Thread: American Politics
+
Add Report
Results 4,651 to 4,665 of 22491
-
04-07-25 02:42 #17841Senior Member

Posts: 8041If you think that is a Ponzi scheme
Then you must think all revenue-generating programs are Ponzi schemes. All taxation takes money from someone to pay for things. Real things.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Nobody is telling current Social Security recipients that their checks are the result of profits from magical investments and will never get smaller. Quite the contrary.
The low and affordable FICA tax is collected revenue to pay out to recipients. Period. The shortfall in the midst of a unique Baby Boomer increase in recipients is made up for with a low risk REAL investment return. There is no Madoff monkey business about it.
If any one of dozens of sensible fixes to it is applied, the easiest and least noticeable among them being to raise the FICA tax cap from where it is today at about $176,100 to, oh, let's say to the amount President Musk The Liar gets in government subsidies every 3 hours, $1,000,000, the program can probably continue for many decades going forward without reducing anyone's benefit amount and keeping up with all but perhaps Trump Tariff increases in the Cost Of Living.
In addition to that simple and easy fix that might take a 15 minute signing process in a single government office, we could increase the FICA tax-paying workforce. Biden's brilliant use of immigrant inflows to contribute to his historic recovery from Trump's Pandemic while also tamping down the rate of inflation it was otherwise destined to generate comes to mind. Even more brilliant about that fix is the undocumented immigrant workers pay the FICA tax but never collect Social Security. Unless and until they become naturalized citizens or one of a few other relatively rare loopholes, that is. But that doesn't always happen.
If that isn't done then, guess what, Social Security still won't evaporate on the embarrassing discovery that "there are no gains on the money invested" as in Madoff's scam. It will always be there. The only difference will be everybody's check will begin to get smaller and smaller every year for a while until all the Baby Boomers die at President Musk The Liar's lie of 150 years old.
Privatization brings a whole new set of insurmountable problems with it for the country. Not the least of which is President Musk The Liar and his Assistant Trump deciding which of their Deadbeat crony's failing businesses will get a chunk of those revenue investments.
Meanwhile, nothing has prevented anyone from investing another 2% of their paycheck every week into whatever higher risk and potentially higher return instrument they wanted to invest it in throughout the entirety of their typical 40 plus year working life to add to their S. S. Check. No need for the USA governmrnt to making that decision for them.
-
04-07-25 01:39 #17840Senior Member

Posts: 4043Quote from front page of NYT today
When he came into office, President Barack Obama asked whether one of his Democratic predecessors, Bill Clinton, had given away too much in allowing China to join the World Trade Organization. Mr. Obama imposed a 35 percent tariff on China from 2009 to 2012, for dumping tires into the American market. And when President Joseph are. Biden Jr. Inherited Mr. Trump's first-term tariffs on China, he left them in place.
Originally Posted by Goatscrot
[View Original Post]
-
04-07-25 00:28 #17839Senior Member

Posts: 7901Stick to subjects you are knowledgable about
Sam Bankman Fried did not run a ponzi scheme. He founded a crypto brokerage firm. It failed. People who lost money lost money, lost that money due to their own incompetence. You can pull your crypto out of ANY crypto brokerage firm and self custody it. Try that with Social Security! The ONLY way to compare the two is if you really don't understand either one.
I keep it real up in dis ***** and I give it to you straight no chase. You want to debate the issue, bring it on.
Your serve!
-
04-06-25 23:59 #17838Senior Member

Posts: 273100% with you on this, Tiny. While I never have been a fan of Trump, I can completely understand why he has come into power twice. There are millions of Americans who've been let down by the system and for whom the American dream is somewhat of a nightmare. I am as far as you can get from a socialist but it does seem to me that in the west in general but especially in America that while the pie has grown massively the share of the pie accruing to different segments has changed considerably. That isn't great, but contrary to many leftists I don't think that's the worst phenomenon either (as long as everyone rises it's not a big deal if some rise much more than others). No, the much bigger issue is what economists may refer to as an externality or maybe second order effect: e. G. As a nation grows increasingly wealthy, the value and cost of the capital base in most relevantly real estate grows commensurately much more and this cascades downwards. In conjunction with this the income of the lower earning segments has remained stagnant as a consequence of technological advancement and of globalisation, so there you have it: Millions of people who are earning in real terms slightly more than they would have in the 70's with costs vastly greater. And there is the issue you are flagging, what are they going to save? BTW, a lot of people talk about AI dystopia and how it could shake up the economy negatively, I say tech has been doing just that for decades. We just haven't woken up to it. There's a very interesting book on this called Power and Progress by noble prize winning author Daron Acemoglu.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
I am not wised up to how America got into this mess of $36 trillion+ of debt but I get the sense it's irresponsiblity of a series of administrations. Regardless, what's the solution? So, savings by ordinary Americans is out. These tariffs are imbecility. I kind of agree America needs a new new deal. We've discyssed you guys need a revised health system the likes of German, Singapore, Japan, Aus, etc. And if they can figure out a decent system much cheaper so can you guys. That would save a hell of a lot of money for the ordinary American. Then some kind of an interventionist approach which mitigates against the aforementioned externalities. I strongly disagree with extraordinary growth in real estate value, it serves no value to society and just increases inequality. You have some crazy cost of living there, and I'm not qualified to understand quite how it is so, but it seems the labour pool and the lack of automation have quite a lot to do with this. But then you need pragmatic policies to deal with aforementioned externalities. You need a smart visionary leader. But for now, this batshit motherfucker is driving, so I guess we just kick back and just enjoy the ride. Happy Black Monday everyone.
-
04-06-25 16:19 #17837Senior Member

Posts: 7901A simple fix to Social Security
If Congress left the taxes collected for Social Security in a separate account filled with 30 year T-Bonds, it would stop being a pay as you go system. Life Insurance companies have actuarial tables that can be used to insure the solvency of the program. My first proper job after university was for a Mutual Life Insurance Company. I know of what I speak!
The problem is not with the program, it lies squarely with the fiscal irresponsibility of the Legislative Branch of Government. Article 1.
-
04-06-25 16:11 #17836Senior Member

Posts: 2560From that description social security sure sounds like a Ponzi scheme to me. They don't want to get the old people upset so they jump through hoops to try to explain why it's not. You don’t get the money you and your employer paid into your social security “lockbox” back with interest. Rather a good chunk of what you and your employer pay goes to people who currently are pulling money out of the scheme. The social security system depends on attracting a larger and larger number of participants or it falls apart. In my book that’s a Ponzi scheme. Yeah, government can cut your benefits or raise the tax rate on younger workers and keep the scheme going longer. And Bernie Madoff didn’t have the power to do that. So what. I believe participants in Bernie Madoff’s scheme will get back most of what they paid in and Sam Bankman Fried’s will actually get back more than they put in. That does mean they weren’t running Ponzi schemes.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
-
04-06-25 08:58 #17835Senior Member

Posts: 4043https://www.thefp.com/p/liberation-d...irth-of-a-maga
Originally Posted by Goatscrot
[View Original Post]
https://x.com/bungarsargon/status/1901449346417098893
-
04-06-25 04:36 #17834Senior Member

Posts: 8041A Ponzi Scheme vs the USA's Social Security Program
President Musk The Liar has joined a gaggle of other Numbskull Winger Liars in claiming the USA's Social Security Program is a Ponzi Scheme. It is difficult to determine which side of that lie they are lying about the most; what a Ponzi Scheme is or what the Social Security Program is.
Uh. For starters, the SSA has never paid "early investors with money taken from later investors to create the illusion of big profits", as is the case with a Ponzi Scheme. The USA's Social Security Program has always, always, always been a pay-as-you-go system where the FICA tax revenues are paid out entirely to SS recipients every year. There is no "illusion" of any profits being made from that revenue OTHER than the small percentage of it invested in the safest, low risk investments on Earth from the SSA Trust Fund that is there only to fill in for any shortfall between what is collected and what is paid out to maintain the earned amount of payment to the recipients.
But that investment produces real gains the exact same way it does if you, Larry Summers or I invested a spare dollar or two into those exact same 100% legal and legitimate investment instruments. All of the money collected, paid out and the money earned in that Fund is real and not an illusion.
Of course, we know it is real. Otherwise, Trump's billionaire cronies would not be slobbering all over their lobster bibs to get their hands on it for privatization. Something I assure you they would not do if they actually believed what they hope their constant lies about it will cause their targeted suckers into believing; that it is all just a Ponzi scheme.
Let's take a look at both and see how much those liars are lying about them, shall we?
Ponzi Scheme: Definition, Examples, and Origins.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/ponzischeme.asp
Social Security Explained: How It Works and Types of Benefits.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/socialsecurity.asp
Fact check: Elon Musk calls Social Security a 'Ponzi scheme'
https://www.wral.com/story/fact-chec...heme/21926444/
-
04-05-25 23:57 #17833Senior Member

Posts: 4043Who wouldn't love to see this
Barry "the Beech" Hussein for the 1% vs Our Lord and Savior.
Originally Posted by Goatscrot
[View Original Post]
Has anyone seen the 2028 polling lololol its showing Stephen Smith leading "the pack" LMFAO.
Even he pointed out how pathetic are they that hes leading the polls lololololol.
https://www.breitbart.com/sports/202...ird-term-race/
Above all else I'm pretty sure AIPAC will make sure "Barry the Beech" doesn't win a 3rd term lololol.
-
04-05-25 23:43 #17832Senior Member

Posts: 4043Marquessa? Ouchhhhhhhhhhhh
Something tells me I struck a nerve with my Ayn Randian turd comment ROTFLMMFAO.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
04-05-25 20:38 #17831Senior Member

Posts: 2560I believe we've discussed this before Goatscrot. It's called Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). A lot of countries have tried it, including Chile, Venezuela, Argentina, Brazil, Turkey and Zimbabwe. I've been watching that closely in Turkey for years. President Erdogan there finally had to give up and revert to conventional monetary policy. Unfortunately inflation is so ingrained in the economy that it's hard to get it to go away, even with interest rates higher than inflation.
Originally Posted by Goatscrot
[View Original Post]
What happens is that inflation gets out of control. The MMT solution is to raise taxes, presumably sky high if you have hyperinflation. That's difficult or impossible to implement politically and economically. If you've increased the money supply by a large amount, and the velocity of money doesn't go down, I don't see how you avoid inflation. And you're not going to reduce the velocity of money enough to make a difference by raising taxes on the top 1% or the top 10% You'll have to raise them on everyone.
Another argument is that MMT is sustainable as long as you're borrowing in your own currency, and not, for example, in dollars. That's not true though, as has been shown in places like Zimbabwe, Venezuela and Hungary where the government was primarily borrowing in its own currency.
This should be a progressive's wet dream, as MMT if implemented results in much larger government, and if you tax the higher income earners disproportionately, redistribution. However, mainstream progressive economists like Paul Krugman believe it's bunk. As does Tooms' favorite mainstream Democratic Party economist, Larry Summers.
Unfortunately perhaps, there is no free lunch.
-
04-05-25 20:19 #17830Senior Member

Posts: 2560Too many Americans live hand to mouth HotDog. I have friends, middle class Americans, who would be in the top 2% or 3% of income earners worldwide. And yet they say they just can't get by. You'd need to put a gun to their heads to get them to save. Well, the Singaporean system kind of does that. Combined employer and employee payroll contributions to the employee's Central Provident Fund account amount to about 35% of base income I think. And the money goes into a personal account, which should appreciate in value with the years. It's not like social security or Medicare in the USA, which Elon Musk correctly described as Ponzi schemes. Money from the account can be used for medical expenses, retirement, a down payment on a house, and education. Major medical expenses are paid for by insurance provided by the state. Health care expenditures in Singapore are about 6% of GDP, compared to 17% in the USA. And metrics like life expectancy and infant mortality are much better in Singapore.
Originally Posted by HotDog666
[View Original Post]
If the USA had a system like that, retirees today would be living high on the hog. A portion of the money would have been invested in U.S. equities, which have been on a tear for decades. Furthermore, this would solve the "problem" with trade deficits. Savings in the USA would go up, ergo trade deficits would go down.
Fantastic post, better than anything I've read in the WSJ or FT. Somebody over in the Stupid Shit in Kyiv thread asked why people post and read about politics and world affairs on a hooker board. Well, this is why.
Originally Posted by HotDog666
[View Original Post]
Thanks to the Marquessa. If she hadn't quoted you I never would have seen the post.
I hope Republican Congressmen or the Supreme Court grow some cajones and stop the madness, or Trump comes to his senses. Otherwise your prediction about 2025 may just come true. I do not believe what Trump is doing is constitutional. He's using national security as the basis for his executive orders. How much sense does that make? Imposing tariffs on Canada, the UK, Europe, Australia, Japan, Vietnam, etc. for the sake of national security? Incredible.
-
04-05-25 18:46 #17829Senior Member

Posts: 4846LOL. Tell that to the citizens of Venezuela. Hugo Chavez tried that. How did that work out?
Originally Posted by Goatscrot
[View Original Post]
And why would anyone be productive when the government just takes whatever they want? Again, this model has been tried, and it failed horribly in the USSR.
Originally Posted by Goatscrot
[View Original Post]
"A government check does not bounce"? Say what? Tell that to the people in Argentina whose nation has serially defaulted on its debt. Back in 2000, the dollar and Argentine peso were at par, one peso to one dollar. Now it takes 1,079 Argentine pesos to buy one USA dollar. And you are not worried about that?
Originally Posted by Goatscrot
[View Original Post]
I am sure this guy gets thousands an hour to lecture to government bureaucrats telling them what they want to here. He must have been a huge hit with the USAID crowd. Hell, this clown would have been great as Hugo Chavez's economic adviser.
-
04-05-25 10:17 #17828Senior Member

Posts: 3923Again the so-called debt is simply the amount of dollars in circulation that have not been taxed back. Could be paid off with the stroke of a pen with no ill effects. As long as there is productive capacity, natural resources and labor, you can inject currency into a system. The problem arises when there isn't productive capacity ie. What happened during covid.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
The debt doesn't worry me in the least.
Here's a wonderful article on Warren Mosler.
https://slguardian.org/the-illusions...ng-the-frauds/
-
04-05-25 10:08 #17827Senior Member

Posts: 273Tiny, so you're suggesting America essentially becomes a lot like Singapore. I lived in Singapore briefly sometime back and regret not making a permanent shift there. They have constructed an almost utopian society where there's zero crime, an incredible standard of living, decent public services, pragmatic blind eyes on mongering. Of course, it's not a real democracy, but given the state of affairs in America and the West in general, I'm not sure that's such a bad thing.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]

.png)







Reply With Quote


