Thread: American Politics
+
Add Report
Results 1,126 to 1,140 of 22474
-
06-26-26 18:27 #21349Senior Member

Posts: 2560From what you quoted: "Total tax rates (income tax + sales tax + property tax) on middle income Americans are much lower than European levels. " In an earlier reply to you I also said you'd have to impose a regressive value added tax to pay for what progressive Democrats want. Of course the USA has the ability to raise tax substantially on the less-than-wealthy and become like France. Progressive Democrat politicians refuse to admit they can't do that just by taxing people who make over $300,000 a year (Biden) or who are worth more than $100 million (Warren and Newsome). They're using class warfare to get votes.
Originally Posted by HotDog666
[View Original Post]
As to tariffs I don't like them for the reasons you don't. However GDP growth has chugged along nicely despite them. When I get some time, I'll elaborate in a reply to Elvis who disagreed in another of his thought provoking (honestly) posts.
-
06-26-26 17:13 #21348Senior Member

Posts: 8034Like the increase in USA factory construction? Thank Joe, not Donnie
Joe Biden caused factory construction to increase. By American companies, for American companies, benefitting Americans and hiring American workers.
Originally Posted by Canada
[View Original Post]
Behold the usual stark contrast between the economic policy and stewardship results of Dems like Joe Biden vs those of Repubs like Donald Trump:
Trump's tariffs are causing harm to American manufacturers instead of benefiting them.
March 18, 2026
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy...enefiting-them
Attention actual USA Citizens qualified to register and vote in the USA; if you prefer the latter results in the above linked citation, vote Dem up and down the ballot in every election. If you prefer the former results, either don't bother to vote or, worse, vote for candidates other than Dems anywhere on your ballot.Manufacturing jobs have declined during Trump's first year back
Trump's core rationale for tariffs has been that they would force more factories to open in the U.S. and would generate enough revenue to close federal budget deficits. But that hasn't materialized.
Factories continue to shed workers, with 98,000 manufacturing jobs lost during Trump's first full 12 months back in the White House. American companies that foot the bill for tariffs are now suing the Trump administration for more than $130 billion in tariff refunds. Meanwhile, the federal deficit is projected to climb over the next decade.
................
Construction is up but that's due to Biden's bill
Some of the bright spots in construction cited by the White House appear to be the result of programs launched by then-President Joe Biden, a Democrat.
Factory construction spending began to accelerate in 2022 with the anticipation of government support from Biden's CHIPS and Science Act, which included big subsidies for computer chip plants. The law was a primary contributor to a historic surge in the annualized rate of construction spending on manufacturing facilities, said Skanda Amarnath, executive director of the economic policy group Employ America.
-
06-26-26 16:54 #21347Senior Member

Posts: 2560Another reason not to want to make the USA more like France
The climate virtue signaling in France has become so strong that people are dying. Instead of encouraging elderly and infirm French men and women to seek and install air conditioning the government encourages coping mechanisms, like wetting yourself with water and eating cold soup. If you have ac you should confine it to one room and set the thermostat to 79 degrees Fahrenheit. This is from today's WSJ. Meanwhile, the good people at the left-of-center Economist took a model developed by a French researcher and applied it to forecasted temperatures on June 24 to June 26. That indicates there will be 1500 excess deaths from heat in those 3 days in Paris alone! And the death rate should be up about 300%! I'm writing from my mobile phone and those are pay sites anyway, but if you have subscriptions you'll have no problem finding the articles.
-
06-26-26 16:26 #21346Senior Member

Posts: 8034So what? Good for foreign companies, bad for the USA Consumer and Workers
The A. I. Overviews:
Originally Posted by Canada
[View Original Post]
Is manufacturing still losing jobs in the USA?
+3
Yes, the U.S. manufacturing sector is still losing jobs, despite a surge in factory construction spending and rising output. The industry has faced persistent job declines, with factory employment hitting a six-year low in recent surveys.
Key facts regarding the decline include:Massive Layoffs: Job cuts at U.S. factories recently reached their highest levels since the 20082009 financial crisis.Historical Context: The U.S. has lost roughly 4.5 million manufacturing jobs since 2000 as production shifted to countries with lower labor costs, such as India, Vietnam, and Mexico.Key Drivers: Economists point to a mix of heavy automation on the factory floor, high operating costs, and lingering uncertainties caused by global trade policies and tariffs.The Construction Paradox: While investment in building new manufacturing facilities (especially for electronics and semiconductors) has skyrocketed, these are temporary construction jobs. The resulting automated, high-tech factories require significantly fewer permanent workers to operate once built.If you want to understand this trend better, let me know:Which specific industries you are most interested in (e.g., autos, semiconductors, aerospace).Whether you want to focus on national policy impacts or regional labor trends.U.S. manufacturers are still shedding thousands of jobs, as workers ask White ...Mar 6, 2569 BE In the meantime, employment data shows American manufacturers are continuing to cut jobs, with the U.S. shedding 83,000 manufacturing jobs during Mr. Trump's fi...CBS NewsFactory job cuts in June neared financial crisis and Covid levels, S&P says - CNBCJun 23, 2569 BE Job cuts at U.S. factories ran near their highest levels since the end of the global financial crisis in 2009 and the Covid-19 pandemic as worries grew over glo...BTW, were you thinking that foreign companies moving manufacturing to the USA was going to cause prices of those products to decline for the American Consumer?Are more foreign companies moving manufacturing to the us under Trump?
+4
Yes, many foreign companies are expanding their manufacturing footprint in the U.S. to bypass sweeping trade tariffs. However, this "reshoring" effort hasn't translated into a broad domestic factory hiring boom, as total U.S. manufacturing employment has actually declined overall.Specific actions by foreign companies include:Pharmaceuticals: Swedish drugmaker AstraZeneca committed to a $50 billion investment to expand U.S. production by 2030, while GSK is investing $30 billion.Automotive: Hyundai Motor Group is investing $21 billion in U.S. operations, and Honda moved production of its Civic hybrid from Mexico to Indiana.Consumer Goods: Italian coffee maker Lavazza is pushing to have 100% of its U.S.-sold products manufactured locally to avoid Reuters tariff fallout.Despite these high-profile capital investments from overseas, the Wall Street Journal reports that total U.S. manufacturing employment has declined by over 200,000 roles in recent years.
Uh. Nope.
Good for GDP? Since when?Do products made by foreign companies in the usa cost more?
+8
Products manufactured by foreign companies on U.S. soil generally carry higher price tags. This is primarily driven by the higher cost of U.S. labor, stricter regulatory standards, and steep localized overhead. Additionally, many components for these items must still be imported, triggering supply-chain fees and import tariffs.The primary factors driving up costs include:Labor & Benefits: U.S. manufacturing wages and mandatory worker benefits (such as health insurance) are substantially higher than in manufacturing hubs like China or Vietnam.Compliance & Overhead: American factories must comply with strict environmental, labor, and safety regulations, which require significant capital to maintain.Imported Parts: Foreign companies often build "made-in-the-USA" assembly plants but still rely on globally sourced raw materials and electronic components
Trump Has Sent Americas GDP Into a Downward Spiral.
April 9, 2026
https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/ar...134836388.html
To recap:Between October and December, America's real gross domestic product fell from 4.4 percent to just 0.5 percent, the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis reported Thursday.
That figure is significantly less than the agency's second estimate of 0.7 percent growth, reported last month.
Trump's Tariffs are "working" to increase prices for products the American Consumer wants or needs to buy while losing jobs for the American Working Men and Women and sending America's GDP into a downward spiral.
Oh, and the rate of inflation due to Trump's policies is increasing rather than decreasing, which Trump loves:
Trump says 'I love the inflation' as US prices rise at fastest rate in three years.
June 11, 2026
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0myzxjkw99o
Its Not Just High Gas Prices Inflation Is Now Spreading Through the U.S. Economy.
May 28, 2026
https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/ar...181248183.html
-
06-26-26 14:13 #21345Senior Member

Posts: 1337Interesting article
An interesting article. I hadn't seen it.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
06-26-26 13:13 #21344Senior Member

Posts: 273OK, maybe I misunderstood your position in the comment:
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
"However, if you believe the highest end of mankind is to raise revenues for all encompassing government, you're not going to be able to milk the rich for much more than the USA already is. The maximum tax rate (federal + state + local) on ordinary income is 40.8% to 54% and on long term capital gains 23.8% to 39%, depending on location. That's close to Western European levels. Total tax rates (income tax + sales tax + property tax) on middle income Americans are much lower than European levels. You can't raise anywhere close to what Progressives like AOC and Bernie Sanders want by upping taxes on the wealthy."
It seemed to me that you don't think that the US has any capacity to increase its tax take. Which is the reason I displayed the overall tax as a proportion of GDP rankings. While I don't think the European models of extreme taxation are right or feasible, that doesn't mean the status quo is sustainable. The bottom line is America has a huge and growing debt overhang and none of Trump's policies (if you can call them that) aren't fit for purpose or their counterproductive. How do you propose to manage this?
I'm glad that you're not making BS claims like some here that the tariffs have reduced trade deficits (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4ge4yxwnlno)
-
06-26-26 05:30 #21343Senior Member

Posts: 2560Canada, The link in this post may be of interest
I have NEVER asserted the USA was a high tax country. A number of times in this thread I've said it was a low tax country, compared to other advanced economies. In fact, I said that in what you quoted.
Originally Posted by HotDog666
[View Original Post]
I have said the USA has a very progressive tax system compared to most other countries. Try a search on user Tiny 12 and keyword Mankiw. Or here's a less scholarly, more recent piece. To be honest I haven't read the .pdf yet, rather just the summary.
https://www.fraserinstitute.org/stud...countries-oecd
As to what you pulled from Perplexity and Gemini, I already said the same thing, much more succinctly, in the post you quoted:
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
06-26-26 04:35 #21342Senior Member

Posts: 1337Agreed
Totally agree. France along with numerous other high tax countries are failing. Even Sweden is making changes to be more a capitalist country. USA is still the best country to work and live in.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
06-26-26 04:29 #21341Senior Member

Posts: 1337The reason
You may be the reason that they put directions on shampoo bottles.
Originally Posted by Sirioja
[View Original Post]
-
06-26-26 01:44 #21340Senior Member

Posts: 1337Tariffs are working
Tariffs are not only working to equalize the trade deficits but it is also bringing in hundreds of companies from several countries moving their manufacturing to USA. So far 42 Canadian companies have moved their manufacturing to Canada. Japan and South Korea have moved numerous companies to USA. GDP is increasing monthly and USA has finally evened to trade tariffs with most countries. Most people are smart enough to see this but sometimes their TDS just deteriorates their minds. USA is winning and it's fun to watch. What a difference from the Biden fiasco.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
-
06-26-26 00:32 #21339Senior Member

Posts: 273I'm not taking a dogmatic position on being a high tax rate nation- I was simply refuting your made up assertion that the US is a high tax rate country when it clearly isn't, and Trump's assertion that the US needed tariffs to pay down the national debt. That clearly wasn't his intent, and the fact is he didn't have any idea on what his intent was, he shaped shifted his way through the tariffs and why they were necessary (to pay down the debt; no it's because we're being raped by China; no it's because we need to bring back industry; no it's because.) and he didn't follow through with consistent policies on anything; and in fact carried out adverse and contradictory policies concurrently with the tariffs.
See, that's my real beef with you Tiny and Elvis. That you persist in bending yourselves out of shape to find some semblance of rationale or logic or consistency to this fool when there simply isn't any. You don't see the commonality in capricious shape shifting that he did on tariffs and that on the Iran debacle but I do because it's freaking undeniable.
Oh and I don't know where you carry on finding your facts from; I asked both Gemini and Perplexity whether your assertion about the TCJA was correct re providing relatively better cuts to the lesser off; the answer is with the exception of those on Generally no; I'll provide the full summary below. The reality is a lot more nuanced than you're presenting it.
Did the tcja reduce tax for lower income more than higher income people?
Generally, no: the TCJA did not cut taxes for lower-income households *more* than for higher-income households in dollar terms, and many analyses find the largest dollar benefits went to higher-income households. But on a percentage-of-tax or percentage-of-income basis, some low- and middle-income groups saw larger relative reductions, so the answer depends on how you measure "more. ".
How the effects differ.
Low- and middle-income households benefited from the larger standard deduction and expanded child tax credit, which helped many working families. Higher-income households benefited more from rate cuts and some provisions that were more valuable at the top of the income distribution, so their total dollar gains were often larger.
What this means.
If you mean "who got the biggest tax cut in dollars," the answer is usually higher-income households. If you mean "who got the biggest cut relative to what they paid," some lower-income groups did better, and one analysis found the bottom half saw a larger percentage reduction than the top 10 percent.
Plain-language takeaway.
So the fairest short answer is: the TCJA was not mainly a bigger tax cut for lower-income people overall, though it did provide meaningful relief to many of them. The distribution was mixed, with relative gains for some lower-income families but larger total benefits concentrated higher up the income scale.
URL's removed as these don't seem to go through.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
-
06-25-26 13:13 #21338Senior Member

Posts: 27215But with Trump and China, death will arrive fast for most, from heat from pollution. Check your lungs and heart performances. High heat will be a good test to know who will survive or not. Same like in savana, strong and weak. This will be new WW arriving soon. After trying to rob their petrol, I hope Trump will help Venezuela now, when he wants to give 300 billions to mollahs still leading Iran.
Originally Posted by NewtonYork
[View Original Post]
-
06-25-26 05:22 #21337Senior Member

Posts: 811Forget all this politics stuff guys, what really matters now is the question of who is Sadie Sink playing in the new Spiderman movie. I'm voting for Jean Gray!
-
06-25-26 04:23 #21336Senior Member

Posts: 811I'm sad though. I thought for sure we'd be at WW3 by now, with nukes raining down all around us. But nada, zilch, zero, nothing. Still alive, living this shitty shitty life. Everything that's been happening, it was our best hope for the end of the world, but there's still 2 and a half years left. Nuclear armageddon could still happen, let's keep our fingers crossed OK?
-
06-24-26 21:31 #21335Senior Member

Posts: 4845LOL. Hot Dog, what do you think happened with the Trump tariffs? All the critics said prices would skyrocket, and they did not. Furthermore, Trump collected so much money he was going to give back $2000 to every taxpaying American. The businesses paying the tariffs ate them. It was the exact opposite of what you and so many econmists said then. It was a tax on thei rich and the money would have been going to everyone including the poor. Your TDS and economic theory has blinded you to this reality.
Originally Posted by HotDog666
[View Original Post]
The Supreme Court ordered Trump pay back the tariffs to the businesses AKA the rich. You have such bad TDS that you do not even acknowledge that. Had Trump involved Congeress with the tarfifs, he could have gotten some part of what he wanted passed. That is part of why he gets a F in execution.
What China is and has been doing is produce goods so cheaply that they lose money in the short term and drive people out of business. Then they screw you once they are your sole provider of that good or service. Ideally, the tariffs work to end that game.
But the other reason Trumg gets a F on execution is he flew off the handle and acted so impulsively. I got an argument with some economist about how we were all going to have pay more for shoes, and I told him that he was full of it. If tariffs drive up the price, and they did not by the way, people would downgrade, buy used, or go without. Shoes have very elastic demand.
While I was saying that, someone chimed in and said that they could produce shoes as cheaply as China in a fully automated factory in the USA for $9 a pair. But if I were going to build that plant or invest in one, I would need to know the China tariffs were going to hold. They did not. The other thing is I want a fixed idea on what my costs are. Given many items that you need to build an automated factory come from abroad, then I would to know what my costs were, and that was impossible to know given that Trump was changing tariff rates every other day.
So the long term goal of tariffs was getting the USA less dependent on imports and moving factories back home was a complete dud. There was no uptick in investment in American factores with the tariffs and IMO it was Trump's lack of guidance that caused that to happen.
I have already raved about Seymor Hersh and his sources. The headline is Trump breaks with Bibi. This is part of what was written: The MOU between Iran and the USA marks a historic rupture.
Originally Posted by HotDog666
[View Original Post]
It had been an American political ritual, like kissing babies when campaigning, to support Israel in all things, as did President Joe Biden after the horrific Hamas attack inside Israel on October 7, 2023. There was no second guessing then from Washington, only a commitment of US arms, as Netanyahu initiated what would become years of bombing in Gaza, a campaign that has killed tens of thousands of Palestinian women and children, leading to public censure of Israel around the world.
An Israeli combat hero, whom I've known for decades, and who over the years has repeatedly expressed admiration for the United States, bitterly described Trump's actions in "reorienting" its Middle East policy to make Iran the lynch pin as a "betrayal of Israel by our best ally. " he added, sadly, that "Iran has oil and control of two waterways," referring to the Strait of Hormuz and a second choke point in the Horn of Africa off Yemen, an Iranian ally. "This will not be Bibi's final blow," the Israeli added, referring to criminal charges against the Prime Minister that are still pending.
My understanding of the current reasoning of Trump and Vice President JD Vance, who has emerged as the president's well-spoken envoy and confidant on all things Iranian and, now, oil, is that Netanyahu's expanding air and ground war in Lebanon was seen in Washington as an unwanted obstacle to US rapprochement with the Iranian leadership. "If Bibi can't win in Gaza" over Hamas, I was told by the US official, "how can he beat the Iranians? Trump has done something no one else could dohe has taken on Bibi, who overplayed his hand. Israel is no longer a dominant issue and Trump is telling Bibi, 'My place in the world is more important than your place.'
End of link. IMO Trump made a massive error listening to Bibi and starting the war, but he also admitted it was a mistake and bailed. To admit you are wrong is a rare thing for a pol to do.

.png)







Reply With Quote


