Thread: General Info
+
Add Report
Results 12,346 to 12,360 of 17479
-
10-14-11 15:23 #5134Senior Member

Posts: 1572Warning: long, chocolate-hearted rant
David,
Originally Posted by David_33
[View Original Post]
You make two good points: first, that NGO executive salaries—and the lifestyles they purchase-are often an irritant when displayed in the developing countries they propose to serve; second, that NGOs contributed to the mess in Haiti. I agree on both points, but both also need to be qualified.
Haiti has been characterized as NGOs and the UN run amok. The new Haitian president claims that the post-disaster philanthropic outpouring is all spent. It's not clear how he knows that, but we can take him at his word. It seems to me, however, that it's sort of a chicken-and-egg problem: no functional government, too many NGOs working with haphazard regard for each others' activities. Both are part of the problem, but which one is the 'cause' of the mess? Some are now insisting that the NGOs need to get out of the way and let government play the role it's supposed to play. Right! Just like it's been doing since the sugar plantation slaves revolted against the plantation owners in the late 18th Century. How's that worked out over the ensuing 200 plus years?
Regarding CEO salaries, I found one source, whose legitimacy I can't substantiate, reporting that the 'average' NGO CEO's salary is $97,000. Seems like a lot of money, but I'd be willing to bet that's a mean salary—calculated by dividing the sum of all salaries by the number of salaries. Mean salaries are notoriously skewed toward the few huge salaries at the top end. Median salary—the point at which 50% of salaries are larger and 50% are smaller—is most certainly less than $97K. In addition, the data for high end salaries are necessarily more reliable than for low end salaries, since the latter come from the odds and ends of little organizations operating on shoestring budgets, voluntary labor, and unreliable records.
Please consider the range of organizations that fall under the vague definition of nongovernmental organization. The World Bank characterizes NGOs as private organizations that pursue principally humanitarian or cooperative, rather than commercial, objectives, such as relieving suffering, alleviating poverty, protecting the environment, providing basic social services, or promoting community development—primarily in developing countries. They run the gamut from World Vision, ostensibly the largest international NGO ($1.03 billion annual revenues in their latest tax return), down to little community-based organizations with one or two feebly-paid, mostly voluntary, leaders. I have no particular truck with World Vision; they're a Christian organization and I've been an avowed agnostic for more than 40 years. But their annual report brochure claims that they delivered disaster relief for 80 international emergencies, developed clean water sources in Africa, provided thousands of small business loans, promoted HIV / AIDS prevention education, and provided 4 million child sponsorships. Their annual report brochure contains not a single whisper about [CodeWord908] or sexual exploitation. And this is the biggest NGO in the world. They paid their CEO, Richard Stearns, $391K: a lot of money, but not when compared to for-profit corporations with similar revenues. Admittedly, if Richard Stearns came to Manila, he'd stay at Shangri-La in Makati or Ortigas, but his ostentatious comings and goings make him look like just another rich Kano to the few Filipinos who'd see him.
At the other end of the scale is the little community-based NGO I know in a municipality just outside metro Manila. It operates on a shoestring, with four poorly paid employees, trying to create disaster readiness for squatter communities built in the low-lying flood plains of two rivers. They also promote sustainable small-scale business and maintain a revolving micro-finance loan program. They live on small government grants and money infused from a couple of large international NGOs. Their CEO is becoming known as an expert on the impact of disasters on informal settlements, and he knows how to do community organizing, but he's seen as a threatening irritant to corrupt local politicians who regard the squatters as collateral damage that's unavoidable in their continued pursuit of public financial largesse. He is not our enemy, any more than Richard Stearns is.
So why this chocolate-hearted rant from Skip about NGOs? Because it matters what we do with our annoyance about the efforts of some to attack sex trafficking in the most simplistic and misguided fashion. Sex trafficking does exist in the Philippines, but the careless characterizations of some zealots make it appear that all sex for pay here is synonymous with exploited women and children. It matters how we respond to them.
Not all NGOs are the enemy; in fact, most are not. And even in an NGO like Human Rights Watch, there appears to be a growing awareness that the dynamics are more complicated than what's often conveyed in the popular press. Surely much of the anti-trafficking passion is fomented by a segment of feminists and by fundamentalist religious do-gooders. And then there are the many others who ride along on the wave of passionate rhetoric without really reflecting on its inconsistencies. There is also a mass of journalists who have had little incentive to think critically about the complex dynamics of sexuality, pay for play, and world poverty.
I will shut up now and let others offer their critique and suggestions, but I think that branding NGOs as the generic enemy is not a particularly helpful course of action.
X, even those of us for whom chocolate flows through our hearts and heads like to get a little flowing over the little head as well from time to time. You helped me bring back fond memories of my own first chocolate.
-
10-13-11 15:58 #5133Senior Member

Posts: 4567Topic was apparently NGOs / NGO in Haiti?
Now that doesn't sound very nice D 33.
But it does bring back memories of Puerto o Prince. At the tender age of 18 it was revealed to me that my American poverty was actually not so bad at all, had my first good black lovin', and took a tour of a rum factory up on the hill.
I need a calendar and notes to know what I did last week and what I have to do in the coming week, but I remember so much of that trip some thirty years ago. X.
Originally Posted by David_33
[View Original Post]
-
10-13-11 12:41 #5132Regular Member

Posts: 3074I would prefer to throw them under their four wheel drive vehicles, after they leave a five star restaurant on their way to their 5 star hotel. A brief visit to Haiti will prove my point.
Originally Posted by Skip Kost
[View Original Post]
I would cynically postulate that they wouldn't want to end trafficking because it would end their salaries and 5 star lifestyle. But that's just MHO.
-
10-13-11 11:34 #5131Senior Member

Posts: 1572The reporter and at least one of the "experts" interviewed in the story that RK linked did play very loosely with terminology, moving carelessly from "slavery" to child exploitation, to trafficking, "people being held against their will," and "dehumanization." Unfortunately, it's difficult for those of us on our side of the equation to be able to draw attention to the overblown aspects of the script--because in doing so we draw undesirable attention to our participation in the hobby. But it's also important not to throw all NGOs under the bus. In general, NGOs attract people who want to make a difference, and, like people everywhere, including on ISG, many of them end up buying into overly simplistic explanations of how things work in the world. And then some of them become passionate cheerleaders for these overly simplistic narratives. But I hold out some hope. I will try to attach a story here that showed up in The Economist last November that cites some very thoughtful observations from Human Rights Watch-to the effect that cracking down on "trafficking" both ignores the underlying causal dynamics (e.g., poverty) and often leads to police brutality against prostitutes and forcing sex work underground, where prostitutes are much more vulnerable. Human Rights Watch is, as I recall, an NGO.
Originally Posted by David_33
[View Original Post]
Meanwhile, an article in the current Utne Reader cites a BBC poll that found "71% in favor of greater social acceptance" (of prostitution) and an online CNBC poll that "found 85 percent in favor of decriminalization." Maybe better days are coming.
-
10-13-11 07:14 #5130Senior Member

Posts: 762In cebu we have a club already called bulldog. Last time I was there they looked like they had hired the local dogs to work that bar. Hehehe
-
10-13-11 06:51 #5129Senior Member

Posts: 8158Woof!
Hahaha. Bulldog!
Originally Posted by FreebieFan
[View Original Post]
-
10-13-11 06:24 #5128Senior Member

Posts: 4084When the price of ladies goes too high.
Or when the retirement pay just can't buy a little action.
Let the "dog" jokes begin.
http://blogs.miaminewtimes.com/ripti..._after_his.php
-
10-13-11 02:57 #5127Senior Member

Posts: 4084Or his gut. Ooops.
Originally Posted by Bloomberg
[View Original Post]
-
10-12-11 12:14 #5126Regular Member

Posts: 26Excellent marketing by the US embassy. The Philippines should pay this guy more to stick his head out.
Originally Posted by Fast Buck Artist
[View Original Post]
-
10-12-11 09:02 #5125Senior Member

Posts: 251This kind of publicity usually results in MORE sex tourists coming over. I am not sure if thats a good or bad thing, depends on your prospective. More sextourists means prices might rise, but that in turn will attract more girls to "the oldest profession".
Originally Posted by Red Kilt
[View Original Post]
-
10-10-11 17:22 #5124Senior Member

Posts: 3359"I guess that the figures are similar for the US."
Ummmm, no.
-
10-10-11 15:56 #5123Regular Member

Posts: 3074The NGOs love it. Notice how they morph the subject into focusing on "slavery" and child prostitution, using the terms "used and exploited". It reminds me of the NGO organized raids on the nightclubs in Cebu searching for under-aged and trafficked girls and coming up empty handed. The sour faced guy in London who was pushing NGOs as a replacement for "faulty Philippine institutions" was using a teleprompter.
-
10-10-11 15:04 #5122Senior Member

Posts: 3306I posted this link on the Manila thread but in the interests of sequencing it should be reposted here.
Originally Posted by Red Kilt
[View Original Post]
As I predicted in an earlier Post # 5127 in this thread yesterday, the focus is now squarely on the issue of Sex Tourism in the Philippines.
The Al Jazeera network has weighed in now with a full-blown 25 minute discussion on the issue on its "Inside Story" segment.
I saw it today on the ANC news channel today and found the following link on the Al Jazeera webpage for the full discussion.
http://english.aljazeera.net/program.858495767.html
-
10-10-11 11:16 #5121Senior Member

Posts: 3306Agreed FF and no question that his comment was not "diplomatic". He is now very aware of that.
Originally Posted by FreebieFan
[View Original Post]
However, I cannot help feeling that he will now do whatever he can, albeit quietly and out of sight, to vindicate his comments in some way (as most males when caught out and backed into a corner tend to do).
Whatever pressure he brings to bear and whatever support he gives to the Senators who are making noises about the scale of prostitution in this country, it cannot be a good thing for the mongers who rely on organised venues (like Burgos and AC for example) for their kicks.
For you and I who choose alternative pools and abhor both afore-mentioned places, absolutely nothing will change.
-
10-10-11 09:59 #5120Senior Member

Posts: 251And how exactly did they come up with that statistic, interviewed every filipina and asked her if she is a prostitute? :)
Originally Posted by Gangles
[View Original Post]
Prostitution is legal in Australia and illegal in Philippines, duh, of course there will be more prostis Reported where they are out in the open daylight

.png)








Reply With Quote


