Thread: American Politics
+
Add Report
Results 11,176 to 11,190 of 22479
-
01-03-23 20:06 #11304Senior Member

Posts: 2560In your last couple of posts, you appear to say the massive fiscal stimulus in 2021 was justified so that Democrats would do better in the Mid Terms. That is, Biden and the Democrats were trying to buy elections by giving away free money. Fair enough. Like your evidence that the stimulus depleted inventories, it makes sense.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
This is a hoot:
"It worked so well that now, less than 2 years after the Biden stimulus was put into the system and with NO more economic stimulus expected to emanate from the House, as predicted, there is a moderate surplus of goods and products in inventories."
Well, after "it" (the American Rescue Plan or ARP) was passed and $1400 checks were sent out, the Inventories / Sales ratio, from your graph, dropped from 1.24 to 1.10, in one month. And it's only come back to 1.22 since. So apparently we've just gotten back to where we started, before the ARP, in replenishing inventories.
I enjoyed this as well.
"What do you suppose that will do to prices? Suppliers hate it but aren't going to shut down again in protest. They can't. There is still abundantly more economic stimulus in the form of Infrastructure activity on the way."
The reason factories all over the world cut back on production was because they couldn't sell as much as before. Many had to either make cuts or go bankrupt. You initially had lower demand, and also the supply chain disruptions. So you want them to keep churning out products, just let them pile up, when they can't be sold? And go bankrupt? That makes even less sense than the Biden Administration's reasoning that oil and gas companies should ramp up production, to improve the Democrats' prospects for the mid term elections, when the Progressive Democratic platform threatens their very existence.
Interest expense on our massive national debt has increased a lot. Debt held by the public is $24 trillion. At 4% interest, that would be $960 billion per year. Given that Federal Revenues in 2022 were about $4.9 trillion, that's huge. I don't know how we're ever going to pay down significant debt. Biden and Trump and the Democrats apparently didn't think about that when they were passing COVID relief spending amounting to 25% of GDP. Or when the Democrats were passing legislation to add an additional $3 trillion in spending, in addition to the ARP, over the last couple of years.
As to "Democratic Demand Side Economics", Keynes would be rolling over in his grave. He never envisioned continually growing debt as a % of GDP. He favored paying down the debt when times were good, like Larry Summers and Bill Clinton, working with a Republican Congress, did in the late 1990's. The ARP was passed when annualized QoQ GDP growth was 6.3%, and unemployment had declined from 12.90% of the workforce to 6. 2%. Things were on the mend. Yeah, at that point it didn't make sense to start paying down debt. But a $1. 9 trillion, largely untargeted fiscal stimulus, was way over the top. It would have made sense then, and now, to target more aid, for example, in ways that would help poor children. But as Summers has noted, the ARP crowded out those kind of socially beneficial programs.
-
01-03-23 19:41 #11303Senior Member

Posts: 2560Again, this sounds like the Democratic equivalent of a QAnon conspiracy theory to me.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
When I Google "How many lives did the Trump Vaccines save" I get articles and papers that estimate from 2 to 3 million in the USA, and 20 million worldwide! And that's just during the first year or two after the vaccines became available! President Trump himself said the Trump Vaccines may save up to 100 million lives!
Thank You President Trump! And Thank You Moderna, BioNTech and Pfizer!
-
01-03-23 16:17 #11302Senior Member

Posts: 1604Actually, no
You have proposed phrasing as an or and, in truth, the correct phrasing should have been and. In other words: "(a) Trump is a compulsive liar, and (b) Trump believes his own bull shit. "
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
01-03-23 05:46 #11301Senior Member

Posts: 8036Global supply-chains snapped out of it and reopened, goods and products began to be manufactured again, shipping and deliveries were made. It wasn't just the prospect of a couple of stimulus check shots in the arm. That would not have been enough to produce the seismic change necessary to deal with this unprecedented Great Repub Downturn. No, they would need to know it was overwhelming.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
And as any real world political historian knew, it would only be about 2021, as big and as early as possible, and some of 2022 before the campaigns began. That's it.
All with only 1 Senate seat buffer between getting ANYTHING done and getting NOTHING done for every minute of every hour and every day from January 20,2021 until today.
Otherwise, you, Larry and I could sit around with our Thoughts and Prayers waiting for Zimbabwe to step up to the plate and provide enough assurance to those global supply-chains to snap out of it and get moving strong enough to start supplying the globe again.
Thanks, Joe.
It worked so well that now, less than 2 years after the Biden stimulus was put into the system and with NO more economic stimulus expected to emanate from the House, as predicted, there is a moderate surplus of goods and products in inventories. That is exactly where any thinking economist would have hoped we would be by now but might not have believed was possible at the end of 2020.
What do you suppose that will do to prices? Suppliers hate it but aren't going to shut down again in protest. They can't. There is still abundantly more economic stimulus in the form of Infrastructure activity on the way.
So the pendulum swung back a bit too far. No biggie. It swung. And in a direction favoring the consumer this time. It is now in position to settle into a normal range.
Thanks, Joe.
Dem Demand-Side economics vs Repub Supply-Side economics.
-
01-03-23 05:34 #11300Senior Member

Posts: 2560Good post Elvis, interesting debate
The elderly got vaccinated in larger percentages than younger people. And presumably so did individuals that were at higher risk as a result of diabetes, heart disease, etc. However, if you segment into age groups, I think you'd be right Elvis. And that's the correct way to look at the numbers, comparing death and hospitalization rates for people with similar ages.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
I think your percentages are in the ballpark. However, hospitalization and death rates are a couple of orders of magnitude higher in older and high risk people compared to the young and healthy. For them COVID is still a significant concern. And if everyone in the USA gets Omicron and one in a thousand die, that's 300,000 people. I'm not sure about the tank style immune system analogy. The way I think about it is you can get your immunity from infection or you can get it from vaccinations. And it's easier and safer getting it from the vaccinations.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
Again, I'm thinking from the perspective of someone who's older or higher risk. If you're 30 years old, I think your analogy makes more sense.
Yeah, 40,000 people sounds like a lot. The writer admits he knows about as much about statistics as I do, meaning not very much. Intuitively, 21 deaths from all causes in the mRNA group and 17 in the placebo group doesn't sound like a significant difference to me. In 2020, around 10% of deaths in the USA were attributed to COVID. So maybe you'd expect about 2 more deaths in the placebo group (10% of 19), and you actually had 4 more in the mRNA group. I believe this is statistically insignificant. I'd put a lot more stock in larger studies that show much higher COVID death and hospitalization rates in the unvaccinated. Although, admittedly, unlike the Pfizer trial, IF YOU SEGMENT BY AGE GROUPS, you may have the handicap you mentioned, that perhaps the vaccinated were healthier to begin with.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
I'm a huge fan. I think the Mickey Mouse / China episode Randy mentions might be my favorite.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
I'm an agnostic on natural vs. Lab origin. It's awfully suspicious that the disease arose in Wuhan. But there have been bat cornaviruses obtained in the wild that were much closer genetically to COVID 19 than SARS. I'm reading that SARS is closer to the original COVID 19 coronavirus than the original virus is to some recent Omicron variants. Anyway, this is above my paygrade. There are some very smart people on both sides of the debate who do nothing except study viruses. The original consensus was natural origin, but the majority may agree with you now. Robert Redfield does anyway.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
There was no magic solution. Look at what's happening in China today. We muddled through, like everyone else. Earlier on I was very critical of Trump. But looking back, I don't know how much of a difference he really could have made. He did push Operation Warp Speed, and helped get FDA approvals in record time. Lockdowns suck. If you can strap on N95 or KN95 masks and get on with business, or stay home if you're sick, that might have been the best approach. But it's easier said than done.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
And also because everyone now has at least some immunity from previous infection and vaccination.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
I'm under 65 and I'd take it, but then like I mentioned before I'm a big fan of drugs and vaccines, in general.
Originally Posted by Elvis2008
[View Original Post]
-
01-03-23 04:54 #11299Senior Member

Posts: 2560
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
I've agreed with you, extensively, in two posts, that supply chain glitches were partly responsible for inflation. Other causes were too much fiscal stimulus (Biden's American Rescue Plan - the ARP - in particular), and a Fed that was asleep at the wheel. After the Democrats unwisely decided to throw gasoline on the fire in 2021 with the ARP and inflation went up, the Fed should have started raising interest rates, but it didn't.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
About the inventories to sales ratio, yes, you see a big drop when those $1400 per person stimulus checks hit. The IRS started mailing out the checks on March 12. And the ratio falls from 1.24 in February to 1.10 in March. Why did that happen? Because people spent that Biden money. Retail Sales, SEASONALLY ADJUSTED*, went from $503 billion in February, 2021 to $558 billion in March! One of your fellow Democrats on another hooker board happily remarked that several of his buddies had gone out and bought big screen TV's with their Biden Money.
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RSXFS
I never said that excess demand from excessive fiscal stimulus depleted inventories and partly caused supply chain glitches. But now that you bring it up, it makes a lot of sense. Yes, I think we can blame the ARP for creating too much demand, and the supply chain just couldn't keep up with it!
*They adjust for February just having 28 days.
-
01-03-23 02:46 #11298Senior Member

Posts: 8036Not just Barron
Trump told Woodward he told Barron a 2 month heads up would have been enough to prevent the spread in China from becoming Trump's Pandemic.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
He told the world his intel was that "three or four months" could have done it:
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...-a9416406.html
Yeah, China is always secretive. That's why we embeded science officials in their labs to guide, monitor and issue effective warnings to the world of potential Pandemics early enough to prevent them from emerging in the first place."All of the people the talent that we have would have loved to have had three or four months of additional time, Mr Trump said at the White House. They didnt have that time. They read about it in the newspapers like everybody else.
He added: China was very secretive. Very, very secretive. And thats unfortunate.
You know, the ones Trump inexplicably removed from those China labs 5 months earlier. Guess he hadn't heard about that China "secrecy" thingy by then.
Notice he apparently never told anyone a "5 month" heads up would have done it, carefully avoiding the actual amount if time his disastrous decision involved. Perhaps for fear that a review of what was happening over there "5 months" earlier would draw direct attention to his removing the agents whose job it was to do exactly that while looking back just "2 months" or "three or four months" would not show anyone was there to monitor and issue those warnings anyway. Because he had removed them 5 months earlier.
That is a form of misdirection, a sign that he is aware of his responsibility in our not getting the heads up we needed to prevent Trump's Pandemic. And I would say that is strong evidence that he does not believe his own lies. He is knowingly trying to con everyone with his lies, not merely blathering stuff he believes to be true but isn't true.
Same as he did about everything significant and insignificant, from his prowess as a businessman, the size of his inauguration crowd, the state of the economy he inherited from Obama, the state of it as the result of his stewardship, the virulence and mode of spread of coronavirus, whether or when it will go away without a vaccine, who won the 2022 presidential election, Putin's intel vs America's intel, Trump University, Trump's Election Defense Fund, etc.
If he actually believed any of the lies and nonsense he blathered all these years then he is the dumbest fucker on two feet. And whether having millions and millions of Americans willing and eager to support as so-called president and vote for the dumbest fucker on two feet is worse or better than their supporting and voting for the most blatantly obvious compulsive liar and con man on two feet is an interesting but somewhat unimportant question.
-
01-02-23 23:47 #11297Senior Member

Posts: 2560It feels like deja vu all over again!
Hmmm, Trump lied to his son, Baron. Does that mean that.
(a) Trump is a compulsive liar, or.
(b) Trump believes his own bull shit.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
01-02-23 23:00 #11296Senior Member

Posts: 4845Tiny, that is not placebo controlled comparisons. People who got vaccinated by and large are healthier than people who did not.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
And when you state percent reduction, that is a meme that helps whatever intervention you want. It sounds good but is almost meaningless. I think omicron has a less than 1% hospitalization rate and the official death rate is really close to one in a thousand but in reality it is probably even lower than that. And if it the vaccine does anything, it is on the basis of the tank style immune system that destroys both good and bad tissue which means it is not free from side effects. And it is not always cut and dry if someone was admitted to a hospital with a condition caused by Covid or if Covid was just along for the ride.
When the gold standard trial was designed and a true apples to apples comparison was made, there were more people who died in the vaccine group: https://medium.com/microbial-instinc...y-6d89b1de0c8d.
It is BS then for people to claim vaccines prevent death when the best evidence shows they do not. The only thing the vaccines were scientifically proven to do was to prevent a person from catching one strain of Covid that no longer is around.
I do not know if you are a South Park fan Tiny, but here is their explanation of how the virus spead: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNMRD9nCASw.
It is hilarious but the sad part is that it is more believable than the idiotic explanation given by our government leaders.
Of course, the virus came from a lab, and China took down all the info it had about the virus down of his web sites. And China was actively feeding the USA and other nations disinformation on how bad the virus really was. No USA rep would have been able to do squat in China.
The other part that gets me is we have a bat biting a pangolin and the pangolin runs a thousand miles to Wuhan and somehow gets into the wet market there. No other animals were found to have Covid then but post pandemic we now know of other animals that have Covid. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019...g/animals.html.
So hang with me for a second. The government says it did not cause Covid, a pangolin and bat did. And even though Covid started via animal transmission, we think locking down people and only people will cure Covid. We do not need to lock down animals (even bats and pangolins) to cure Covid. What gets me is how convoluted you have to get to buy this government is good BS, but you have guys like Tooms eating it up.
To him, the virus was not created by government. Government lockdowns worked and would have worked even better if more Republicans would have complied, and the reason the Covid epidemic is over is because of vaccines.
In reality, the pandemic is mostly over because the virus mutated into a less virulent form like most viruses do, which is what Trump correctly said would happen, and the government interventions ranged from helping a bit to doing nothing to causing great harm. All in all, government intervention was a huge negative. It is just if you are beaten over the head with a news story day after day, people want to think you can do something about it.
And with Paxlovid, there is often a rebound effect with it. You get better and then sick again. This happened to both Fauci and Biden when they took the drug.
But yeah, if you are under 65, there is no reason to take the drug. There is no benefit and a risk of side effects, none appear too severe as of yet but you never know.
-
01-02-23 20:14 #11295Senior Member

Posts: 8036Another chart
Well, it looks likes Trump's 2020 stimulus checks and the USA domestic auto sales weren't enough economic stimulation to get global supply-chains back up and moving all that much after all. If anything, America might have done more to get those chains filling inventories even faster on all retail markets.
Retailers: Inventories to Sales Ratio:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RETAILIRSA
Shhh. Don't tell Larry Summers the 2021 stimulus probably should have been bigger.
-
01-02-23 19:55 #11294Senior Member

Posts: 8036I'm right
Then I guess everyone on the planet was wrong about the collapse of global supply-chains by the end if 2020 and into 2021 and the suppliers were just faking it. Proven by your USA Domestic auto sales charts.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Oh wait. Trump was already sending stimulus checks in 2020 and maybe that triggered some auto sales. Gee, I wonder why that wasn't enough to set worldwide economies up and get global supply-chains moving again. Yeah, they were just faking it.
-
01-02-23 15:44 #11293Senior Member

Posts: 2560So you’ve got nothing to refute my points
You're wrong about demand from consumers with money in their pockets. By the fall of 2020, retail sales, adjusted for inflation, were at all time highs.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RSXFS
And unit auto sales were close to pre-pandemic levels.
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TOTALSA
Look at the 5 year series.
Thanks for putting me in the same category as Larry Summers. That's very kind, but I don't know jack about macroeconomics compared to him.
-
01-02-23 15:29 #11292Senior Member

Posts: 8036Just two dots to connect. Big ones. Very close to each other. Not complicated.
https://news.yahoo.com/bob-woodward-...091902598.html
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Trump says China should have told us about coronavirus. He removed the official meant to do that.Talking to Woodward on March 19, 2020, Trump said Barron, then 13, asked what was going on and he answered: I said, it came out of China, Barron. Pure and simple. It came out of China. And it shouldve been stopped. And to be honest with you, Barron, they shouldve let it be known it was a problem two months earlier ... the world wouldnt have a problem. We could have stopped it easily.
A US epidemiologist was embedded with the Chinese CDC. The Trump administration discontinued the position.
March 23, 2020
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-polit...dc-embed-quick
The Trump administration told the United States embed at the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) that the position would be defunded, causing her to leave her post in July 2019, according to a report from Reuterss Marisa Taylor. The embed helped train Chinese public health experts and served in part as a liaison between Chinese officials and their counterparts in the US.
With the administration planning to discontinue the role, the embed return to the US about five months before China began to see its first Covid-19 cases. Under normal circumstances, the embed likely would have passed information about the novel virus to US officials. Instead, Chinese officials were able for weeks to conceal the virus and the threat it posed, leading to a delay in the worlds response to what was then a matter of great concern and is now a pandemic.
-
01-02-23 08:44 #11291Senior Member

Posts: 8036So you've got nothing to refute my point
I was so looking forward to your explanation for why and how all those global manufacturers, supply-chains, shipping and delivery firms would magically put Trillions into staffing up, cranking up factories, producing abundant supplies of goods and products and be poised to fill orders, ship and deliver ASAP in the wake of Trump's Pandemic's unprecedented 2-tear economic coma and millions upon millions of jobs wiped out long BEFORE there was overwhelming demand from customers with MONEY in their pockets ready to be spent so as to, you know, make sure even the first customers out of the gate would not be inconvenienced by a pesky low supply-high demand rate of inflation.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Alas, you've got nothing for the real problem at hand in the real world as it really exists. As usual. You and Larry Summers.
-
01-01-23 22:50 #11290Senior Member

Posts: 2560That's a new one, Crooks and Liars, a Progressive media site dedicated to calling Republicans crooks and liars. Well, Americans need to pull their heads out of the sand. Most of the politicians at the federal level are crooks and liars. The only exceptions in my book are some of the Republicans who Trump made unelectable.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
The one substantive point you make in your post, with basis in fact, is about supply chains. I've already addressed this in a previous reply. Supply chains are fucked up partly because of lockdowns in China, which again I presume you and many other Democrats would support if you were Chinese, based on your criticisms of Trump and Republican governors. Then there were the Trump tariffs, which Biden could have remedied with the stroke of a pen. Instead he piled more restrictions on China, and the result is wholesale re-construction of supply chains to avoid Chinese production.
Also there's the war in Ukraine / Russia, which sent fuel prices up, re-routed Russian oil, gas and coal to new markets, and caused grain prices to go up and grain supply to go down. You and I may dislike Trump, but my guess is none of this would have happened if he'd been re-elected. Furthermore, Democrats' existential threats to the fossil fuels industry in the USA (banning drilling on federal leases, banning fracking, going too fast to net "0" carbon emissions) definitely increased the cost of electricity and natural gas used for heating and industrial applications in the U.S. And made it more difficult for USA LNG to serve as a partial replacement for Russian gas supplies to Europe. The effect on gasoline prices wasn't as great, but still there to an extent.
And how about the effect of the American Rescue Plan on logistics in America, in 2021? Poorly targeted extended unemployment benefits and other handouts (e.g. $1400 checks to most Americans) discouraged work. A lot of younger American males, many of whom could have worked in warehouses and driving trucks and the like, decided to sit on their asses at home. And then there was the situation in the California ports. American businesses came up with a list of solutions for the port hang ups, and the Newsome administration basically told them to fuck off.

.png)







Reply With Quote


