Thread: American Politics
+
Add Report
Results 11,791 to 11,805 of 22487
-
10-20-22 13:08 #10697Senior Member

Posts: 2560Your religion is anti-neoliberalism. I and most others who view ourselves as fans of free markets believe in rights for labor, including the right to unionize, and reasonable regulation of business by government.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
Thanks. I did enjoy the read, in the same way I enjoy watching Rachel Maddow or Lawrence O'Donell. If you exclude their "reporting" on Trump, they're wrong in about 90% of what they say. But it's a window into how the other side thinks.
-
10-20-22 13:03 #10696Senior Member

Posts: 2560Why would the OECD, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, which generated the metrics, be USA biased? It's headquartered in France and the majority of its funding comes from Europe. You could create the same tables in Euros or pounds and they would show the same thing.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
After a quick look, I can't find data by year for real wages in European countries. But I'd dare say you see the same trend towards lower growth rates and real middle class wages across Western Europe and Japan, as a result of globalization and technology, as you see in the USA.
Still the middle class has made strides forward. Here's an interview with Bruce Meyer, an economist who focuses on poverty, inequality and social safety net programs at the University of Chicago. No doubt you'll poo poo this, since the University of Chicago was once a hotbed of supply side economics (Hayek and Friedman, both mentioned in your Mobiot piece, taught there). Also, like the Guardian, the AEI reputedly is biased. But I read your Monbiot piece and hope you'll read this. While Meyer doesn't say this, his thoughts agree with my observations of middle class living conditions in the USA versus Europe and Japan. We have more cars, larger living spaces, more appliances, air conditioning, and things usually cost less (not necessarily right now) and are more available in the USA.
https://www.aei.org/economics/inequa...h-bruce-meyer/
A couple of quotes,
There are very tangible things that you can look at to see that people in the middle of the distribution are better off than they were 20, 30 years ago. For example, if you look at the share of people in the middle of the income distribution that have central air conditioning, or maybe only a couple of room air conditioners, or have a dishwasher, or a washer and a dryer in their house or apartment those numbers for the middle look like the numbers for the top 20% as of 20 or 30 years ago. So theres been quite dramatic improvements if you look at tangible things like what kinds of appliances have in the house. You can also look at the size of peoples houses or apartments square footage, number of rooms those things have gone up quite sharply for people in the middle of the distribution....
....Well, when you talk about the broader income distribution, particularly those at the bottom, its very important to pay attention to taxes, and in-kind transfers, and to the fact that our income data sources tend to undercount a lot of key transfers from the government. Much of what we have done over the past 20 or 30 years to help those at the bottom of the income distribution has been in the form of tax credits, like the Earned Income Tax Credit, or transfers that are in-kind like food stamps, which we now call SNAP, or housing benefits, or Medicaid. And those benefits are not counted in our official income or poverty statistics. Omitting those leads to a huge understatement of the resources available to those at the bottom of the distribution....
-
10-20-22 12:33 #10695Senior Member

Posts: 8039The Deadbeat Repub Party
In classic Repub Party fashion, deabeat Repubs shoulder none of the heavy lifting, assume none of the political risk, leave all of the work to the Dems, do nothing but slam and snipe at the Dems for their hard work and effective legislation and then swoop in afterwards and try to con their constituents and the American voter into giving them credit for it. LOL.
Biden Calls Out Socialist Republicans Now Begging for Money From Program They Voted Down
https://news.yahoo.com/biden-calls-s...191450315.html
It is beyond all debate and will now and forever be proven in the data and actual record of results that, in just the past 21 months, POTUS Joe Biden's Administration and his Dems in Congress have accomplished more to materially improve the lives of more Americans, especially Repubs in Red States, as well as to strengthen and spread democracy and Western democratic alliances around the world than all of the Repub Administrations and all of the Repub members of Congress of the past century or more combined.
By stark contrast, no administration, now the holy template for all future Repub administrations and slavishly aped by virtually every Repub in Congress and running for election, inflicted more damage to the health, well-being and the economy of America as well as the cause for democracy around the world than the immediate previous one that still refuses to simply apologize for his total disaster, admit defeat and go away.
Snap out of it.
Wake up.
Pay attention.
Vote accordingly.
-
10-20-22 06:59 #10694Senior Member

Posts: 1945I don't agree with everything George Monbiot writes, but this is the best I have ever read from him. Neo-lieralism is: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2016/apr/15/neoliberalism-ideology-problem-george-monbiot
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
"freedom for the pike, not for the minnows. Freedom from trade unions and collective bargaining means the freedom to suppress wages. Freedom from regulation means the freedom to poison rivers, endanger workers, charge iniquitous rates of interest and design exotic financial instruments. Freedom from tax means freedom from the distribution of wealth that lifts people out of poverty. The greater the failure, the more extreme the ideology becomes. Governments use neoliberal crises as both excuse and opportunity to cut taxes, privatise remaining public services, rip holes in the social safety net, deregulate corporations and re-regulate citizens. The self-hating state now sinks its teeth into every organ of the public sector. ".
Hope you enjoy the read. I know you hold the Bible close to your heart, but we atheists hold the truth close close to ours. Neo-liberalism can never fix our problems, bcos it doesn't have our needs at heart.
-
10-20-22 06:22 #10693Senior Member

Posts: 1945Superb summary
Freddie Sayers coming good again. Super interviewer. Great guests.... COVID stuff.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Fr0-TMdjQ0
-
10-20-22 05:52 #10692Senior Member

Posts: 2742Yep, enacting Medicare Advantage was the most egregious and wasteful money scam of the 20th century. They relentlessly spam and confuse seniors getting them to sign up for inferior medical plans by offering a few bucks in return. What they do is criminal, and it's not a figure of speech.
Originally Posted by Spidy
[View Original Post]
-
10-20-22 03:37 #10691Senior Member

Posts: 1945Sorry, but I dno nt accept that at all. The metrics have been heavily criticised and are biased to the USA. They don't equalise differences across countires properly. It's similar to how some people try to use IQ tests to demonstrate that black people are more genetically stupid. It doesn't work bcos you cannot apply the same metric across different countries.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
And even if they did, it would have nothing to do with my points that middle classes are being squeezed. To confron that claim you would have to demonstrate that the middle class is no worse off now in real terms than it was in previous years. And it has nothing to do with the inequality.
-
10-20-22 02:12 #10690Senior Member

Posts: 2004Repubs Trojan Horse "Social Security Advantage"...in the works?
Just like democracy, Repubs, just want to kill off everything that democracy stands for and represents.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
So while, Social Security and Medicare, have always been long standing pillars of democracy, they stand in the way of an eventual Repub neoliberal privatization of America.
Much like Medicare and Medicare Advantage, just wait for Repubs, to introduce the Trojan horse that is "Social Security Advantage", to insidiously negate the last bastions of social safety nets, Americans have worked for.
-
10-20-22 01:48 #10689Senior Member

Posts: 2004Medicare Advantage is a right-wing Trojan horse
Medicare works just fine for many Americans. I think the ONLY problem with Medicare, is the right-wing Trojan horse that is Medicare Advantage, meant to eventually privatize Medicare.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Medicare Advantage Is a For-Profit Scam. Time to End It.
https://www.commondreams.org/views/2...am-time-end-it
Medicare Advantage, pawns itself off as being better than Medicare, when in fact it is just a multi-trillion dollar scam. It deceives and uses deceptive practices to fools current users of Medicare (especially the elder) into there "Advantage" program, to relieve and Americans of their premiums, while denying medical care, by using fancy policy loopholes designed to minimize and rebuff Americans, of the necessary medical care needed.
Medicare Advantage Money Grab
https://publicintegrity.org/topics/h...ge-money-grab/
Just get rid of Medicare Advantage, problem solved. Or at the very least forbid / copyright them from using the Medicare name.
-
10-20-22 01:37 #10688Senior Member

Posts: 2560Thank Goodness for Neoliberalism!
I finally figured out what neoliberalism is. I googled it in Wikipedia.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoliberalism
Neoliberalism, that is free market capitalism, has lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty. Thank goodness it predominated over socialism and communism!
-
10-19-22 23:55 #10687Senior Member

Posts: 2560This is a link to the tables you're questioning.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispos..._capita_income
Please note that both tables include in kind transfers from government for health care costs and education costs. For example, if Germany provides free university education, that's included in German per capita disposable income. This makes your argument about health care and education costs mute.
The "PPP" means the numbers are adjusted on the basis of purchasing power. They've been adjusted for differences in costs between countries. The exchange rates are irrelevant. If the value of the Euro depreciates 50% against the dollar in a day, the disposable income based on PPP or purchasing power parity (after normalizing for the cost of comparable goods between countries) won't change.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity
"Small places" refers to Luxembourg, Liechtenstein, the Isle of Man, Bermuda, San Marino, the Cayman Islands and the Falkland Islands:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP) _per_capita.
Luxembourg has a population of 632,000 and by some standards, including median disposable income per person and household disposable income (see Wikipedia table you're complaining about), the USA ranks higher. The other places I'd suspect all have populations of less than 100,000.
The five countries I referred to, the USA, Switzerland, Ireland, Singapore and Hong Kong, all have populations of 5 million or more. Please note that Denmark, Finland, Norway, and New Zealand all have populations in the 5 million to 6 million range. I don't think you'd question whether they're real countries.
Also if you limit GDP per capita to large countries, the difference between them and the USA will be more stark. Germany, with a population of 84 million, has the highest GDP per capita adjusted for PPP of any country of size except the USA. Its GDP per capita adjusted for PPP is about 15% less than the USA. The next highest after Germany, France, is lower by about 25%. And I'll point out that government expenditures and revenues as a % of GDP in France are a lot higher than Germany. Maybe that's why France is poorer.
-
10-19-22 23:16 #10686Senior Member

Posts: 2004The Usual Suspects
So true, w/r to the Alex Jones and Donnie J. Dummkopf, in cahoots, as far back as 2015 on Info Wars, when Roger Stone, hitched the two into right-wing conspiracy bliss.
Originally Posted by EihTooms
[View Original Post]
Funny how the usual suspects tend to show up on the lunatic fringe right-wing media outlets and are the purveyors of nutjob quackery conspiracy theories.
Donnie "the Devil" J. Dummkopf (the worst US president in history), Roger Stone (exiled Repub flunky, loser and lacky), Steve Bannon (fascist Viktor Orbn wanna be), Stuart Rhodes (Oath Keepers Founder, fmr Ron Paul staffer, white supremacist, militia strongman, Branch Davidian Church Waco) and Alex Jones (arch conspirator and right-wing nutter, Branch Davidian Church, Waco)
It started primarily with the Sandy Hook conspiracy and then from there to Pizzagate, to QAnon, to Charlottesville and the great replacement theory, to Corona Virus, to "stop the steal" lies and the Jan 6th "peaceful non-riot" and "patriots" exercising their political discourse.
Alex Jones has his fingerprints pretty much on all those crazy theories since Sandy Hook and to a large degree, at the center of the foundational front, for how disinformation and false narratives gain traction the right-wing media sphere.
Lately all the QAnon\Repubs\Bothsidesism political party does, is limp and larch from one conspiracy theory to the next, as soon as the Repub lunatic fringe, like Alex Jones, dreams up the next conspiracy, one after the other.
Naturally, as the gullible goose-stepping QAnon\Repubs\Bothsidesists, follow behind, parroting the same conspiracy drivel, lock, step and barrel.
-
10-19-22 23:03 #10685Senior Member

Posts: 1945That is a shockingly poor take. Firstly, the stat is clearly based around the USA as its benchmark bcos everything is in USD. So other countiries's median income is exposed to whatever rate of excha is prevailing at the time. Plus it does not account properly for cost of living. For example, in the USA, bcos the government just pays out its tax receipts in helping the rich and buulding bombs, the USA people need to pay for their own health care, pay for continued education, pay for pizzas at USD 15+ a pop.
Originally Posted by Tiny12
[View Original Post]
Furthermore it says nothing about WHERE the USA has come from. After World War 2 the USA owned half of the world's wealth. Now it is being overtaken by China. The USA middle class were much better off at all times during the past 70+ years than they are now.
You also say "If you exclude small countries and petrostates", and then you go on to use "Switzerland, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Ireland" as examples to support your point. You can't have it both ways.
"Smaller government produces better results. ".
Not at all. All it does is lead to stats like this. Sure the US citizens need higher incomes. BCOS THEY HAVE TO PAY FOR EVERYTHING (health / education etc) and at hihg prices due to neo -liberalism and lack of state support.
-
10-19-22 20:07 #10684Senior Member

Posts: 2560The only way you'd come up with the USA being as unequal as Colombia or Brazil is by ignoring taxes and transfer payments, a common trick of Progressives. See my wikipedia link in the post you're responding too. Median, by definition the middle of the middle class, per capita income in the USA after transfers and taxes is higher than just about any place. If you exclude small countries and petrostates, the only countries with per capita GDP comparable to the USA, are also countries like the USA where government expenditures as a % of GDP are low: Switzerland, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Ireland. Smaller government produces better results. It's preferable IMO to leave more money in the hands of the people and businesses, instead of devoting larger and larger resources to our wasteful and inefficient federal government. The private sector is the engine of economic growth, not government.
Originally Posted by JustTK
[View Original Post]
As to public utilities and public transport and the rest, I believe New York City and California and all other progressive cities and states should be free to spend as much of THEIR money as they want on public services and public welfare. Have at it. As to shocking public services my ass. Maybe where you live. Where I live things work better than in Europe. We have efficient city, state and county government, and I don't begrudge paying taxes to support them one bit. The politicians in Washington D.C. though who want to enforce their priorities on us should go f*ck themselves.
The USA doesn't subsidize the rich per se. It's the opposite. See the reply to Xpartan below, where I partly address your points about inequality. The federal government does give away lots of corporate welfare, to farmers, agribusiness, green companies and the like. And that should stop. I agree with you about the poor and shit wages, and believe it makes sense for many cities and states to raise minimum wages. There should be additional support for poor single mothers and children. And better education.
You're right that real median wages and household income haven't increased enough since the late 1970's. But will point out that they really started to take off in 2019 before COVID hit. I'd attribute part of that to the CORPORATE tax cut and deregulation. You'd undoubtedly poo poo that. The stagnation of wages is a result mostly of improvements in technology and globalization though. There's not a lot you can do about that, unless you want to go back to horses and buggies, or paying lots more for goods. Which I guess does fit with the Progressive goal of making everyone more equal without giving a f*ck whether everyone becomes poorer in the process. Progressive Democrats should focus on improving the lot of the poor instead of dragging down the rich.
-
10-19-22 19:36 #10683Senior Member

Posts: 4845[Deleted by Admin]
EDITOR'S NOTE: This report was redacted or deleted to remove sections of the report that were largely argumentative. Please read the Forum FAQ and the Forum's Posting Guidelines for more information. Thank You!

.png)







Reply With Quote


