hear the "Biden must quit" crowd repeating the same odd refrain:
1. Trump told lie after lie after lie.
2. Joe Biden did not call him out on those lies.
3. We need a candidate who will call Trump out on his lies and not let him just get away with it.
Questions:
Didn't these people watch the Presidential Debate Quiz Show?
Didn't they understand what the agreed upon ground rules were?
Uh, several of Joe Biden's responses began with some variation of "he's LYING", "Everything he just said was a LIE" and so on.
Uh, the ground rules were the Quiz Show contestants could NOT jump in, interrupt or talk over the other Contestant or his mic would be cut off. Which, if Biden had done what these critics appear to be wishing he had done, typically pro Repub Mainstream Media would be having a party showing video clips of an out-of-control, rule-flaunting, angry faced Joe Biden's mouth moving with no audio for it.
This was not the kind of Presidential Debate Quiz Show those critics apparently wish it had been; There was no open mic for both sides throughout.
There was a strict 2 minute limit with a strict 1 minute response time.
Sure, Biden could have spent the entire 3 minutes total allotted to him per question itemizing every 30-50 lies Trump told throughout, he's lying, he's lying, he's lying. But instead I counted and cited here several important policy proposals and plans for his 2nd term.
There was no cheering crowd, each side applauding an interruption and rewarding their guy for the loudest, funniest or craziest zinger.
The fact that Joe Biden kept the rules squarely in his mind, the mic cut-off issue and the time limits etc for every one of those 90 minutes, all while making it clear that he understood and was pointing out Trump's constant lying AND still putting on the record those popular 2nd term proposals and plans argues as much as anything that Biden, despite his cold and hoarse voice, was totally cognizant of the rules and parameters of that Quiz Show far better than his critics did.
I keep waiting for somebody on the typically pro Repub MSM to remind their audience of the exacting rules for that Quiz Show and how it was meant to calmly and unemotionally convey intelligent proposals and policy plans for a 2nd term, of which there were none from Trump, instead of one of those rousing, zinger-filled, crowd-cheering free-for-alls.
But 5-6 days later, nothing.
https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/ec...04/id/1171280/
Posting Limitations
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
Forum Rules
|
|