Thread: American Politics
+
Add Report
Results 12,031 to 12,045 of 22482
-
10-01-22 19:09 #10452Senior Member

Posts: 2560Interesting post, thanks. Bloomberg and Brookings are both basing their stories on the Tax Policy Center. The Tax Policy Center was set up by the Urban Institute and Brookings Institute. It's not merely left of center, it's left wing, and staffed by Progressive economists. The change in after tax income is explained by our sharply progressive tax system. Overall, we have the most progressive tax system in the OECD, and the federal income tax is more progressive than sales taxes and property taxes. Anyway, if a low income earner is paying at an average 10% tax rate, and you cut his taxes by 10%, the increase in his after tax income is 1%. If an upper income earner is paying at 40%, and you cut his taxes by 5%, his after tax income increases by 2%. So yes, the upper income earner shows a larger increase in after tax income.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
You have a point when you say that all I looked at were the tax tables. I don't know everything that went into the TCJA. I make more than the average American, and my taxes went up. I have a real estate property in a foreign country that I hold through a foreign company. I have to pay at an 80%+ tax rate on income from the foreign property, because of the GILTI tax in TCJA! And I can't take full advantage of the state income tax deduction any longer. But certainly the TCJA helped Donald Trump, for example, a lot. The Trump Organization undoubtedly benefits greatly from the QBI deduction for pass through entities from income associated with high levels of depreciation.
Your sources are old and, being based on TPC analysis, biased. It would be better to look at actual, recent data. I pulled IRS tax statistics for 2017,2018 and 2019 (last year available), and compared tax rates for those years by income level. You can do this if you wish here.
https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-t...d-gross-income
The tax cuts took effect on January 1, 2018. It didn't really make a difference whether I looked at 2017 vs. 2018 or 2017 vs. 2019, overall the numbers looked similar. For 2017 vs. 2019, people earning $10,000 or less saw their taxes cut by 27% to 40%. That's not a big deal though, because they were paying little taxes to begin with. The big winners were people making $40,000 to $500,000. Their taxes went down from 16% to 18%. People making $20,00 to $40,000 and $500,000 to $1,000,000 saw cuts of 10% to 12%. Those who benefitted the least made in the range of $10,000 to $20,000 and $1 million+.
So this basically looked like another sop to the middle class, who account for the majority of voters. Which perhaps was the intention all along. One caveat, I'm not sure that the TCJA was entirely responsible for the changes in average tax rates, there may have been other factors at play.
Americans for Tax Reform, which like the Brookings Institute is biased, published this piece on how the tax system became more progressive after the TCJA. They don't really show cause and effect though. Anyway, their numbers are almost certainly correct:
https://www.atr.org/new-cbo-report-f...s-progressive/
Editorial Comment: One thing that amazes me, from the piece, is that the top 1% pays 41.7% of the income tax. And Democrats still say the wealthy don't pay their fair share. Democrats need to focus their efforts on helping those who aren't doing as well as the rest of us, instead of tearing down the people at the top. To their credit, Kyrsten Sinema and a few others do exactly that, despite the pressure from the progressives to concentrate on class warfare.
As to the corporate tax cuts, you really need to get over your Stockholm Syndrome and appreciate what's best for your stock portfolio and America. The effects of the tax cuts were reflected more in wages than in a reduced unemployment rate. We got to 3. 5% unemployment before COVID hit, the lowest since 1969. How much lower can you go? Real wages and household income took a huge jump upwards in 2019. As to capital spending, regardless of what the survey says, it jumped up after the TCJA. The "capital expenditures" component of stocks in the S&P 500 index was in the range of 71 to 76 in 2012 to 2017. It was 71.43 in 2017. It jumped up to 83.46 in 2019 and 90.90 in 2019.
A lot of money came back to the USA as a result of the TCJA. Companies were keeping it overseas because they'd have to pay up to 35% tax on it if they brought it back. Wharton said as much as $2. 8 trillion were parked overseas. I'm not sure how much of that came back, but through expansions, capital spending, dividends, share buybacks, and parking the money at USA Banks where it can be leant out, what money that did come back is now circulating in our economy.
I can't understand why anyone would take the position that the corporate tax rate didn't need to come down. Including state income taxes, our average rate was around 40%. The next highest in the developed world was Australia, at 30%. And Australia, unlike the USA, doesn’t tax dividends. Yeah, some companies with loopholes and who had subsidiaries in tax haven countries, were getting by just fine. (Aside: The TCJA helped in this regard with the GILTI tax that I was b*tching about above. Now companies can't park money overseas and avoid taxes from their foreign operations, because of TCJA.) But many of our companies just weren't competitive. Even Obama and Biden wanted to bring the rate down to 28%.
This will be my last post for a while. I've gotten addicted to replying to your posts and it's eating up way too much time. You're a worthy competitor on the battlefield of ideas, especially considering you're fighting from a much weaker position, having to defend the economic policies of a Democratic Party that's increasingly dominated by progressives.
P.S. If you want my Excel table or the capex data for the S & P 500 send me a PM with an email address. I cant link to them.
-
10-01-22 18:00 #10451Regular Member

Posts: 1056Angels on the head of a pin
Here is a thought: all Americans are war mongering sociopaths. Every last one of them. Nice numerical cut off points but little good to all the others murdered by Americans and their proxies. Despite the considerable competition, Americans are far and away the scummiest war mongers the world has ever seen.
-
10-01-22 17:54 #10450Senior Member

Posts: 2560Please note my disclaimer: While my numbers are correct, I don't believe this. Democrats aren't any bigger war mongers than Republicans. This is part of an intervention, to try to help Tooms recognize spurious correlations and Double Think, and to cure his Stockholm Syndrome.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
This is an attempt to try to get you to understand, for example, GDP growth is lower when a once-in-a-hundred-year pandemic strikes. And higher after we're rebounding from the worst depression in USA History. And neither has anything to do with whether a Republican or Democrat is president.
-
10-01-22 15:26 #10449Senior Member

Posts: 8037Got anything yet?
Forgive the "simplistic" approach, Paulie. But it has been several days since I offered this exceedingly simple challenge and so far not one person has come up with a single item. Including you. Maybe you didn't see it so I will repost it here and now for you.
Originally Posted by Paulie97
[View Original Post]
Yes, I was trying to make it as simple and easy as possible for any pro-Repub Bothsider or outright Repub supporter to jump in, meet or beat this simple challenge and show me the way.
However, unless someone wants to highlight and praise the 2-3 worst Great Repub Depressions / Great Repub Recessions and Massive Jobs Destruction in history as fine examples of what Repubs can "accomplish" with legislation they pass while occupying the White House and controlling both houses of Congress, I'm afraid we're not going to see much of a list here:
Shall we dance through a short list of legislation passed when a Dem was in the White House and Dems controlled both Houses of Congress?
Social Security. A favorite of yours I believe.
Medicare. Ditto above.
Medicaid.
Unemployment Insurance.
The Civil Rights Act.
401 ks For Rank and File Employees.
The 1993 Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act.
The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act.
The Affordable Care Act.
The American Rescue Plan.
The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act.
The CHIPS and Science Act of 2022.
The Inflation Reduction Act.
To name just a few.
Ok, now it's your turn or anyone else's turn. Please list a few legislation highlights from when a Repub was in the White House and Repubs controlled both Houses of Congress.
-
10-01-22 14:52 #10448Senior Member

Posts: 8037How does that help your Bothsider argument?
Ok, let's go with your idea.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
With the constant and most common denominator for crap economic results being a Repub in the White House, accompanying oil shocks and all ("August 2001 PDB? What August 2001 PDB"? GW Bush might well have asked in September of that year), I guess the only conclusion is when Dems control Congress during those times the Repub POTUS is just plain ineffectual and unable to prevent those dastardly Dems from fucking up his economy. By contrast, Dems in the White House can somehow manage to get some positive things done anyway with Repubs controlling Congress.
So how does that support your contention again?
My contention still is that any legislation proposed, fought for and passed by Dem Presidents and Dems in Congress is diminished in its effectiveness and positive results with every Repub vote it receives. Why wouldn't that be so if those are votes are coming from people who think this government of, by and for We, The People and nobody else "is the problem" and have gleefully gone to war against it?
Oh, and on that last point, if Repubs are so effective and positive either when they are in the White House or when they control Congress, why have they never proposed and passed a single piece of meaningful legislation or anything whatsoever worthy of being revered and cited as something that Makes America Great when they controlled BOTH the White House and Congress over the past century?
I challenged you and anyone else here to rack their brains, rip through Google Search and come up with the list of legislation even remotely rivalling that of Dems when they were in the White House and controlled both houses of Congress. That was several days ago. So far not one person has been able to come up with anything.
I mean, we know they produced 2-3 of worst Great Repub Recessions and Crashes in history thanks to the legislation they came up with under those circumstances. But I was hoping to be surprised by something, you know, a bit more positive than those Repub "accomplishments. ".
-
10-01-22 14:17 #10447Senior Member

Posts: 8037Japan attacked our military base at Pearl Harbor and then Germany declared war on America in WWII. Do you really think that meant America "chose" to go to war with them?
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Eisenhower committed America to the Vietnam War by word, deed and treaty:
Southeast Asia and the Vietnam War
https://media.defense.gov/2019/Feb/2...ology%20v1.pdf
USA military body bags were being returned from Vietnam long before Kennedy was elected. The change Kennedy made was in allowing our troops to shoot back.1959
May 25: With authorization from the White House, Adm. Harry Felt, the
CINCPAC, told General Williams that U.S. advisors with the ARVN could
accompany Vietnamese troops on operations, provided they do not become
involved in actual combat. Historian Fredrik Logevall called this new order
highly significant. To this point, U.S. troops had been confined to corps
and division headquarters, training commands, and logistic agencies and
had been obligated to remain behind whenever their units were on patrol.
Now they would be in the field, in harms way, their advising duties greatly
expanded. U.S. personnel had been participating in patrols before this time,
unofficially, including Williams himself on occasion.59
July 8: Six Vietnamese communist guerrillas attacked the quarters of the
thirteen-man U.S. advisory detachment at Bien Hoa. Two U.S. soldiers,
Maj. Dale R. Buis and MSgt. Chester M. Ovnand, died in the assault,
the first U.S. servicemen killed in action in Vietnam since Lt. Col. Peter
Dewey in 1945 (see Sept. 26, 1945). Buis and Ovnard are the first two
names that appear on the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington.63
-
10-01-22 13:41 #10446Senior Member

Posts: 8037Details. Remember?
I'm sure you just forgot about the phase outs, catch up increased taxes and cleverly concealed and delayed costs to the lower and middle income earners in order to "pay for" those disproportionately high tax cuts for corporations and top margins, the ones that wouldn't phase out, diabolically timed to kick in after certain subsequent midterm and general elections as I recall. Even Hitler wouldn't have done that. But it was in all the news at the time. That was one of the reasons "retiring" Senator John McCain slammed it. However, being a Repub he signed it anyway.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Nice try though.
A Year After the Middle Class Tax Cut, the Rich Are Winning.
December 18, 2018
https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2...-consequences/
Once the tax bill is paid for, low- and middle-income households will be worse off.Distribution of Trump Tax Cuts Favors Wealthiest
On average, in 2018, taxes declined for everyone, but top groups got the biggest benefit
Income group (Average income)
Percent change in after-tax income
Lowest quintile ($14,170) - 0.4%
Second quintile ($36,450) - 1.2%
Middle quintile ($65,640) - 1.6%
Fourth quintile ($114,370) - 1.9%
Top quintile ($347,940) - 2.9%
Source: Tax Policy Center estimates
Note: Average federal tax (includes individual and corporate income tax, payroll taxes for Social Security and Medicare, the estate tax, and excise taxes) as a percentage of average expanded cash income.
January 2, 2018
https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-fr...-be-worse-off/
Remember when Trump proclaimed he was going to be the "most job-creating president in the history of the universe" or some such nonsense? He sold that god-awful waste of $2. 5+ Trillion in taxpayers' money on that premise and on his prediction that it would drive Real Annual GDP growth up to "3%, 4%, 5%, some people say 6% LOL. It never hit 3%.The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) will cut taxes by almost $1.5 trillion over the next decade, largely benefiting corporations, pass-through businesses such as partnerships, and people who inherit large estates. The bill will also provide modest tax reductions for most wage and salary earners.
Though some households will do better than others, it sounds like almost everyone is a winner at first glance. But tax cuts are not free; they eventually have to be financed with higher taxes or lower spending. And once those financing requirements are taken into account, most low- and middle-income households are likely to be worse off than they would have been without the tax cut in the first place.
Previous TPC analysis shows that households in every income group will be better off on average due to the direct provisions of the tax cut. However, after accounting for a plausible financing mechanismin which the tax cuts would be paid for with equal-per-household increases in taxes or reductions in benefitsmany low- and middle-income households will lose more than what they gain from the tax cuts themselves.
(and more)
Did Trumps tax cuts boost hiring? Most companies say no.
January 28, 2019
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy...mpanies-say-no
Yeah, I'm pretty sure if those tax cuts had benefitted the lower and middle income earners as much or more than they did corporations and the top margins and not made those lower and middle income earners "pay for" Trump's Classic Repub tax cuts for the rich, the Trump economy would not have produced 1. 5 Million fewer jobs with those $2. 5 Trillion cuts than without the cuts.The vast majority of American businesses havent boosted hiring or investment as a result of the Republican tax law, according to a survey by the National Association for Business Economics.
Eighty-four percent of businesses said they didnt accelerate hiring because of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which President Donald Trump hailed as a bill for the middle class and a bill for jobs. Only 6 percent said they had more hires because of the law and 10 percent said they accelerated investments, according to the survey.
But they didn't.
Actually, Biden and the Dems "extending" them as they were originally set DID cut taxes for lower and middle income earners since allowing them to do what they were destined to do re increasing costs for those marginal earners instead of cutting costs for them.
Dems, the Party of Meaningful Tax Cuts, Strike Again!
-
10-01-22 12:19 #10445Senior Member

Posts: 2001Bothsidesism, care to substantiate any of its claims?
Yep, I've said it before, about the "bothsidesist". The dude does not put in the work, to provide support to substantiate any of his claims / arguments. Next he'll tell ya to go read "book xyz" from "Joe Author", that'll explain all my "say so".
Originally Posted by EihTooms12
[View Original Post]
And now he's piggy-backing and riding on Tiny 12 "data / evidence" coat tails, and pawning off the work, as if its his own findings, as if he did the work.
-
10-01-22 12:14 #10444Senior Member

Posts: 2001Doing the work to substantiate your claims
BTW, I will say this however, you do, do the work and unlike the arch "bothsidesist", you do provide actual evidence, data and information to substantiate, support or refute said opinions / claims.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
10-01-22 07:19 #10443Senior Member

Posts: 2001Huh...being "right"?
What are you talking about??? Not that there is anything wrong with being a right-wing evangelist, but that rant just sound like one. Just saying!
Originally Posted by Tiny 12
[View Original Post]
Look just because any BM here, in this discussion/opinion forum, is in disagreement with the arguments you put forth, be it, a Dem, Repub, QAnon, Bothsidesist, left, right or otherwise, is not a case IMHO about being "right".
Any political discourse, counterpoints or information I present is meant to frame and/or support my POV. I don't really care if you think, I'm simply trying to be "right".
You, Tiny 12 and the arch "bothsidesist", who stands for nothing and falls for everything, seem to think, we somehow need to accept/agree the arguments you put forth. WE DON'T!
Let me put it to you like this:
One BM here, thinks Donnie "the Devil" J. Dummkopf (aka. the 45th pres. aka.Agent Orange) is a god, meanwhile I personally think he's a devil.
Is he right, I am I right? He'll continue to provide whatever opinions/evidence to support his claims and so will I.
While I may find his opinions/claims distasteful, I reserve the right for him to make them. The only "right(s)" that I'm concerned with is, equal rights, people's rights, human rights, civil rights, voting rights...etc
For me it's that simple. I am not here to be "right", as you see it. I'll provide my counterpoints, arguments and opinions and let them stand or fall on their own.
If you have an opinion on said topics and provide arguments to support your POV and not just here to BM bash or bash America, then I welcome your input.
-
10-01-22 05:26 #10442Senior Member

Posts: 8037We all know the fix for that
Oh, sorry, but if you don't like FDR (or JFK / LBJ, Carter, Clinton, Obama and now Biden) getting credit for pulling us out of serious economic downturns and catastrophes, the fix is for the American electorate to prevent the Repubs that preceeded them from producing serious economic downturns and catastrophes.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
And from all available historic evidence the only way to prevent them from doing that is to vote all Dem down every ballot every time. Once in, Repubs apparently can't help but produce those results. And a vote for a Third Party candidate or not voting typically results in Repubs winning. So those last two are not options for America avoiding the next Great Repub Depression / Recession, Massive Jobs Destruction and Catastrophe.
Hoover famously exacerbated the Great Repub Depression with his Smoot-Hawley Tariffs and his Classic Repub mistake of providing Supply-Side / Trickle-Down government aid and spending on the exact wrong people. The Great Repub Depression didn't just "hit" or "happen" on Hoover's watch.
Coronavirus was another endemic viral spread that very likely could have been contained or at least significantly damage reduced had the leaders of the proven Pandemic Prevention and Response teams not gone missing where they were needed most for more than a year by Trump contrary to all expert warnings not to do something so dangerous and stupid. And especially had Trump not compounded that disastrous decision by spending critical year 2020 doing, lying and saying everything a World Leader could do, lie about and say to make sure it would become the historically deadly economy and global supply-chain-destroying and Inflation producing Trump's Pandemic it became.
Those were Trump economic decisions. Trump's Pandemic didn't just "hit" or "happen" on his watch.
-
10-01-22 05:25 #10441Senior Member

Posts: 2560Here are tax cuts from the Republican's 2017 TCJA, calculated as (1- (marginal rate after tax cut)/(marginal tax rate before tax cut)), for single filers at particular levels of income:
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
$30,000 - 20% tax cut.
$50,000 - 12% tax cut.
$100,000 - 14% tax cut.
$250,000 - 6% tax increase.
$400,000 - 6% tax increase.
$1,000,000 - 6. 5% tax cut.
https://taxfoundation.org/historical...ates-brackets/
The tax cut was not disproportionately directed to higher income earners. In fact, it made the tax system more progressive.
I take issue with your statement: "Then the beauty of Dem leadership is you get the superior economic results without invading Poland and creating the Holocaust. " Strictly speaking this is true, as no Democratic President has invaded Poland. Yet. However, please see my post below about the correlation between Democratic Presidents and major wars. The Democrats are a bloodthirsty lot, disposed to sacrifice many lives so they can juice the economy and get more votes come election time.
Disclaimer: I actually don't believe this, the part about bloodthirsty Democrats. This is part of an intervention, to try to help Tooms recognize spurious relationships and Double Think, and to cure his Stockholm Syndrome.
HOWEVER, In general, GDP growth during wars and their aftermath when Democrats were president was very good -- there were a few years with 18%+ GDP growth. Does this deserve consideration if you're trying to show that Republicans are worse than Hitler at managing the economy? Why of course not.
-
10-01-22 04:43 #10440Senior Member

Posts: 8037You got it
Yes, Carter's reduction of the Capital gains tax from 35% to 28% along with his guidance to require companies to offer the tremendous tax-deferred long term retirement investment advantage of 401 k accounts to their rank and file employees and not just their top executives and Clinton's exemption of $500,000 for marrieds and $250,000 for singles on the equity of their primary residence sale every few years, just to name two, were far and away greater "wealth generating" tax and economic policy results for many, many more Americans than all of the piddling Repub 3-5% marginal tax cuts dangled over the heads of middle and lower income margin earners while those utterly useless disproportionately high tax cuts for the wealthy stood by slack-jawed stupid and useless during the following next Great Repub Recession and Massive Jobs Destruction.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
You know, the Great Repub Recessions that always require a huge influx of deficit spending, government intervention and government expansion to pull us out of them because those brave free market top marginal income "job creators" who got the big tax cuts can't be coaxed out from under their beds without it?
Of course, that comes right before "smaller government" Repubs start repealing decades long precedent Rights To Privacy in order to invade our bedrooms, bathrooms, up asses, vaginas and around penises to outlaw sex for pleasure and restrict it for the purpose of procreation only.
-
10-01-22 04:08 #10439Senior Member

Posts: 8037Uh
I already posted the link and report for what those Spineless Ryan, Moscow Mitch and Traitor Trump tax cuts accomplished; costing American taxpayers $2. 5+ Trillion just so corporate executives could buy their own company stocks.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Other than that, nothing. That is a Classic Repub tax policy result going back to Coolidge / Hoover. Well, that is, if we generously ignore the infrastructure projects, real jobs creation, border control and crime prevention investment opportunities lost by flushing all that money down the shitter as another Classic Repub tax and economic policy "accomplishment. ".
Yes, that helped keep Trump's stock market record afloat. So what? The stock market is not "the economy. " The reason the stock market also performs notably better under Dem stewardship than Repub stewardship is precisely because of those numbskull Repub tax and economic policy and agenda decisions and results that no Dem did nor should have supported and voted for.
-
10-01-22 02:43 #10438Senior Member

Posts: 2560I don't see where you're disagreeing with me, except to say the Spidy and Tooms tribe is always clearly right. Well, someday Joe Biden is going to say that all the Democrats will be raptured and go to heaven. And all the Republicans will stay behind on earth. And he's going to set a date. And all the Democrats are going to say Biden is clearly right. And when that day passes and you're still here, I wonder what you and Tooms are going to say. It's going to be the Democrat Tribe's "January 6 moment. " I can't wait!
Originally Posted by Spidy
[View Original Post]

.png)







Reply With Quote


