Thread: Stupid Shit in Kyiv
+
Add Report
Results 3,031 to 3,045 of 4602
-
01-31-23 16:19 #1572Senior Member

Posts: 1956Lol
Why not display some intestinal fortitude and articulate an argument rather than just drop links that aren't even to any specific videos or articles? Colonel McGregor is a Putin buttboy. There's a slew of US generals both on the right and left that staunchly disagree with him. The American Conservative is a far right, isolationist publication founded by the bigot and Nazi sympathizer Pat Buchanan.
Originally Posted by Questner
[View Original Post]
The bottom line is that it's in both our national interest and that of our European allies that borders are not changed through aggression. We also can't afford to shrink at nuclear saber rattling given the precedent it would set. Putin needs to fail and he's going to. Russia since the fall of the USSR has been repeatedly invited to join the civilized world but has refused. They will remain our enemy until they change their minds. But I and others have covered this ad nauseam in the recent past, calling out the whataboutism and other deflections and faulty analysis from far right advocates like Kerzog, I believe was the name, and Drama Queen also. I'm not doing it all over again as the work was already completed, but I encourage anyone curious to look up my posts on this thread.
P.S. Thankfully this isolationist angle represents a minority view among Republicans and that's much more so the case among Democrats. Slava Ukraini.
-
01-31-23 07:26 #1571Senior Member

Posts: 540Reasons why it might not be just for show.
Prior to last Feb 24th, Ukraine was managing its affairs under the status quo. Whatever corruption was going on was part of the fabric of that status quo.
Originally Posted by DramaFree11
[View Original Post]
Post-invasion, most Ukrainians (politicians + population, from every poll I've seen) have come to the conclusion that their future welfare and existence won't be secure without menbership in the EU, at a minimum, and hopefully also NATO. For either of those two things to happen, Ukraine will need to step up its anti-corruption game. Not for show, but for real.
Another reason is that a population in which so many have experienced the death of family, friends, and acquaintances, are likely to be much less tolerant of corruption during a time of war. Every act of corruption will be viewed, and rightly so, as a direct betrayal of the forces fighting to defend Ukraine and an even more heinous betrayal of those who have given their lives.
-
01-31-23 06:26 #1570Senior Member

Posts: 2745Where can I see this "footage"?
You've got it all wrong. Those were Russian 50+ something, not Ukrainians.
Originally Posted by Riina
[View Original Post]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QONzVd11Xw
-
01-31-23 03:10 #1569Senior Member

Posts: 1751Sure, as our saying goes 'We don't take bribes, we give them'. Good read / listen from the US POV:
https://www.youtube.com/@douglasmacgregorcol5835/videos
And in Foreign Affairs section https://www.theamericanconservative.com/.
-
01-30-23 23:27 #1568Senior Member

Posts: 724In fact, Putin has been actively promoting corruption in Ukraine for decades. He tries to undermine any notion of a fair and democratic society at every point. It's not like both are tarred with the same brush. Putin / Russia is immersed in the mud and tries to drag Ukraine down with it. Sometimes he succeeds, sometimes the best Ukrainian leaders succeed (and sometimes they fail).
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
-
01-30-23 17:14 #1567Senior Member

Posts: 2892Both countries are as corrupt as Hell! I have my doubts about Ukraine and this is probably just for show, but we can hope that they are finally getting their act together.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
-
01-30-23 04:31 #1566Senior Member

Posts: 540Nice try, no cigar.
Nice attempt to misrepresent my meaning by quoting a small portion of my post while pointedly avoiding a mountain of context. Here's the whole thing:
Originally Posted by Riina
[View Original Post]
Got any response to the ENTIRE post? Since I clearly stated that the principle of self-defense trumps all else. And since I go out of my way to point out that, even if Zelensky is found guilty of corruption and removed, it wouldn't change the fundamental right of Ukrainians to defend their lives and their land.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
Any questions?
P.S. And it remains the height of hypocrisy that all those who get their panties in a twist about corruption on the part of Ukraine, real or alleged, never utter a SINGLE word about the uber-corrupt kleptocracy that rules Russia.
P. P.S. I'm overjoyed at the fact that Ukrainians are outraged by reports of corruption. That means they're making progress toward full EU integration, while Russia marches steadily backward toward their third-world fate.
-
01-26-23 03:50 #1565Senior Member

Posts: 750Sounds like you have also viewed the footage of older men rounded up at gun point and forced to fight.
Originally Posted by Beijing4987
[View Original Post]
-
01-25-23 08:26 #1564Senior Member

Posts: 707My 2 cents
How does the gifting in Ukraine compare to the American War in indochina or the Double Bill American War in Iraq and Afghanistan? By the way, the corrupt leaders in Ukraine are doing a good job in organizing their populace to resist and "decorating" the countryside with the invaders. As at StarskyUa says "improved".
-
01-25-23 01:10 #1563Senior Member

Posts: 750Oh yeah. Why is every Ukrainian I know irate with what's happening? The leadership is a cancer.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
-
01-08-23 02:08 #1562Senior Member

Posts: 2225Yes, I agree. Doesn't have to make sense or completely be believed by the public.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
As you note, Peter the Great is probably the connection the Russian hawks are trying to make with the country's imperialistic past. As head of both the church and country, Peter the Great harks back to the European history of Christianity and conquest. The Tsar was appointed by God no less.
-
01-07-23 22:11 #1561Senior Member

Posts: 540Putin throws everything against the wall to see what sticks.
Whether it's the pseudo-religious argument, or styling himself as the new Peter the Great (reclaiming historical Russian lands), or claiming to be a victim of NATO and the West, the goal is the same: to delegitimize and dehumanize Ukraine and thereby provide a justification for Russian aggression. It's really not important for anyone to believe any of it, it's only useful to have various excuses you can point to. In fact, having multiple excuses means Russia can conveniently shift gears whenever challenged.
Originally Posted by WyattEarp
[View Original Post]
That latter point is important because each of those bogus arguments melt away when subjected to close examination. When stripped down to its core, the Russian justification has always been, very simply, "because we can" (or at least because they thought they could). But the brutal honesty of that position isn't easy for every (internal and external) audience to swallow. So Russia has no problem telling people whatever it takes to "sell" their aggression as something more palatable.
-
01-07-23 18:11 #1560Senior Member

Posts: 2225I couldn't help commenting on this one line that I read in the article you posted.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]
"While many voices in the Russian information space strongly criticized the ceasefire announcement, certain hardline elements seized on Putin's statement to continue to propagate the narrative that Putin is a protector of religious values and morals".
This bit of orthodox christian proselytizing that has emerged in Russian propaganda is amazing. It's a little bit like "have ideology, will travel". It's also a bit rich given Putin's KGB poster boy past. It appears the Russians who were so good at trying to isolate their people and feed them a steady diet of propaganda for most of the 20th century have developed a propensity to sling the bullshit.
How does that go over inside Russia? Can the Russians really shut down access to internet information? Do any of our resident Russophiles think Putin is some great spiritual and moral leader?
On the world stage, it certainly can be said that imperialistic tendencies generally need an ideology for justification and motivation. This one however can be categorized as theater of the absurd.
In the grander.
-
01-07-23 05:49 #1559Senior Member

Posts: 540Two points in response
First, my post was forward-looking and, as such, was not intended to examine the past in any great depth. Where I do mention past events, like the Kharkhiv campaign, it's primarily for the purpose of pointing out challenges and other factors that might be specifically relevant to the four upcoming developments I listed.
Originally Posted by Paulie97
[View Original Post]
Second, Ukraine has reclaimed Kherson, the city, but nowhere near the entirety of Kherson Oblast. If you look at the map in the link below you'll see the blue (Ukraine reclaimed) area on the west bank of the Dnipro. The red area is still under Russian control and Kherson city is pretty much right on the dividing line. The way you worded your post makes it seem as if the battle for that area is over when, in fact, it's still very much contested.
https://www.criticalthreats.org/anal...january-6-2023
BTW, the contrast between the Kherson and Kharkhiv campaigns serves to reinforce my point that the unique factors that allowed such a rapid victory in Kharkhiv are unlikely to be repeated.
Any questions (wink)?
-
01-06-23 07:16 #1558Senior Member

Posts: 1956??
Pretty good write up, though you completely overlooked the fact that Ukraine reclaimed Kherson in the south after nine months of enemy occupation, a highly strategic and "significant" region where a pseudo referendum was held. In your attempt to sound fair and balanced you overlooked a very important detail. Wink.
Originally Posted by Jmsuttr
[View Original Post]

.png)







Reply With Quote


