Thread: General Info
+
Add Report
Results 226 to 240 of 7607
-
10-29-24 22:01 #7382Regular Member

Posts: 1109It's really tough to deny things you've written and published. This is you on Oct. 25: "I wonder how long it will be until those card issuers stop reimbursing" Don't you just hate it when people go back and directly and unequivocally prove you're lying?
Originally Posted by FunLuvr
[View Original Post]
-
10-29-24 20:17 #7381Senior Member

Posts: 1195In your previous post, you said "The reimbursement is not a loss for the companies that do it." You now say it may be unprofitable. I realize "unprofitable" and "loss" are not synonymous, but it's very difficult to maintain zero sum total with expenses that vary.
Originally Posted by SubCmdr
[View Original Post]
Last year, Schwab's bank deposit account balances decreased by 23% while the number of bank accounts increased by 7%. Those "smart people" who are seeing this may see some red flags.
I've never said Schwab will eliminate the reimbursements. I said I wonder, with increased expenses, how long it will be until they change the reimbursements.
-
10-29-24 12:28 #7380Senior Member

Posts: 7883Asked and Answered by The Cmdr
There is a concept that wage slaves do not understand that business owners are very familiar with. The concept is Opportunity Costs.Please explain how a company that issues the card is making money from an ATM withdrawal
The bank that issues the card, they are paying the paying the reimbursement to their customer that is using a ATM network being maintaining by someone else. Period. Full Stop! They pay this fee in order so they do not have to maintain a ATM network of their own. These are the Opportunity Costs that the issuing bank does not have to incur. Read my post previous to this one and others. The issuing bank has made a business decision to make the reimbursements. There are very smart people running the numbers. And over the last 32 years, Charles Schwab has reimbursed my ATM fees worldwide that I have incurred for my account. I have no reason whatsoever to believe that policy will change. Even if it is unprofitable it may be considered by them to be a loss leader in order to draw in more business.
Individuals need to learn the purpose of banks. Banks are not there to make individuals happy. They are there to facilitate transactions. Each transaction you make using said bank is a opportunity for them to charge a fee. They do this because they are Businesses. Businesses need to earn a profit in order to stay in business. For the individual the ATM fee is the cost of doing transactions that benefit your personal financial situation. If a ATM fee has not value to you then you need find a way to minimize them or eliminate them.
Personally, I do not see the point of complaining about the price of something in a free market system. If the ATM fees are going to make or break someone then maybe that person should put in more work in their country of origin in order to earn the money you need, before you step onto the plane to become a International Trick!
The Defense Rests!
-
10-28-24 10:35 #7379Senior Member

Posts: 2125Fidelity and Schwab not making money on the ATM withdrawal itself, but as others have mentioned they make money off of their brokerage fees and the spread. Between buy and sell prices for securities that people purchase through their brokerage accounts.
Originally Posted by Nounce
[View Original Post]
As for traditional banks like Wells Fargo and Bank of America (who are also card issuers) they actually do make money on ATM withdrawals especially out of network or foreign ATM withdrawals. I know for a fact that wells fargo charges a set $5 usd fee per foreign withdrawal to its cardholders who make ATM withdrawals. This is on top of any fees the ATM itself charges. They also have been known to charge a 3% foreign conversion rate fee as well. So traditional banks definitely make money from ATM withdrawals as a card issuer.
Cash management / brokerage accounts such as Fidelity are not making anything off the ATM withdrawal but they are hoping you hold your securities portfolio with them and then they will make money off of your trades. They offer the ATM fee reimbursements as a perk.
I've been off in Thailand Philippines and soon to be in Indonesia and I've already been reimbursed $550 usd in ATM fees from Fidelity. And no I don't withdraw $10 at a time it's usually between $100-200 usd worth of local currency I withdraw at a time. I don't like doing the maximum as I don't feel comfortable with that much cash all at once and also I have had problems in Colombia where an ATM charged me for a withdrawal but never gave me my cash, so that is the main reason I don't do maximum.
-Gabacho.
-
10-27-24 16:50 #7378Senior Member

Posts: 3423Look at it collectively
You look at it in a very narrow way. I know they make money from me and the cash I have sitting in there can easily support 10 or even 100 others so for me I am losing money vs if I try to manage it better.
Originally Posted by FunLuvr
[View Original Post]
The Colombian banks have figured it out. Once they found out they don't lose business by charging a fee. They raise it. They pattern fits.
-
10-27-24 16:33 #7377Senior Member

Posts: 1195Download the Uber and DiDi apps. Look at them for what they charge for your trip. Then offer InDriver something less than that.
Originally Posted by WanderingMan
[View Original Post]
-
10-27-24 16:22 #7376Senior Member

Posts: 1195Please explain how a company that issues the card is making money from an ATM withdrawal, and how much they make from each withdrawal. Ten years ago, almost all the ATM's in Colombia were fee free. Now, I think all of them have a fee. Is that because the banks got greedy? If your answer is that the banks have to maintain the ATM's, well, they also had to maintain them when they were fee free.
Originally Posted by SubCmdr
[View Original Post]
-
10-27-24 07:58 #7375Regular Member

Posts: 1109I use my credit card at the Dollar Tree for $1. 25 plus tax all the time before I go to the gym. No minimums. I think those are against the credit card companies' policies. Saw them a few times at Indian owned stores in Reno and Las Vegas. Been in this city two years, use the card for small amounts all the time. On the checking limits, that's required by law for "money market accounts" and some other types.
Originally Posted by LoveItHere69
[View Original Post]
However, I did notice that E-Trade now has some requirements to get the rebates. You could get it a few ways, by keeping a minimum cash balance, by having minimum total assets, by having direct deposit, maybe some other stuff.
-
10-27-24 03:05 #7374Senior Member

Posts: 1008It was an exaggeration. Basically people making lots of tiny dollar amount of withdrawals. That is hard to believe? Try this. Think in reverse. Someone making lots of tiny purchases with their credit card. Retail companies got tired of that so now there are minimum purchase amounts because the credit card fees were killing any profit. Many banks charge for checks now. Many banks have a maximum amount of checks you can write per month now.
Originally Posted by Huacho
[View Original Post]
If a ton of guys keep opening accounts to get free ATM usage but deposit little money or do not put money in the brokerage accounts, Schwab will most likely drop the free ATM. That is common sense. Nothing free lasts forever.
With all the super stupid things you have read, heard, and seen in your life (especially lately), how can doubt anything?
-
10-27-24 02:11 #7373Senior Member

Posts: 163I downloaded the Indrive app as suggested. It will be a bit unique to offer a fee to go somewhere, but it's an adventure.
Originally Posted by MrEnternational
[View Original Post]
My friend is a bit old fashioned and takes cash everywhere. He may not even have an ATM card, seriously. Based on your information though, it looks as if US credit cards are accepted in Colombia. That's good news for dining options.
-
10-26-24 22:36 #7372Senior Member

Posts: 7883Please don't fall for the hype.
Exactlly, as a ATM user my complete is the local limits on the amount of currency you can pull out or the ATM each time.
Originally Posted by Huacho
[View Original Post]
Very first bank account I got in my life I received a ATM card. They were paying me per transaction to use the ATM. The reimbursement is not a loss for the companies that do it. Remember the ATM operator gets their fee. The company reimbursing their clients do not have to maintain a ATM network. It is a WIN / WIN / WIN and you can bet as many COP as you would like that very smart people within these companies have run the numbers and have made the decision based on what they saw.
Please don't believe the hype. Think like a capitalist, not a wage slave.
-
10-26-24 15:01 #7371Regular Member

Posts: 1109I have never heard of anyone doing that, and it's silly and I doubt it's a widespread problem.
Originally Posted by LoveItHere69
[View Original Post]
-
10-26-24 12:30 #7370Senior Member

Posts: 1008Since it is free you have guys that abuse it taking $10 out everyday for a month instead of $300 once a month. All that has to be tracked and documented. That is a cost that needs to be recouped somewhere. ATM fees keep going up and up because the machine needs filled with money, paper for receipts, and machine maintenance. Nothing free lasts forever. Think of more and more grocery stores doing away with bags (bring your own) and charging for bags. Some stores charge a quarter to use the shopping cart but the quarter is returned if you return the cart to the builing rather than leave it in the parking lot because the expense of paying a worker to round up cart all over the parking lot.
Originally Posted by MrEnternational
[View Original Post]
I would guess that the use of cards for overseas has increased by 5 times from 10 years ago as people learned about the few companies that offer fee free ATM cards.
-
10-26-24 04:16 #7369Senior Member

Posts: 18826Evidently they are making so much money in other areas that they are able to forego it as pertains to ATM fees. Another thing they did a couple of years ago was to stop charging on trading transactions. If I recall correctly, it used to be $8. 95 per transaction. I figure they are missing out on way more money not charging for trades than they would be for reimbursing ATM fees.
Originally Posted by FunLuvr
[View Original Post]
-
10-26-24 02:41 #7368Regular Member

Posts: 1109Since they've been doing for over 20 years, they have likely concluded that the goodwill is worth it. I know many people who opened Schwab accounts primarily for that reason.
Originally Posted by FunLuvr
[View Original Post]

.png)







Reply With Quote


