Thread: Rants and WTF are you talking about and Coronavirus!
+
Add Report
Results 11,896 to 11,910 of 12549
-
05-23-20 23:37 #654Senior Member

Posts: 27215I didn't read here people die in Stockholm streets, but I wrote Stockholm is worst deaths rate with more than 1000 deaths, competing with NYC where we could see fridge trucks in streets, full of dead, and also Hart island. We will see for second wave, if it happens, let's try just to be able to control first one.
Originally Posted by Arnold15
[View Original Post]
-
05-23-20 21:06 #653Senior Member

Posts: 544I have never said to isolate the young and healthy, but I was correcting you in just having the elderly with underlying conditions as the vulnerable group.
Originally Posted by Arnold15
[View Original Post]
Cases in Sweden are likely underestimated as their test rates are still very low.
Sweden economy will suffer as much as the rest of Europe, according to some analysts in FT: https://www.ft.com/content/93105160-...8-a7b262cd4b6e and this makes me wonder, why pay a high death toll then.
Finally, I want to make one thing very clear here as I may have come across a bit harsh earlier: I absolutely love Sweden, the Swedish people and food but I think they could have done more in this case to save lives. That's all.
Rock.
-
05-23-20 19:22 #652Senior Member

Posts: 8450Munchkin
Yes, let us blame Steve Munchkin! There the little culprit is in the middle with a couple of his cronies!
Originally Posted by Beijing4987
[View Original Post]
-
05-23-20 19:00 #651Senior Member

Posts: 707Kill grandma and grandpa
Let the asympomatic roam free and live off their recent ancestors nest egg. Since they have an insufficient education in most countries it's only a matter of time before they exhaust their funds at the discos and realize it's time to hunt down the rich. One person in South Korea was traced back from 215 infections spread over 5 bars. The crumbs led back to Grandma's house where the big bad Wolf 🐺 devoured her. Betsy Devos will make sure the for profit colleges get their dough for the insufficient education provided to Hansel and Gretel. It was a gruesome story when written and later sanitized to mask the ugly truth. Thank Steven Munchkin and Kamala Harris for all those home foreclosures in California, suckers. Just call me argumentative.
-
05-23-20 18:33 #650Senior Member

Posts: 743Generally yes but
The methodology and accuracy of the count is not exactly the same between any two different countries, however similar countries should be broadly in line. In this case however, Sweden and Czechia, the discrepancy is so damn huge, that it would be all but impossible for Czechia to not have a dramatically lower death toll at current (I am not speaking about herd immunity or the hypothetical second wave).
Originally Posted by Arnold15
[View Original Post]
When the figures are this far apart and the fact that figures from Czechia have far more integrity than Belarus, China or Russia, their death toll and infection rate has been undoubtedly lower. Yes, no 2 countries use the exact same methodology and capture data the same way, however when the discrepancy is so incredibly large the conclusion is beyond dispute.
-
05-23-20 18:33 #649Senior Member

Posts: 281Very well written.
Originally Posted by ShooBree
[View Original Post]
I fully agree with you.
The health and economic consequences of mass unemployment due to lock-down will become several times larger than the health consequences of the Covid19-virus.
-
05-23-20 18:27 #648Senior Member

Posts: 281Statistics on reported Corona-death are not comparable between countries. Countries count deaths in different ways.
Originally Posted by RockyV
[View Original Post]
Also take account of number of infected. And wait for the second wave. It will happen. You apparantly did not take account of that in your biased statistics.
More than 93 % of dead people in Sweden are older than 70 years. Average age of Corona-deaths: 81 years.
Almost all have at least one underlying disease.
Why then isolating young and healthy people and killing healthy firms?
More clever to let society be open and protect risk groups.
NO.
The Big Gamble is to lock down the whole economy.
Nobody (neither you) knows the consequences of this, since it has never been applied before during any pandemic.
Your main argument is "Everybody else locked down, so it must be the correct strategy".
Did you take account of the health consequences of mass-unemployment?
Please, stop spreading Fake News.
China does this every day to get economic advantages.
-
05-23-20 18:07 #647Senior Member

Posts: 281I have never written that Sweden gain any GDP towards other countries because they are a little more open for a few months.
Originally Posted by McGrath
[View Original Post]
Did you mix the posts?
If lock-down is a clever strategy that do not harm the economy.
Why not locking down the economy for 2-3 years?
Future will show if Sweden or Spain / Italy / France will beg for money and loans from EU / ECB.
I never said that only Sweden counts Corona-dead people the right way.
I said that countries count in different ways.
In such case, comparing statistics with reported Corona-deaths between countries is worthless.
The only accurate way to compare countries is to count "excess deaths".
How many died this year compared to previous years.
-
05-23-20 17:51 #646Senior Member

Posts: 281Not nationalistic.
It is about economic rationality.
It was early well known which people were in the risk group of Covid-19: old people with underlying diseases like hypertension, diabetes, heart- and lung-problems.
A clever strategy would be to keep society open and focus on protection of the risk groups.
Anyway, politicians like Macron chose to isolate young and healthy people and slaughter the whole society, because "other countries did the same" or "China told us to lock-down".
"If all others do the same, then this strategy must be the correct one".
But here, China has a Hidden Agenda. China wants US and Europe to lock down, in order to get an economic lead.
Many European and US firms - as in the automobile sector - will soon wake up and find themselves in a real bad position.
There is absolutely no previous experience of total lock-down and the consequences of such a non-clever strategy.
Anyway, this extremely risky strategy has been applied.
It is not possible to pause the whole economy like an X-Box game, and then believe that everything will work as usual.
Important. Unemployment will cause deaths too, in the form of suicides, mental health and alcoholism. Often people with many remaining years to live will die. But these deaths are more abstract.
As I have written, Swedish Government made severe mistakes by not isolating risk groups at retirement homes.
Visits to elderly people at retirement homes were forbidden on April 1.
Secondary schools and universities - with no risk groups - were closed on March 17 ! Compare!
Sports arenas were closed even earlier.
When Swedish people returned from Austria and Italy in February, those working in Government administration (e.g. Departments, Central bank and different authorites) were sent home.
But returning people who worked at hospitals or retirement homes were not sent home! Not very clever.
I do not have any faith whatsoever for these immunity-tests performed in Sweden.
Huge numbers have been sick with Corona-symptoms in the period February-May in Sweden.
I also know people that have tested positive for immunity. But only those who were sick the last weeks. Not those that were sick in February and March.
We do not know which level of antibodies a person must possess to get a positive test result. Several tests have circulated in Sweden the last months.
Originally Posted by DeltaIndigo
[View Original Post]
-
05-23-20 17:30 #645Senior Member

Posts: 207First of all, everything about economics is wrong in that post. Sweden doesn't gain any GDP towards other countries because they are a little more open for a few months. I first came to Frankfurt because of the banks were there so I know some things about this.
Sweden is a small open economy with a floating currency, in the long view, how the rest of the world goes Sweden will go.
And the notion that Sweden is the only country that can count dead people the right way is ridicoulus.
-
05-23-20 16:10 #644Banned Member

Posts: 970History will tell as it always does, and the winners usually get to write the story. Lockdown or no lockdown is the question and the answer is simple. The lockdown slowed the virus spread, allowing governments, hospitals and medical providers to become more prepared. This came at great expense and is delaying the spread of the virus. Not locking down let's the virus spread and in vulnerable sections of society the cost of life is higher. The reall story will arrive if / when a safe vaccination is available. If this happens this summer, then lockdown proponents will celebrate their success in saving millions of lives. If the cavaccine doesn't arrive for another 10 years the chapter will already have been written and many countries around the world will have suffered great economic loss. Of course, the antivacs groups will stand in protest, saying the government is poisoning their children.
Originally Posted by DeltaIndigo
[View Original Post]
-
05-23-20 15:44 #643Senior Member

Posts: 743Not a bad answer
About one point, I would differ, I do know a lot about Stockholm, since I had lived there for over 3 years, but this was a long time ago. Your response is quite measured and temperate, however the arguments I have heard from others are really not rationale and are based upon certain tenets of faith. Well I am familiar with this blind faith and confidence which is inspired by nationalist feelings.
Originally Posted by Arnold15
[View Original Post]
I would just gently say this, about comparing to neighboring countries with similar climates and population densities (Denmark's is a lot higher though) you can see what the differing mortality rates from a severe vs a very relaxed lock down could be, really the fairest test would be the exact same environment, but this is obviously not possible.
The level of immunity should be higher in societies which have a more relaxed or no lock down, however it seems that in every systematic test in every place these numbers are far lower than the proponents of herd immunity have advocated. Some studies say it is up to 20% in New York, that could only be the case given its very high urban density, it would be far lower in LOS Angeles (I know both cities quite well) given the lock down in both places, I these the North American lock downs are far less strict than the European ones.
I would expect Sweden to have more people who are immune, but thus far these numbers as verified by studies are still far too low and the prediction of herd immunity by June or August is premature.
The assertion that these tests are flawed and many more people are surely immune is unfortunately just a matter of faith in the absence of hard evidence.
-
05-23-20 15:06 #642Senior Member

Posts: 281It is nothing wrong in that post.
Originally Posted by McGrath
[View Original Post]
I live in Stockholm and follow what happens here every day.
But people in this forum who DO NOT LIVE in Stockholm and who do not know what is going on here, seem to know more about Sweden than Swedish inhabitants.
Systematically referring to super-biased statistics.
And they do not know how to calculate "excess deaths".
And definitely do not understand what "the second wave" means.
Especially, they do not know what kind of mistakes the Swedish government did.
1. Not isolating people at retirement homes and 2. Not informing immigrant groups.
-
05-23-20 15:00 #641Senior Member

Posts: 8450Exactly what I was thinking and more, including a lack of knowledge regarding both medical science and history. But, enough said already.
Originally Posted by McGrath
[View Original Post]
-
05-23-20 14:39 #640Senior Member

Posts: 207With that post and all the wrongs in it you include yourself in your own statement.
Originally Posted by Arnold15
[View Original Post]

.png)







.png)
Reply With Quote


