Thread: General Reports
+
Add Report
Results 136 to 150 of 14540
-
08-03-26 11:17 #14405Senior Member

Posts: 8044Oh yes they would, but it is a special case if soliciting for prostitution.
If crowds of African and Vietnamese ladies were confronting tourists on the street, grabbing their hands and insisting the tourist buy their box of World Famous Chocolate or Girl Scout Cookies, I have no doubt the police would arrest them for disturbing the peace, creating a public nuisance, loitering or some such charge.
Originally Posted by SubCmdr
[View Original Post]
And check out their visa status along the way.
When they are behaving that way to sell sex, there is a specific charge in the law for that kind of "behavior. " It is stated quite clearly in the Code and the Act and it is the "bahavior" while soliciting for prostitution that is the crime.
What is not stated as a crime or anything illegal is the discrete selling of sex between consenting adults in Thailand. Which is why nobody is arrested, charged, tried, convicted, sentenced or penalized in any way for it in Thailand.
Buying, selling and eating candy and cookies is also neither illegal nor a crime in Thailand.
Or will you now try to unnecessarily spook international tricks, curious P4P girls, anyone else for whom English is not their first language as well as most other casual readers and visitors of this International Sex Guide website over how they'd better stay on the run as fugitives of justice if they dare to eat candy or a cookie in Thailand by posting disingenuous big bold statements on your posts' subject lines such as:
Eating candy and cookies is NOT legal in Thailand!
-
08-02-26 23:13 #14404Senior Member

Posts: 7910The Cmdr points a few things out!
The arrests are being made for Prostitution. If they were selling candy the Police would have no case. It is not possible for a foreign girl to get a work permit for sex work in Thailand.
The Defense Rests!
-
08-01-26 05:32 #14403Senior Member

Posts: 8044For the most part, police have no case against Thai street girls
Right off the bat there is the issue of foreign prostitutes working at a job and earning money with Prostitution who very likely do not have a Work Visa. So that's when Immigration Police have a reason to take over. And along the way they might discover an overstay as well.
Originally Posted by HorseTrader
[View Original Post]
But on the issue of the illegal and criminal practice of "shamefully and openly" soliciting for Prostitution "in a public place" and all the usual "pestering", "disturbing the peace", "creating a public nuisance" type of addendum and qualifiers that are the actual crimes committed regarding Prostitution in Thailand under those circumstances, I can only say my experience walking down Soi 4, Soi 7/1, Soi 11 and on Sukhumvit in Bangkok has been that the African girls and yes, the Vietnamese girls, and certainly many Ladyboys of any ethnicity are the ones most grabby and insistent and vocal about wanting me to take them for a Short Time or Long Time. Many times I have had to struggle to extricate myself from an African lady who not only will maintain a grip on my wrist until I have dragged them skidding on the soles of their shoes practically from the Novotel Hotel to Charlie's Kitchen while they're asking if they can kiss me the whole way or a Vietnamese lady who will grab my wrist, not for as long as some African ladies but will still walk along next to me after I have said No Thanks from the front of Maison Hotel to past Fitsgeralds Pub and Restaurant. And we all know about Ladyboy pestering.
Now, I couldn't care less about that kind of pestering. I think its fun and funny. But I am still struggling to loosen their grip or shoo them away so I can go on to my destination.
But I am guessing there are many men from around the world who are not charmed by the behavior, don't think it is funny, are concerned about what the wife and kids might think if the happen to arrive onnthe scene after picking up a chicken skewer down the soi or, these days, definitely don't want the folks back home to see them dragging along a lady or Ladyboy on a YouTube video that might make it look like something it isn't. Or might be repulsed by the physical contact and attention. Whatever.
However, it is very rare that a actual female Thai Prostitute freelancer on the street behaves so aggressively. And especially not when the street is packed with other Thais and tourists to see them doing it so boldly.
But crowds of tourists don't stop some of the African ladies, Vietnamese ladies and Ladyboys I have been grabbed by on those streets.
I think even the police are trying to draw as broad and wide a line as possible between what is illegal and a crime with regard to the way Prostitution is being sold "shamefully and openly" in a public place and the basic exchange of money for sex between consenting adults which is obviously not illegal or a crime in Thailand, for the sake of any ladies who need the money. It just happens that Thai prostitutes don't take giant steps over that broad and wide line and into what is unavoidably obviously illegal and a crime as other Prostitutes do. In my experience at least.
-
07-31-26 16:02 #14402Senior Member

Posts: 7910It is called Selective Law Enforcement
Not a fight brother, a intellectual discussion.
Originally Posted by HoustonPlayer
[View Original Post]
For those that do not understand, street enforcement of the law is not done from Ivory Towers by lay people reading the law and given their interpretation of it. Those who make the best arguments are the ones that call the Police when things go bump in the night. They have never strapped on iron and confronted a armed suspect in protection of their fellow citizen.
What you are witnessing is called selective enforcement. When crime is being committed there are limited enforcement resources. Those resources are directed by the managers of the Police guided by the Prosecutors of the crimes.
All Law Enforcement is selective Law Enforcement
-
07-31-26 15:55 #14401Senior Member

Posts: 7910Prostitution is NOT legal in Thailand
This is not Law School. I am not in class. I will not be subjected to the Socratic method of teaching of Thai Law by a individual who is not a member of the bar in Thailand.
https://www.thaiexaminer.com/thai-ne...o-be-deported/
I am blind and cannot see. But my assistant reads the news stories to me. I understood the arrests to be for Prostitution. Bangkok police swooped on Sukhumvit Soi 4 after viral videos exposed street prostitution. They only find out about visa violations after the arrests for prostitution.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
I don't know and you don't know either. Perhaps if you were a member of the bar you could call up the prosecutor and ask for some professional courtesy. You could ask them why? Then you could explain it to us. But you are not a member of the bar in Thailand are you. It is a restricted occupation even if you had a work permit. That is why the guy in the video is a managing director instead of an attorney in Thailand. He has a work permit that allows him to be in the office. But he is not allowed to practice law in Thailand.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
How do I know this? It helps me to have an attorney on retainer when dealing with the laws in Thailand. I am a farmer. Farming is a restricted occupation in Thailand. As a foreigner I cannot own land in Thailand. But if I formed a corporation and hired 4 Thai workers I could buy land and farm. Wait, Wait, I couldn't farm but I could get a work permit, my title would be managing director and therefore I could be in the field directing my workers who are actually doing the farming.
Once again you are asking the wrong person. I am not a law enforcement officer or a member of the bar in Thailand. The police have their Standard Operating Procedures. Perhaps since you speak Thai and I don't you can ask the police and explain it to all of us.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
I never said that. I said prostitution is not legal.. That has been my position during this entire discussion. You are the one that says under these specific conditions prostitution has no criminal penalties. That does not make it legal. If it was legal ti would be allowed under all circumstances instead of just under these specific conditions
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Objection, Councilor asked and answered his own question incorrectly.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Once again you are asking the wrong person.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
I am not a law enforcement officer or a member of the bar in Thailand. The police have their Standard Operating Procedures. Perhaps since you speak Thai and I don't you can ask the police and explain it to all of us.
That is a correct reading of the article as I understand it.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Actually no! I have proven that Prostitution is not legal in Thailand. That is why they propose:
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
The draft would repeal Thailands prostitution law and recognise sex workers as employees with labour and social security protections.Objection: Speculation Sustained.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Once again you are asking the wrong person. Perhaps you should ask a member parliament here in Thailand.
It is not possible for a foreigner from getting a work permit for sex work. It is a restricted occupation for Thais.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
This is correct. Why? Because if prostitution was legal in Thailand there would not be a faction of individuals who wanted to make it legal.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
The Defense Rests!
-
07-31-26 05:39 #14400Senior Member

Posts: 2221Of all the reported such arrests, I cannot remember any of the prostitutes being Thai.
Originally Posted by HoustonPlayer
[View Original Post]
"The group comprised three Vietnamese women, one Tanzanian woman and one Filipino transgender woman. ".
-
07-31-26 04:27 #14399Senior Member

Posts: 472I have no dog in this fight but I have a question. Why did they arrest 5 when there over a 100 prostitues on the same Soi 4 every night?
Originally Posted by SubCmdr
[View Original Post]
-
07-31-26 03:41 #14398Senior Member

Posts: 8044You quoted the magic word that made their alleged activity a crime
Yep, alleged street prostitution. There's the kind of magic word, qualifier and addendum that the Thai Penal Code and Prevention and Suppression of Prostitution Act specify is when prostitution activity becomes a crime even though Prostitution itself is not a crime. Can you think of any other reason they would include the word street in the report of those arrests?
Originally Posted by SubCmdr
[View Original Post]
Add your quote from the reports you linked to my quotes from them and there should be no doubt in anyone's mind that those arrests were for the tangential and independent "shamefully and openly" "in public places" activity related to prostitution and not "for Prostitution. "
-
07-30-26 19:53 #14397Senior Member

Posts: 7910Plain Language. Prostitution is Illegal in Thailand
I read the entire article. I don't just cherry pick in order to make an argument. I have no need to save face.
https://www.thaiexaminer.com/thai-ne...o-be-deported/
Only in the minds of the delusional do the police make arrests for something that is legal in Thailand.Five foreign women have been arrested in a late-night police raid on Bangkoks Sukhumvit Soi 4 after complaints and viral videos exposed alleged street prostitution in one of the capitals busiest nightlife districts.
All five now face prosecution under Thailands Prevention and Suppression of Prostitution Act. Immigration authorities have also begun action to revoke their permission to stay before deporting them and placing them on a permanent blacklist.
-
07-30-26 17:50 #14396Senior Member

Posts: 8044Uh. No.
If you actually read these reports you link, you'll see the first one is the same old same old about foreign prostitutes apparently making a spectacle if their solicitation for prostitution in a public place and Immigration Police arresting them for visa violations:
Originally Posted by SubCmdr
[View Original Post]
Why weren't they charged with "committing the crime of Prostitution" instead of the same tangential, independent violations for which Thai law and the ACT clearly state are illegal and crimes while mysteriously omitting the simple words that would make Prostitution between consenting adults illegal and a crime?Bangkok police swooped on Sukhumvit Soi 4 after viral videos exposed street prostitution, arresting five foreign women now facing prosecution, deportation and lifetime bans. The raid also exposed legal limits on police powers under Thailands prostitution laws.
..........
They were charged with soliciting, offering, following or harassing people in public for prostitution. The charge also covers conduct carried out in a manner considered public, shameful or a public nuisance under Thai law.
Investigators said the alleged offences occurred in full public view on one of Bangkoks best-known entertainment streets. Notably, the investigation relied on both public complaints and evidence circulating online.
Oh, and again, why do the police always have to wait until neighbors complain about being able to tell what the solicitations are about shamefully and openly and then they have to observe it from afar themselves before the realize, yep, those foreign ladies sure are shamefully and openly soliciting for prostitution alright?
If the crime was soliciting or offering sex for money anywhere and under any conditions because Prostitution is, according to you, illegal and a crime, why don't plainclothes police just attach a hidden audio / video device, walk up to those ladies up close and personal and record what the ladies say to them? Why bring all this "shamefully and openly" bit into it? LOL. Of course, it is because if the prostitute is discretely offering sex for money one-on-one up close and personal, the police have no case against them.
Can you come up with another reason why they never, never, never do a sting operation like that rather than this "shamefully and openly" stuff?
Your second link specifically spells out what "legalizing" Prostitution rather than simply not citing it as illegal or a crime would pro-actively do on behalf of Prostitutes, which Thailand now considers a legitimate "occupation" if need be, as alluded to in your first link above as well and was the topic Attorney Ben Hart referenced in his blog.
See, you have also inadvertently, apparently, proven my prediction and assessment correct in that the new law proposed for what they repeatedly refer to as "sex workers" in that article is all about "legalizing" Prostitution in Thailand rather than "de-criminalizing" Prostitution in Thailand.Thailands bid to legalise and protect sex workers has been thrown into doubt after Parliament voted 17-6 to classify the landmark reform as a financial bill. The move hands Prime Minister Anutin the power to decide whether the legislation lives or dies.
Why aren't they debating about whether or not to "de-criminalize" a behavior you claim is illegal or a crime, contrary to The Thai Penal Code and the Prevention and Suppression of Prostitution Act, instead of all this talk about "legalizing" it so the state can set regulations, safety measures and collect taxes on the income of it, which is the only thing the state means when they say "make legal" a transaction that already isn't illegal or a crime?
Until now, the entire topic of Prostitution is only referenced in The Thai Penal Code, that ACT and possibly in Immigration rules that forbid foreigners from working at any occupation for money without a Work Visa if not outright forbidding them from "sex work. " The proponent of the proposed law want to move it to the area of business licenses, benefits, insurance, safety regulations, oversight and taxable income. That's "legalization", not "de-criminalization".
-
07-30-26 04:18 #14395Senior Member

Posts: 8044Where did you read that in your linked reports?
Those conditions don't "make Prostitution Illegal" any more than speeding makes driving a car illegal, as was brilliantly explained by another poster previously. It's the conditions that are illegal. None of your linked reports cite a section of any law or ACT that state prostitution to be illegal or a crime but only for the tangential, independent conditions that are illegal and crimes.
Originally Posted by SubCmdr
[View Original Post]
From your April 2026 report link:
Your first December 2025 link appears to be the same report as your April 2026 link.Police detained 16 foreign women, primarily from Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uganda, for allegedly breaching Section 5 of the Prevention and Suppression of Prostitution Act 1996, which prohibits contacting, soliciting, or approaching individuals in public places for the purpose of prostitution.
..........
One woman was found to have overstayed her visa and was handed over to Pattaya City Police Station to face additional immigration charges. The remaining three women are in the process of having their visas revoked and are being held ahead of deportation to their home countries.
From your second December 2025 link:
Your December 2024 report linked is very brief and vague, does not cite the section in any law or ACT for which the foreign ladies were arrested but all indications are they were arrested for the exact same tangential, independent reasons the foreign ladies in the above linked reports were arrested for and not "for Prostitution", for which there is no citation in any of your linked reports for which section in any Thai law or ACT that could possibly be applied to it.Eight foreign women were arrested early Wednesday along Pattaya Beach Road for soliciting sex in public. The operation targeted the entrance to Soi 13-13.4, following multiple complaints from local residents and tourists. Chon Buri Immigration officers led the crackdown, citing concerns over public nuisance and violations of Thai law.
..........
A total of eight women were apprehended during the operation. Among them were five Ugandans, two Uzbeks, and one Madagascan. Subsequently, the suspects were transferred to Pattaya City Police Station for questioning and formal charges. Authorities charged all eight under Section 5 of the Prevention and Suppression of Prostitution Act 1996.
The statute criminalises contacting, soliciting, or pestering individuals in public spaces for prostitution. Furthermore, it includes provisions for public nuisance caused by such acts. Each woman was fined ฿1,000 immediately following the arrest.
Note that no locals or tourists complained, was pestered by or felt victimized by a public nuisance of any Thai ladies soliciting sex in a public place, only by foreign ladies. And in none of your links is there a report of so much as one customer, potential customer or any man anywhere near or engaged in conversation with those foreign ladies arrested "for Prostitution".The arrests followed complaints made by locals and tourists about a group of foreign women standing at various spots along the beach and offering sex for money, police said.
Police monitored the women's behaviour until they confirmed that they were offering sex for money. The officers arrested 20 suspects, nine Ugandans, eight Uzbeks, two Madagascans and one Rwandan aged between 26 and 51.
-
07-30-26 03:58 #14394Senior Member

Posts: 7910Arrests continue to be made because Prostitution is Legal in Thailand!
https://www.thaiexaminer.com/thai-ne...o-be-deported/
When will the individuals claiming that prostitution is legal explain to me the framework being used to arrest foreign nationals for prostitution in Thailand? I guess a plain reading of the law by lay people and ivory tower observations do not stand up at the street level.
Then we have this:
Sex Worker Protection Act The draft would repeal Thailands prostitution law and recognise sex workers as employees with labour and social security protections.
https://www.thaiexaminer.com/thai-ne...hailand-legal/
Thailand wants to make something that is already legal, legal?
ROTFLMAO!
-
07-29-26 20:09 #14393Senior Member

Posts: 7910The arrests are being made for Prostitution
The arrests are not being made for independent violations. They are being made because the law has specific language about the conditions that make Prostitution Illegal.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
-
07-27-26 07:06 #14392Senior Member

Posts: 8044Not really
Despite the occasional typically lazy and culturally preferred simple news headline that arrests or round ups were made "For Prostitution", and actually one of those headline writers did put in the extra work by describing it as "Prodtitution Activity", every one of those cases is for the usual addendum and qualifiers clearly cited in the Thai Penal Code, that ACT, by me and others here and not For Prostitution.
Originally Posted by SubCmdr
[View Original Post]
Foreign workers with possible visa violations.
Conducting it as a business openly and publicly.
Your last link provides the "tell".
By the way, did you know that the term "solicitation" as it pertains to a crime and specifically to Prostitution is actually fairly specific about it being done "in a public space" where casual passers-by or observers can tell exactly what is being said and offered and not about a discrete conversaion? That is obviously the way Thailand sees it too. Otherwise, there would be sting operations set up all over the country with plain clothes officers waiting for the magic words to be whispered by a consenting adult into the microphone hidden in their shirt pocket.The arrests followed complaints made by locals and tourists about a group of foreign women standing at various spots along the beach and offering sex for money, police said.
But there are not any of those kind of sting operations going on anywhere in Thailand. They don't even care about pursuing a reasonably presumed private conversation about it digitally / online. Instead, they have to wait until there are public complaints about prostitutes crowding the sidewalks, blocking entrances to nearby businesses, saying the words loud enough for the Anderson Family to know what is being offered as they stroll by to have dinner at Hooters and so on.
Solicitation meaning
https://share.google/aimode/3VRX9CXKdNxwQnU43
Legal and Criminal Meanings
Prostitution: Offering sex for money in a public space.
Solicitation for prostitution.
How the Offense Occurs:
In-Person: Approaching someone on a street or in a public place to propose a trade.
Digital: Using text messages, dating apps, or websites to arrange a paid sexual meeting.
Sting Operations: Police officers posing online or on the street as buyers or sellers to catch individuals making an offer.
-
07-26-26 15:59 #14391Senior Member

Posts: 7910The Police are making arrests for Prostitution because it is legal in Thailand?
April 2026
https://thethaiger.com/news/pattaya/...ion-activities
Police detained 16 foreign women, primarily from Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uganda, for allegedly breaching Section 5 of the Prevention and Suppression of Prostitution Act (1996), which prohibits contacting, soliciting, or approaching individuals in public places for the purpose of prostitution.
December 2025
https://thethaiger.com/news/pattaya/...ion-activities
December 2025
https://www.thaiexaminer.com/thai-ne...r-deportation/
December 2024
https://www.bangkokpost.com/learning...ion-in-pattaya

.png)








Reply With Quote


