Thread: Other Areas
+
Add Report
Results 1,846 to 1,860 of 4053
-
07-25-15 17:14 #2208Senior Member

Posts: 8158I'm game
Already I've somewhat agreed, and acquiesced to your request. The reason I mention the 'Report Post' button are:
Originally Posted by Mbsl65
[View Original Post]
1. There is a way to complain to Admin (other than just the public complaints here), and I want everyone (not just MB) to know what that is, and 2. I don't mind if you report my posts. I'm sure others have done so in the past. However since I've never been warned (or even contacted) by the board Admin, I doubt it will get you anywhere.
The phils boards somehow got 'hijacked' long before I got here (1990's?) by the old guard. I was simply proceeding in the same mold (sorry you felt it was BS). If the gents want a change, then I'm game (and am now repeating myself regarding such). Probably we'll have to agree to disagree on the way to operate the board, but I've already stated I'm willing to do it differently. That decision is not based on MB's publicly calling the method BS, its based on the writings of various gents. BTW I've been contacted in PM many times both recently and in the past over this issue. There are guys who really really don't like the current method, and guys who really really don't want to change the current method of newbs not posting questions. Each side seems fiercely adamant. I've told many of them to post their thoughts in the public forum, but they did not.
-
07-25-15 07:15 #2207Senior Member

Posts: 1194Actually it is the number of lazy questions and the pollution it creates that has put me off contributing more, plus the feeling of many people who think that because they paid twenty bucks they are somehow entitled to my time. Not to mention the appeals to the "monger brotherhood code".
Originally Posted by DashingDon
[View Original Post]
It seems different things grate different people, who could have guessed.
Oh yes, and the small difference in the number of useful contributions both online and in the flesh coming from different people. Some of us judge people on that. Shocking, I know.
-
07-25-15 06:29 #2206Senior Member

Posts: 356One of the culprit is you and you are expecting me to complain about you. Why should I? I am calling your BS publicly and it is more than enough.
Originally Posted by WestCoast1
[View Original Post]
-
07-25-15 06:24 #2205Senior Member

Posts: 8158You can always report a post to the board Admin if you think it somehow violates the Board rules. I think there is a 'Report Post' button.
Originally Posted by Mbsl65
[View Original Post]
-
07-25-15 06:17 #2204Senior Member

Posts: 356We are not criticizing his or others' contributions. We are criticizing their manner. Anyone can contribute somewhat useful info. The issue is jumping on the posters regardless of what. If you all notice same group of people are supporting each others too. Because they are the same ones are ganging on the posters. From now on, we all need to call their BS until they can not feel themselves as self appointed moderators. This also includes Photos Section. I will no longer honor their wishes since I see no reason to do so.
Originally Posted by FernandoAlonso
[View Original Post]
-
07-25-15 06:11 #2203Senior Member

Posts: 8158?
Apology DD, I missed your post here recently. I was not aware of Jackson having a problem with any of my posts. I've never been moderated / warned here, and never been contacted by Admin regarding such.
Originally Posted by DashingDon
[View Original Post]
-
07-25-15 05:29 #2202Senior Member

Posts: 872Outside view and advice
Gents,
I am reading this as outsider to PH but we had and have similar situations on boards I am an only a regular member too.
I have seen boards literally get destroyed by this.
This is for f* sake a mongering board and not Queen Elizabeth coffee chat. There are personalities here that are strongly opiniated. That is good. They may go overboard at times. But they are the heart and soul of the Board here. If you not like them or their opinion move on. Ignore it at your own loss. But stop behaving like YOU own things here. Without WC, WR etc there would be very little info. And they earned their right.
If you move to a new neighborhood you do no start telling the incumbents what to do. Or do you?
Giving people feedback that what and how they say things may be not the best way to do it is of course a good thing. But this aggressive behavior only suits egos. It surely does nothing to improve the situation for others.
What I read here makes it very clear who is trying to be helpful and who is not.
When I started here in another geography I got a lot of help from people like WC etc. I was very grateful even I did not like all I heard and clashed with people. But I first tried to contribute and then induce changes. Not bash in the door shouting.
For a time we had an exceptional board. Now the discussions are only noobs asking question without any RTFF and old hands getting attacked for being unhelpful. But people only ask and criticize. Few are giving back.
So information wise things are as bad as it gets apart from the pm help given by people like WC etc.
These boards live from our participation and mutual respect. Which needs to be earned. WestCoast maybe judgmental at times and only be a normal member. But his contributions give him that right a thousand times.
IMHO. And stay as you are!
FA.
-
07-24-15 07:45 #2201Senior Member

Posts: 6783DD,
Originally Posted by DashingDon
[View Original Post]
Good to see you posting again and with such intelligence and foresight. Best read all the posts from KK, RK etc before you comment as you ten to shoot from the hip at times and then get annoyed when others all you out. Read what has been said and you will see no one appoints anyone as moderator or whatever, just there is a modicum of order and understanding. Where you normally post does not have that hence you see anyone trying to male the thread readable and enjoyable (and not full of inane, lazy, and outright stupid FRs).
Go to the Indian board and if you truly want that style of thread ask Jackson for you own so you handle all the "where is a good hotel in Manila" or "please send me her digits bro" questions. WC, KK, RK et al (including myself) would be happy not to read that rubbish so the Philippine thread is more informative. Or do you prefer chaos and banality? LOL.
-
07-24-15 05:46 #2200Senior Member

Posts: 302Postings on the Philippines Boards
This debate on the running of the Philippines board continues here in "Other Areas". I am going to cut and post this reply of mine into the "General Info" forum, as I think it more appropriate there. I hope this does not upset Mbsl65 who seems to prefer an undisciplined approach where anything could be posted anywhere.
I agree with your opinion Westcoast. But it is a free board where it is so easy for anyone to post anything, anywhere, (like here under "Other Areas" We do need some form of disciplined approach and order. And it is through guys like yourself WC that the Philippines Forum is one of ISG's better ones. I also agree WC with your stance on the "Photo Galley" being for posting of photos and not being clogged up with other comments when there is a separate "Photo Gallery Chit Chat" for photo discussion and feedback.
Originally Posted by WestCoast1
[View Original Post]
But, my opinion, I do disagree with you WC on the need to post a field report before you can ask a forum question. I don't mind questions from anyone, newbies or otherwise. But questions where the answers are pretty obvious with a simple scroll back in the forum or a simple Google search, should be exposed for what they are -lazy research. I am with you WC on those that keep asking questions, but never see a report of the ultimate exerience.
Well said Red Kilt. It is these lazy, sometimes inane, questions that can frustrate more experienced members like WC who, I must say is one of the most generous in sharing information, and photos, on these forums, or by way of a personal messages.
Originally Posted by RedKilt
[View Original Post]
Kongking.
-
07-24-15 04:28 #2199Senior Member

Posts: 360This behavior of posters like WR and West Coast appointing themselves as judge and jury has been a thorn in Jackson's side for years. He has said many times that the biggest problem on the board was these self-annointed 'judges' who have the effect of making others reluctant to write. A proverbial sparrow can't fall from a tree in the Philippines without these know alls pontificating about it.
-
07-24-15 03:58 #2198Senior Member

Posts: 3306I tend to send many more PMs these days than place posts on the open board. That's one of the benefits of membership; you can send requests for and receive tips from other members through PMs.
Originally Posted by WestCoast1
[View Original Post]
Most of the lazy questions come from newbies who discover the board and immediately fire off some inane request that regular readers know has been "done to death" in many different places. I just skip past them nowadays; I cannot even be bothered reminding them to RTFF. What's the point of encouraging lazy newbies who (in WCs words) take but don't give (rhetorical question).
OTOH, if they are lazy but paid-up members, then I sometimes send them a PM and remind them to either read back on a particular thread or nominate some selected posts by number in response to their question, despite its apparent inanity.
-
07-23-15 22:33 #2197Senior Member

Posts: 356Thank you for making your clarifications. So this establishes that you are nothing but another user like me and others. So, I am publicly asking you and others to cool down your attitude towards to others by welcoming them rather than running them away.
My words are also towards to so called "senior members" who harass and jump into everything with an angry attitude. Best regards.
Originally Posted by WestCoast1
[View Original Post]
-
07-23-15 20:34 #2196Senior Member

Posts: 1459Because Buko is a long-time member and writer of informative FRs I took his criticism seriously. A few years ago WC and I debated this very issue, and I was one who felt being as helpful as possible had its merits and would pay off in great FRs. Experience proved my assumption mostly wrong. I still post answers if I feel a newb has made an attempt to ask a decent question. I check the board just about every day so I have a feel of what's been discussed recently and what hasn't. When it's been several months since the same question was asked I usually will jump in because going back 25 pages or so may not be realistic for most. Anyway, by the time someone leaves secondary school they should be able to ask specific questions and understand the basics of searching to gather information. From time to time we see people here who are unable (or more likely unwilling) to do this. If English competency (not to be confused with fluency) is so beyond their skills they really ought to look for a board in a language they can function in.
Originally Posted by BukoMax
[View Original Post]
The drop off can be attributed to many reasons. Sure, some are put off by the reception when they post the most general of questions that are easily answered by simply reading a half dozen or so pages. I also see far fewer questions about where to get Viagra and how to get to AC from Manila - we used to get swamped with those. I may be to blame for this since I posted a few guides in the blog section addressing these frequently asked questions - I grew weary of the same questions being asked repeatedly. Perhaps guys hit the threads, see the statements that they ought to read first, so do, find the answers they need, and move happily on.
I concur. I will point out when we get good FRs from newbs, and we have gotten some really well written and informative ones in the past month or so, WC has added them to the Reports of Distinction.
Originally Posted by WestCoast1
[View Original Post]
More than the photos he posts, I think WC, who is highly respected member of the forum and who has received a lot of praise from new paying members for the help he's given them via PM, has earned it. He isn't a formal moderator, but if anyone here deserves such distinction it's him.
Originally Posted by Mbsl65
[View Original Post]
I'm grateful he's here and the results of his effort are plain to see: the best board on ISG. You may argue with his methods, but you can't argue with success.
In conclusion Mbsl, if you dislike seeing RTFF posts you can do something about it: Post answers. Actively monitor the threads and promptly offer your informative answers.
-
07-23-15 20:14 #2195Senior Member

Posts: 8158Nothing. Period. I'm saying there are basically two ways to run the board:
Originally Posted by Mbsl65
[View Original Post]
1) Let anyone post anything he wants. 2) Keep some kind of order to it.
I prefer #2 (as does WR). You all will do as you like. There was a similar discussion recently on the Photogallery thread. Some folk would like to let anyone there post anything. Others would like to see the PG used by picture-posters only (that's my preference, keeping comments on the PG Chit-Chat thread). I would argue that both sides get to present their views.
Like Amanut, a long time ago, one of my first posts in the Phils section was a vague question: Whats a good hotel to stay at in Manila. I got shot at by several of the old guard, telling me to keep the inane questions from a newb in the PM. One of those gents PM'd me with a good suggestion for a hotel in Makati, and reminded me to stay off the open board until I had a report to give. I went on to PM several other board regulars and got good suggestions from those nice gents also. This has been going on for a long, long time. I'm not saying its the 'right' way, just the way that I prefer. Anyone may dissent.
-
07-23-15 18:04 #2194Senior Member

Posts: 356So, with your own words, you are a user / participant of the bulletin board like everyone else. So, what makes you think that you are so special post or enforce rules here? Are you a self-appointed moderator here? Can you make it clear please?
Originally Posted by WestCoast1
[View Original Post]

.png)








Reply With Quote


