Thread: Stupid Shit in Kyiv
+
Add Report
Results 2,281 to 2,295 of 4600
-
07-12-23 04:44 #2320Senior Member

Posts: 1956Regarding respect
Kremlin propaganda / false information has fueled an unprovoked invasion of a sovereign land while directly targeting and murdering civilians with precision weapons. This has also involved the deportation and indoctrination of about 200 K Ukrainian children. Their false narratives are no more worthy of respect than Holocaust deniers. Plus respect wouldn't do any good anyway as you can't reason with such people while they'd never honor any agreements. But we are covering ground that was covered long ago, and in greater detail. Anyone interested can go back to the start of the war and forward, chronologically in this thread.
P.S. Regarding the Russian speakers in the Donbass that prefer Russia, it's a good thing that they have a short journey, whether by car or foot. Get out of Ukraine and don't let the door hit you in the ass. It's easy. Go be Russian. A lot of Russian speakers were planted in that area since the Stalinist era famine that killed off millions of Ukrainians.
-
07-12-23 02:55 #2319Senior Member

Posts: 2742No one can be a hero all the time.
And as communicated to you, Tiny, I'm well aware that Gorby gave different accounts on different occasions, but his earlier accounts can be dismissed with prejudice for a simple reason: he and his foundation had to coexist in the same country with Putin right after Putin's 2007 Munich speech launched Russia's most rancid anti-Nato campaign since the Cold War. Thus, Gorbachev's 2008 and 2009 interviews should be considered strictly a way to appease his increasingly volatile and totalitarian chieftain.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_M...Vladimir_Putin
In 2011 when Putin's intent to usurp power indefinitely became abundantly clear, Gorbachev publicly denounced Putin and repeated his accusations the following years.
So it only stands to reason that Gorbachev in 2008 and 2009 doesn't hold a candle to Gorbachev in 2015.
And even beyond Gorby's own words, you've been offered enough evidence that there have never been any agreements and / or promises not to extend Nato beyond the borders of Germany. If you can't except the facts, I don't think there is anything else that can be done about it.
-
07-11-23 10:26 #2318Senior Member

Posts: 451They are a pair of cunts. The interactions with them are the same as with the Russian State, respectful engagement made no difference, both of those fuckheads ignored any debate, lied over and over again, and spread falsehoods and propaganda. Next time read the history of the thread before telling us to show respect.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
07-11-23 05:54 #2317Senior Member

Posts: 2560Fair enough. I don't want to intrude upon your private war fest.
Originally Posted by Paulie97
[View Original Post]
Just one last thing for Xpartan first though.
As communicated to you earlier.
Originally Posted by Xpartan
[View Original Post]
Gorbachev in 2008:
"The Americans promised that Nato wouldn't move beyond the boundaries of Germany after the Cold War but now half of central and eastern Europe are members, so what happened to their promises? It shows they cannot be trusted."
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...-Cold-War.html
Gorbachev, from 2009:
"Kohl, US Secretary of State James Baker and others assured me that NATO would not move an inch east. The Americans didn't stick to that, and the Germans didn't care. Maybe they even rubbed their hands at how well the Russians were ripped off. What did it bring? It's just that the Russians no longer trust Western promises."
https://www.bild.de/politik/2009/bil...4098.bild.html
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3_0GqPvr4U
-
07-10-23 22:02 #2316Senior Member

Posts: 1956Tiny
That's what he's been doing daily for many months now on the American Politics thread in the ISG "Opinions" forum while calling himself a centrist. He's been debunked from here to Sunday then recently came to this thread to restart even though he's never been to Ukraine. Likely he discovered this discussion by searching the post histories of people he's been going back in forth with on the other thread.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
For example he has ignored all that facts that clearly debunk the notion that Russia was given an oral promise regarding no NATO expansion into Eastern Europe. It's plainly false, but even if true only a complete fool wouldn't insist on getting something so important in writing.
https://hls.harvard.edu/today/there-...-enlarge-nato/
https://www.politifact.com/factcheck...reement-again/
https://theconversation.com/ukraine-...he-east-177085
So what can you do with someone who digs in online, ignores all corrections and keeps repeating the same fallacious arguments over and over? Ultimately all you can do is ignore them.
https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Argumentum_ad_nauseam
-
07-10-23 21:43 #2315Senior Member

Posts: 2742Gorby says your link is a baloney
And Gorbachev debunked your Council.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
The topic of NATO expansion was not discussed at all, and it wasnt brought up in those years. I say this with full responsibility. Not a singe Eastern European country raised the issue, not even after the Warsaw Pact ceased to exist in 1991. Western leaders didnt bring it up, either. Another issue we brought up was discussed: making sure that NATOs military structures would not advance and that additional armed forces from the alliance would not be deployed on the territory of the then-GDR after German reunification. Bakers statement, mentioned in your question, was made in that context. Kohl and German Vice Chancellor Hans-Dietrich Genscher talked about it.Sure, why not flip a bird to all East European nations by bringing in the same crazy bear they are seeking protection from? I mean, do these people think they matter? Huh!
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
I might have an even better idea for you. Let's start hiring abusive husbands and boyfriends for Domestic Violence shelters. I'm sure that would work out just fine.
So that's what realpolitic is -- pipe dreams galore.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Propagandists are the lowest form of life on this planet. Not happening.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
07-10-23 17:55 #2314Senior Member

Posts: 2560Would you trust a poll after the start of the war in "Russian controlled parts of Donetsk and Luhansk," even if conducted by respected Ukrainian institutions like Dzerkalo Tyzhnia?
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
Yes, the Slavic Studies Council at the National Securities Archive at George Washington University did debunk your side of the argument hard.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-b...-leaders-early
Wikipedia presents both sides of the argument. Mine's more compelling.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contro...NATO_expansion
Firstly if Russia had been on a path to NATO not long after the USSR disintegrated and Yeltsin became president, Putin might never have been elected, or at least his views might be very different today. Yes, it would have been a long process, but well worth it if it had succeeded.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
I'm no expert on this. Yuriy Davydov, NATO Research Fellow, was. Perhaps you could debunk what he said. For example, that "voluntary mutual co-operation (with NATO) in the field of security would be a key to assertion of democratic values" in Russia. Or that "the final outcome of Russia joining NATO would be the establishment of an integrated, structurally formed security system of free and democratic states on the vast territories from Vancouver to Vladivostok. It could contain dozens of states that never fight against each other, thus establishing an extensive peace zone and exerting restraining influence on the surrounding areas. This system could to a certain extent become a model of comprehensive international security system. ".
https://www.nato.int/acad/fellow/98-00/davydov.pdf
Treat them with respect and they most likely will engage respectfully.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
https://youtu.be/C3_0GqPvr4U
-
07-10-23 14:12 #2313Senior Member

Posts: 451You bring up a poll 3 years before the start of the war? Facepalm! No further comment needed.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
The expansion of NATO argument has been debunked hard, I can't believe you're bring this up now. Facepalm!
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
"We could be dead by now" "It's possible".
Given the evidence before our eyes of the Russian army performance versus deprecated NATO arms, if there had been a kinetic war, Russia would have been fucked hard. So yes it's "possible", but in the sense that an asteroid could hit our heads tomorrow.
Wow a lot of parroting of Kremlin narratives. In line with the Kremlin narrative you also have neglected to explain why Russia didn't just trade and become an equal partner instead of secretly fucking with everyone and invading it's neighbours. As Kasparov predicted, putting a former KGB agent in charge is not going to work out well.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
NATO is setup to counter the "chimpanzee with a machine gun" that is the Russian state. Please explain how admitting Putin into NATO and sharing all of our weapons technologies and strategies would have been a good idea?
You have a lot of disingenuous arguments, but at least try to engage in debate, unlike the other pair of absolute fuckheads. You'll find people here are not completely blind to the realities of what is happening, however it is not constructive to engage in debate with Z propagandists.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
07-10-23 04:40 #2312Senior Member

Posts: 2742Exactly!
Any peace agreement with Russia other than "please-don't-shoot-at-us-while-we're-getting-out" (like the one that ended the war in Afghanistan) is pointless.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
-
07-09-23 22:00 #2311Senior Member

Posts: 2560Please see this article from 2019.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
https://www.kyivpost.com/post/7557
"Only 5.1 percent of people living in the Russia-controlled parts of Donetsk and Luhansk regions want Ukraine to regain control over the territories. Half (50.9 percent) want a union with Russia and another 13.4 percent said the region should accede to Russia with a "special status." For the whole of Donbas, including its Ukraine-controlled areas, 49.6 percent want it to become part of Russia, with another 13.3 percent choosing such a scenario with a "special status" for Donbas. A fifth (19.2 percent) see Donbas as part of Ukraine."
So apparently 50.9% wanted to live in a Russian oblast, and another 13.4% in something like a Russian territory (e.g. like Puerto Rico in the USA). Only 5.1% wanted to live in a Ukrainian controlled oblast.
I don't know much about the referenda.
Russia's gotten a lot more than what it bargained for when it decided to invade Ukraine. NATO, the west and Ukraine must have much more credibility in Russia's eyes. Putin is rational. Seeing the cohesiveness of the west and the expansion of NATO to include Finland, he must be less enthusiastic about his adventures outside the Russian republic, or at least those that he believes will attract the west's attention.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
I don't know the history of the Budapest memoranda, but suspect they were intended to protect Ukraine from the West more so than from Russia. Russia believes it was betrayed by NATO and the USA, when NATO expanded eastward after 1990, and Putin who's nationalistic and somewhat paranoid has unfortunately looked to correct this. If the USA and UK had committed troops to Ukraine as you apparently suggest we could be dead by now. Probably not, but it's possible.
Agreed.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
If the USA and Europeans are mostly funding the war effort they should have a say. And should IMHO push for an end to the war in a way that provides security for Ukrainians.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
Yes, Russia has and probably will continue to employ soft power and troll factories to destabilize Ukraine and sow discord in the Europe and the USA. It didn't have to be this way. If the west had pursued friendlier relations with Russia after the breakup of the USSR, maybe even making Russia a part of NATO as proposed by Putin in 2000, the world would be in a lot better shape. Perhaps Russia would look a lot like Hungary today, semi-autocratic but inside the tent instead of outside.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
OK, you're much more realistic than I thought you were about how long this may last. And maybe I'm an optimist about what the future holds after this war is over. I hope not.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
https://youtu.be/C3_0GqPvr4U
-
07-09-23 21:18 #2310Senior Member

Posts: 451I do not think it is possible for you to conclude that there are parts of Donbass where the majority want to be part of Russia. Where are you getting this information? Was it from the "election" results, what is your opinion on the "referenda" conducted in Donetsk and Luhansk?
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Allowing Russia to leave this conflict with something more than what they had previously will destroy any credibility for NATO as guarantors of peace. How would this even be possible, when the US and the UK did not step in when Russian broke the Budapest memoranda? Ukraine would be dependent on the whims of whoever was in charge and if Trump wins the next election, he has already stated he will try to force Ukraine to cede territory.
It is certainly not up to the likes of you (or me for that matter) to tell Ukrainians what is in their best interests, they have made it clear they want self determination, and the majority of Ukrainians are strongly opposed to ceding territory to Russia.
Given that the Russians continually lie and also break each and every accord they sign, I would say it is not possible to make any deals with them at all. If they are not completely exterminated from Ukrainian land, they will most likely regroup, and try again as soon as they can, and if they cannot do it via military means, they will employ all their soft power and troll factory resources to destablize Ukraine, and continue trying to sow discord in Europe and the US. This is not an outcome I want to see.
We have seen time and again that appeasement does not work. It will not work here. This conflict may span more years, however during that time, Russia will become more and more of a pariah, and during that time each Western power is doing all they can to remove any dependencies on their resources, which means that income for Russia will only shrink, not matter what the oil and gas price.
Russia as it is now is a dangerous and belligerent state, and I have had my eyes opened and fully agree with my friends in the Baltics and Poland, that they are not to be trusted in any way.
Should the Federation break up, only then will there be a chance for long term peaceful relations with Russia, but until then we need to give Ukraine everything it needs to defeat the invaders / occupiers / war criminals.
-
07-09-23 20:26 #2309Senior Member

Posts: 2560Hugely pro-Russian? You completely mischaracterize what I wrote.
Originally Posted by VinDici
[View Original Post]
Of course I don't approve of the use of cluster munitions, chemical weapons or kidnapping. Yes, you have righteousness on your side. And yes, Russia and the Ukraine have already used cluster bombs on each other, so this is nothing new. As a USA Citizen I don't approve of my country using cluster bombs or providing them to other countries. I also don't approve of capital punishment, although I imagine that analogy is lost on you.
According to the press, one of the reasons the USA is providing cluster bombs is because the USA's supplies of certain other munitions is running low, as a result of military aid to Ukraine. The USA no longer manufactures cluster bombs, and I believe the last time it used them was 20 years ago. We're unlikely to use them in the future, on humanitarian grounds. But apparently it's OK to give them away.
Your, Zelensky's and others position that this cannot end until Russia withdraws to pre-2014 borders is a recipe for an endless war. And it's not fair to the people of Crimea, and probably some parts of the Donbass, where the majority want to be part of Russia. And, while they may not recognize it yet, it's not in the best interest of other Ukrainians, as it prevents a peace agreement that assures the country's security.
A peace agreement need not call into question the efficacy of NATO. It could involve a side deal with Ukraine where NATO guarantees its security.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3_0GqPvr4U
-
07-09-23 19:28 #2308Senior Member

Posts: 451It's a bit interesting that you suddenly started posting here after Q stopped and are hugely Pro-Russian.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Since you are pointing out the DPCIMs that the US will provide to Ukraine, I would love to hear your opinion on the extensive and continued use of cluster munitions and more recently chemical weapons by the Russian armies? Also would be very good to know your stance on the kidnapped children, which is reported to be more than 500,000, who have been taken from Ukraine to be "educated" in Russia.
Please enlighten us?
Xpartan is correct, any result other than Ukraine winning back its land back to the 2014 borders at a minimum would be a catastrophic loss for the Western nations and call into question the efficacy of NATO. Russia can withdraw wherever it likes, there is no sword of damocles on the Nation, Putin on the other hand.
-
07-09-23 05:28 #2307Senior Member

Posts: 2560https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...s-Ukraine.html
Originally Posted by Xpartan
[View Original Post]
https://youtu.be/C3_0GqPvr4U
-
07-08-23 22:28 #2306Senior Member

Posts: 2742Paper tiger.
1. No, Russia can't sustain that indefinitely. You're referring to GDP as if it's a sacred cow. What is GDP? Tanks are GDP. Aircraft are GDP. Mines, bombs, missiles, big arms, small arms, it's all there, in GDP. If the government spends 30 or 50 percent of their budget on war, heightened security, and hysterical propaganda (all TV stations and periodicals in Russia are owned and financed by the government), the numbers don't matter. GDP can be sky-high just because the economy has shifted from making tractors to making tanks (or, more likely in this case, refitting the old ones that had already been written off on the paper), and with 30 percent of the budget classified -- YOU JUST DON'T KNOW how much exactly the government spends on war. But what anyone in Russia who's not an idiot knows, it's a lot and it's unsustainable.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
The quality of the Russian military hardware is also dubious. There are no more legit ways of getting western components, and Russian economy depends on everything. Russian hardware is not just inferior to the West, it's light years behind. They can't build modern tanks or aircraft any longer. They started bringing to front lines T55 -- that's from 1940's! Their bombers and fighters are still superior to Ukraine's, but vastly inferior to even outdated F16 if -- BIG IF -- Ukraine finally gets them. Then it's the reckoning time.
2. The 9 trillion quote was in rubles. At the time of the publication it was $126 billions.
3. "Followed by peace" is not an option. There are two realistic options. To keep supporting Ukraine until they win and to stop supporting them with full understanding that they won't stop fighting. The second option would be a disaster. For us (see #4).
4. I don't know what it is, your stubbornness, some kind of deep-seated Russophilia, or crypto-admiration of Putin, but you're fundamentally wrong. Betraying Ukraine now when they're winning and helping war criminal Putin survive this calamity he started, would be, first and foremost, our own defeat, and not Ukraine's. Am I happy that Roosevelt wasn't as "fiscally responsible" as you guys.

.png)







Reply With Quote


